Repository navigation
Decision regions: the region_check proof form (PF-24, PrismPM#605) - #474
Conversation
…heckpoint) `LexLeanRuntime.Regions` (namespace `LexLeanRegions`) joins the runtime project: the data of a first-match decision over natural-number fields, its semantics written in exactly the shapes the backend emits (Nat.blt/ble/beq, `!`, `&&` folded from the left, `if b then`), the local box obligations of a property, and `holds`, the soundness theorem a `region_check` proof applies. Every row pins its exact axioms; `holds` and everything it uses are within propext and Quot.sound. This commit is the export checkpoint: it carries the one-time oracle, tests/runtime-library/regions-oracle/ (the authored Lean, the fold-law exporter narrowed to `Regions`, and a `to_notation` helper), which the next commit removes. The record is tests/runtime-library/REGIONS.md: the regenerated environment equals the authored one in all 379 rows. UOR-Foundation/prismpm#605 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Its result is recorded in tests/runtime-library/REGIONS.md; RT-01 holds the input absent from the release tree. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A property of a first-match decision over natural-number fields is proved by local box obligations instead of one linear_arithmetic case split per property. `region_check` lowers the theorem `breaks request = false`, the judge's rules, and the property's bounding box (read from the module's prior declarations) to the data of LexLeanRuntime.Regions, and emits exact LexLeanRegions.holds R d P B (by decide +kernel) [(request).f, ...] rfl The data is written in the backend's own shapes, so the module's `breaks` is definitionally the runtime's `breaks` of the data and the kernel checks that: the lowering is not trusted. Linking refuses, with the reason, a theorem outside the fragment (a `!=` in a rule, a field the property leaves unbounded, a comparison that is not field-against-constant) and the form used as a branch; language 1.1 refuses the form. R3: PF-24 in SPEC.md §31 and model/ids.toml (483 IDs), its scenario, and conformance_pf_24 over the new examples/decision-regions, whose planted defect (heating without its occupancy test) Lean refuses at exactly the two properties it breaks. SPEC.md §17.12 gains *Decision regions*; the v2 module and snapshot schemas admit the kind; VERIFICATION.md records two planted defects. Verdant Resonance (35 rules, 15 properties), which linear_arithmetic could not prove, verifies in about 73 s. The language-1.2 identity changes; the locks, goldens, fixture expectations, and verification records are regenerated in the commits that follow. UOR-Foundation/prismpm#605 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…hat names it Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ackages, and verification records for the new language-1.2 identity Written by the repository writers on Linux x86-64 with the pinned Lean 4.32.1: check-fixtures, check-golden, check-calculus, check-production-export, and verify-examples --write. examples/uor-atlas is not regenerated here: its CensusCert11 verification was killed by the host out-of-memory guard (13 GB). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Bounded source/acceptance triage at91912e (not complete proof or generated-product approval): I found no demonstrated kernel bypass in the inspected fragment/lowering boundary. The emitted proof still applies the pinned LexLeanRegions.holds theorem with a kernel-decided obligation and checks the original target through Lean; its declared axioms are exactly Quot.sound/propext.
Two concrete delivery items remain with this implementation owner:
- The explicitly omitted uor-atlas/CensusCert11 current-identity records still block the normative example/expected-record equality requirement. Complete and review that missing writer output on sufficient resources before final-tree acceptance; normal CI validation does not itself adopt regenerated output. Preserve valid completed evidence and avoid repeating already completed producers.
tests/runtime-library/REGIONS.mdends with a blanket claim that every language1.2 verified record was regenerated, contradicting the Atlas exception in this PR body. Make the evidence wording match what was actually produced.
Keep this draft until the remaining outputs, complete final-head gate, same-run honesty and repro are accepted. This review did not rerun the 379-row or Verdant measurements, inspect all2675 changed files, or perform a full proof audit. No competing patch, identity wave or qualification run has been started.
