Skip to content

Tracking: native-surface audit for the 5 agents added in PR #677 (skills/prompts/rules, not just MCP) #708

Open

Description

@rohitg00

Tracking issue. PR #677 shipped MCP-only adapters for 5 new agents (Warp, Cline, Continue, Zed, Droid). MCP is the lowest-common-denominator wrapper. It flattens agentmemory's 8 skills + 4 commands + 12 hooks into "just tools" and loses the slash-command + skill-autoload semantics each agent's native surface provides.

This issue tracks the per-agent native-surface audit results filed in #703–#707.

Per-agent breakdown

Agent Native surfaces we missed Effort Issue
Warp Already scans .claude/skills/. Zero work, just verify + document trivial #703
Continue prompts: + rules: keys in config.yaml (we wrote only mcpServers:) medium #704
Cline .clinerules/ directory for rules small #705
Zed Auto-loads .clinerules / AGENTS.md. Covered by the Cline / cross-agent rules adapter trivial #706
Droid .factory/skills/<name>/SKILL.md. Same format as Claude Code skills small #707

Cross-cutting finding

The skills format is converging. Warp, Factory.ai, and (post-v1.4.0) Zed all scan some variant of <dir>/skills/<name>/SKILL.md with name: + description: YAML frontmatter. agentmemory's existing 8 Claude Code skills are portable to all three with zero rewriting. Only the install path differs.

Suggests a shared helper rather than 5 near-identical adapters:

// src/cli/connect/skills-installer.ts
function installSkillsTo(rootDir: string, layout: "claude-style" | "warp-merged"): void
  • installSkillsTo("~/.factory/skills/", "claude-style") for Droid
  • installSkillsTo("~/.warp/skills/", "claude-style") for Warp (when not relying on .claude/skills/ autoload)
  • Future: same helper for Zed v1.4.0+

AGENTS.md is similarly cross-cutting. Cline, Zed, Factory, and most modern agents auto-load it. A single writeAgentsMd() would replace per-agent rules adapters for Cline + Zed (and possibly others).

What's genuinely not portable

Hooks. PreToolUse / PostToolUse / SessionStart / etc. are essentially a Claude Code exclusive. Of the 5 agents in PR #677, none have a public hook API. Continue has model interceptors but not a tool-event hook bus. We should be explicit in README that hooks are a Claude-Code-only surface and stop implying they're available everywhere.

Suggested order of attack

  1. Native audit: Warp auto-discovers .claude/skills/ for free #703 Warp. Verify + README. Zero new code. Lands today.
  2. Native audit: Droid skills use Claude SKILL.md format, install all 8 #707 Droid. Copy skills into ~/.factory/skills/. Tiny new adapter on top of existing MCP. ~80 LOC.
  3. Native audit: Cline missing .clinerules/agentmemory.md #705 Cline + Native audit: Zed auto-loads via Cline / AGENTS.md fallback #706 Zed. Combined AGENTS.md / .clinerules writer covers both.
  4. Native audit: Continue config missing prompts: and rules: keys #704 Continue. Biggest, write prompts: + rules: properly. Last because most invasive.

Each lands as its own PR. No bundled-mega-PR. Small reviewable diffs.

Not in scope here

Activity

  1. rohitg00 commented on May 28, 2026

    @rohitg00
    OwnerAuthor

    Update: npx skills add subsumes 4 of 5 issues

    Finding: npx skills add rohitg00/agentmemory already works out of the box. Just tested:

    ◇  Repository cloned
    ◇  Found 8 skills
    ◇  Available Skills
        commit-context, commit-history, ... (8 total)
    

    skills@1.5.9 (by vercel-labs) reads .claude/skills/*/SKILL.md from any git repo and installs to the calling agent's native skill directory. Its keyword list covers 4 of the 5 agents from PR #677: warp, cline, continue, droid. (Plus 45+ others.)

    Reframed plan

    Issue Original Revised
    #703 Warp Write native adapter Close as redundant — npx skills add rohitg00/agentmemory -a warp
    #704 Continue Write prompts: + rules: adapter Close as redundant — npx skills add rohitg00/agentmemory -a continue
    #705 Cline .clinerules/ writer Close as redundant — npx skills add rohitg00/agentmemory -a cline
    #707 Droid .factory/skills/ install Close as redundant — npx skills add rohitg00/agentmemory -a droid
    #706 Zed .zed/skills/ adapter Keep open — Zed not in skills CLI keyword list yet

    agentmemory connect vs npx skills add are complementary

    • agentmemory connect <agent> writes the MCP server config so tools are available.
    • npx skills add rohitg00/agentmemory -a <agent> installs skills so the agent knows when/how to use the tools.

    Both needed for full integration. The skills CLI install is what we were going to hand-roll in 4 separate adapters; offloading to vercel-labs/skills saves ~600 LOC of per-agent file-tree manipulation and tracks new agents automatically as the upstream keyword list grows.

    What still needs to ship

    • Update agentmemory connect <agent> to print the matching npx skills add hint after a successful MCP wire. No subprocess spawn — keeps connect deterministic + offline-capable; users run the install themselves.
    • README: document the two-step pattern.
    • Native audit: Zed auto-loads via Cline / AGENTS.md fallback #706 Zed: separate adapter or wait for skills@1.6.x+ to add Zed support.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions