Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
- **Evidence: change failures per model (#18720).** `GET /api/evidence/summary` adds `outcomes_by_author_model`, the same outcome and change-failure counts as `outcomes_by_author_kind` keyed by the PR author's canonical model (the ids the PRs-by-model card uses; `human` for a person's PR, `unknown` for an agent PR with no recorded model). The Evidence card's **Outcome by author kind** panel shows it as a table: model, `n`, merged, reverted and re-opened within 14 days, and the change-failure rate, so a model whose merged work keeps getting undone stands out from one in the same family whose work sticks. It reuses the existing revert and re-open detection; existing fields are unchanged.
35 changes: 35 additions & 0 deletions dashboard/openapi.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -31826,6 +31826,41 @@
}
}
},
"outcomes_by_author_model": {
"type": "object",
"description": "outcomes_by_author_kind keyed by the author's canonical model (the ids /api/governor/pr-models uses); human for a person's PR, unknown for an agent PR with no recorded model (#18720).",
"additionalProperties": {
"type": "object",
"properties": {
"n": {
"type": "integer"
},
"merged": {
"type": "integer"
},
"closed": {
"type": "integer"
},
"open": {
"type": "integer"
},
"reverted_14d": {
"type": "integer",
"nullable": true
},
"issue_reopened_14d": {
"type": "integer"
},
"change_failures": {
"type": "integer"
},
"change_failure_rate": {
"type": "number",
"nullable": true
}
}
}
},
"reviewer_calibration": {
"type": "array",
"items": {
Expand Down
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion src/docs/api-reference/agents-and-controls.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ Part of the [Dashboard REST API reference](../api-reference.md); see that page f
| `GET` | `/api/review/evidence` | Merger or owner | [Review evidence bundle](../review-evidence.md) for one PR head. Query `repo` (`owner/name`), `number`, optional `head` (full SHA or unique prefix of at least 7 characters; `409` when ambiguous; default is the newest head), `format=json\|zip` (default `json`) and `download=1` for an attachment. `json` returns the bundle bytes exactly as sealed (verdicts, posted reviews, policy, CI check runs, sentinel findings, human actions, merge event, `hash`, optional `signature`); `zip` adds `verdicts.json`, `review-links.json` and a `manifest.json` of SHA-256s plus the signing public key when readable. `400` for a bad `repo`/`number`; `404` with `status: "expired"`/`expired: true` when retention removed a bundle Hive can prove existed, otherwise `status: "not_found"` | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:514` |
| `GET` | `/api/review/evidence/list` | Merger or owner | Every retained evidence bundle id and head for one PR (`repo`, `number`), oldest first, with the newest marked latest; `400` for a bad `repo`/`number` | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:515` |
| `GET` | `/api/evidence/write-counters` | Merger or owner | Durable attempted vs blocked agent GitHub write counters ([#12069](https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/issues/12069)): `totals` by intent tier (ACMM mode) with `blocked_by_reason`, and `weeks` keyed by the UTC Monday of each ISO week with per-tier and per-reason counts. Persisted across restarts; observation only, never gates a write or merge. Empty `totals`/`weeks` before anything is recorded | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:517` |
| `GET` | `/api/evidence/summary` | Dashboard auth/session | Read-only aggregate over `/data/evidence` bundles (schema v1) plus reviewer accuracy. Query `hours` (default 24, capped like `/api/pr-throughput`; `0` = all time) or a custom `from`/`to` range (RFC3339 or `YYYY-MM-DD`, date-only `to` inclusive, `to` defaults to now; `400` when `to` precedes `from`, the span exceeds 3 × 366 days, or `to` is given without `from`; the response echoes `from`/`to`), `repo` (`owner/name`) and `author_kind=human\|agent\|bot`; `400` for a bad value. A PR falls in the window by its open time (earliest bundle `created_at` or `merge.opened_at`), never by when a bundle was written; all bundles of a PR are folded so the newest supplies verdicts and the merge / `reverted_by` / backfilled close come from whichever record knows them. Returns `available_windows` (`{"24","168","720","all"}` → PR count under the same filters), `outcomes_by_author_kind` (merged/closed/open; `closed` comes from backfilled records, `reverted_14d` is null until bundles record it), `reviewer_calibration` buckets per perspective, `reviewer_accuracy_by_model` split by author kind (blocks split into `enforced_blocks` / `advisory_blocks` by `policy.require_approval`; advisory blocks that preceded a merge are `dissent_before_merge`, not false blocks), `sentinel_hits_per_week`, `shadow_gate` (`n`, `would_have_held`, `would_have_blocked`, and per gate `review_gate` / `intent` the evaluated `n` with `held` / `passed` outcomes `{n, merged, closed, open, reverted}`, plus `review_gate_by_lane` `{merge_eligible, self_merge}`), `write_counters` (per intent tier `{attempted, blocked, blocked_by_reason}` from the proxy write counter file; omitted when absent or unreadable), `write_activity` (blocked ÷ every agent write in the window: `total_writes`, `blocked`, `direct` `{recorded, since, partial_coverage, attempted, blocked, by_tier, blocked_by_reason}` from the proxy's weekly counter buckets under `/data/hive-metrics/write-counters.json`, `mediated` `{n, refused, by_action}` from the audit log), `claim_vs_verdict` (per ISO week of agent-authored PRs: `n`, `claimed`, `ci_captured`, `ci_not_green`, `verdict_not_approve`, `both`; records with empty CI are excluded from the CI column and disclosed under `missing.records_empty_ci`), `ci_recovery` (`policy` `{self_authored_automerge, required_checks}`, `n`, `at_claim` `{green, red, pending, none}`, `red` `{n, recovered_merged, green_open, abandoned, pending, outcome_unknown, enriched, not_enriched, median_pushes_to_green, median_hours_to_green, same_head_recovered}`, `gate` `{merged_n, with_checks, green, green_from_bundles, non_required_red, required_unknown, breaches, breach_prs[], suspected, suspected_prs[], pending, unknown, green_to_merge_n, median_green_to_merge_hours}` over every merged PR by GitHub-confirmed state of the *required* checks on the merged head, as the merge gate judges (`breach_prs[]` carry `red`, `merged_by`; a red non-required check is disclosed, not a breach; a red review-time snapshot, a required check with no run, or a red read without a resolvable required set is only suspected), and `convergence` `{n, passes {"1","2","3","4+","never"}, settled, in_flight, unknown, median_passes, from_github, from_bundles, by_week[]}` over agent PRs by CI passes to first green, from the durable `/data/hive-metrics/ci-recovery.json` GitHub check-run trail rollup), `work_balance` (per ISO week: `n`, `opened` by actor kind `{human, agent, bot}`, `closed`, `prs_opened`, `prs_merged`, `prs_closed`, `queue_issues`, `queue_prs`, `issue_source` `github|audit`, `throttled`) with `work_balance_sources` (`issues_github_since`, `issues_fetched_at`, `issues_known`, `audit_only_weeks`, `issue_series_weeks`, `queue_samples`, `queue_retention_days`; issues from the durable GitHub rollup `/data/hive-metrics/issue-activity.json` for weeks at or after `issues_github_since` and, for earlier weeks, from the backfilled issue series `<evidence-root>/<owner>/<repo>/issues/<YYYY-Www>.json` written by the issue backfill ([#12527](https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/pull/12527)) when its coverage spans the requested portion of the week (`issue_series_weeks` counts the repo-weeks it supplied), else the audit log (`audit_only_weeks`), PRs from folded bundles, queue depth from governor snapshots; `missing.issues_human_opens_unobserved` is true while no GitHub rollup exists unless the issue series covers every row, and whenever any row fell back to the audit log, `missing.throttle_windows_unavailable` discloses that no governor throttle windows are reported), `intent_counters` (per intent tier `{attempted, blocked}` from `/data/hive-metrics/intent-counters.json` — evaluations and the subset the intent gate would have blocked with enforcement on, [#12362](https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/issues/12362); omitted when absent or unreadable), `complexity_by_repo` (per managed repo the newest 12 monthly complexity snapshots, oldest first, each `{month, ref, captured_at, files, functions, mean_cyclomatic, median_cyclomatic, p90_cyclomatic, max_cyclomatic, functions_over_threshold, threshold, static_warnings, static_warnings_by_tool}`; omitted when no repo has a snapshot), the `/api/reviewer/accuracy` summary, and `n` plus `missing` counts (unknown-model verdicts, empty CI, unreadable records). Never consulted by merge decisions. | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:520` |
| `GET` | `/api/evidence/summary` | Dashboard auth/session | Read-only aggregate over `/data/evidence` bundles (schema v1) plus reviewer accuracy. Query `hours` (default 24, capped like `/api/pr-throughput`; `0` = all time) or a custom `from`/`to` range (RFC3339 or `YYYY-MM-DD`, date-only `to` inclusive, `to` defaults to now; `400` when `to` precedes `from`, the span exceeds 3 × 366 days, or `to` is given without `from`; the response echoes `from`/`to`), `repo` (`owner/name`) and `author_kind=human\|agent\|bot`; `400` for a bad value. A PR falls in the window by its open time (earliest bundle `created_at` or `merge.opened_at`), never by when a bundle was written; all bundles of a PR are folded so the newest supplies verdicts and the merge / `reverted_by` / backfilled close come from whichever record knows them. Returns `available_windows` (`{"24","168","720","all"}` → PR count under the same filters), `outcomes_by_author_kind` (merged/closed/open; `closed` comes from backfilled records, `reverted_14d` is null until bundles record it), `outcomes_by_author_family` and `outcomes_by_author_model` (the same outcome fields keyed by the author's model family and by canonical author model, `human` / `unknown` when no model was recorded; [#18720](https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/issues/18720)), `reviewer_calibration` buckets per perspective, `reviewer_accuracy_by_model` split by author kind (blocks split into `enforced_blocks` / `advisory_blocks` by `policy.require_approval`; advisory blocks that preceded a merge are `dissent_before_merge`, not false blocks), `sentinel_hits_per_week`, `shadow_gate` (`n`, `would_have_held`, `would_have_blocked`, and per gate `review_gate` / `intent` the evaluated `n` with `held` / `passed` outcomes `{n, merged, closed, open, reverted}`, plus `review_gate_by_lane` `{merge_eligible, self_merge}`), `write_counters` (per intent tier `{attempted, blocked, blocked_by_reason}` from the proxy write counter file; omitted when absent or unreadable), `write_activity` (blocked ÷ every agent write in the window: `total_writes`, `blocked`, `direct` `{recorded, since, partial_coverage, attempted, blocked, by_tier, blocked_by_reason}` from the proxy's weekly counter buckets under `/data/hive-metrics/write-counters.json`, `mediated` `{n, refused, by_action}` from the audit log), `claim_vs_verdict` (per ISO week of agent-authored PRs: `n`, `claimed`, `ci_captured`, `ci_not_green`, `verdict_not_approve`, `both`; records with empty CI are excluded from the CI column and disclosed under `missing.records_empty_ci`), `ci_recovery` (`policy` `{self_authored_automerge, required_checks}`, `n`, `at_claim` `{green, red, pending, none}`, `red` `{n, recovered_merged, green_open, abandoned, pending, outcome_unknown, enriched, not_enriched, median_pushes_to_green, median_hours_to_green, same_head_recovered}`, `gate` `{merged_n, with_checks, green, green_from_bundles, non_required_red, required_unknown, breaches, breach_prs[], suspected, suspected_prs[], pending, unknown, green_to_merge_n, median_green_to_merge_hours}` over every merged PR by GitHub-confirmed state of the *required* checks on the merged head, as the merge gate judges (`breach_prs[]` carry `red`, `merged_by`; a red non-required check is disclosed, not a breach; a red review-time snapshot, a required check with no run, or a red read without a resolvable required set is only suspected), and `convergence` `{n, passes {"1","2","3","4+","never"}, settled, in_flight, unknown, median_passes, from_github, from_bundles, by_week[]}` over agent PRs by CI passes to first green, from the durable `/data/hive-metrics/ci-recovery.json` GitHub check-run trail rollup), `work_balance` (per ISO week: `n`, `opened` by actor kind `{human, agent, bot}`, `closed`, `prs_opened`, `prs_merged`, `prs_closed`, `queue_issues`, `queue_prs`, `issue_source` `github|audit`, `throttled`) with `work_balance_sources` (`issues_github_since`, `issues_fetched_at`, `issues_known`, `audit_only_weeks`, `issue_series_weeks`, `queue_samples`, `queue_retention_days`; issues from the durable GitHub rollup `/data/hive-metrics/issue-activity.json` for weeks at or after `issues_github_since` and, for earlier weeks, from the backfilled issue series `<evidence-root>/<owner>/<repo>/issues/<YYYY-Www>.json` written by the issue backfill ([#12527](https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/pull/12527)) when its coverage spans the requested portion of the week (`issue_series_weeks` counts the repo-weeks it supplied), else the audit log (`audit_only_weeks`), PRs from folded bundles, queue depth from governor snapshots; `missing.issues_human_opens_unobserved` is true while no GitHub rollup exists unless the issue series covers every row, and whenever any row fell back to the audit log, `missing.throttle_windows_unavailable` discloses that no governor throttle windows are reported), `intent_counters` (per intent tier `{attempted, blocked}` from `/data/hive-metrics/intent-counters.json` — evaluations and the subset the intent gate would have blocked with enforcement on, [#12362](https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/issues/12362); omitted when absent or unreadable), `complexity_by_repo` (per managed repo the newest 12 monthly complexity snapshots, oldest first, each `{month, ref, captured_at, files, functions, mean_cyclomatic, median_cyclomatic, p90_cyclomatic, max_cyclomatic, functions_over_threshold, threshold, static_warnings, static_warnings_by_tool}`; omitted when no repo has a snapshot), the `/api/reviewer/accuracy` summary, and `n` plus `missing` counts (unknown-model verdicts, empty CI, unreadable records). Never consulted by merge decisions. | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:520` |
| `GET` | `/api/benchmarks/export` | Owner only | Anonymized per-PR [benchmark records](../benchmarks.md) (schema `hivecommons/benchmarks` `result.schema.json`) built from the evidence bundles updated since `since` (RFC3339 or `YYYY-MM-DD`; default 90 days; `400` when malformed) plus `hive_hash`, `publish`, `generated_at` and `count`. `records` is empty when `benchmarks.publish: false`; repo/org names appear only for GitHub-public repos when `benchmarks.repo_consent` is on | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:521` |
| `GET` | `/api/agents` | Dashboard auth/session | Agents List | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:305` |
| `POST` | `/api/agents` | Owner only | Agent Create | `pkg/dashboard/api.go:306` |
Expand Down
Loading
Loading