Repository navigation
BS-22, BS-23, BS-24: the lexer, layout algebra, and generic notation as language-1.2 source (#269) - #451
Conversation
The row is the second slice of #269: `surface::lex::{lex, quote}` as language-1.2 source. The case fails until the module is an entrypoint of the project; the source follows. The row's statement carries no counts. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`lexText` and `quoteText` scan by loops under `iterate_until` and join the pieces of a string once, so neither recurses and a string costs its length. White space is `AxiomOutput.whiteLength`, which BS-01 holds to the oracle's `char::is_whitespace`. The module is an entrypoint and the two roots are exported; the lock is this tree's, and the regeneration replaces it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The row is the third slice of #269: `surface::doc::render` as language-1.2 source. The case fails until the module is an entrypoint of the project; the source follows. The row's statement carries no counts. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`renderDoc` keeps the oracle's two stacks as lists and pops one node at a time under loops bounded by the number of nodes. A concatenation is a chain of cells, so putting its parts on a stack is two items and nothing recurses over a document. The module is an entrypoint and the root is exported; the lock is this tree's, and the regeneration replaces it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
BS-22 stacks on BS-21. The conflicts keep that tree with this member's own edits applied over it: the SurfaceLex entrypoint and module, the register at 480 IDs (SPEC.md, the README, the RP-07 check and its case), the README's bootstrap row through BS-22, the CHANGELOG entry, and the BS-22 subsection of VERIFICATION.md after BS-21's. The lock and CONFORMANCE.md are the tree's and are rewritten next. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…es it The first run of conformance_bs_22 (293 s, on BS-21 and SL-13): every differential agrees (1,828 lexText and 1,362 quoteText runs under the evaluator, 5,738 under the pinned rustc), and 45 of the 46 plants were detected. "the space is a control character" changes the check of scanStep, which meets a byte only where a piece of a string starts; a run of plain bytes is read by rawStep under its own bound, so the plant's vector "a b" never reached it. The plant's vector is now a string that starts with a space, " a"; the lexer is unchanged. All 46 are detected, and the case stops at the stack-bound step until the regeneration commits bootstrap/lex_text and bootstrap/quote_text. VERIFICATION.md says so in place of "the case has not run". Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
BS-23 stacks on BS-22. The conflicts keep that tree with this member's own edits applied over it: the SurfaceDoc entrypoint and module, the register at 481 IDs (SPEC.md, the README, the RP-07 check and its case), the README's bootstrap row through BS-23, and the CHANGELOG entry. The lock and CONFORMANCE.md are the tree's and are rewritten next. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…h them The first run of conformance_bs_23 (705 s, on BS-22, BS-21 and SL-13): the evaluator agrees on 1,807 runs and the rendered package under rustc on 6,555, and 18 of the 21 plants were detected. The three missed were each the vector's fault, not the layout's: the delete plant was tried at the group's exact width, where one column less still fits (now one column short); the past-the-width plant on a group with visible content, which fails to fit either way (now a group of one soft break, whose flat form takes no column); and the fuel plant on a concatenation, whose parts the node budget counts twice (now a single text, one node and one step). All 21 are detected, and the case stops at the stack-bound step until the regeneration commits bootstrap/render_doc. VERIFICATION.md says so in place of "the case has not run". Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
# Conflicts: # README.md
The row is the fourth slice of #269: `surface::generic::{parse, print}` as language-1.2 source over the standard library's Json. It is stacked on BS-22, BS-23, and the members SL-11, SL-12, and SL-14. The case fails until the module is an entrypoint of the project; the source follows. The statement carries no counts. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`parseGeneric` lexes with lexText and reads the tokens with an explicit stack of frames, so it admits no recursion; the object's members are sorted when it closes. `printGeneric` builds the document by the structural recursion the standard library's writer uses and lays it out with renderDoc. The module is an entrypoint and the roots are exported; the lock is this tree's, and the regeneration replaces it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`SOURCE` was never used, and the lint of the first draft refused it as dead code. It was the only error of that step, so the case compiles. