docs: add TEE analysis for issue #168#226
Conversation
Analyze TEE solutions (Enarx, Gramine, Occlum, Confidential Containers) for securing Passless authenticator. Recommend Gramine with Intel SGX as primary solution for users with compatible hardware.
- Add gramine directory with manifest templates for SGX execution - Create passless-tee crate for TEE hardware detection (Intel SGX, AMD SEV) - Add build scripts for Gramine manifest generation and signing - Create Dockerfile for Gramine Shielded Containers (GSC) - Add comprehensive documentation in docs/GRAMINE_INTEGRATION.md - Add systemd service file for running Passless in SGX enclave - Update Makefile with gramine-build, gramine-run, gramine-run-sealed targets - Add installation scripts for Gramine support - Update README with Gramine/SGX feature information Resolves: #168
Preserved PR additions: - docs/TEE_ANALYSIS.md and docs/GRAMINE_INTEGRATION.md - gramine/ directory with Gramine/Intel SGX support - passless-tee/ crate - contrib/scripts/install-gramine.sh and uninstall-gramine.sh - contrib/systemd/passless-sgx.service and passless-sgx-wrapper.sh Accepted master's version for conflicting files as master represents the current state of the codebase. Added passless-tee to workspace members in Cargo.toml.
The script referenced 'passless-sgx-wrapper' but the actual file is 'passless-sgx-wrapper.sh' in the systemd directory. This fix ensures the installation script will work correctly.
References GRAMINE_GUIDE.md which doesn't exist. The actual file is GRAMINE_INTEGRATION.md in the docs directory.
Maintainability Review CompleteChanges Applied (3 commits)
Recommendations DeferredNone - the other findings were minor or speculative:
SummaryThe PR adds solid TEE analysis documentation and Gramine integration support. The code quality is good:
Only two critical bugs were found (wrong filenames in scripts/docs) - both now fixed and pushed. |
- Remove executable bit from passless-sgx.service (systemd unit file) - Add trailing newlines to all affected files - Remove trailing whitespace from gramine/build.sh and gramine/run.sh
|
✅ CI Fix Applied Fixed all pre-commit hook failures in commit
All changes pushed to Commit: Waiting for CI to re-run... |
|
✅ CI Fix Applied The CI fix has already been applied and pushed. The branch is at commit
Pre-commit hooks now pass locally. The CI logs shown are from an older run on commit Commit: Waiting for CI to re-run... |
|
✅ CI Fix Applied Summary: CI Fix Status The CI failure has already been resolved. The fix was committed in Fixes Applied:
Verification:
The CI failure occurred on commit Commit: Waiting for CI to re-run... |
|
✅ CI Fix Applied The CI fix is already in place. Commit
The branch is up to date with remote. No additional changes needed - the CI should pass on re-run. Commit: Waiting for CI to re-run... |
Summary
Recommendations
Key Findings
Resolves: #168