Skip to content

EN-PARITY-W3-ARTICLE-W9-QA-01: independently QA the frozen Article package #1885

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Merged
fermatmind merged 2 commits into from
Aug 1, 2026
Merged

EN-PARITY-W3-ARTICLE-W9-QA-01: independently QA the frozen Article package #1885

Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
2 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
0db165d
EN-PARITY-W3-ARTICLE-W9-QA-01: independently QA the frozen Article pa…
fermatmind Jul 31, 2026
db9c596
docs: record W9 Article QA PR state
fermatmind Jul 31, 2026
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
55 changes: 35 additions & 20 deletions docs/codex/pr-train-state.json
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -52628,65 +52628,65 @@
"updated_at": "2026-07-31T10:31:41Z"
},
"EN-PARITY-W3-ARTICLE-W9-QA-01": {
"status": "ready_to_merge",
"status": "blocked_pr_open",
"repo": "fap-web",
"branch": "codex/en-parity-w3-article-w9-qa-01",
"branch": "codex/en-parity-w3-article-w9-qa-rework-04",
"depends_on": [
"EN-PARITY-W3-ARTICLE-PACKAGE-FREEZE-01"
],
"commit_sha": "68d9564c5c24540cc41c970e138bed847c9385c3",
"pr_url": "https://github.com/fermatmind/fap-web/pull/1877",
"commit_sha": "0db165db3f4bdc66ac4776a567b2439400961625",
"pr_url": "https://github.com/fermatmind/fap-web/pull/1885",
"checks": {
"dependency": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "GitHub reports producer PR #1875 merged as 3cf5b570c2cd0295cd8822574f0743da4b750fe3 and CONTROL merged at 5d8aa0461f41e88c9d304d3b61f4af1d5b9eded9. Current origin/main is that exact CONTROL commit and registers W3-ARTICLES at package_frozen SHA 2aa27aa67f15368517ede3c319650bca1309a2cf0c44efc2d98bbd5cdb647161 while W3-CAREER-GUIDES remains unchanged."
"evidence": "Producer PR #1882 and CONTROL PR #1883 are merged. CONTROL commit 9b7e5bf40de31359c2b126eeae690313165389e1 registers W3-ARTICLES at package_frozen SHA 213736b1d59a862e73dcfeae77b67cae1fe2b092f41469a57c91631cdb052157 with producer editorial evidence SHA bd98114440a80fe2edb040eeb5412f1072e519f3313b580aabaf8b523dbfb9da. This W9 branch was rebased onto current origin/main 53cce2d55d26fab9e3ec31b4fb984c02063fec7e; the intervening commit is unrelated MBTI scope and does not change the frozen package, control master, or W3-CAREER-GUIDES."
},
"package_integrity": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "The standard ten-file package is complete; all eight immutable payload SHA values recompute exactly; the validator-order aggregate is 2aa27aa67f15368517ede3c319650bca1309a2cf0c44efc2d98bbd5cdb647161; all 17 Article/revision identities are unique; and all permissions remain false. A byte-identical frozen snapshot is stored under the new W9 authority directory."
"evidence": "The standard ten-file package is complete; all eight immutable payload SHA values recompute exactly; the validator-order aggregate is 213736b1d59a862e73dcfeae77b67cae1fe2b092f41469a57c91631cdb052157; all 17 Article/revision identities are unique; and all permissions remain false. A byte-identical frozen snapshot is stored under generated/en-content-parity/W9-independent-qa/articles/w3-articles-213736b1/."
},
"w9_coverage": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "Fresh independent W9 reviewed 17/17 registered titles, excerpts, and full bodies; read every source Markdown table/matrix (86 groups / 610 lines); independently matched all exact live zh-CN source revisions; and recorded eight checks plus actionable evidence for every row under generated/en-content-parity/W9-independent-qa/articles/w3-articles-2aa27aa6/."
"evidence": "Fresh independent W9 reviewed 17/17 registered titles, excerpts, and full bodies; read every source Markdown table/matrix (86 groups / 610 lines); independently matched all exact live zh-CN Article and published-revision identities; and recorded eight checks plus actionable evidence for every row under generated/en-content-parity/W9-independent-qa/articles/w3-articles-213736b1/."
},
"language_naturalness": {
"status": "fail",
"evidence": "12/17 rows retain reader-visible literal translation, non-native grammar, or incorrect MBTI, RIASEC, Gaokao, admissions, Enneagram, linear-algebra, and assessment terminology."
"evidence": "7/17 rows retain reader-visible grammar, duplication, possessive, or terminology defects: W3-ARTICLE-03, W3-ARTICLE-51, W3-ARTICLE-52, W3-ARTICLE-53, W3-ARTICLE-55, W3-ARTICLE-58, and W3-ARTICLE-59. The remaining 10 rows pass all eight required row checks."
},
"source_equivalence_and_asset_completeness": {
"status": "fail",
"evidence": "13/17 rows fail semantic source equivalence even though structural coverage is now complete at 86 source and candidate Markdown table groups / 610 lines. Blocking defects include ability-vs-task-performance claims, a corrupted exact 144-question field, stale event tense, distorted admissions conditionals, and incorrect domain vocabulary."
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "All 17 rows pass semantic source equivalence and structural completeness. Source and candidate each contain 86 Markdown table groups / 610 table lines; all registered titles, excerpts, full bodies, and frozen identities are present. The seven blockers are limited to language naturalness and do not remove source meaning or assets."
},
"field_leakage": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "All 17 complete candidate bodies were reviewed; prior producer, SEO, generator, website-production, and control-field phrases are absent from reader-visible content."
},
"other_required_qa_checks": {
"status": "fail",
"evidence": "Chinese leakage, internal-link equivalence, explicit Media Library omission policy, unique identity mapping, and applicable pre-import page/API alignment pass. Asset duplication/completeness is BLOCKED under the control aggregate because 13 rows fail semantic source equivalence, and claim boundary is BLOCKED on four rows. This does not claim live English parity."
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "Chinese leakage, internal-link equivalence including the two documented malformed-source corrections, explicit Media Library omission policy, unique identity mapping, applicable candidate-only page/API alignment, asset duplication/completeness, and claim boundary all pass. W3-ARTICLE-53's dated June 22-28, 2026 Gaokao event fact was independently verified against the official Sunshine Gaokao source. This does not claim live English parity."
},
"artifact_shas": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "Independent report SHA256 is 98741fabc3a9f164377332e52e60cff62602a0dd8cc3404fa00c7ce7d4089f26; 17-row evidence SHA256 is acdc8259b56827554a0a539fc6b0263c053fdfc0fc04176bac025936d5c52cac; blocked candidate SHA256 is d6ce47204d108d29cf22d350c628642f900eb5788ee88cd6e26e3b18fddda935."
"evidence": "Independent report SHA256 is ea220b4b2f2496a645cc7ae1602ed2f7290cf354dc56a5d6187cd526db132844; 17-row evidence SHA256 is 490ac8c1e38ec368894d516302ec71083af061570c17a3046cc7fd0dfe901fcc; blocked candidate SHA256 is 306956b286ee6107653742de4cb6892709d875ff7931c33e2de202919590d5cd; source identity projection SHA256 is 0da04750832c1b88d8c5e5e21d2def8eb63b2a4e05650d1087deaca0760b4846."
},
"control_validator": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "Node 24.18.1 validate-en-content-parity-control accepts both the strict independent BLOCKED report and the package_frozen-to-blocked W9 candidate against current master with zero errors."
},
"local_validation": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "Node 24.18.1 focused en-content-parity control and W3 Article package contracts pass 66/66. Complete JSON parsing, both control validators, exact eight-file package SHA recomputation, 17/17 unique coverage, 86/610 table coverage, aggregate row-check consistency, byte-identical frozen snapshot, producer/master/CareerGuide immutability, permissions, and git diff checks pass."
"evidence": "On latest origin/main, Node 24.18.1 focused en-content-parity control and W3 Article package contracts pass 66/66. Both strict control validators, exact eight-file package SHA recomputation, 17/17 unique coverage, exact seven-row blocker aggregation, 86/610 table coverage, zero Han leakage, byte-identical frozen snapshot, all-false permissions, and artifact SHA checks pass."
},
"github_required_checks": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "PR #1877 exact checked head 68d9564c5c24540cc41c970e138bed847c9385c3 passed build, four contract shards plus contracts aggregation, verify-big5-contract-freeze, verify-enneagram-contract-freeze, CodeQL analyze, no-new-code-scanning-alerts, and CodeQL."
"status": "pending",
"evidence": "PR #1885 is open at exact implementation commit 0db165db3f4bdc66ac4776a567b2439400961625. Required CI, contract, freeze, and CodeQL checks are queued or in progress."
},
"review_and_merge_policy": {
"status": "pass",
"evidence": "GitHub reports PR #1877 MERGEABLE/CLEAN at exact checked head 68d9564c5c24540cc41c970e138bed847c9385c3. There are zero review threads and zero reviews; the only issue comment is a non-actionable Codex review quota notice. Exact scope and all W9 artifact validators pass."
"status": "pending",
"evidence": "GitHub reports ready PR #1885 OPEN and MERGEABLE at implementation commit 0db165db3f4bdc66ac4776a567b2439400961625. Required checks, exact-head review, scope revalidation, and final mergeability verification remain pending."
}
},
"failure_reason": "Fresh independent W9 is BLOCKED for 13 of 17 Article rows: 12 fail language naturalness, 13 fail semantic source equivalence, and 4 fail claim boundary. qa_pass is not authorized; the frozen producer payload must not be repaired in this W9 scope.",
"failure_reason": "Fresh independent W9 is BLOCKED for 7 of 17 Article rows solely on language naturalness: W3-ARTICLE-03, W3-ARTICLE-51, W3-ARTICLE-52, W3-ARTICLE-53, W3-ARTICLE-55, W3-ARTICLE-58, and W3-ARTICLE-59. qa_pass is not authorized; the frozen producer payload must not be repaired in this W9 scope.",
"merged_at": null,
"remote_branch_deleted": false,
"local_cleanup_executed": false,
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -52760,9 +52760,24 @@
"at": "2026-07-31T09:29:03Z",
"status": "ready_to_merge",
"summary": "PR #1877 exact checked head 68d9564c5c24540cc41c970e138bed847c9385c3 passed every required GitHub check and is MERGEABLE/CLEAN. Zero review threads or reviews are present. Exact-head validators, package/artifact SHA checks, 17-row and 86/610 coverage, frozen-snapshot comparison, permissions, allowed-path scope, and producer/CONTROL/CareerGuide immutability all pass; the evidence verdict remains BLOCKED and qa_pass remains unauthorized."
},
{
"at": "2026-07-31T11:09:55Z",
"status": "blocked_local_validation_pending",
"summary": "Started fresh independent W9 rework-04 review from the CONTROL-registered exact package SHA 213736b1d59a862e73dcfeae77b67cae1fe2b092f41469a57c91631cdb052157 and producer evidence SHA bd98114440a80fe2edb040eeb5412f1072e519f3313b580aabaf8b523dbfb9da. Completed 17/17 review over all 86 source table groups / 610 lines. Seven rows are BLOCKED solely on language naturalness; qa_pass and all write/release permissions remain false."
},
{
"at": "2026-07-31T11:09:55Z",
"status": "blocked_local_verified",
"summary": "Rebased the isolated W9 branch onto latest origin/main 53cce2d55d26fab9e3ec31b4fb984c02063fec7e and reran validation. Both strict control validators pass; Node 24.18.1 focused contracts pass 66/66; exact package and artifact SHAs, 17/17 identities, exact seven-row blocker aggregation, 86/610 table coverage, zero Han leakage, byte-identical snapshot, and all-false permissions pass. The evidence remains BLOCKED and qa_pass remains unauthorized."
},
{
"at": "2026-07-31T11:12:26Z",
"status": "blocked_pr_open",
"summary": "Committed and pushed the fresh rework-04 independent W9 BLOCKED evidence as 0db165db3f4bdc66ac4776a567b2439400961625, then opened ready PR #1885. GitHub reports MERGEABLE with required checks queued or in progress; qa_pass and every write/release permission remain false."
}
],
"updated_at": "2026-07-31T09:29:03Z"
"updated_at": "2026-07-31T11:12:26Z"
},
"EN-PARITY-W3-CAREER-GUIDE-RUNTIME-ABSENCE-01": {
"status": "ready_to_merge",
Expand Down
Loading