You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Schema design review: standing-approval record agenda (PR 62 lead note) + interim-default wording #64
Tracking issue for the schema design review of the standing-approval record. The agenda was recorded in #62 (docs/review-2026-11-13/14-synthesis-and-rulings.md, "Schema design review agenda", a lead note, not a ruling).
The review proposes, and the operator rules on:
Whether one standing approval may cover privileged or baseline changes. Until the operator rules, a standing approval covers ordinary changes only. The check against the validator's derived ceremony class (map §9.8) stays.
How persisted rejects (DC-2) apply under a standing approval. They stay.
How approval_seq single use, or its high-water mark, applies to a record that authorises more than one change. It stays.
Which signers a standing approval may name outside developer mode. This is ruled only for developer mode (Smaller 1).
X-trust-06, which is proposed and not yet ruled.
Dropping any check other than the per-change nonce needs an operator ruling.
Wording follow-ups from the PR 62 round-6 reviews (non-blocking):
The interim "ordinary only" default names "a standing approval" only. Ruling L5 (B2) lists two nonce-less modes, "a hold window, or an owner-enrolled standing approval". The default should say it covers every standing mode that applies without a per-change yes (Fable round-6 nit 1, adversary round-6 info).
The reading's label "(lead decision, PR 62 round-3 review)" dates the wording to round 3, but rounds 4-6 changed it. It could read "(lead decision, PR 62 review)" (Fable round-6 nit 2).
Activity