You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
The "shortened" result of emergency truncation is longer than the original: a 4001-character tool output became 4064 cha | 紧急截断的"缩短"结果比原文还长:4001 字符的工具输出截断后变 4064 字符 #3935
changed the title [-]紧急截断的"缩短"结果比原文还长:4001 字符的工具输出截断后变 4064 字符[/-][+]The "shortened" result of emergency truncation is longer than the original: a 4001-character tool output became 4064 cha | 紧急截断的"缩短"结果比原文还长:4001 字符的工具输出截断后变 4064 字符[/+]on Oct 20, 2026
Activity
[-]紧急截断的"缩短"结果比原文还长:4001 字符的工具输出截断后变 4064 字符[/-][+]The "shortened" result of emergency truncation is longer than the original: a 4001-character tool output became 4064 cha | 紧急截断的"缩短"结果比原文还长:4001 字符的工具输出截断后变 4064 字符[/+]docs: verif module README rewrite + AGENTS.md rule 14
ranxianglei commentedon Oct 20, 2026
(ai: vllm-qwen/qwen3.8-27b)
查重: 不重复。 open+closed 全量检索(关键词: truncate/截断/savedTokens/emergency)无同症状条目。同家族但机制不同:#3691(截断震荡,已修)、#3813(截断制造缓存接缝,已立)——本 issue 是第三个独立缺陷:替换文本比原文更长,产生方在
kernel/src/truncate-tools.ts的truncateLargeToolOutputs,前两者都不覆盖它。标签: bug + scope/kernel + p2(窄带宽触发、仅紧急路径、影响有界——4001~~4062 字符的工具输出每条约多 ~60 字节,不阻塞会话,故 p2 非 p1)。
审核三步已完成,结论:
kernel/src/truncate-tools.ts:96)只有original.length > keepPrefixChars + keepSuffixChars(默认 4000),replacement = prefix(≤2000)+ 标记(\n\n...[truncated for context space] — original ~N tokens]...\n\n,4 位 token 数时 ≈61 字符)+ suffix(≤2000)。原文落在 (4000, ~4062] 区间时替换必然更长。kernel-change声明、版本 bump、人工评审档)。remaining反向增长(循环不早停)、并触发 emergencyTruncateNode 里savedTokens <= 0分支——误报 "none were large enough to save tokens" 诊断 + 可能喂大 terminalStreak(fix: stitched-stream usage double-count after compress re-request (adapter-anthropic >0 guard) #300 终局态误判风险)。开始实现:定向复现脚本 → 修复 → kernel/tests 回归测试 → bump kernel 版本 → PR(Closes #3935)。
ranxianglei commentedon Oct 20, 2026
(ai: vllm-qwen/qwen3.8-27b)
修复完成:PR #3957(kernel-change 已声明,kernel 0.0.137 → 0.0.138,Closes #3935):#3957
结构化八问:
original.length > keepPrefix+keepSuffix(默认 4000),没把替换文本恒带的 ~64 字符标记开销算进下限,缺"截完必须更短"这条不变量;且savedTokens += tokens - countTokens(replacement)无负值守卫——负节省让remaining反向增长(候选循环不早停),并喂给下游savedTokens <= 0分支(误报 "none were large enough" 诊断 + terminalStreak 可能虚增,fix: stitched-stream usage double-count after compress re-request (adapter-anthropic >0 guard) #300 终局态误判风险)。复现实测与你的 solver 见证逐字一致:len=4001 → 4064 字符,deltaChars +63,savedTokens −15。4063 字符窄带;每受影响消息多 163 字节、token 账目最多 −15/条、可触发误导性诊断与 stuck streak 虚增。p2:能用但明显有问题,有界不阻塞。keptBudget = len − marker.length − 1);再对每个候选加双重守卫——替换必须严格更短且按会话估计器严格更少 token,否则原样跳过。新不变量:truncatedCount > 0 ⇒ savedTokens > 0。选了你建议的方向一(收缩保比例),未动 minOutputTokens 语义(方向二动配置语义面,不必要)。行为变更披露(旧→新):默认配置下 4001~4063 字符原文:旧 = 一律替换为 4064 字符(更长)、savedTokens≤0;新 = 收缩到严格更短(如 4001→4000,省 1 token)或按估计器无收益时原样保留、savedTokens>0 ⟺ 有截断。其余区间行为不变。
收工判定:定向验证已过(38/38 相关套件 + typecheck + prettier,全量交给 CI);kernel 改动属人工评审档,CI 绿后请人工 review 合并 PR #3957。
ranxianglei commentedon Oct 20, 2026
(ai: zhipuai-lb/glm-5.3)
已修:PR #3972(kernel 0.0.144,stacked on #3956,合并顺序 #3956 → #3972)。
修法:keep 窗口总量钳到原文在标记下方实际留出的空间(
maxKeep = len − marker − 4,floor 64)+ 最终严格更短拒施保险;≥4068 字符的大输出字节完全不变(4066 pin 保持),无空间的候选原样跳过。打桩 6 pins(kernel/tests/issue3935-truncation-shrink.test.ts)覆盖整个膨胀窗 4001–4200。Merge pull request #3972 from ranxianglei/2026-10-20_3935-3945-verif-…
kernel: every applied truncation clip comes out strictly shorter (ran…
fix(verif): emit str.substr, not str.extract - cvc5 rejects the latter