The uor-atlas records were not regenerated at the new identity; the record said every one was. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…on-obligations # Conflicts: # CHANGELOG.md
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Bounded delta readback at9f9d928: the regeneration-wording finding is addressed by1e746; REGIONS.md now explicitly excludes Atlas. The release integration adds only the maintenance Cargo.lock/CHANGELOG delta; region proof/runtime/generated-product source is unchanged from the prior inspected scope, so no duplicate source or producer review was performed.
Atlas current-identity verification records remain the concrete unresolved output blocker. This stays draft pending that owner's output review and complete resulting-head qualification. The prior review was bounded triage, not a complete proof/product audit, and this delta review does not expand that claim. No writer, test or CI run was repeated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…aces, and snapshot proof kinds know PF-24 Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Correction to my earlier reviews5865263518/5865729927: I withdraw the requirement to regenerate Atlas records for this language-1.2 identity change. The exact-head Atlas manifest and lock both select language1.0; their blobs and entrypoint are unchanged from the release base, and compiler_semantics_id_for excludes runtime1.2 and v2 schemas from that identity. My previous inference from the earlier OOM/staleness wording was wrong. No Atlas writer should be repeated on that premise. Ordinary committed-record verification remains part of acceptance.
The remaining concrete correction is small: tests/runtime-library/REGIONS.md still says Atlas records carry the previous identity. Update that paragraph to match the corrected PR body and unaffected language1.0 scope; historical OOM does not establish stale records.
The fc57→5800 delta contains five gate/documentation support changes for PF-24, with no additional concrete source blocker demonstrated in this bounded review. This does not establish the full proof/product audit: affected language1.2 outputs, complete resulting-head CI, same-run honesty and independent reproducibility still need acceptance under the existing owner. No runtime, writer, measurement or gate was repeated.
… unaffected The paragraph said its committed records carried the previous identity. They do not: the project is language 1.0, nothing under it changes, and the language-1.2 runtime and v2 schemas are outside its identity. The out-of-memory run only failed to re-verify them. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The remaining documentation finding is resolved at5e5c518: the only change from5800 is REGIONS.md, which now correctly distinguishes regenerated language1.2 projects from unaffected language1.0 Atlas records. The prior Atlas-regeneration requirement remains withdrawn; no repeat writer is needed on that premise.
No new blocking source delta was found in this documentation review. It does not expand the earlier bounded proof/product review: complete resulting-head qualification and affected1.2 output acceptance remain with the existing owner. Exact-head repro43126857745 passed; CI43126858163 is still active. No completed proof, producer, test or measurement was repeated.
…on-obligations # Conflicts: # bootstrap/expected/build/manifest.json # compiler/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/collections/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/fold-laws/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/helpdesk/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/higher-order/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/language-1.2/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/models/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/nested-induction/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/production-coverage/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/production/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/reasoning/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/recursion/expected/build/manifest.json # examples/recursive-data/expected/build/manifest.json # std-models/expected/build/manifest.json # std-reasoning/expected/build/manifest.json # stdlib/expected/build/manifest.json
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
[P2] Reconcile SM-38 declaration goldens for the resulting PF-24 compiler identity. This exact merge preserves actual release5dcc ancestry, but the imported outputs are incomplete/stale in two concrete places:
- examples/decision-regions/expected/build has no declarations directory or declarations manifest row. Its Main is a language1.2 semantic module, and the imported api.rs now emits that output for every such module.
- The LanguageTwelve/Main declarations blob906165cd is byte-identical to release5dcc (manifest output SHA92ec9b45), while its manifest compiler-semantics changes from635a25ac to28156029. declaration_id.rs explicitly frames compiler semantics into the IDs, and api.rs supplies the selected language identity. Retaining that parent-generated file does not reconcile it with this compiler identity.
These are source/committed-output correspondence findings, not claimed runtime failures or an audit of all101 imported declaration files. Please produce and review the required declaration outputs/manifest rows with the official resulting-source golden writer, including the new example. Reuse other valid completed products; no parallel writer or repeated export/verification/measurement is requested. Also update the PR body's current register count483→484; historical SM-38 records need not be rewritten.
