feat(update): add auto-update system with verification and validation…

[AlexMikhalev]

… reports

[AlexMikhalev]

GitHub Runner Execution Results

PR: #423 - feat(update): add auto-update system with verification and validation…
URL: #423

❌ python-bindings.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ test-on-pr.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ ci-optimized.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ vm-execution-tests.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ ci-native.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

✅ Powered by terraphim-github-runner

[claude]

Code Review: Auto-Update System Implementation

Overview

This PR introduces a comprehensive auto-update system for Terraphim AI binaries. The implementation is well-structured with ~12,000 additions across 38 files, primarily adding the terraphim_update crate with supporting modules and extensive documentation.

---

✅ Strengths

1. Excellent Architecture & Modularity

• Clean separation of concerns across modules: config, downloader, rollback, scheduler, signature, platform, notification, state
• Well-designed async API using tokio::spawn_blocking to handle blocking self_update operations
• Builder pattern for configuration (UpdaterConfig, DownloadConfig)
• Proper error handling with anyhow::Result

2. Comprehensive Documentation

• Extensive rustdoc comments with examples
• Multiple design documents: DESIGN-AUTO-UPDATE.md, RESEARCH-AUTO-UPDATE.md, VERIFICATION-REPORT-AUTO-UPDATE.md, VALIDATION-REPORT-AUTO-UPDATE.md
• README with usage examples in crates/terraphim_update/README.md
• Phase 2 roadmap in .github/issues/AUTO-UPDATE-PHASE2.md

3. Security Considerations

• Signature verification module (though placeholder implementation)
• SHA256 checksum validation for backups (rollback.rs:183-189)
• Uses self_update with rustls and signatures features
• Backup integrity validation before rollback

4. Testing

• Integration tests in tests/integration_test.rs covering:
  • Full update flow
  • Backup/restore roundtrip
  • Permission failure scenarios
  • Backup retention
• Unit tests in lib.rs for version comparison logic
• Test coverage for edge cases

---

⚠️ Issues & Concerns

Critical: Security Gaps

1. Signature Verification is Placeholder Only 🔴

// crates/terraphim_update/src/signature.rs:58-80
pub fn verify_signature(
    _binary_path: &Path,
    _signature_path: &Path,
    _public_key: &str,
) -> Result<VerificationResult> {
    // ... checks file existence ...
    Ok(VerificationResult::Valid)  // ⚠️ ALWAYS returns Valid\!
}

Impact: Updates are NOT cryptographically verified. This is a critical security vulnerability allowing:

• Man-in-the-middle attacks
• Malicious binary distribution
• Compromised update servers

Recommendation:

• Either implement proper signature verification using self_update's signature features
• OR clearly document this as MVP limitation and add security warning
• Consider using minisign or ed25519-dalek for production

2. Version Comparison Vulnerability

// crates/terraphim_update/src/lib.rs:43-73
fn is_newer_version_static(version1: &str, version2: &str) -> bool {
    let v1_parts: Vec<u32> = version1
        .trim_start_matches('v')
        .split('.')
        .take(3)
        .map(|s| s.parse().unwrap_or(0))  // ⚠️ Silently fails to 0
        .collect();
    // ...
}

Issues:

• No semver compliance (pre-release versions, build metadata ignored)
• Silently converts parse errors to 0 (e.g., "1.2.3-beta" → "1.2.3")
• Could misorder versions with pre-release tags

Recommendation: Use semver crate:

use semver::Version;
fn is_newer_version(v1: &str, v2: &str) -> Result<bool> {
    let version1 = Version::parse(v1.trim_start_matches('v'))?;
    let version2 = Version::parse(v2.trim_start_matches('v'))?;
    Ok(version1 > version2)
}

High Priority

3. Compilation Warnings 🟡

From diagnostics:

• scheduler.rs:382:13: Unused mutable variable receiver
• integration_test.rs:119:13: Unused import std::os::unix::fs::PermissionsExt
• integration_test.rs:234:9: Unused variable i

These must be fixed before merge (fails cargo clippy).

4. Error Handling Could Be More Robust

// crates/terraphim_update/src/lib.rs:198
Err(e) => Ok(UpdateStatus::Failed(format\!("Check failed: {}", e))),

Converting errors to successful Ok results loses error context. Consider:

Err(e) => Err(anyhow\!("Update check failed: {}", e))

5. Potential Race Conditions

// crates/terraphim_update/src/lib.rs:559-563
let rt = tokio::runtime::Runtime::new()?;
rt.block_on(async { check_for_updates_auto(&bin_name, &current_version).await })

Creating nested runtimes inside spawn_blocking can cause panics if called from async context. Use tokio::runtime::Handle::current() instead.

Medium Priority

6. Backup Rotation Logic Incomplete

// crates/terraphim_update/src/rollback.rs:198
pub fn rotate_backups(&mut self) -> Result<Vec<String>> {
    let mut removed = Vec::new();
    // Implementation cut off at line 200

Need to verify this is complete and handles edge cases:

• Empty backup directory
• Concurrent modifications
• Disk full scenarios

7. No TLS Certificate Validation Mentioned

While using rustls, there's no explicit verification of:

• GitHub's TLS certificate pinning
• OCSP stapling
• Certificate revocation checking

Recommendation: Document TLS security assumptions or add explicit validation.

8. Scheduler State Management

The scheduler (start_update_scheduler) returns a JoinHandle but doesn't provide:

• Graceful shutdown mechanism
• State persistence across restarts
• Recovery from scheduler crashes

---

📝 Code Quality

Best Practices Adherence

✅ Follows Rust idioms and naming conventions
✅ Proper use of async/await patterns
✅ Good module organization
✅ Comprehensive error types with thiserror

Areas for Improvement

9. Test Coverage Gaps

Missing tests for:

• Network failure scenarios (timeout, DNS errors)
• Concurrent update attempts
• Rollback after partial installation
• Scheduler persistence/recovery
• Permission escalation on different platforms

10. Platform-Specific Code Needs Validation

#[cfg(unix)]
{
    use std::os::unix::fs::PermissionsExt;
    perms.set_mode(0o755);
}

Windows/macOS equivalents not shown. Need to verify cross-platform compatibility.

11. Documentation Debt

The PR includes many planning/design docs (HANDOVER-AUTO-UPDATE.md, PHASE5_INTEGRATION_SUMMARY.md, etc.) that should probably:

• Move to docs/ directory
• Be consolidated
• Have orphaned files cleaned up post-merge

---

🔍 Performance Considerations

Good

• Exponential backoff for retries (line 22 in downloader.rs)
• Configurable timeouts
• Async operations don't block main thread

Concerns

• No mention of download size limits (could DoS with huge files)
• Checksum calculation loads entire file into memory (fs::read in rollback.rs:184)
• Consider streaming hash for large binaries

---

🛡️ Security Recommendations (Priority Order)

1. Implement Real Signature Verification 🔴 (Blocker)
2. Switch to semver crate for version comparison 🟡 (High)
3. Add hash verification for downloads 🟡 (High)
4. Document threat model and security boundaries 🟢 (Medium)
5. Add rate limiting for update checks 🟢 (Low)
6. Consider update channel separation (stable/beta) 🟢 (Low)

---

📋 Action Items Before Merge

Must Fix

• Fix compilation warnings (unused variables/imports)
• Implement or document signature verification limitation
• Fix nested runtime creation in scheduler
• Add semver dependency and proper version comparison

Should Fix

• Add network failure tests
• Complete backup rotation implementation
• Add graceful scheduler shutdown
• Move documentation files to proper locations

Nice to Have

• Streaming hash calculation for large files
• Download size limits
• More detailed error types
• Cross-platform compatibility testing

---

💡 Suggestions

Consider Adding

1. Dry-run mode for testing without actual updates
2. Bandwidth throttling for background downloads
3. Partial download resumption for interrupted downloads
4. Telemetry opt-in (as mentioned in Phase 2 doc)

Documentation

Add to README:

• Security model and trust assumptions
• Minimum supported versions
• Rollback limitations
• Network requirements

---

🎯 Overall Assessment

Quality: High - Well-architected, documented, and tested
Security: Medium-Low - Critical signature verification gap
Completeness: 85% - Core functionality solid, some edge cases need work

Recommendation: Conditional Approval pending:

1. Security issue resolution (signature verification)
2. Compilation warning fixes
3. Documentation updates

This is excellent foundation work for Phase 1. The Phase 2 planning shows good foresight. Once security gaps are addressed, this will be production-ready.

---

Review completed per CLAUDE.md guidelines - focusing on security, performance, and Rust best practices.

[AlexMikhalev]

GitHub Runner Execution Results

PR: #423 - feat(update): add auto-update system with verification and validation…
URL: #423

❌ ci.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ ci-optimized.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ test-on-pr.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ ci-native.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ vm-execution-tests.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

✅ Powered by terraphim-github-runner

[AlexMikhalev]

GitHub Runner Execution Results

PR: #423 - feat(update): add auto-update system with verification and validation…
URL: #423

❌ python-bindings.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ test-on-pr.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ ci-optimized.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ vm-execution-tests.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

❌ ci-native.yml

Execution failed: VM allocation failed: Allocation failed with status: 429 Too Many Requests

✅ Powered by terraphim-github-runner

[github-actions]

Documentation Preview

Your documentation changes have been deployed to:
https://ced6e681.terraphim-docs.pages.dev

This preview will be available until the PR is closed.