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…o BS-24 BS-24 stacks on BS-23. The conflicts keep that tree with this member's own edits applied over it: the SurfaceGeneric entrypoint and module, the register at 482 IDs (SPEC.md, the README, the RP-07 check and its case), the README's bootstrap row through BS-24, and the CHANGELOG entry. The lock and CONFORMANCE.md are the tree's and are rewritten next. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… the merge The bootstrap lock follows the SurfaceGeneric entrypoint, CONFORMANCE.md is written from the model with the BS-24 row, and the three places that named the standard library's Json reader `SL-12` name it `SL-13`, as #415 renamed it (`SL-12` stays Host's reservation). Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…'s vector The first run of conformance_bs_24 (259 s, on BS-23, BS-22, BS-21 and SL-13): the evaluator agrees with the oracle on 1,080 reads and 607 prints, and 31 of the 32 plants were detected. Two faults. The printer's rank table spelt the key `axioms` as `axoims` (0x61786f696d73), so a seeded object printed it after an unranked key where the oracle prints it before; the literal is now 0x6178696f6d73. The plant `a tag need not be a name` named `a b`, two bare words that never reach the test of bareness; it now names `a word of digits and a letter` (`1a`), which the oracle refuses and the planted reader admits. All 32 are detected, and the case stops at the stack-bound step until the regeneration commits bootstrap/parse_generic. VERIFICATION.md says so in place of "the case has not run". Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… of print_generic `cargo xtask check-production-export --write` at verify width 1 (2,893 s) on BS-24 over BS-23, BS-22, BS-21, and SL-13: the bootstrap export gains the parse_generic and print_generic packages, every package records the merged tree's digests, and the lock follows. conformance_bs_24 then passed whole with LEXLEAN_MEASURE_STACK=all (1,894 s), which measured the row of bootstrap/print_generic in tests/stack-bounds.json (PD-08). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`cargo xtask check-golden --write` on the regenerated export. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`LEXLEAN_EXAMPLES_PART=without:uor-atlas cargo xtask verify-examples --write` at width 1 (8,074 s); the UOR Atlas example is skipped on this host, as before. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…S-13 to BS-15 The committed export gains six packages (those of BS-21 to BS-24 on this tree), so the committed manifests, packages, programs and crates each grow by six and the corpora the cases draw from them follow: 20 constants in seven cases, their §31 rows, register statements and scenarios, and the §17.23 prose that repeats them. Measured under LEXLEAN_COUNTS=fast with the count writer of #442 applied and removed again; the writer placed every number. BS-11, BS-12 and every mutant draw are unchanged. VERIFICATION.md carries the landing's table. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
BS-22, BS-23, and BS-24 were regenerated together on a tree that holds BS-21's source byte for byte, so this tree's export, build oracles, verify records, lock, stack bounds and counts are a superset of BS-21's and are kept; the rows, statements, scenarios and §17.23 prose carry the counts of the six front-end packages. VERIFICATION.md keeps BS-21's count section, and the section of BS-22 to BS-24 counts from BS-21's tree (300 -> 305). The records of BS-21 to BS-24 now say each case passed whole on its regenerated tree. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
BS-27 stacks on the combined landing of BS-22, BS-23, and BS-24 (#451), whose export, records and counts it takes; the merge is clean. The bootstrap lock follows the SurfaceTooling entrypoint on the merged tree. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Bounded static review of exact head c074339, stacked on #395 at 8b9715b. Two count descriptions need reconciliation with this head’s factories:
- P2 — BS-15:
rust_package.rsconstructs(324 + 182 + 2000) + (305 + 137 + 305) = 3253normative rustc runs. The BS-15 statement/scenario and mirrors inmodel/ids.toml,features/suites/bootstrap.feature, SPEC §31 and CONFORMANCE still state 3190. Please update the authoritative descriptions and official projections while retaining all cases. The earlier #395 target of 3238 is specific to that parent; this head has advanced further. - P2 — BS-07: SPEC’s prose near line 8420 states 1392 vectors while the same sentence now says 356 per root. The four roots and
rust_lower.rsfactory imply4 × 356 = 1424. Please reconcile that prose with the current factory; #395’s earlier 1404 target is likewise parent-specific.
All five new package inventories are present, so this review does not carry forward a missing-products finding. Package presence, effect rows and named-case wiring were checked statically; the author’s runtime durations and full product/certificate closure were not independently re-executed here. Implementation and qualification remain with the existing owner; this is not final acceptance or broad #269 completion.