The earlier Atlas regeneration requirement remains withdrawn, and its documentation correction remains resolved. Exact-head repro passed; the draft CI is still incomplete. Independent bounded integration receipt3b08ecf1 records the136-path delta and these samples; this is not a repeated proof audit or full product acceptance.
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Terminal CI43130959531 now provides a narrower product-reconciliation target. The single saved rest-job log130902956430 reports284 passes and7 failures: GC-01, GN-01, RB-02–05 and RB-07. Independent static decoding of all four RB-02–05 manifest pairs shows that only sources[0] differs: committed46bcb26a… versus generateda9477044…. GC-01/GN-01 first report compiler/rust/negative/arithmetic-invented-overflow.json. No program/export/effect change was found in those four decoded comparisons.
RB-07 separately reports that compiler/rust/rust-std/adt-evaluation builda9477044 does not bind the committed TargetFixtures source d746739e…. Its source-map check combines semantic ID, source path and source hash, so the message does not identify which field is wrong. Please reconcile the intended final compiler/source-map binding and affected generated-manifest closure through the official owning writer, retaining unchanged completed products. This evidence does not justify blindly repeating the entire calculus or identity wave, and generated IDs should not be hand-edited.
The existing declaration-golden/census findings remain separate. The withdrawn Atlas-regeneration requirement stays withdrawn. Exact repro success does not resolve these observed failures. Receipt2e8a7438 preserves the focused log and decoded comparison; no test, producer, log replay, artifact download or stopped TC-03 validation was run.
…rds with the official writers On the merge of release/v0.4 (SM-38) into this branch, run on Linux x86-64 with the pinned Lean 4.32.1: check-golden, check-fixtures, check-calculus, and check-production-export with --write, and verify-examples --write (part without:uor-atlas) as far as propositional-logic. The writers replace the conflicted build manifests taken from the base: every language-1.2 manifest now lists its declarations output and this branch's identity, and examples/decision-regions gains its declarations golden. The compiler build records semantic ID 46bcb26a, the one the committed calculus packages bind; check-calculus holds all 977 generated files equal to their generator. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…on-obligations # Conflicts: # CHANGELOG.md # README.md # SPEC.md # bootstrap/expected/build/manifest.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/AxiomOutput.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/CalculusCheck.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/GnafValidate.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/PrimitiveScan.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RuntimeValidate.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustAssemble.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustAst.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustBodies.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustLoops.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustLower.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustMoves.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustPackage.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustPrint.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustSucceed.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustTerms.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/RustValidate.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/StructuralGrammar.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/SurfaceDoc.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/SurfaceGeneric.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/SurfaceLex.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/TokenAudit.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/ToolingAst.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanBoot/ToolingLatex.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanStd/Buffer.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanStd/Json.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanStd/Numeral.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanStd/Order.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanStd/Sha256.map.json # bootstrap/expected/build/maps/LexLeanStd/Text.map.json # bootstrap/lexlean.lock # crates/conformance/src/cases/repository.rs # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/apply_moves/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/apply_moves/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/assemble_items/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/assemble_items/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/audit_tokens/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/audit_tokens/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/check_arguments/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/check_arguments/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/check_manifest/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/check_manifest/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/check_program/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/check_program/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/correspond_crate/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/correspond_crate/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/dead_functions/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/dead_functions/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/fallible_functions/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/fallible_functions/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/fold_bodies/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/fold_bodies/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/function_shells/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/function_shells/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/is_closed_lean_name/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/is_closed_lean_name/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lex/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lex/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lex_text/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lex_text/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/loop_function/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/loop_function/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_bodies/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_bodies/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_frame/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_frame/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_types/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_types/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_value_at/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/lower_value_at/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/parse_audit_output/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/parse_audit_output/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/parse_generic/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/parse_generic/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/parse_module/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/parse_module/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/print_crate/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/print_crate/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/print_expr/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/print_expr/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/print_generic/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/print_generic/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/quote_text/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/quote_text/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/reject_atoms/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/reject_atoms/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/render_doc/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/render_doc/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/render_package/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/render_package/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/render_tooling_latex/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/render_tooling_latex/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/scan_source/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/scan_source/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/site_trees/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/site_trees/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/succeed_bodies/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/succeed_bodies/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/use_trees/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/use_trees/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/validate_crate/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/validate_crate/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/validate_request/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/validate_request/provenance.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/validate_runtime/package.json # tests/production-export/bootstrap/packages/rust-std/validate_runtime/provenance.json # xtask/src/spec_links.rs
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Bounded product-delta review at d48a52b on actual release aaf8455: the sampled findings from254c are structurally reconciled. The compiler manifest, TargetFixtures map, four previously failing negative manifests and adt-evaluation package now agree on46bcb26a. The previously missing DecisionRegions declaration and manifest row are present, and LanguageTwelve's declaration no longer retains the old release blob.
This retires the old missing-file/unchanged-blob and sampled a947-versus46bcb diagnosis for this head. It does not claim the seven cases passed, verify every new declaration ID, or audit all2,739 changed paths. The withdrawn Atlas-regeneration request remains withdrawn; no producer, old log or completed check was repeated.
The known census wording still needs correction: the PR body says483 while exact-head model/ids.toml has494 rows and the new CHANGELOG already says494. Current draft run43195281073 has12 required groups skipped; even if its remaining job succeeds, it is development evidence rather than full final-head acceptance. Repro43195281146 passed at this head. Existing owner retains readiness, final qualification and landing.
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Exact-head terminal diagnostic for d48a52b: CI43195281073, rest job131106284198, reports290 conformance passes and one failure. GC-01, GN-01 and RB-02–05 now PASS, retiring those six old failures.
Remaining RB-07 blocker: compiler/rust/rust-std/adt-evaluation: no verification of the build46bcb26a… is committed. Exact-head rust_packages.rs60–80 requires a matching LexLeanAudit.A46bcb26a78a0357ffba6c8270c0ddd424. audit filename under compiler/expected/verify/audit before the later source-map assertions. This is a missing current-build verification artifact, not the old a947/46bcb map mismatch; those sampled binding repairs remain credited.
Please reconcile the affected compiler verification evidence through its official product path, retaining completed valid outputs. The evidence does not justify an Atlas regeneration or a blind all-project writer repeat. This diagnostic does not establish that later RB-07 assertions will pass.
Repro43195281146 passed, but twelve required groups were skipped in this draft run: full final-head qualification is still owed. One new focused log was archived; no old log, runtime test, producer or gate was repeated. Existing owner retains the repair.
Applied the regenerated.patch from regenerate.yml run 43319095851 on 02d9a29 (the production-export, records without:uor-atlas, and oracles writers, then counts and stack bounds). 1819 paths: the verification records of bootstrap, stdlib, compiler, std-reasoning and std-models, the bootstrap build oracle, and the bootstrap production export. check-freshness passes on the result. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The previously missing current compiler-verification artifact is now structurally repaired at2c1e6705. An exact old/new Git-tree comparison accounts for2,315 changed paths despite the compare/PR file-list caps. Current46bcb26a audit/process artifacts are committed; sampled TargetFixtures package, map and source bindings agree, and sampled bootstrap75b76e3c exports/provenance agree. This credits adoption and supersedes the missing-file finding in5875193285; it does not establish every generated byte or later RB07 assertions.
Use the existing owner qualification on this head to establish the remaining product/gate acceptance. Draft CI43341479857 is active and exact repro43341479905 passed. No Atlas regeneration, old log refetch or completed producer repeat is requested. The earlier withdrawn Atlas prerequisite stays withdrawn. Keep PF24's decision-region contract distinct from #507's proposed PF26 conditional-chain work during integration. Existing owner retains the implementation and final qualification; no readiness transition or merge was performed.
…nditions [regenerate] When the fixed script leaves a goal open, a second attempt adds LexLeanLaws.ite_eq_iff, which reads an if equal to a value as the disjunction of its branches, and the propositional simplifications that drop a decided branch. A proof the fixed script closes keeps its proof term and axioms. The laws module is the export the #117 oracle wrote (120 declarations, all equal to the compiler's Lean); the runtime modules it imports are the same on this line. fold-laws gains a fourteen-condition band with two theorems. PF-24 belongs to #474, so this is PF-26 (PF-25 is #303's). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3MWG2BeFisFkR1Kebg
Both sides moved the language-1.2 compiler-semantics ID. Generated conflicts take the base's side, and both IDs (06639c99... from the base, 28156029... from this branch) are replaced by the merged a82990b56aa082f57e3bf3e2d6494d75a8170f26e269448de19110f5459655ad in the locks, manifests and export packages. The register is 495 IDs (RB-24 and PF-24): README, SPEC.md §31, RP-07 and spec_links follow; CHANGELOG keeps both entries. The generated records are regenerated by regenerate.yml next. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…P-07, spec_links Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Applied the regenerated.patch from regenerate.yml run 43406352156 on fd7e641: the production-export, records (without:uor-atlas) and oracles writers, then counts and stack bounds. 5616 paths follow the merged language-1.2 compiler-semantics ID a82990b5... check-freshness passes on the result. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Bounded adoption review credits the official products from successful regeneration43406352156. Exact top-level/subtree comparisons preserve the prior authored proof/runtime/source/config inputs; this commit changes product subtrees. Sampled bootstrap lock/manifest/export provenance agree on compiler a82990b5 and semantic029d7d04. Compiler manifest, adt-evaluation package, TargetFixtures map and the committed current audit agree on db1406e9. The prior missing-artifact and sampled binding findings remain retired; no new concrete source blocker was demonstrated.
This is product-adoption and sampled binding credit, not an independent audit of every generated byte or a repeat of the 379-row export/Verdant measurements. The withdrawn Atlas-regeneration requirement remains withdrawn. The existing ready-head CI43422460142 is active, and exact repro43422446258 passed; canceled push43422446151 is excluded. Complete all dynamically required jobs, final evidence disposition and actual merged-tree equality before landing.
One small narrative correction remains: the PR body says494 register IDs while the current source census is495. Existing owner retains qualification. No writer, proof, test, log or CI action was repeated.
…gion-obligations The base adds no language or schema file, so the merged language-1.2 compiler-semantics ID stays a82990b5... and every generated file stays current (check-freshness passes). LANGUAGE_1_2_SEMANTICS_ID, the constant RP-19 introduces, follows it. The register is 496 IDs (RP-19 and PF-24): README, SPEC.md §31, RP-07, spec_links, CONFORMANCE.md and the CHANGELOG entry follow; CHANGELOG keeps both entries. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The focused integration is credited: exact parents4177a590 +actualb4ac72e5 preserve source/product history. The complete22-path delta imports #499's check-only feature and #516's workflow repair plus the combined census. No language/schema/PF24 implementation or previously adopted generated-product path changes, so the retained products and earlier source evidence remain applicable without another writer.
The new checked1.2 constant is a82990b5…, matching this branch's retained product/compiler identity. Imported RP10 independently recomputes the full tree; source consistency is credited, with runtime acceptance left to the current gate. No new concrete source blocker was demonstrated.
Current fullCI43433085919 is active and exact repro43433085885 passed. Canceled4177 run43422460142 is excluded entirely from final acceptance. Finish the current gate and final actual-tree acceptance. The body now says495 whereas this combined source census is496; this is a minor narrative correction, not a reason to repeat products or measurements. Existing owner retains qualification.
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Postlanding acceptance confirms delivery of PF24/region_check on release/v0.4. Full CI43433085919 passed all70 materialized jobs and772 steps, including same-run honesty, supported hosts, Atlas join and all normative partitions. Exact-head repro43433085885 passed. Canceled4177 runs are excluded.
