You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
dashboard: "Let hive decide — preview" is a wall of text (doubled "Hive would", contradictory merge button, no hierarchy) #15397
Screenshot of the "Let hive decide — preview" dialog on hive's own spoke, for #15332:
yikes - this is a mess. different fonts, repeated wording, placement of text and buttons, explanation is confusing.
and, after a first pass:
this needs to be exceedingly simple to understand and act on.
What the dialog showed
Let hive decide — preview
⚠ hivecommons/hive#15332 — Sentinel flagged security-relevant changes at 7af26e9: changes 1 sensitive path(s)
hivecommons/hive#15332 — Hive would: Hive would: send #15332 back with direction: make CI green without widening scope; keep the smallest reversible change, then it merges. Why: The head is not mergeable yet; the direction names the fix and nothing else.
• hive posts the direction on #15332
• the author's clanker pushes a new commit; the row moves when it lands
It records a "/hive decision" (or a recommendation when the question is the hive's own policy), lifts the park and stamps an audit marker. Rails: it never merges, never acts on a held item, never grants secrets or permissions, and leaves the sentinel label to a person.
[Cancel] [Approve & merge as-is] [Let hive do that]
Problems
"Hive would: Hive would:" — the prefix is composed twice (the plan API's summary already carries it and stageTrackerDelegatePlanText prepends it again).
repo#number repeated on two lines.
Three type sizes/colours with no hierarchy; the "then" bullets are inlined into a paragraph.
The rails footer is boilerplate that drowns the one decision that matters.
"Approve & merge as-is" is offered although the preview itself says the head is not mergeable — a contradictory action. It must be hidden (or disabled with a reason) when the ladder (🐛 Let hive decide: close already-fixed PRs instead of adopting them #15301decision.ladder) / head facts rule out mergeable-as-is.
Button placement/alignment is inconsistent with the other hive dialogs (.hive-dialog-btn family).
Target
Readable in 3 seconds: title + one subject line; one verb-first decision sentence in plain words; one why line (≤ 12 words); at most two "then" items; everything else (rails, ruled-out rungs, sentinel detail) behind a single collapsed Details. Exactly two buttons by default — [Cancel] [Let hive do that] — a third only when the item is mergeable as-is. No jargon in the visible text (no "park", "audit marker", "stage", "ladder", "/hive decision"). Visible text ≤ 60 words for the #15332 case, enforced by a test. One renderer shared by PR, issue and the adopt/close/return variants from #15301.
Activity
🐛 dashboard: Let hive decide preview is one clear decision, not a wal…