Skip to content

Activity Monitor: operator-readability findings from a live walkthrough (12:11–16:59 ET, 0470256 → aa9b530) #15096

Closed

Description

@clubanderson

Why

Owner (2026-10-28 12:11 ET, verbatim):

Hive is doing the right things mostly; we now need to keep the user informed of it — like a video game they can watch and see what happens easily.

Right now I look at these rows and want to take action, but I need to know what my options are; once I act I need to see that I acted and what I chose; I need to see that work is in progress. Throughout the Activity Monitor we need visual cues for (a) current state, (b) whether work is happening in that state, (c) what decisions humans and hive made. This has to be exceedingly clear, easy to read, and concise.

Owner (12:14 ET): the game is a mental model for what must always be legible — position, moving vs waiting, what's blocking, transitions, failures, completion — not a visual theme. Professional, enterprise-acceptable; plain legend words (working / waiting on X / set back by Y / merged); 150–300 ms transitions, one gentle highlight on change, understated merge celebration.

Method

Live, read-only walkthrough of hive's own hosted dashboard (hive.hivecommons.dev, Activity Monitor, 40–47 rows) through the operator's Chrome tab via CDP, four passes: 12:11 and 12:29 ET on 0470256, 14:17 on 9627b20, 16:59 on aa9b530 (after #14995 #15013 #15014 #15011 #15016 #15056 #15060 #15063 #15080 #15084 rolled). Each pass: full-board screenshot, every chevron / pill / age / tooltip / ⋯ menu read as a human would, graded per row on

(a) can I tell the state and why · (b) is hive working on it right now vs waiting, on what · (c) what decisions were made, by whom, when · (d) what can I do next and what will it cause · (e) 2-minute watch test: if I just watched the screen, would I know what hive did?

Spot-checked against GitHub (gh pr view … --json labels,state,mergeStateStatus, ≤1 call per row per pass). Full per-row tables and screenshots for every pass are in the operator's ~/hive-work/op-eyes/<ts>/findings.md.

Activity Monitor 12:11 ET, before the roll — every amber chevron looks identical whether Soaking, CI/Review, Fixing or a 26h-old Returned to contributor

Consolidated findings — status after aa9b530

Legend: ✅ fixed on the live board · 🟡 partially / shipped-but-not-observed · ❌ open · PR = covered by a merged/open PR (checked by number).

# Finding (exact UI text) Grade After roll Covered by Suggested
G1 No cue that hive is working on a row. 16:59: top bar scanner RUNNING NOW, adjudicator RUNNING NOW ×2, reviewer queued UP NEXT, yet 0 of 47 rows carried cue-working/cue-acting. Fixing · 5h (#14921), Fixing · 12h (docs#500), Soaking, Ready for auto merge all render a static chevron. b ❌ e ❌ 🟡 #15014 shipped the spinner/stripes, but they fire only on operator actions Drive the working cue from hive's own activity (SSE already consumed by the tracker): working: adjudicator · 40s, reviewer queued · 2nd. New scope.
G2 Red "needs human" breathe (data-motion=needs-human) on rows nobody is waiting for a human on: Open · blocked · since 3h (#15030 #15045 #15047 #15089 — tooltip: "lifts when PR merges"), Actionable · blocked (#14636), Actionable · stalled (#14598), Returned to contributor · Next move: clanker (#15064). b ❌ 🟡 chip count fixed (Needs human 13, was 19) #15013 fixed the chip Breathe only when Next move: human; blocked/returned rows get a static amber "waiting on #14945 / @login". New scope.
G3 Age has no tooltip and no stable meaning. since resets on every hop (#14976 bounced Actionable → CI/Review → Actionable → Needs human in 2h, each time now), is blank on all Open · hold rows, and disagrees between issue and PR rows (#15009 3h vs 1h; #15051 2h vs 25m). a ⚠️ ❌ — Tooltip "in this stage since 01:58 · last hive action 11:44 (nudge #2)"; always render age; +N hops marker when a row has bounced.
G4 Pills without tooltips: hold +1, needs rebase, regressed +1, stage ↓, v5/v6/main, tracker 2/4, needs human (mod pill). hold never says who/when/why. +N never expands. c ❌ d ⚠️ 🟡 (waiting on @x (online, 1 nudge) and stalled +2 now have tooltips) #15070/#15054 (presence on waiting-on pill) hold · @clubanderson · Oct 12 · "wait for v6 epic"; expand +N on hover.
G5 Decision trail has no actor / time / reason — only Trail: Actionable → Claimed → Actionable → Covered by PR inside the issue-number tooltip. No row at 16:59 showed a decision badge although Merged today lists actions minutes earlier. c ❌ e ❌ 🟡 shipped, not observed #14992 (badge shows what you chose), #15003 (closed) Row-level trail chips Claimed by scanner 09:55 → Returned (conflicting) 10:42 → nudge ×2 → adopted 12:46.
G6 ⋯ menu items state no consequence: Hold, Re-evaluate now rescan, Mark needs-human…, Let hive decide delegate, Approve (/lgtm + /approve), Give direction…. Decide PR #14822… ▸ submenu does not open on hover. Hold offered on a row already on hold (#7563). d ❌ ❌ #15085 / #15087 add actions, not explanations One-line consequence under each item: "adds hold to #14822; hive stops touching it until released". Hide Mark needs-human… / Hold when already in that state.
G7 No post-action acknowledgement visible on the row (what I chose, when). c ❌ e ❌ 🟡 shipped #15014 toasts, #14992 badge Verify on next operator action; keep the last event per row (see N3).
G8 Stage headers (Merge gate), the ✓ column and since header have no tooltips. a ⚠️ ❌ — Header tooltips; label the ✓ column "Merged".
G9 Meta updated 2s ago · stale (contradictory; was · fresh at 14:17, back to · stale at 16:59); anomalies chip with no count. a ⚠️ ❌ — "cache 2s · GitHub data 4m old"; "0 anomalies".
G10 Jargon in the only "why" text: review gate: no review bundle, adoption stalled: contributor lane: workflow path, 085 park is overwritten by 071/072, 085 tooltip lists three possible causes ("sentinel alert, hold/needs-decision label or human-only rule") instead of the actual one. a ⚠️ 🟡 (090 text and the hold popover are plain English ✅) #14995 (popover), #15063 (plain-words decision outcome) Name the actual cause and actor: "needs-decision set by reviewer @x at 10:31: approve-with-rationale".
G11 Rows that finish vanish without an end state. Merges now celebrate ✅, but PRs closed unmerged / superseded (PR #14979, PR #14939 off #7563) simply disappeared between passes. e ❌ 🟡 #15014 / #15060 (merge only), #15011 (auto-close superseded) Brief Closed · superseded by #N / Closed unmerged end state before the row leaves the board.
G12 stage ↓ (#15061), regressed +1 (#15064) markers have no from→to / reason; cue-setback class present on 3 rows but renders nothing visible. a ⚠️ 🟡 (stalled +2 now shows "080 Merge gate → 070 Fixing at 04:26 because conflicting" ✅) #15014 (setback event line) Same from→to+reason text on every setback marker, visible on the row not only in a tooltip.

