Repository navigation
DEVICES: the Pixel 9a's modem and GNSS cells to works (opt-in), as its fingerprint cell - #764
Conversation
|
Thank you for splitting this into three commits, and for being plain about where each one stands. I'll decide it myself, as you offered. My thinking so far:
One practical point: #659 edits the Suspend cell on the same row, and I'm merging it first, so this one will need a rebase onto it. The cells don't overlap. |
…t cell already uses
Calls, texts and mobile data work from the device package's boot unit once the owner enables it; the cell already says why it is not on by default (marking slot B is on hold, derekross#483) and names the two gaps (the far end's echo on the speakerphone, no earpiece route). That is the state the 9a's fingerprint cell calls works (opt-in).
|
Rebased onto main after #659, and the GNSS commit is out: this is now the legend line and the Modem cell only. I'll send the GNSS cell again once a package with the 9a's client is published (#748). On the Modem cell, either word is fine with me. "Partial" is the better fit for the two gaps if the legend reads a gap that way. |
f3bcdf1 to
f5ebdee
Compare
|
My decision: I'll take the legend line and the 9a's Modem cell. "works (opt-in)" is fine as the term, and it already describes the 9a's Fingerprint cell. Please drop the GNSS commit for now: the repository's On my side, the website reads "works (opt-in)" as plain "works", with a stray bracket in the detail. I'll fix its parser before this reaches omamobile.org. |
|
Thank you. This is now exactly what I decided: the legend line and the 9a's Modem cell, with GNSS left for when a package with the 9a's client is published (#748). CI is green and it merges cleanly with today's main, so I'm merging it. The title still mentions GNSS, so I'll write the squash title to match what's in it. I'll fix the website's parser for "works (opt-in)" before the page picks this up. |
A proposal for the 9a's row, and yours to refuse: the Modem and GNSS cells from "testing" to "works (opt-in)", the wording the 9a's fingerprint cell has had since #248. Three commits, so you can take any part.
Why
The legend's "testing" is "works by hand, not yet on by default". Neither cell is by hand any more. Since #372 the device package's boot unit starts the modem, the phone service, the bridge and gnssd at boot once the owner enables it, and it has done so on my palmtop through every reboot since 2026-11-09. What keeps it from "works" is the default, and the cell already gives the reason: marking slot B on the 9a is on hold (#483), and with B unmarked a reset spends one of ABL's tries. That is the fingerprint cell's situation: it works, and a stated safety reason keeps it off until the owner turns it on.
What
testing (becomesworks (opt-in) (. Nothing else in the cell changes: it still names the hold as the reason and the two gaps, the far end's echo on the speakerphone and the missing earpiece route. If you'd rather those gaps make it "partial", I'd understand; the legend's "partial" says "on by default", which is why I didn't pick it.omamobile-gnsshas no HAL client for the 9a, so for an install from the repository GNSS doesn't work until a package is built with it (make -C packages/omamobile-gnss/bionic NDK=…on the build machine beforetools/build-packages; omamobile-gnss 0.2.10, build-packages: a package without the Pixel 9a's HAL client says so #749 makes a build without it say so). On a palmtop with the client it has been fixing on every session I've run, the last one 104 of 109 GGA sentences on 2026-11-13.When #483 and its guard (#484) are in and the boot unit goes on by default, both cells lose the "(opt-in)". I've offered rebased branches for both on their pull requests.
Not touched
The Suspend cell. With linux-omarchy-mobile#232 and #556 the 9a sleeps with the modem up (the counts are on those pull requests and in #758), but none of that is merged, and this morning's runs turned up a new problem with sleeps longer than three minutes on a kernel without idle states, which I'll write up separately.
tools/pr-checkandtests/allpass; the change isdocs/DEVICES.mdonly.