You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Replace the disconnected manifest comparison with a machine-readable contract derived from the package transaction that current Bluefin actually executes. Utah should either install each effective requirement or carry a documented, issue-linked exception.
Acceptance criteria
The parity source covers Bluefin's effective base, version-specific, external, and multimedia transactions.
CI detects additions/removals in the effective Bluefin payload rather than only changes to an unused manifest.
Every Utah exception has rationale and a tracking issue.
The resulting image records and verifies the exact resolved contract.
This issue's goal is covered by open PR #117 (feat(parity): compare the built image with Bluefin's image, not list with list), which superseded the manifest-parsing approach in PR #60 by comparing Utah's built image against Bluefin's rechunked inventory (dev.hhd.rechunk.info). PR #117 is currently open and undergoing maintainer review (@hanthor and @castrojo) with pending design decisions around baseline management.
When PR #117 is merged, note that a maintainer editing the PR body to link/close this issue can resolve it.
Closing: the acceptance criteria are met on main, though not through #117 (closed unmerged):
Effective payload as the parity source: baselines/bluefin/rpms.tsv and surface.tsv are measured from the published ghcr.io/ublue-os/bluefin:stable image (scripts/image-baseline.py, feat(baselines): measure Utah against the published Bluefin and Dakota images #264). That covers the base, version-specific, external and multimedia transactions, not just base.toml.
CI notices payload changes: .github/workflows/image-baselines.yml re-measures every week and opens a PR. just check fails that PR if any new gap has no entry in baselines/triage.toml.
Every exception has a rationale and an issue: baselines/triage.toml covers image gaps, and [unavailable] in packages/utah.toml requires a tracking issue for each entry, enforced by feat(contract): fail CI on stale [unavailable] entries #418.
Resolved contract recorded in the image: scripts/verify-rpm-contract.py writes /usr/share/utah/package-origins.{json,txt}.
If part of this is still missing, please reopen and name the criterion.
Evidence: 46bc45d (#264) baselines/ + scripts/image-baseline.py; .github/workflows/image-baselines.yml weekly re-measure PR; just check fails on untriaged gap (baselines/README.md); 2aeacba (#417) scripts/audit-bluefin-parity.py; scripts/verify-rpm-contract.py generate_provenance_report -> package-origins.json
Closed in a backlog sweep after verifying against current main; reopen if this is still reproducible.
Activity
mrbobbytables commentedon Sep 22, 2026
This issue's goal is covered by open PR #117 (feat(parity): compare the built image with Bluefin's image, not list with list), which superseded the manifest-parsing approach in PR #60 by comparing Utah's built image against Bluefin's rechunked inventory (
dev.hhd.rechunk.info). PR #117 is currently open and undergoing maintainer review (@hanthor and @castrojo) with pending design decisions around baseline management.When PR #117 is merged, note that a maintainer editing the PR body to link/close this issue can resolve it.
— hive: backend=copilot model=gemini-3.8-flash
🐝 Hive Agent:
contributor| SHA:unknownhanthor commentedon Oct 3, 2026
Closing: the acceptance criteria are met on
main, though not through #117 (closed unmerged):baselines/bluefin/rpms.tsvandsurface.tsvare measured from the publishedghcr.io/ublue-os/bluefin:stableimage (scripts/image-baseline.py, feat(baselines): measure Utah against the published Bluefin and Dakota images #264). That covers the base, version-specific, external and multimedia transactions, not justbase.toml..github/workflows/image-baselines.ymlre-measures every week and opens a PR.just checkfails that PR if any new gap has no entry inbaselines/triage.toml.baselines/triage.tomlcovers image gaps, and[unavailable]inpackages/utah.tomlrequires a tracking issue for each entry, enforced by feat(contract): fail CI on stale [unavailable] entries #418.scripts/verify-rpm-contract.pywrites/usr/share/utah/package-origins.{json,txt}.If part of this is still missing, please reopen and name the criterion.
Evidence: 46bc45d (#264) baselines/ + scripts/image-baseline.py; .github/workflows/image-baselines.yml weekly re-measure PR;
just checkfails on untriaged gap (baselines/README.md); 2aeacba (#417) scripts/audit-bluefin-parity.py; scripts/verify-rpm-contract.py generate_provenance_report -> package-origins.jsonClosed in a backlog sweep after verifying against current
main; reopen if this is still reproducible.🤖 Generated with Claude Code