New after aa9b530

# Finding Grade Covered by Suggested
N1 Needs-human popover does not open on stage-085 rows. Clicking Needs human decision 👤 (button.ham-decision-trigger[aria-haspopup=dialog]) on #14816, #14633, #14976: aria-expanded stays false, no .ham-decision-pop, no JS error. It works on Open · hold rows (#13216: "Should the hive work on this issue? … Accept triage / Release hold / Mark needs-human"). d ❌ regression in #14995 — not covered Fix the trigger→popover wiring for 045/085/090 (likely issue-key vs PR-key on nested rows).
N2 The chevron lost its hover text: title="", the text moved to data-ham-tip which nothing renders. Hovering Needs human decision now shows nothing (regression vs. 12:11). a ⚠️ not covered Render data-ham-tip through the custom tooltip or restore title.
N3 cue-event line ("Hive: unblocked · 1m ago") appeared once and faded; 10 min later zero event lines on 47 rows despite 5 merges in 40 min. A spectator who arrives late sees nothing. e ⚠️ #15014 (fades by design) Keep the last event per row persistent (dimmed, with age); fade only the highlight. One line per row.
N4 Ready for auto merge (#15083, #15088) shows no queue position / soak timer / gate it waits on — visually identical to Soaking. Soak countdown ("23m left") exists only in the tooltip. b ⚠️ #15084 (vocabulary) partially Queued · behind 2 · soak 23m left on the chevron.
N5 Fixing with no fixer evidence for 5h / 12h; the stalled pill was removed from #14910/#14911 while nothing changed. b ❌ not covered After N min without a fixer run: Fix not started · 5h + Re-kick action.
N6 Top-bar agents (adjudicator RUNNING NOW) are not linked to rows — no row can say "adjudicator is on this". b ❌ e ❌ not covered (same root as G1) Per-row working cue from agent kicks.

Contradictions with GitHub seen during the walkthrough

⋯ menu on a Needs-human row — no consequence text on any item; the Decide submenu does not open on hover

16:59 ET on aa9b530 — new chips and counters; no row carries a working cue although three agents are RUNNING NOW

The needs-human popover opens on an Open · hold row (#13216) but not on any stage-085 Needs human decision chevron

Proposed acceptance test (the 2-minute watch)

Open the Activity Monitor and don't touch it for two minutes. For every row that changed you should be able to say, without hovering or clicking: where it is, whether hive is working on it (and which agent), what it is waiting on, what just happened to it (who/what, how long ago), and — if it left the board — how it ended.

Activity

  1. clubanderson commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @clubanderson
    MemberAuthor

    Iterations 5 (17:14, aa9b530) and 6 (17:17, after roll 2 → dd412e4)

    Activity Monitor on dd412e4

    50 rows. Meta updated 1s ago · stale. Top bar: reviewer queued UP NEXT, reviewer, scanner. Chips Needs human 12, On hold 12, Merged today: 33 (#14701 17:06, #14989 16:56, #15042 16:48).
    Screenshots: 00-activity-monitor-full.jpg, 01-viewport.jpg.

    2-minute-watch (16:59 → 17:14)

    Row Then Now Spectator verdict
    #14633 → PR #14701 Needs human decision 7h PR in progress · 10h, PR sub-row gone ❌ Contradicts reality: #14701 merged at 17:06 (per Merged-today tooltip) yet the row tooltip says "An open PR #14701 covers this issue (PR at 074 adopted by hive)". The issue went backwards on the board (Merge gate → PR in progress) when its PR merged. No "merged ✓ · closing" end state. Who decided (Let hive decide → adopt → merge)? Not shown. (G11 + G5)
    #15083 → PR #15086 Ready for auto merge · 6m Ready for human merge · untrusted author · 1m ❌ Hive-authored PR (@hivecommons-hive[bot], author/hive) labelled "untrusted author"; vocabulary flipped within 15 min with no event line. GH label 090 matches UI, so the stage derivation is wrong, not the display. New N7.
    #15036 Needs human decision 2h Actionable · 5m ⚠️ Someone answered — trail "Claimed → Needs human decision → Actionable", no who/when/what. (G5)
    #15051 → #15070 Needs human decision Needs author · 2h ⚠️ needs rebase pill vanished; age unchanged although state changed (G3).
    #15061 Adopted by hive · stage ↓ Soaking · 1m ⚠️ stage ↓ vanished silently; soak countdown only in tooltip (N4).
    #15025 CI / Review · now Fixing · now ⚠️ Set back — no cue-setback text, no reason on row (G12).
    #14993 Open · 4h Actionable · 6m ✅ hop visible.
    event line — one cue-event fading: "Hive: Hive adopted this PR; hive is addressing the review findings — review swarm requ…" 1m ago; gone 60s later ⚠️ Text is a full sentence, doubles "Hive: Hive", truncated — not the "concise one line" the owner asked for. (N3)
    cue-working 0 rows 0 rows (spinners 0) while reviewer queued UP NEXT ❌ G1 unchanged.