Actual merge fd7cedd has ordered parents b4ac72e +5869ebe0d54510118b76e37d38337d1268186b18. Its tree276beeabf80ca310123c0b8f1d67337cd09b718b equals both the reviewed head and the qualified synthetic112146c755ccf303179ee1fd50c1e92b38520585. Independent final auditcf17f325 confirms these bindings and reuses the retained source/product reviews. The body count496 is corrected. No final acceptance review was found between CI completion and the external merge; this accurately records postlanding verification, not retroactive premerge approval.
The region proof route, supported-fragment refusals, example verification and false-property rejection now have complete resulting-tree gate acceptance. Earlier379-row export/Verdant measurements retain their original scope and were not repeated. No Atlas writer or identity regeneration was required for this audit. The plan-only landing push is evidence reuse, not a second full gate. PrismPM#605 downstream disposition and broader unfinished parents remain separate; no unrelated issue closure is inferred.
…generate on it [regenerate] #474 moved the language-1.2 identity and took PF-24, so the products of c56c53e no longer apply. The merged tree is release/v0.4's with PF-26's sources only, PF-26 placed after PF-24 in the register, §31, the scenario and the test wiring; the README range is PF-01..PF-26 and the register is 497 IDs. The Laws export is reused: Portable and Collections are unchanged on the line. Every written output comes from release/v0.4 and is regenerated on this tree under the gated workflow. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3MWG2BeFisFkR1Kebg
Implements UOR-Foundation/prismpm#605 upstream: a proof form that proves a decision model's properties through local box obligations instead of one
linear_arithmeticcase split per property.Why
Verdant Resonance (7 fields, 35 first-match rules, 15 properties) checks but does not verify: each property's
linear_arithmeticscript splits the 35-rule judge, andomegafails on a branch. The properties are true (brute force over all 3,131,000 in-bounds requests). The proof has to stop growing with the case split.What
LexLeanRuntime.Regions, a sixth native runtime module (namespaceLexLeanRegions, imports onlyInit). It holds the checker data (Cond,Rule,Property), its semantics, the box obligations, andholds, the soundness theorem: ifobligation B R d P = true, thenbreaks R d P x = falsefor every request of the box's width. Every row pins its axioms;holdsuses onlypropextandQuot.sound. It was exported once from authored Lean through the fold-law oracle. The regenerated environment equals it in all 379 rows (tests/runtime-library/REGIONS.md).region_check, a language-1.2 proof form for a theorembreaks request = false. The backend reads the judge's rules, the property, and its bounding box from the module and emits:exact LexLeanRegions.holds R d P B (by decide +kernel) [(request).f, …] rflThe runtime's semantics use the backend's own shapes (
Nat.blt/ble/beq,!,&&folded from the left,if b then). So the module'sbreaksis definitionally the runtime'sbreaksof the lowered data, and the kernel checks that equality. The lowering is not trusted: a misread module produces a proof Lean refuses (VERIFICATION.md, planted defect (a)).!=in a rule, a field the property leaves unbounded, a comparison that is not field against constant, the form used as a branch, or language 1.1.Evidence
linear_arithmetic{…}replaced byregion_check{}, runslexlean verifyin about 73 s. A planted defect (rule2's proximity limit 20 → 60) is refused with LLV7002 at exactlyinv004Holdsandinv008Holds.PF-24(register: 496 IDs, withRB-24andRP-19from the base), its scenario, andconformance_pf_24over the newexamples/decision-regions:Identity
The language-1.2 compiler-semantics ID changes. The locks, goldens, fixture expectations, calculus and production packages, and verification records are regenerated by the repository's writers in the
chorecommits (Linux x86-64, pinned Lean 4.32.1). On the regenerated tree,check-golden,check-fixtures, andvalidatepass.examples/uor-atlasis a language-1.0 project. Nothing under it changes, and its records reference neither the language-1.2 identity nor its runtime, so they are not regenerated; the gate's Atlas shards verify them as committed. (An earlier version of this description called them stale. That was wrong.)Not in this PR
by_checker_delta, PrismPM#604).🤖 Generated with Claude Code