|
@humuhumu33 Coordinating the next release/v0.4 candidate: #395 landed at c66f83d two minutes before #459 finished its full 50-job qualification. #459 is therefore being reconciled onto the new accepted source before its next gate; it retains the test-only BS-15 optimization and complete existing coverage. The observed Linux BS-15 duration fell from 10,304.13 to 6,090.03 seconds on its earlier qualified tree. Please coordinate the next landing order with #459 so we do not invalidate another long final-tree run. We are preserving your #451 work and not starting duplicate parser/regeneration work. Stacking the next refresh on the reconciled #459 candidate, or qualifying after its landing, would carry the optimization forward without competing candidate waves. I will link the reconciled head here once source review is complete. #405 remains the accepted-history forward lane; this unmerged feature is not being imported into it. |
The conflicts are generated bootstrap files only, taken from the line and regenerated in the commits that follow. The three surface parts join the Intel print lane that #450 requires of every BDD part. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`cargo xtask check-golden --write` on the regenerated export. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…-21 landed `LEXLEAN_EXAMPLES_PART=without:uor-atlas cargo xtask verify-examples --write` at width 1; the UOR Atlas example is skipped on this host, as before. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Qualification coordination for new head 441338a: live GitHub shows both PR-event CI42827654603 and manual-dispatch CI42827628679 running the full matrix on this same head, created ten seconds apart. They are separate runs and their jobs must not be combined for acceptance. The PR-event run is the candidate qualification record I am tracking; please account for the concurrent manual run when deciding whether further CI work is necessary. I have not canceled, rerun or dispatched either run. The actual c66f base plus 441338a synthetic merge 2e4c70d has the same c0148ddd tree as the head. I am checking the prior count findings against this updated source. Existing #459 landing-order coordination6759909869 still applies: #459 remains unmerged and fully qualified on c66f, so please coordinate accepted landing order before either candidate invalidates the other’s base. No competing source or regeneration work is being started. |
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The two prior P2 count findings persist at exact head 441338a on actual c66f:
- BS-15:
rust_package.rsis unchanged from reviewed c074. It constructs(324 + 182 + 2000) + (305 + 137 + 305) = 3253normative rustc runs, while model/ids.toml, features/suites/bootstrap.feature, SPEC §31 and CONFORMANCE still say 3190. Please reconcile the authoritative descriptions and official projections without removing cases. Parent #395’s 3238 is not the count of this head. - BS-07:
rust_lower.rshas 356 vectors across four rustc legs, totaling 1424. SPEC near line8428 still says “1,392 vectors (356 per root...)”. Please reconcile the prose with this factory; parent #395’s 1404 is likewise a different tree.
The accepted c66f Intel workflow is retained, with the three surface parts added to its print lane. The merge history retains actual c66f and the GitHub synthetic merge tree equals the head tree c0148ddd. This bounded source review does not establish full generated-product closure or final qualification. New PR-event CI42827654603 and manual CI42827628679 remain separate; completed jobs must not be aggregated between them. No regeneration or runtime evidence was repeated. Existing owner retains implementation/qualification; #269 stays open and #423/#424/#425 are not yet closed.
|
Post-landing readback: GitHub records an external merge at 16:59:07 UTC as 700196c. Its ordered parents are actual c66f83d + final head441338a; its c0148ddd tree equals the reviewed head and tested synthetic2e4c70da. Independent terminal CI review confirms PR-event42827654603 attempt1 completed all54 jobs and600 steps successfully, including same-run honesty, all Atlas work/join, supported hosts and the Intel construction/lanes/receipt aggregate. Exact-head reproducibility42827654327 also passed. The separate manual42827628679 is excluded from these counts; no canceled jobs or other runs were aggregated, and no gate was repeated. This records actual landing and CI evidence, not resolution of source review5843508086: BS-15 still claims3190 versus factory3253, and BS-07 prose still claims1392 versus1424. No final source clearance was submitted before this external merge. Full-body delivery review leaves #423/#424/#425 open pending the remaining acceptance disposition; broad #269 remains open. Existing owner retains the corrections. #459 now needs current-base reconciliation review before landing, and #405 remains the existing owner’s actual-history forward lane. |
Part of #269: the next three slices of the front end as language-1.2 source, regenerated together and landing as one:
BS-22SurfaceLexlexText,quoteTextsurface::lexBS-23SurfaceDocrenderDocsurface::doc::renderBS-24SurfaceGenericparseGeneric,printGenericsurface::generic::{parse, print}It supersedes #416, #417, and #418, which were stacked on each other and could only be regenerated together: each member's export, records and counts depend on the packages of the ones below it. Based on #395 (
BS-21), whose regenerated head this branch merges, so the diff is these three members only.Evidence
Measured on the normative host (WSL Ubuntu, Rust 1.97.1, Lean 4.32.1), on BS-21 over
release/v0.4afterSL-13:conformance_bs_22conformance_bs_23conformance_bs_24The first runs found and fixed: a source defect in BS-24 (the printer's rank table spelt
axiomsasaxoims), and plants in BS-22, BS-23, and BS-24 whose vectors never reached them. VERIFICATION.md records each.Regeneration
One regeneration at verify width 1 on the combined tree: the production export (2,893 s), the three cases above, the build oracles, and the bootstrap verify records (8,074 s; UOR Atlas skipped on this host as before).
printGenericadmitsrecursion, and its stack row (bootstrap/print_generic, 1,376,256 bytes debug) is intests/stack-bounds.json. The five new packages move the counts ofBS-05toBS-08andBS-13toBS-15from BS-21's tree (300 -> 305 manifests): 20 constants, written in one pass by the count writer of #442, which placed every number.BS-11,BS-12, and every mutant draw are unchanged.Gates at the head
cargo fmt --check,validate-model(482 IDs),validate-spec-links(482 rows), the 17 RP cases, the locks current, and the nine bootstrap count parts underLEXLEAN_COUNTS=fastwith nothing moved. The nine parts run whole on CI.Closes #423, closes #424, closes #425 (the BS-22, BS-23, BS-24 delivery slices). #269 remains open.
🤖 Generated with Claude Code