Repository navigation
Description
Use case
An operator pastes the whole inception interview into Dashboard Hive Chat as one message: answer 1 to answer 7, submit, approve, one per line. Only the first line runs. The rest becomes text inside answer 1. The operator gets no warning.
Test on the v6 edge spoke, as owner:
- The paste is chat seq 81: 709 characters, 8 newlines, 9
!inceptiontokens. - The bot sends one reply:
✅ Recorded answer 1 (1 of 7)…. - The audit has no
inception_answerand noinception_approveafter the paste. The phase staysclarify, andanswersis{}. - After a separate
!inception submit,answers.languageis 689 characters. It is the paste without the!inception answer 1prefix. It has 9 lines and 8!inceptiontokens. - The state has only the key
language. Questions 2 to 7 have no answer. - The
languageconstitution fact has the same 689-character body. - The scaffold is
lang=go, while the answer starts withC++ CLI application…. - A separate
!inception approveworks:inception_approveis in the audit.
The reply to submit is ✅ Submitted 1 answers. The remaining 6 questions use their defaults. Nothing says that the answer holds other commands.
Affected: operators who run inception through chat and paste several commands.
Proposed solution
When one chat message has several lines that start with !, run each line as its own command, in order. Each command sends its own reply, as if it had been sent alone.
A message with a single command behaves as today.
Alternatives considered
Free-text description. The operator writes a paragraph or multiple paragraphs or a engineered prompt or text ref, not commands. The agent maps it to the questions, shows what it understood for the operator to confirm, and asks only about the gaps. This matches how people describe a project. It is a larger change, because the agent step decides the result. It also changes the fixed 5–7 question flow in brainstorm-advisory.md.
Workaround today. Send one command per message. This works, but it gives no hint to the operator that a paste is stored as one answer.
Scope and compatibility
- Target branch or version:
v6. - Operator impact: a pasted block of
!inceptioncommands runs as written. Today it stores 9 lines as one answer. - Contributor/agent impact: the chat router,
src/pkg/chat/router.go, handles one command per message. - Migration or backwards-compatibility concerns: a message with one command is unchanged. Behaviour for lines that do not start with
!is not specified here. Unprefixed replies were not tested.
Additional context
By the code at 15a6de7fc:
routeMessage(src/pkg/chat/router.go:118-125) strips the first!and splits once on the first space.cmdisinception.argsis the rest of the message, newlines included.cmdInception(src/pkg/chat/inception.go:69-75) takes the next word as the subcommand.restis everything after it.cmdInceptionAnswer(src/pkg/chat/inception.go:206-233) splitsrestonce on a space. The first part is the number. The second part is the whole remainder of the message. It is stored as the answer.- No inbound code splits a message into several commands. The
Split("\n")calls insrc/pkg/chat/are for SSE parsing, outbound message splitting and error summaries. docs/inception.md:122-136describes one command per message. It does not mention a multi-line paste.
Environment: Hive Hub spoke on Kubernetes, https://availableslotlke648397260827-9hmc-k3sw.lke.hive.hivecommons.dev, branch v6, channel edge, commit 15a6de7fc (release 6.30.1). Operator kanrenibm, role owner. Date 2026-11-15.
Timeline (UTC):
12:28:34 inception_start
12:32:28 chat.dashboard.message seq=81 (the paste)
12:33:52 chat.dashboard.message seq=84 (!inception state: only question 1 has a check mark)
12:34:20 chat.dashboard.message seq=86 (!inception submit)
12:34:20 inception_answer count=1
12:37:46 chat.dashboard.message seq=91 (!inception approve)
12:37:47 inception_approve
Related: the scaffold language in this run is not C++. That is a separate bug.
Not determined:
- Whether the brainstorm agent used the other six answers from inside the stored text. The facts mention those topics, but the kick text is not logged in full.
- Other chat backends were not tested. Only Dashboard Hive Chat.
Full logs: logs/step0_* to logs/step5_*.
Activity
hivecommons-hive commentedon Nov 15, 2026
Thanks — this hive only works issues from OWNER, MEMBER, COLLABORATOR automatically. A maintainer can admit this one by adding the label
triage/accepted(configured inissue_filter.reporter_trust.untrusted_require_labels). Until then the hive will not claim, label, or open PRs for it. See https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/blob/HEAD/GOVERNANCE.md#reporter-trust-and-escalation for what these terms mean and how to become a trusted reporter.clubanderson commentedon Nov 17, 2026
Closing as obsolete in its current form. #18419 (merged 2026-11-16) retired the inception API, and the v6 chat
!inceptioncommand still calls those removed routes, so the whole command is currently broken, not just multi-line pastes. Tracked as #18565, which moves chat inception onto Inception (Spek) sessions or removes it, and carries forward your multi-line requirement: each line runs in order, or the message is refused clearly, and later lines are never folded into the first answer. Thanks for the thorough report.github-actions commentedon Nov 17, 2026
@kanrenibm this issue was closed by @clubanderson as not planned.
If this was closed by a merged PR, the fix only takes effect once it ships in a tagged release and your deployment updates to it — check your running version against the fix before concluding the fix failed.
If you are still seeing the problem, comment
/reopenand it will be reopened for you — you do not need write access. Please add what you are still observing (running version, logs, steps) so it is not closed the same way again.