You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Contributor-lane PRs park at 085 needs-decision during CI/Review with no finding surfaced #15640
hive's own hosted spoke, 2026-10-29 ~22:30 EDT: ~12 contributor-lane PRs authored by contributors' clankers (#15312, #15324, #15343, #15410, #15433, #15482, #15487, #15489, crux#53, docs#514, docs#518) sat 3–21h. Issue labels stayed stage/040-covered-by-pr; the tracker showed "PR in progress · @x's clanker" in CI/Review. Every cycle:
stage labels: reviewer verdict route … raw_verdict=requires_human decision_requested=true stage=085-needs-decision reason=contributor-lane:decision-requested
merge train: PR left out of every train why=human-merge
Nothing on the PR said what the review had found; nothing surfaced a decision anywhere a person looks.
Owner rule
there should be no decisions by a human while these are in ci/review — unless the review found something.
Root cause
The review swarm did run. The reviewer's decision_requested marker forces every perspective to requires_human, and aggregateReports honoured it blindly for non-hive-authored PRs (hive-authored PRs already go through the DecisionRiskClasses denylist). Nothing checked whether the question was backed by a finding, and nothing carried what was found into the verdict record.
The 085 comment was posted, but stage labels were withheld by the write-back gate (stage_label kind needs the hive-review opt-in at L5 for non-hive-authored items — by design), so the issue stayed at 040 and the tracker fell back to "PR in progress" (display side fixed by 🐛 adoption: offline clanker PRs don't stall at 'PR in progress' #15593, not yet rolled).
Expected
While a PR is in CI/Review the hive runs CI + the review swarm to completion. A person is asked only when the review found something concrete (duplicate, trust-surface/risk-class question, high-risk marker, finding at the human threshold, unresolvable red CI), and the record says what. A contributor PR that needs a human's merge click waits at the merge gate (090, human-merge rule), not at 085 during review.
Activity
🐛 review: only a security finding parks an untrusted PR during CI/Review
🐛 review: only a security finding parks an untrusted PR during CI/Rev…
🐛 fix: keep a contributor PR's security hold when a sibling perspecti…