    Global re-grade (unchanged from iteration 4 unless noted)

    G1 ❌ · G2 🟡 · G3 ❌ (confirmed again: #15051) · G4 🟡 · G5 ❌ (#14633, #15036 decisions invisible) · G6 ❌ · G7 🟡 · G8 ❌ · G9 ❌ (stale) · G10 🟡 · G11 ❌ (#14701 merged → row regressed instead of ending) · G12 🟡 (#15025 setback silent) · N1 not re-tested · N3 ⚠️ (event line verbose/duplicated prefix).

    New


    Operator-eyes — iteration 6 — 17:17 ET — AFTER ROLL 2 (dd412e4) (#15056/15060/15063/15080/15084 live)

    Banner: "Upgraded aa9b530 → dd412e4: 9 unreleased changes." 50 rows; chips Needs human 11 / On hold 12 / Merged today 33. Tab picked up the new frontend without reload.
    Screenshots: 00-activity-monitor-full.jpg, 01-viewport.jpg.

    Re-grade after roll 2

    # Finding aa9b530 dd412e4 Evidence
    G1 Working-vs-waiting cue ❌ ❌ open cue-working rows = 0, spinners 0, while top bar shows scanner reviewer reviewer active.
    G2 Motion only on needs-human 🟡 🟡 unchanged.
    G3 Age resets/doesn't reflect state change ❌ ❌ #14633 since empty; #15095 Open · since 18m but age column blank.
    G4 Which agent is on it 🟡 🟡 agent names only in header, not on rows.
    G5 Decision trail: who/when/what ❌ 🟡 partial Popover now says "Asked by the hive · 1 hour ago" / "Asked by triage" (#15063) — question is attributed; the answer still isn't (#15036 "Actionable" with lingering needs human decision chip, no actor).
    G6 Option consequences ❌ 🟡 partial Popover text explains outcome of hold ("the hive does nothing until the hold is released") and accept triage; ⋯ menu items still bare verbs ("Hold", "Won't fix…").
    G7 Event line / transition visibility 🟡 🟡 0 event lines captured in two evals; transitions (#15088 Ready for auto merge → Awaiting merge gate) silent.
    G8 Blocker named on row ❌ 🟡 partial #15088 now reads "Awaiting merge gate · open PR #15090 covers it (PR at 060-reviewed)" and #14934 "Soaking · soak window complete" (#15084 vocabulary) — but "soak window complete" + Next move: hive with no motion = is anyone merging it?
    G9 stale meta ❌ ❌ "updated 2s ago · stale" still contradictory.
    G10 Needs-human discoverability 🟡 🟡 chip + popover good; see N1.
    G11 Merged rows vanish / issue row regresses ❌ ❌ #14633 still "PR in progress · An open PR covers this issue" 11 min after PR #14701 merged.
    G12 stage ↓/stalled markers w/o tooltip 🟡 🟡 unchanged.
    N1 Decision popover doesn't open on PR-parked (085) rows ❌ ❌ still open DOM click on trigger of #14816/#15009/#14938 (stage 40, tip "stage/085-needs-decision… Next move: human") → no .ham-decision-pop. Control: #13216 (hold) and #14976 (045) open fine. Operator must use ⋯ → "Decide PR …▸" instead; nothing tells them that.
    N2 Trigger has title="", tip only in data-ham-tip ⚠️ ⚠️ unchanged (no native hover text).
    N3 Event line verbose/duplicated "Hive: Hive …" ⚠️ not observed no event lines fired during capture.
    N4 Soak countdown hidden ⚠️ 🟡 "soak window complete" now on chevron; remaining time still tooltip-only.
    N7 Hive-authored PR labelled "untrusted author" ❌ ❌ #15083→#15086 and #15009→#15017 (author/hive, @hivecommons-hive[bot]) both "Ready for human merge · untrusted author".
    N8 No end state on issue row when nested PR merges ❌ ❌ #14633.

    Good after roll 2

    Still the two biggest gaps for the "watch for 2 minutes" test

    1. Nothing moves while hive works (G1) — zero working cues across 6 iterations, including with 3 agents running.
    2. Decisions and merges leave no trace on the row (G5/G11/N8) — the board reverts rather than concludes.
  2. added
    help wantedDenotes an issue that needs help from a contributor. Must meet "help wanted" guidelines.
    on Oct 28, 2026
  3. hivecommons-hive commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @hivecommons-hive
    Contributor

    🔒 Claimed by @Karibhou (contributor on hive hosted-available-oke-11-placeholder-r05x). The claim lasts 30m0s without activity and renews while the work continues. Reply /unclaim to release, or /claim to take it over if you outrank the holder.

  4. hivecommons-hive commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @hivecommons-hive
    Contributor

    🔓 Claim by @Karibhou released (lease revoked).

  5. clubanderson commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @clubanderson
    MemberAuthor

    Iteration 7 (17:48 ET, dd412e4) — did the merge celebration fire for #14945 (17:18) / #15067 (17:42)?

    Facts read from the live tab (read-only, CDP)

    Check Result
    SPA build dd412e4 (v5.186.4-839-gdd412e4, banner "Upgraded aa9b530 → dd412e4"); navigation.type = reload, document loaded 17:16:07 — i.e. the tab self-reloaded after roll 2 and was on the new build before both merges. Not a stale pre-roll tab.
    Celebrate setting hive.tracker.celebrate unset → default on (⚙ → Merges checkbox checked). prefers-reduced-motion = no. Sound: hive.tracker.sound=0 (off) → no zap either way.
    Merge detector _stageTrackerZapped = {pr#14945, pr#15067} → both merges were detected by the SPA. _stageTrackerPRHost maps pr#14945 → issue#14934, pr#15067 → issue#15061 (host rows resolved, so celebrateRow had a row for each).
    Merged-today counter "Merged today: 4" — tooltip lists #15067 17:42, #14945 17:18, #14701 17:06, #14989 16:56. Both merges ticked the count. (Regression: the same chip read "Merged today: 33" on aa9b530 at 17:14; after the reload the seed dropped to 4 — merged_24h/audit seed lost.)
    Residual DOM traces cue-merged rows 0, cue-token 0, _stageTrackerCelebrating {} — expected, the effect is 2.5 s pin + 0.52 s flight and the event line lives ≤2 min. No persistent trace exists after ~2 min by design.
    Where the chip is #activity-monitor-merged sits in .ham-toolbar (position: static). Operator's tab: scrollY = 10423, chip at top = −2295 px, first row at −2139 px → the counter, the glow target and any token landing are off-screen when scrolled into the list, which is where an operator reading rows is.
    Row after merge #14934 still shows "PR in progress" with a nested "○ #14945" sub-row 30 min after #14945 merged (screenshot). #15061 is gone from the board (issue closed). No "merged ✓" end state on either. (G11/N8 again.)

    ⚙ → Merges → Test celebration (slowed ×6 via an injected stylesheet so CDP frames could catch it; removed after)

    Verdict

    The celebration would NOT have been reliably visible to an operator with the tab open since 17:13, because: (1) it is a one-shot 2.5 s glow + 0.5 s token with sound off and no persistent trace; (2) the target chip and the row are in a non-sticky toolbar/list — at the operator's scroll depth both the source rows and the "Merged today" chip were off-screen; (3) the Test button plays behind its own modal and at the top of the list, so even the self-check shows nothing. The detector and counter did fire (both PRs in the zapped set, count 2 → 4), so this is a visibility failure, not a detection failure.

    Suggested fixes (for the celebration PR owner)

    1. Make .ham-toolbar (or just the Merged-today chip) position: sticky; top: 0 inside the section, so the token always has an on-screen landing and the count pop is seen.
    2. If the source row is outside the viewport, start the token from the viewport edge nearest the row (or skip the flight and flash the sticky chip) rather than animating off-screen.
    3. Test celebration: close the dialog first (or render the dialog non-modal/transparent for 3 s) and celebrate the first visible row; scroll it into view if needed.
    4. Leave a persistent trace: issue row shows "✓ merged 🐛 fix: release label-blocked serialized lane fronts during sweeps #14945 · 17:18" for the rest of the day instead of reverting to "PR in progress ○ 🐛 fix: release label-blocked serialized lane fronts during sweeps #14945"; keep the merge event in the ✓ cell tooltip.
    5. Fix the seed regression (33 → 4) so "Merged today" survives the SPA self-reload.

    #15101 (merge-gate pill two-line clip) and merge-train rows

    #14934 still 'PR in progress' with ○ #14945 sub-row 30 min after merge; toolbar + Merged-today chip 2,295 px above this viewport

    ⚙ → Merges → Test celebration plays behind the modal and on an off-screen row

  6. clubanderson commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @clubanderson
    MemberAuthor

    Iteration 8 (18:02–18:10 ET, dd412e4) — adoption pairs after "Let hive decide" / Approve — N10–N12

    Rows watched: #15023 (#15029 → #15123), #15083 (#15086 → #15124), #15088 (#15090 → #15125), #14816/#14822 (Approve 17:59), #14938/#14947 (Re-run decision). Polls at 18:02:30, 18:05:06, 18:06:22, 18:07:19, 18:07:58, 18:09:01, 18:10:03. Screenshots 20-, 22-, 23-*.

    Timeline as seen on the board

    Time #15023 / #15123 #15083 / #15124 #15088 / #15125
    18:02 issue chevron CI / Review; sub-rows: #15123 CI / Review 6m + #15029 ✓ Adopted by hive 3m (both lit amber) same shape same shape
    18:04 → Awaiting merge gate; event line "Hive: moved to stage/060-reviewed" same still CI / Review
    18:06 event line gone (≈2 min) tooltip reason flips to "check Sign-off survives the squash still running" → new event line with that full sentence → Awaiting merge gate + event line
    18:07:34 — #15124 merged (13 min after creation 17:54:38). Issue row #15083 gone by 18:07:58; _stageTrackerZapped has pr#15124 (detector fired) but no celebrating entry or event trace survived 20 s later. Original #15086 now appears as its own row: "Adopted → #15124 · 8m", GH: OPEN, stage/074 —
    18:10 still Awaiting merge gate (16 min) orphan #15086 row still there still Awaiting merge gate

    #14816 (→#14822): "Needs human decision" + needs rebase; ✓ badge tooltip: "You chose Approve · 05:59 PM EDT · done — your approval was posted as a comment." GH: #14822 OPEN, DIRTY, stage/085 — nothing moved in 11 min and nothing on the row says why (rebase needed → hive won't act / contributor must).
    #14938 (→#14947): "Needs human decision"; ✓ tooltip: "You chose Let hive decide · 05:56 PM · done — the hive decided: adopt-supersede (rule: contributor offline)." GH: #14947 OPEN stage/085, no copy PR after 14 min — the chevron still says the decision is owed although it has been made.

    Grades

    Criterion Result Evidence
    One active row per issue ❌ Each issue carries two lit amber chevrons: copy "Awaiting merge gate ⬡" and original "Adopted by hive ⬡" — original never dims, never strikes through, keeps a green ✓ (screenshot 22). Issue's own strip has no lit segment at all.
    No 090 pill after decision ✅ "Ready for human merge · untrusted author" gone from #15083/#15088 immediately after the decision.
    Toast leads with outcome ⚠️ n/a No row-action toasts visible at 18:02 (actions were 17:53–17:59). Only "Merged today: N" matches [role=status]. The ✓ badge tooltip does lead with outcome ("Addressed — now at Adopted by hive. You chose Approve …") — good, but it is hover-only (badge is a 20 px ✓).
    Decision trail (G5) 🟡 improved Tooltip now names who/what/when/result for both Approve and Let hive decide (incl. the rule). Needs to be visible without hover for the first ~10 min.
    Working vs waiting (G1) 🟡 First sighting of cue-working (2 rows: #15103, #15099). None on the adoption pairs even while CI ran on the copies.
    Event line 🟡 Fires on transitions (good) but (a) leaks label names "moved to stage/060-reviewed", (b) fires on tooltip-reason changes with the whole reason sentence, (c) lives 2 min and leaves no trace.

    New findings

    Copy and original both lit; event line leaks label name

    Original #15086 left as a standalone 'Adopted → #15124' row after the copy merged

  7. clubanderson commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @clubanderson
    MemberAuthor

    Iteration 9 (18:49 ET, dd412e4) — #15009 / PR #15020 four minutes after "Let hive decide" — N13

    What the row shows (literal): strip chevron "Needs human decision 👤" (red/needs-human pulse) in the Merge-gate column · age 4m · badges refs closed (issue #15009 struck through) · ✓ (green, 20 px) · needs human pill (amber outline) · no event line · no working cue · no sub-row.

    Hover texts:

    • Chevron: "stage/085-needs-decision — PR parked on a human decision: sentinel alert, hold/needs-decision label or human-only rule · Next move: human"
    • PR title: "… Needs a human decision — A human decision is owed — label needs-human · Author: @hivecommons-hive[bot] (author/hive) · Next move: human · Flags: needs-human · Since 06:45 PM EDT · 4 min ago · Trail: Fixing → Needs human decision → Fixing → Needs human decision"
    • ✓ badge: "At Needs human decision — A human decision is owed — label waiting on a person. You chose Let hive decide · 06:45 PM EDT (4 min ago) · done — the hive decided: direction (rule: fix then merge). Then the hive moved it to Fixing — human changes requested · 4 min ago. Then the hive moved it to Needs human decision — label needs human · 4 min ago."
    • Popover (click pill or chevron): "A person must decide (marked needs-human; a person must remove the label). Approve, give direction, or close? [Let hive decide] [Approve] [Give direction] [Close as superseded] [Close as won't fix] [Hold] — Asked by the hive · 4 min ago"
    • ⋯ menu: Decide…▸ (Let hive decide, Approve, Close as superseded by…, Won't fix…, Give direction…), Hold, Re-evaluate now, Open on GitHub, Copy link.

    GitHub reality (18:50): PR OPEN, reviewDecision CHANGES_REQUESTED, labels needs-human + stage/085-needs-decision. Comments: 18:23 hanthor /hive decision …; 18:45 hive posts the delegated /hive decision make CI green without widening scope… and "Decision recorded by @clubanderson". So the decision is recorded, but the needs-human label was never removed → stage snapped back to 085 within the same minute.

    Grades (from the row alone)

    Question Grade Why
    a Hive decided? ⚠️ Only inside the ✓ hover. Visible surface says the opposite: "Needs human decision", needs human pill, popover "A person must decide … Asked by the hive · 4 min ago".
    b What it decided? ⚠️ ✓ hover: "direction (rule: fix then merge)" — a rule name, not the direction text ("make CI green without widening scope; keep the smallest reversible change, then it merges").
    c Fixer working on hanthor's review? ❌ No working cue, no agent name, no "Fixing" state — the row left Fixing within the same minute. Trail "Fixing → Needs human decision → Fixing → Needs human decision" reads as a loop. hanthor's CHANGES_REQUESTED is nowhere on the row.
    d Nothing required of me? ❌ Every surface asks for a decision again (chevron, pill, popover with 6 buttons, chip count). An operator who just delegated is invited to decide a second time — or will conclude their click did nothing.

    N13

    After "Let hive decide" the hive records the decision and moves the PR to Fixing, but the needs-human label it was parked on stays → the next sweep re-parks it at 085 and the row re-asks the human. Two fixes: (1) backend — a delegated/recorded decision must clear the needs-human label it answered (or the stage derivation must treat a recorded decision newer than the label as answered); (2) UI — when the ✓ trail's latest entry is a hive decision, the row must say so without hover: event line "Hive decided: fix then merge — fixing hanthor's requested changes", chevron "Fixing", no needs human pill, popover closed or reading "Decided 18:45 by hive (delegated by you) — nothing needed from you". The ✓ hover should quote the direction text, not the rule id.

    Row: Needs human decision + needs human pill + ✓, 4m after the hive decided

    Popover still asks the human to decide

  8. clubanderson commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @clubanderson
    MemberAuthor

    Iteration 10 (18:54 ET, dd412e4) — #14816/#14822 after Approve and #14938/#14947 after Let hive decide — N14

    Literal row text

    #14816 → #14822 (thatguywob, GH: CONFLICTING, needs-rebase + stage/085, CHANGES_REQUESTED): chevron "Needs human decision 👤" · age 16h · badges v5 · ✓ · needs rebase · no event line · no working cue.

    • Chevron/title hover: "Needs a human decision (its PR) — A human decision is owed — adoption stalled: contributor lane: workflow path · Author: @clubanderson · Covering PR: 🐛 fix: preserve owner intent through PR decision paths #14822 · Next move: human · Flags: needs-rebase · Since 01:58 AM EDT · 16 hours ago · Trail: Actionable → Claimed → Actionable → Covered by PR"
    • ✓ hover: "Still at Needs human decision 55 min after you asked — hive says: A human decision is owed — adoption stalled: contributor lane: workflow path. You chose Approve · 05:59 PM EDT (55 min ago) · done — your approval was posted as a comment. Options: Let hive decide · Give direction · Close as superseded · Close as won't fix · Hold."
    • Popover: does not open (N1 still — DOM click on the trigger yields no .ham-decision-pop).
    • ⋯: Decide PR 🐛 fix: preserve owner intent through PR decision paths #14822…▸ (Let hive decide, Approve, Close as superseded by…, Won't fix…, Give direction…), Hold, Re-evaluate now, Mark needs-human…, Open on GitHub, Copy link.

    #14938 → #14947 (GH: MERGEABLE/UNSTABLE, stage/085, no review; earlier copy #14977 CLOSED): chevron "Needs human decision 👤" · age 1h · badges v6 · ✓ · no event line.

    • Title hover: "A human decision is owed — decision requested · Author: @Danathar · Covering PR: 🐛 fix: reject auto-merge queues from untrusted merger identities #14947 · Next move: human · Since 04:58 PM EDT"
    • ✓ hover: "Still at Needs human decision 57 min after you asked — hive says: A human decision is owed — decision requested. You chose Let hive decide · 05:56 PM EDT · done — the hive decided: adopt-supersede (rule: contributor offline). Options: Approve · Give direction · Close as superseded · Close as won't fix · Hold."
    • Popover: does not open. ⋯: same list as above.

    What GitHub already says that the row doesn't

    On #14947 the hive itself posted at 17:56: "Hive decided close this PR and open a fresh hive-authored PR with the same commits, but it hasn't taken effect. What should have happened: … Why it hasn't: Required checks are failing on this branch; nothing merges until they are green. What you can do: Merge as maintainer · Re-run decision · Close as superseded · Send back for a new commit." — exactly the plain-words explanation an operator needs, and none of it reaches the Activity Monitor row (which still says "decision requested"). On #14822 the last bot comment is Prow "PR needs rebase" (16:04); the hive never says what "adoption stalled: contributor lane: workflow path" means or that the rebase is the blocker.

    Grades

    Question #14816/#14822 #14938/#14947
    1 Does the row say the ONE thing I must do, or that I must wait? ❌ Chevron says decide; ✓ hover says you already approved; needs rebase says someone must rebase; menu offers 5 more decisions. Nothing says "wait — blocked on rebase by @thatguywob" or "rebase it / let hive adopt". ❌ Chevron says decide; ✓ hover says hive already decided adopt-supersede; nothing says "stalled: checks red — Re-run decision or Merge as maintainer" although the hive wrote exactly that on GitHub.
    2 Is "adoption stalled: contributor lane: workflow path" explained in plain words? ❌ Appears verbatim in two hovers, never expanded. (It means: a contributor-lane PR that touches CI workflow files needs an explicit owner approval of that head before hive may adopt/merge — and the current head is conflicting.) n/a — but "decision requested" is equally opaque when the decision has been made.

    Good: the new ✓ "Still at … N min after you asked — hive says … Options: …" nudge text is the right instinct — it just lives behind a 20 px hover and still ends by offering more decisions instead of naming the blocker.

    N14

    When a human action or a delegated decision is recorded but the item does not move, the row must switch from asking to explaining: chevron stays where it is but reads "Stalled after your Approve · needs rebase" / "Stalled after hive decided adopt-supersede · checks failing", the event line carries the hive's own stall comment ("Why it hasn't: required checks are failing"), and the primary row action becomes the single recommended one (Re-run decision / Merge as maintainer / Ask @author to rebase) with the rest under ⋯. Internal reason codes ("adoption stalled: contributor lane: workflow path", "decision requested") need a human sentence; the hive's GitHub stall comment already has one — surface it.

    Both rows still 'Needs human decision' ~1 h after the human acted / hive decided

  9. clubanderson commented on Oct 28, 2026

    @clubanderson
    MemberAuthor

    Iteration 12 (19:25 ET, after roll 3 → d93adf9) — every row older than 30 min: moving or stuck, and on whom — N15

    Two points: 18:56 capture (iteration 11, dd412e4) vs 19:25 capture (d93adf9; banner "Upgraded dd412e4 → d93adf9"). "Moving?" = chevron/sub-row state changed between the two, or a fresh event line. 20 rows qualify.

    # stage / pill since last change (Trail / event line / ✓) moving? waiting on does the row SAY it?
    #14816 → PR #14822 Needs human decision · needs rebase · ✓ 17 h ✓: "You chose Approve · 05:59 PM … Still at Needs human decision 1 h after you asked"; Trail ends "Covered by PR" no author (@thatguywob must rebase) + hive (adoption stalled: workflow path) ❌ says "Next move: human" and asks for another decision; never says "rebase by author"
    #14938 → PR #14947 Needs human decision · ✓ 2 h ✓: "hive decided: adopt-supersede · 05:56 PM"; nothing since no hive (its own adopt-supersede never took effect — checks red) ❌ says "Next move: human — decision requested"
    docs PR #500 (issue #496 closed) Conflicting · bot PR · stalled +2 14 h Trail "… Merge gate → Fixing"; new wording after roll no nobody — "the hive does not fix bot PRs; it waits for th[e bot]" / "Superseded by #497 — decide" ✅ new text says who (bot) — but then "— decide" asks me, with no action on the row
    #15082 → PR #15085 Needs author 3 h none no author @clubanderson — conflicting ✅ "Needs @clubanderson — conflicting — @clubanderson must act"
    #15121 → PR #15122 Needs author 1 h none no author — review swarm requested changes ✅
    #15092 → PR #15105 Adopted by hive 1 h Trail "Claimed → Actionable → Claimed → Covered by PR" no hive fixer (addressing review findings) ⚠️ says "Next move: hive" but no working cue, no agent, no queue position for 75 min
    #15147 → PR #15150 Needs author · needs rebase 47 m none no author — rebase ✅
    #15120 → PR #15139 CI / Review 33 m none no reviewer agent ("review gate: awaiting review approval") ⚠️ says "waiting for a verdict" but not which agent / queue position / ETA
    #15117 → PR #15157 (+#15149 Fixing) Needs author · tracker 0/3 · needs rebase 49 m 18:56 "Fixing" → 19:25 "Needs author" (new sub-row #15157 at 19:00) yes author (#15157 rebase) + hive (#15149 fixing) + 3 child issues ⚠️ two lit sub-rows (Needs author + Fixing); "waiting on 3 open child issue(s)" only in hover
    PR #15134 (closes #15099 · closed) Needs author · needs rebase 49 m Trail "CI / Review → Needs author → CI / Review → Needs author" no author — rebase ✅ (loop in Trail unexplained)
    #14786 → PR #14788 PR in progress · draft 21 h none no author — draft ✅ hover: "draft — waits for the author to mark it ready"
    #14798 → PR #14807 PR in progress · needs rebase +1 19 h none no author — draft + rebase ✅ hover; "+1" hides the draft flag on the row
    #15141 → PR #15149 (under #15117) PR in progress · ↳ #15149 · under #15117 49 m 18:56 "Fixing" → 19:25 "PR in progress" (nesting moved) yes (re-drawn, not progressed) hive fixer on #15149 ⚠️ new "under #15117" chip is good; but issue appears to have moved backwards
    #14976 Needs human decision · needs human 3 h Trail "Actionable → Needs human → Actionable → Needs human" no human ✅ asks correctly; popover works; question text only on GitHub
    #14636 Actionable 11 h Trail "… Covered by PR → Actionable" no scanner ("waiting for the scanner to pick it up") ⚠️ says scanner, not why 11 h or when the next pass is (new rows now show "next hive pass in 12m" — this one doesn't)
    #15021 Actionable 2 h Trail "Needs human → Actionable → Needs human → Actionable" no scanner ⚠️ same; loop unexplained
    #15133 Open · blocked · since 1h · blocked on #15104 1 h none no another PR (#15104, itself Needs author) ✅ names the blocker; ❌ no hover, doesn't say #15104 is waiting on the author
    #15155 Open · blocked · since 35m · blocked on #15134 35 m none no another PR (#15134 needs rebase) same
    #14934 New · since 9h 9 h event line "Hive: New · waiting for the stage-label pass (→ 010 actionable), then the scanner (next pass in 12m)"; 18:56 it was "PR in progress ↳ #14945" yes — backwards stage-label pass (hive) ✅ new d93adf9 text is excellent ("no one is working on this right now … Next: … next hive pass in 12m · Gates ahead: triage ✓ → actionable → claimed") — ❌ but contradiction: its PR #14945 merged at 17:18 (Merged-today list); issue reset to "New" instead of closing
    #14646 Open · since 29h · tracker 29 h none no unknown ❌ no hover, no next move, 29 h

    Count: 20 rows > 30 min · moving 3 (#15117, #15141 re-nested, #14934 reset-to-New) · stuck 17.

    Top 3 stuck reasons

    1. Waiting on the author (rebase / conflicting / draft / requested changes) — 8 rows (Activity Monitor: Adopt now and Reroute to another clanker for PRs waiting on a contributor's clanker #15082 🐛 Write-back containment: platform sweeps post to repos the operator never opted in #15121 🐛 Activity Monitor "Merged today" chip resets to 0 on reload — count lives only in the tab #15147 🐛 Delegated decision on a capability gap: model the blocker, stop the un-park/re-park loop, name the missing App permission #15134 README: outcome cards render with fallback fonts and glow; rasterize to PNG #14786 Dashboard ▶ terminal only shows 'tmux session not created yet' for sandbox.runtime: job agents #14798 automerge: conflict-aware merge train for overlapping approved PRs #15117 + Review backlog (security): Armed follow-through routes workflow-path fork PRs to a fixer push the App token cannot complete #15133/Review backlog (intent-alignment): Blocker ledger not cleared on ordinary issue close; blocked_items over-counts #15155 transitively). Rows say so clearly now ✅; what's missing is presence (is the author around?) and a one-click "adopt / nudge".
    2. Human decision already given but not applied — 3 rows (🐛 decision path: approve-with-rationale reads as changes_requested, Refs→Fixes rewrite overrides owner decision, 070 deadlock without a new head #14816 Approve, 🐛 [v6] queue accepts what merge will refuse: empty dashboard.authorized_users, and PAT-queued "@internal" approvals, never merge #14938 Let hive decide, docs fix: persist repo sparkline history across page refreshes #500 "— decide"). Rows keep asking instead of saying "stalled after your decision because X".
    3. Hive's own queue with no visible worker / ETA — 5 rows (✨ feature: (hub): surface "Pause hive" action in the hub spoke dropdown menu #15092 adopted 75 m, Review backlog (security): 404'd closing-keyword target cached as not-a-PR for the process lifetime #15120 review 33 m, [scanner] hub-auth: pin Hub login contract with fail-closed and no-secret-in-URL/log tests #14636 scanner 11 h, [selfreport] agent_login_required: login required detected #15021 2 h, 🐛 [v6] serialized lane: a hold label on the front PR never releases the front, so the lane is blocked until the front timeout #14934 label pass). d93adf9's "next hive pass in Nm · no one is working on this right now" text fixes this for New rows; Actionable/Adopted/CI-Review rows still lack it.

    N15

    Stuck-row legibility after d93adf9: author-blocked rows are now clear; the two remaining gaps are (a) rows where a decision was recorded but did not take effect still ask rather than explain (see N13/N14), and (b) hive-queue rows (Actionable / Adopted by hive / CI / Review) do not carry the new "no one is working on this right now · next hive pass in Nm · gates ahead" sentence that New rows got. Also a fresh contradiction: #14934 regressed to "New · since 9h" with its PR #14945 merged 2 h earlier (issue never closed) — the row should read "PR #14945 merged 17:18 · issue left open — close or reopen work?".

    Full Activity Monitor at 19:25 on d93adf9

  10. github-actions commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @github-actions
    Contributor

    @clubanderson this issue was closed by @hivecommons-hive[bot] as completed.

    If this was closed by a merged PR, the fix only takes effect once it ships in a tagged release and your deployment updates to it — check your running version against the fix before concluding the fix failed.

    If you are still seeing the problem, comment /reopen and it will be reopened for you — you do not need write access. Please add what you are still observing (running version, logs, steps) so it is not closed the same way again.

  11. clubanderson commented on Oct 29, 2026

    @clubanderson
    MemberAuthor

    N16 — open > 2 h, not on hold (20:38 ET, roll 3 · d93adf9 still live; /api/version: behind 15 commits, target 73cdc6d, next update 2026-10-29 17:00Z)

    Board: 39 rows, Since filter = Any age, Per page 50 (nothing hidden). 11 Open · hold rows ignored. 6 rows are older than 2 h by their "since" column.

    (a) waiting on a named human — 2

    row since chevron hover (≤1 line) tell the operator
    hive#14786 → PR #14788 22h PR in progress · draft "Next move: human @clubanderson — draft — waits for the author to mark it ready for review" nothing — you (@clubanderson) must mark #14788 ready
    hive#14798 → PR #14807 20h PR in progress · needs rebase +1 same draft text (the +1 hides "draft"; rebase isn't mentioned in the hover) nothing — you must rebase + mark #14807 ready

    (b) waiting on hive, no worker / ETA — 1

    row since chevron hover tell the operator
    hive#14636 tracker 12h Actionable "Triaged; eligible for the hive to pick up · Next move: hive — waiting for the scanner to pick it up" nothing — wait on scanner. ❌ 12 h of "waiting for the scanner" with no next-pass time (the New rows got "next pass in 11m" in d93adf9; Actionable did not)

    (c) decision recorded but not applied — 2 (the two oldest non-draft rows)

    row since chevron hover tell the operator
    hive#14816 → PR #14822 18h Needs human decision · needs rebase · ✓2 ✓: "Still at Needs human decision 37 min after you asked — hive says: A human decision is owed — adoption stalled: contributor lane: workflow path. You chose Let hive decide · 08:00 PM · done — the hive decided: adopt-supersede (rule: contributor offline). Options: Approve · Give direction · …" nothing you can click fixes it — hive chose adopt-supersede but can't push to a workflow-path fork; the row should say "hive can't adopt this (needs workflows permission) — ask @thatguywob to rebase, or Close as superseded" instead of re-listing the same 5 options
    hive#14938 → PR #14947 3h Needs human decision · ✓1 ✓: "Still at Needs human decision 2 h after you asked — hive says: A human decision is owed — decision requested. You chose Let hive decide · 05:56 PM · done — the hive decided: adopt-supersede … Options: Approve · …" same — decision made 2 h ago, no copy PR exists, chevron still asks. Row should name the stall ("adopt-supersede queued 2 h, no fixer picked it up")

    (d) contradictory / unclear — 1

    row since chevron hover tell the operator
    hive#15133 2h Open · blocked · since 2h · blocked on #15104 "no one is working on this right now — blocked on PR #15104 — nothing moves until the dependency closes" / chip: "lifts when it merges; re-triage if closed unmerged" nothing — wait on PR #15104 (whose own row says Needs author). ✅ clear; listed here only because #15104 is a hive PR waiting on a human — the blocked row doesn't say who ultimately unblocks it

    Cross-cutting

    Screenshot: 00-full.jpg (all 39 rows).

    N16 full board 20:38 ET

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    help wantedDenotes an issue that needs help from a contributor. Must meet "help wanted" guidelines.

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions