Skip to content

Collaboration request: external gyrokinetic validation artefacts #47

Description

@anulum

Blocked modules

  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_eigenvalue.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_interface.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_nonlinear.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_geometry.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_species.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/jax_gk_solver.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_ood_detector.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gyrokinetic_transport.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_online_learner.py

Needed evidence

  • Real TGLF, GENE, GS2, CGYRO, or QuaLiKiz executable runs or documented public reference outputs.
  • Native-vs-external benchmark cases with identical Miller geometry and species inputs.
  • Input decks, raw external outputs, parsed outputs, growth rates, real frequencies, and parser artefacts.
  • Long nonlinear Cyclone Base Case saturation campaigns with solver convergence and late-time heat-flux traces.
  • Published or cross-code saturated heat-flux references.
  • Independent Miller-geometry reference cases for circular, shaped, and high-shear equilibria.
  • Published gyrokinetic or Fokker-Planck collision reference cases.
  • CPU/GPU JAX parity artefacts with backend, platform, dtype, X64, tolerance, growth-rate, and real-frequency metadata.
  • Real or published GK campaign ensembles for OOD threshold calibration and online learner held-out distribution-shift tests.

Claim unblocked

Quantitative gyrokinetic agreement and accelerator-equivalent physics claims. Until these artefacts exist, local implementation and parser tests remain bounded validation only.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    blocked-by-dataBlocked by unavailable external/reference datacollaboration-wantedExternal collaborators can provide artefacts or reviewexternal-validationRequires external code/data/hardware evidencehelp wantedExtra attention is neededphysics-validationPhysics validation and benchmark evidenceroadmapTracked on roadmap

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions