Repository navigation
Description
Scope
Bound draft PR #5326 to a separately approved, Dev-only preview of one-command run --compose and hidden named machine create --pack / start. This ticket does not complete the production artifact, immutable warm claim, or launch-speed requirements. Governing program #5415 and architecture #5413; preserve #5341 and explicit bundle enrollment from merged #5301.
Acceptance
- Obtain owner approval for the revised preview scope and record remaining warm/speed acceptance in separately owned issues, without deleting or checking off unfinished criteria on feat(pack): stage portable composition from current main #5326.
- A composed archive and cache remain data; each cold or repeat invocation re-verifies inputs and mints a one-use, invocation-private Dev proof bound to exact bytes, signer, user and expiry. Cached bytes do not reuse authorization.
- Refuse the proof at installed/reusable bundles, export, production/fleet origin, rematerialization, warm claim, stale/foreign/replayed proofs and changed archive or selected base. Preserve the normal signed-plan and backend admission path.
- Rebase/merge current
maininto feat(pack): stage portable composition from current main #5326 only with its branch owners, resolve conflicts and measured footprint, run current-head CI and reviewed CLI guest-output/refusal checks. Report the existing x86_64, arm64 Linux and macOS evidence as Dev-only; no production or speed claim.
Context and validation
The current PR is draft and conflicted; latest head has no check runs, while older heads have live Dev guest output. Read its body, the composable-pack build contract, ADR-001, ADR-037, and draft ADR-059 before changing a branch. Focus tests in crates/mvm-cli/src/commands/vm/exec.rs, crates/mvm-hostd/src/plan_admission/composition.rs, and tests/cli.rs. Run cargo test -p mvm-cli, cargo clippy --workspace -- -D warnings, cargo check --workspace, cargo run -p xtask -- check-all, and the hermetic BDD lane; name any unrun live backend witness. The branch is owned by its current contributors; this issue does not authorize an unrelated agent to push it.
Depends on: owner preview-scope decision. Independent of: the production schema and warm API tickets. Plan the code change from #5326's actual head, not from a stale local checkout.
Activity
auser commentedon Nov 13, 2026
Scope review packet — Dev preview, not production
Draft #5326 currently has named and transient Dev guest-output witnesses, but its latest head has no reported checks, conflicts with
main, and still describes immutable warm custody plus cold <300 ms / warm <50 ms as blocking acceptance. #5341 already chose a one-command transient, one-use Dev proof that does not enroll the local signer. Neither PR-only signing nor an authenticated cache-hit repeat is production authority.Recommendation for owner approval
If the owner wants the development workflow independently reviewable now, split or explicitly narrow #5326 to its already bounded Dev capability, and keep the unused warm primitive inert/disabled until #5419/#5422/#5427 are implemented and witnessed. Document the slower observed starts honestly; make no warm, speed, fleet or official publisher claim. The original product performance requirements remain in #5415/#5418/#5429—do not mark their checkboxes complete to make this PR mergeable. If owner approval is not given, leave #5326 draft under its current acceptance terms.
Preview acceptance matrix
run --composeand hidden named create/start/stop/restart on authenticated Dev inputs, freshly admitted at each boot; verify guest output and audit/receipt on the exact head for the backend claimed.main, resolve conflicts and measured footprint, obtain exact-head CI and a separate review. No other contributor should force-push this shared draft branch or publish PR-only release assets.Owner call needed: approve this bounded preview scope as a separate merge candidate, or retain #5326's full warm/speed blockers. This comment does not grant permission to merge or change its branch.
auser commentedon Nov 13, 2026
Owner approved the recommended Dev-only preview scope direction in #5413. This does not edit, approve merging, or close the hard warm/speed criteria on draft PR #5326. Its current branch owners must make the scoped change and exact-head validation reviewable; all unchecked acceptance here remains open until evidenced.
auser commentedon Nov 15, 2026
Design-relevance note (2026-11-15 audit for #5415): this issue's vehicle #5326 was closed unmerged per the #5415 triage; the live Dev composition capability is #5263's schema-8
local_composition+--compose(transient-only, signed-input admission per invocation). Checkboxes referencing "#5326's head / rebase #5326" are moot as written. Remaining question for the owner: does #5263's Dev-local composition satisfy the preview intent, or is a fresh narrowed PR wanted? Tracked in the #5415 epic map.