Repository navigation
Conversation
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Bounded source-integration review CLEAR at40c9f6a/treeb4cdbcea, not readiness approval. Actual ordered parents[5dccf9e,494fc28a] retain both histories and the accepted #394 landing. The entire accepted verification history and exact earlier VR-28 evidence suffix are preserved. Core replay/binding implementation and both schemas match the previously reviewed composition; runtime/support/probe/extraction/audit checks remain, and this is not a globally exactly-once claim. The484-ID register/test census and VR-28 statement mirrors are consistent.
One focused honesty log from43151978617/job130963305444 confirms R1: CONFORMANCE.md is stale versus model/*.toml. This matches the acknowledged generated-document debt; use the official projection within the coordinated product phase, not a hand edit or blind gate rerun. Repro43151978472 failed its just-repro step, but its cause has not been diagnosed; no second log was fetched or cause inferred.
The two changed schemas still require the documented coordinated all-language identity/product work, actual Atlas binding/width evidence and one complete final-head gate plus repro before acceptance. Existing source/measurement evidence is retained only for its original scope. No completed kernel-false, SP-05, VR-21/23, export, verification or timing pair was repeated by this review. Existing owner retains the sole #391 carrier and writer/qualification scheduling; #391 remains open. Independent receipt3c5be84a records the bounded evidence.
Closes #391 after the remaining acceptance work passes.
Source integration
Carries the existing reviewed
fix/vr28-single-kernelpreparation at494fc28ainto acceptedrelease/v0.4at5dccf9e5, retaining both histories and the actual #394 landing. Published source commit:40c9f6a586f4a78e366fd284a92d9a7deced0387; reviewed tree:b4cdbceab6687399f160b1dcd8b14b5766eb8bd5.Generated project modules and certificates A/B/E omit their duplicate in-process kernel check only when their successful same-run replay binds the same module and complete main/server/private olean parts. One final guard covers local/imported records, the certificate tail, and staged artifacts. Runtime, support, probe, extraction, and audit modules keep their in-process checks. Existing prefix replay behavior is unchanged; this does not claim globally exactly-once declaration checking.
The only content conflict was the append-only verification history. The entire accepted history and exact VR-28 evidence suffix are retained. Independent source review found a stale capability census; SPEC, the spec-links gate, and README now consistently include all 484 IDs and VR-28. Accepted Host/policy diagnostics are preserved.
Evidence for this source integration
cargo check --locked -p lexlean -p repo-conformance --all-targetspassed in 95 seconds before the documentation/census-only corrections.The earlier controlled gateway verification pair remains 1,863.117 s to 1,243.365 s, 33.264% lower observed wall time in that single pair. Its source, host, ordering/cache limitations, and evidence are preserved in VERIFICATION.md. This is not a Rule30 speedup claim or final-tree qualification. No benchmark was repeated.
Required before readiness or merge
Generated artifacts remain unchanged and are not acceptance evidence for the new schema identities. No new Lean execution, production export, product writer, or full CI gate has been claimed for this reconciliation. Keep this PR draft until those obligations are discharged. The existing source branch remains the sole #391 carrier.