Skip to content

SOTA: benchmark Harness-of-Harness against current Dream Machine self-improvement loop #67

Description

@ruvnet

Finding

Harness-of-Harness: Multi-Day Autonomous Software Development with Continual Improvement (arXiv:2609.01481, submitted 2026-09-01) reports continual planning, coding, and testing loops over existing coding harnesses, with small verifiable increments, independent evaluation, progressive capability exposure, reuse, and versioned histories. Across GameCraft-Bench, FrontierSWE, and ProgramBench with three harness/model pairs, the originating team reports an average relative gain of 52.25% and a maximum gain of 82.86% after three iterations.

Evidence status: originating-team measured with linked GitHub project; not independently reproduced by RuV.

Why this is not a new architecture by default

Dream Machine, MetaHarness, witness, Core Memory, RVM, and the trace-driven optimizer already implement much of the same shape: bounded candidates, independent gates, histories, evidence, rollback, and authority separation. The highest-information task is therefore a differential benchmark, not another framework.

Differential benchmark

Freeze:

  • model and exact version
  • coding harness and version
  • task set and seeds
  • total token/compute/time budget
  • independent evaluator
  • safety and authority policy

Compare:

  1. current Dream Machine plus MetaHarness loop
  2. HoH-inspired loop with progressive artifact disclosure and explicit repair/capability-growth scheduling

Report absolute task success, iteration-to-success, regression rate, token cost, wall time, evaluator cost, artifact reuse, duplicated work, security findings, and historical retention.

Promotion gate

Only import a new primitive if it improves held-out task success by at least 5 absolute points, or preserves success while lowering total compute/cost by at least 20%. If current RuV performs within variance, record that as a negative result and reuse the existing substrate.

Governance

No self-merge, no evaluator mutation, no authority expansion. Statistical claims are subject to the persistent validity gate and independent MetaHarness reproduction.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions