Skip to content

Classify unavailable live interop scenarios on Poppy 0.4 - #29

Open
adewale wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
claude/interop-2026-10-24
Open

adewale wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
claude/interop-2026-10-24

Conversation

@adewale

@adewale adewale commented Oct 26, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

A live Company without conversations or MCP currently produces failed interop cells. This change reports those absent capabilities as unsupported, while keeping failures for manifest-backed adapters that claim the scenario and for broken advertised features. Missing statically required fixture data also stops a live cell before any scenario request.

The PR now targets current main and Poppy 0.4 only. It retains the harness fixes and their regression tests. Main's newer currency and deterministic feedback concurrency tests are preserved. The October reports and 0.3 evidence remain in the previous immutable snapshot.

Changes

  • Mark capability prerequisites in C, CL and ML with offers: true; only a live capability miss becomes unsupported. An advertised MCP API returning no tools still fails.
  • Share live fixture construction and bounded two-pass interpolation between planning and execution. Check fixture-injected references, optional parameters and fixture-known conditions. Preserve literal keys and defer unknown runtime expressions.
  • Document the classification rules and current 0.4 live registry. Application runtime code and permitted live scenarios are unchanged.

Verification

  • Full suite: 2,705 passed, one existing skip, across 134 files.
  • All 474 harness tests and 17 tooling tests passed, along with type checking, spec integrity and documentation references.
  • All four CLI regressions fail when preflight is disabled; with the fix, missing fixture data stops before any adapter call. A complete S0 fixture still runs.
  • Logs, hashes, reproduction command and receipts.
  • Final-head CI passed, including process-crash recovery, hosted consent and the pinned 0.4 Bearer/DPoP kit checks. Container interop passed: 126 cells passed, including 30 against Print with Poppy, with no failures, unsupported cells or errors. Action pinning passed.

Visual evidence

Reviewer cue: fixture-live changes from red fail to grey n/a (unsupported) in both CL and ML. fixture-claimed remains red fail in both.

Base SHA: b2fc42893ce719023681ff0df14a2b485e6d75d3
Head SHA: a013051d270a006b1507002b3ef0893b7cc17ce3

Before: missing live features fail After: missing live features are unsupported
Base 0.4 report: both fixture columns fail CL and ML Updated 0.4 report: live fixtures are unsupported while claimed-support controls fail

The same synthetic discovery response uses actual immutable runner/scenario sources and the production renderer at the same viewport. The renderer's full runtime dependency closure is pinned, checked and hashed. Assertions check all four cell outcomes and the rendered counts. Capture source: 3f240b5f43c97a6012b612f1d0f4e2e0cb7e15e9; the final head adds evidence files only.

Limits and risk

No live Company was contacted. The screenshots demonstrate synthetic classification, and CLI preflight has separate regression tests. A live Company dropping a capability will now appear as unsupported; --require-supported still fails runs that require every cell to execute. Current production discovery and sandbox discovery/Session permissions remain unchanged.

@adewale
adewale force-pushed the claude/interop-2026-10-24 branch from de613e0 to 6b32b10 Compare October 29, 2026 18:18
@adewale
adewale changed the base branch from claude/live-preflight to main October 29, 2026 18:19
@adewale adewale changed the title Interop, 24–26 October: honest live cells, an attributed grid, and the first sandbox order through the agent's cards Classify unavailable live interop scenarios as unsupported Oct 29, 2026
@adewale
adewale force-pushed the claude/interop-2026-10-24 branch from d02855e to a013051 Compare November 12, 2026 23:35
@adewale adewale changed the title Classify unavailable live interop scenarios as unsupported Classify unavailable live interop scenarios on Poppy 0.4 Nov 12, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant