You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
🐛 Parent auto-close closes epics and ignores a maintainer's reopen (torch-spyre/spyre-inference#756) #18869
Hive's decomposed-parent auto-close (closeDecomposedParent, src/pkg/github/decomposed_parents.go, marker hive:parent-autoclose) closes any issue whose tracked children are all closed. It has no exemption for epics and ignores a human reopening it.
Seen on torch-spyre/spyre-inference#756 ([EPIC] Performance parity for multi-modal models, labelled EPIC): hive closed it on 2026-10-19, 2026-11-12, and twice on 2026-11-17 (22:03Z and 22:18Z). The maintainer reopened it each time ("multi-modal perf work is still in flight (e.g. #1471), so this epic is not complete") and then asked "Please stop closing the issue". Hive closed it again 7 minutes after that request. The project worked around it by adding a dummy open sub-issue.
Wanted
Never auto-close a parent that a human has reopened (a reopened event by a non-hive actor after a hive autoclose). A reopen is a maintainer saying the work is not done; hive must not override it. Persist this (marker label such as hive/keep-open, or derive from the timeline) so it survives restarts.
Never auto-close issues labelled EPIC/epic, or hold, unless the repo opts in by config (issues.parent_autoclose: true|false|epics_too). Epics stay open until a person closes them.
Config switch to disable parent auto-close per repo, documented, and shown in the dashboard issue row (pill "kept open: reopened by ").
Closing remains the default only for scanner-decomposed parents that hive itself created.
A hive agent asked to open a pull request that would close this issue, but it is already claimed by clubanderson. No PR was opened; the owner decides whether to proceed.
Fixed by #18871 (merged to v5, 8ce72d8). Epic/hold-labelled parents are no longer auto-closed, a parent a person reopened after a hive auto-close is never re-closed, and repos.<repo>.parent_autoclose (true | epics_too | false) is documented. Follow-up not done: dashboard pill 'kept open: reopened by '. The v6 top-up will carry this via the daily top-up PR.
@joerunde FYI: this is the fix for the hive closing epics (torch-spyre/spyre-inference#756 was closed by the parent auto-close sweep five times, including twice right after a maintainer reopened it and asked it to stop). It is merged to v5 as 8ce72d8. After this, the sweep never closes an issue labelled EPIC or hold and never re-closes a parent a human reopened; repos can switch it off with repos..parent_autoclose: false. It reaches your hive with the next hive build, which I will roll out for you. Until then, keep the sub-issue you added on #756 and please do not close or reopen it again.
Activity
clubanderson commentedon Nov 18, 2026
Claimed; fix in progress.
hivecommons-hive commentedon Nov 18, 2026
A hive agent asked to open a pull request that would close this issue, but it is already claimed by clubanderson. No PR was opened; the owner decides whether to proceed.
🐛 Never auto-close epics or parents a person reopened (#18869) (#18871)
clubanderson commentedon Nov 18, 2026
Fixed by #18871 (merged to v5, 8ce72d8). Epic/hold-labelled parents are no longer auto-closed, a parent a person reopened after a hive auto-close is never re-closed, and
repos.<repo>.parent_autoclose(true | epics_too | false) is documented. Follow-up not done: dashboard pill 'kept open: reopened by '. The v6 top-up will carry this via the daily top-up PR.clubanderson commentedon Nov 18, 2026
@joerunde FYI: this is the fix for the hive closing epics (torch-spyre/spyre-inference#756 was closed by the parent auto-close sweep five times, including twice right after a maintainer reopened it and asked it to stop). It is merged to v5 as 8ce72d8. After this, the sweep never closes an issue labelled EPIC or hold and never re-closes a parent a human reopened; repos can switch it off with repos..parent_autoclose: false. It reaches your hive with the next hive build, which I will roll out for you. Until then, keep the sub-issue you added on #756 and please do not close or reopen it again.