Repository navigation
Description
What happened?
In chat Inception, the language answer is not used for the scaffold. The scaffold is generated as Go.
- Answer 1 (language) was
C++ CLI application with GitHub API SDK. The state stored it unchanged. - Hive log:
ProduceScaffold complete,"files":13,"lang":"go". - The files include
go.mod,main.go,cmd/root.go,main_test.go,Makefile.Dockerfilestarts withFROM golang:1.23-alpine. README.md,AGENTS.mdandCLAUDE.mddescribe a C++ CLI. The scaffold mixes C++ text with Go files.- Chat and the log do not say that the answer was not used.
A previous run on the same spoke answered python. Its scaffold also lists go.mod and main.go.
Impact: the operator gets a project in a language they did not choose, with no warning.
Expected behavior
The scaffold uses the language the operator answered. If Hive cannot generate that language, it says so. It does not switch to Go silently.
Reproduction steps
- In Dashboard Hive Chat, as
owner, send!inception start I want to create an Agent that analyze all the GitHub issue and categorize into different kind of issues based on Labels , description, title, and keywords. - Send
!inception answer 1 C++ CLI application with GitHub API SDK. - Send answers 2 to 7 with any text. Answer 7 submits the batch (
✅ Submitted 7 answers.). - Wait for phase
scaffold. It took 33 seconds in this run. - Read
GET /api/inception/scaffoldorGET /api/inception/state. - The file list has
go.modandmain.go. The state hasanswers.language=C++ CLI application with GitHub API SDK.
Environment
- Branch/version:
v6, channeledge, commit15a6de7fc(release 6.30.1). - Deployment method: Hive Hub (hub-managed spoke, Kubernetes).
- Hive URL: https://availableslotlke648397260827-9hmc-k3sw.lke.hive.hivecommons.dev
- Operating system or Kubernetes version: not recorded.
- Relevant configuration: operator
kanrenibm, roleowner. Brainstorm agent: backendclaude, modelclaude-sonnet-5-5. Date 2026-11-15.
Logs or screenshots
State, GET /api/inception/state (phase scaffold):
"answers": { "language": "C++ CLI application with GitHub API SDK", ... }
Hive log (times -05:00):
06:49:18.941 inception answers submitted answer_count=7
06:49:52.244 supplemented facts from Q&A original=8 supplemented=7 total=15
06:49:53.351 facts extracted, advancing to scaffold count=15
06:49:54.473 ProduceScaffold complete files=13 lang=go project_type=container
06:49:55.370 ProduceScaffold complete files=13 lang=go project_type=container
The log has no scaffold language cross-check override line.
GET /api/inception/ideation-facts, the two constitution facts:
constitution-constitution-read-only-analysis-no-data-leakage body: "The tool MUST NOT close, delete, or otherwise mutate issues; ..."
constitution-what-languageruntime-only-if-not-inferable-from-the-idea body: "C++ CLI application with GitHub API SDK"
GET /api/inception/scaffold, 13 paths: README.md, AGENTS.md, CONTRIBUTING.md, CLAUDE.md, .github/workflows/ci.yml, .github/workflows/nightly.yml, .gitignore, go.mod, main.go, cmd/root.go, main_test.go, Makefile, Dockerfile.
go.mod: module vision-c-cli, go 1.23, require github.com/spf13/cobra v1.8.1.
Full logs: logs/step4_* (this run) and logs/step0_* (previous run, answer python).
Additional context
By the code at 15a6de7fc:
ProduceScaffold(src/pkg/knowledge/inception.go:632) callsinferLanguage(constitution). It does not read the answers.inferLanguage(inception.go:3755-3783) matches keywords for TypeScript, Python, JavaScript, Rust, Java and shell. No match returnsgo(line 3781).- The cross-check (
inception.go:636-642) reads only the idea text. The idea text in this run names no language, so no override applies. - The language fact comes from the Q&A step (
src/pkg/dashboard/inception_watcher.go:1068-1117). It maps thelanguagequestion to aconstitutionfact whose body is the raw answer. docs/inception.md:20-21lists Go, Python, TypeScript, JavaScript, Rust, Java and shell. It does not say what happens for another language.
For this run, neither constitution fact contains a keyword from those lists, so both reach the go default.
Not determined:
- Why the previous run (answer
python) also got Go.findFactByType(inception.go:2152) returns the firstconstitutionfact. Which one is first depends on file order, and the files on the spoke were not read. - Who called
ProduceScaffoldat 06:49:54 and 06:49:55. The chat code does not call it. - Languages other than C++ and Python were not tested.
A separate gap: after the batch is submitted and after !inception approve, chat does not mention the scaffold.
Activity
hivecommons-hive commentedon Nov 15, 2026
Thanks — this hive only works issues from OWNER, MEMBER, COLLABORATOR automatically. A maintainer can admit this one by adding the label
triage/accepted(configured inissue_filter.reporter_trust.untrusted_require_labels). Until then the hive will not claim, label, or open PRs for it. See https://github.com/hivecommons/hive/blob/HEAD/GOVERNANCE.md#reporter-trust-and-escalation for what these terms mean and how to become a trusted reporter.clubanderson commentedon Nov 17, 2026
Closing as obsolete. #18419 (merged 2026-11-16) removed the inception watcher and the Go scaffold generator this report was about (
ProduceScaffoldno longer exists on v5 or v6), and inception now runs as Spek sessions. Thank you for the precise repro, the log lines made it easy to confirm. The underlying expectation still stands: a project scaffold should use the language the operator chose. If you can retest the language answer on an Inception (Spek) session and it is ignored there too, please open a new issue against the session flow and link this one.github-actions commentedon Nov 17, 2026
@kanrenibm this issue was closed by @clubanderson as not planned.
If this was closed by a merged PR, the fix only takes effect once it ships in a tagged release and your deployment updates to it — check your running version against the fix before concluding the fix failed.
If you are still seeing the problem, comment
/reopenand it will be reopened for you — you do not need write access. Please add what you are still observing (running version, logs, steps) so it is not closed the same way again.