Skip to content

Add the in-place byte update primitive (prim update) - #443

Open
afflom wants to merge 50 commits into
release/v0.5from
claude/bytes-set
Open

afflom wants to merge 50 commits into
release/v0.5from
claude/bytes-set

Conversation

@afflom

@afflom afflom commented Nov 9, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Summary

Adds an in-place byte update primitive, prim update. Programs get an O(1) table write, for match finders and adaptive models, where they previously needed a persistent tree with O(log n) cost and an allocation per write.

  • Semantics. TargetSyntax.Prim.update: update bytes at byte is some of the byte string with the byte at at replaced, or none when at is past its end. The TargetSemantics.primitive arm is inline and last, so the existing matcher numbering is unchanged.
  • rust-std.
    • The new item is update_bytes (Item.updateBytes, Machine.bytesUpdate, machine family 44, as SPEC §17.16 numbers it after the merge of release/v0.5), printed as Bytes::update(a, at, byte).
    • RuntimeStd's Bytes::update writes in place through Rc::get_mut when the buffer is unique.
    • When the buffer is shared, it copies and counts the copy.
    • RustStd gains update_bytes and its refinement theorem refines_update_bytes.
  • Lean runtime. Portable gains LexLeanRuntime.update via ByteArray.set!, in place when unique.
  • Certificates. Certificate A gains the lemma prim_update_bytes.
  • Preservation library.
    • RustCorr, RustLemmas and Primitives gain the cases for the new Prim, Item and Machine constructors.
    • Each new case was produced by taking the slice sibling and substituting the constructor, then kernel-checked.
    • RustLemmas gets one new helper theorem, wt_fixedTyped_update.
    • Only these three modules change. All 13 library modules kernel-check.
  • Bootstrap twins. CalculusCheck, RustPrint and RustValidate mirror the new primitive, item and machine.
  • Conformance.
    • Encoders and counts are updated.
    • A LAWS row is added for update_bytes.
    • The RB-20 std differential gains an update_bytes section. It runs every byte case at positions 0, 1, n/2, n-1, n, n+1 and MAX, with bytes 0, 0x5a and 255, each on a unique buffer and on a shared one.
  • Records.
    • SPEC (§17.16 std functions and machine family 44) and CHANGELOG are updated.
    • The compiler-semantics ID moves, so the records bound to it are regenerated:
      • the rust_renderer and rust_runtime_std digests
      • the locks
      • the goldens
      • the calculus packages
      • the verification records
      • the production-export packages

Verification

  • cargo test -p lexlean --lib: 219 passed.
  • lexlean verify --all in compiler/: all 38 modules verified, including refines_update_bytes.
  • Conformance: RB-15, RB-16, RB-20, SP-29, BS-05 and RB-07 pass locally.
  • cargo xtask check-golden --write, check-calculus --write, verify-examples --write and check-production-export --write were run.
  • Not run locally:
    • The uor-atlas verification records, which CI shards and which do not fit this machine's memory, are left to CI and the regeneration wave.
    • BS-04's rustc differential needs more than 13.5 GB to compile its harness.
    • BS-06 takes about 18 minutes; it passed up to the package comparison before the packages were regenerated.

Generated by Claude Code


Generated by Claude Code

Alexander Flom and others added 4 commits November 3, 2026 21:49
Source-only implementation for #434, preserving shared Decimal parse
evidence, exact policies and frozen older-language files.

Runtime/compiler identities and official products remain deliberately stale
until the coordinated v0.5 wave. This known-incomplete source commit skips
CI; final changed-head full acceptance and CI are mandatory before merge.
No post-fix policy, output or certificate pass is claimed.
update bytes at byte is the byte string with the byte at `at` replaced, or
none past its end. rust-std renders it as Bytes::update (update_bytes,
Item.updateBytes, Machine.bytesUpdate, family 40), writing in place when the
buffer is unique and copying, counted, when it is shared; the Lean runtime
uses ByteArray.set!. RustStd states refines_update_bytes, certificate A
gains prim_update_bytes, the preservation library's RustCorr, RustLemmas,
and Primitives gain the cases of the new constructors (kernel-checked), and
the bootstrap twins, conformance encoders and the RB-20 differential follow.
The compiler-semantics ID moves; the records bound to it are regenerated
(uor-atlas verification records excepted).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3Nk2H9geAZ2GKFCNvM
@afflom afflom mentioned this pull request Nov 9, 2026
@afflom
afflom marked this pull request as draft November 13, 2026 19:40
@afflom
afflom changed the base branch from main to release/v0.5 November 13, 2026 19:40

afflom commented Nov 13, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Was based on main, which gets a line only at its tag (SPEC §9.4). Retargeted to release/v0.5 and set to draft. It moves the compiler-semantics ID, so it needs rebasing and one regeneration after the v0.4→v0.5 forward merge (#405) lands.


Generated by Claude Code

claude and others added 11 commits November 14, 2026 21:11
SM-39..SM-41 are claimed on release/v0.4 (#493), so decimal formatting
isolation is registered as SM-43. The generated projections are release/v0.5's,
rewritten by the landing regeneration.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
#441 lands first on release/v0.5; this head follows it.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
Decimal formatting's runtime and certificate sources move the language-1.2
compiler-semantics ID to 6558e37caeeccfcdd86a54c31db6143364f4c8ae4a0c409c4d07dfaec5c11df2.
Every tracked lock whose only change is that ID is relocked with the built
compiler (267); LANGUAGE_1_2_SEMANTICS_ID takes the recomputed ID.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
release/v0.5 numbers the decimal machines 40..43, so the byte update is
machine family 44 (item family 50 is unchanged): ast.rs, the certificate-B
names, the bootstrap printer and validator, RustSyntax/RustSemantics (both
the source and the committed Lean), and the conformance counts follow. The
std crate, its refinement theorems and RuntimeStd gain update_bytes beside
the decimal functions; every theorem unfolds the same definitions. Portable
gains LexLeanRuntime.update over release/v0.5's slice. Generated outputs are
release/v0.5's, rewritten by the landing regeneration.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
The ToString operands of Portable, Fixed and RustLemmas were written under the
node labels they replaced, but each new constant is a node of its own, so the
labels after it named the wrong nodes (LLP2001: "this statement defines node
3602, not node 3600"). The edited statements are unchanged; `lexlean fmt`
numbers the nodes again from symbolic labels. All 19 runtime and preservation
modules are canonical.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
Portable and RustLemmas carry both changes: #437's ToString operands for
formatting and this branch's LexLeanRuntime.update and its cases, numbered
again by `lexlean fmt`.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
The landing regeneration writes every generated output again; the ones this
branch committed were made on its old base. rust_renderer records the merged
renderer sources.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
The SPEC.md text of this branch is written into its chapter module, at the
machine family release/v0.5 leaves free.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
The canonical graphs move the ID to 8c54fe7b15d5ddf9ff9848559747031aaf161e3793ffa932e46c63e6df475972;
written by `just relock-identity`.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
github-actions Bot and others added 4 commits November 14, 2026 23:19
Update joins the primitives nat_bitwise_function maps to None (the match v0.5 added), the
merge marker left between refines theorems in RustStd is removed, and rust_runtime_std is
written by `cargo xtask semantics-records --write` (#545).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
…olation

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
…-core

The byte update moves the ID to cddcb1b0bef5b765fcabe89be5e25ef0ec8a3b736049f058c782adb3df03be6f and the
rust-core descriptor to 4bf56bf9 (the renderer record moves).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
afflom pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 15, 2026
The semantics records take #443's renderer and std runtime with this change's
semantic_ir 17; README counts both landings (523).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
github-actions Bot and others added 2 commits November 15, 2026 01:45
The isolated decimal formatting no longer reaches Classical.choice or Quot.sound,
so the exact policy of the production-coverage root follows (LLV7005 on regeneration).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
afflom pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 15, 2026
Its lock came from #441 under that change's ID and was skipped by the relock (LLC0102 in fixtures-write).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3M8ULnzEQwLLngyBBX
The merge of release/v0.5 brought the fixture with release/v0.5's 1.1
identity (6dc2bc4d), while every other 1.1 lock on this branch carries
bb4bccab, the ID this compiler computes. relock-identity moves only
locks on the majority ID, so it kept the fixture back and the oracles
writer saw LLC0102 (exit 2) instead of LLT4001 (exit 1). Written by
`lexlean lock`; `check --all` now exits 1 with LLT4001.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy
afflom pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 16, 2026

afflom commented Nov 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Fixed at the root. relock-identity relocks only the locks on each language's majority ID at HEAD. The release/v0.5 merge brought tests/negative/evaluation-language-11 with release/v0.5's 1.1 identity (6dc2bc4d), while the branch's other twelve 1.1 locks carry bb4bccab. That is the ID the b2338352 compiler computes, so the script read the fixture as a deliberate pin and kept it back. The fixture now carries bb4bccab, written by lexlean lock, and check --all exits 1 with LLT4001, so the oracle is unchanged and LLC0102 is not accepted.

Both regenerate refs were moved to these heads, which supersedes runs 43848401495 and 43848560938. The identity stage now moves all thirteen 1.1 locks together if the composed compiler moves the 1.1 ID.


Generated by Claude Code

github-actions Bot and others added 2 commits November 16, 2026 14:07
The write recipes of SPEC.md §9.2, run by regenerate.yml (https://github.com/UOR-Foundation/lexlean/actions/runs/43860484653),
rewrote 7084 paths.

The counts writer reported:

    counts: no count moved
…o fmt)

fmt-check on the delivered head reflows crates/lexlean/src/calculus/mod.rs
and crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/calculus_check.rs. Neither is
a compiler-semantics input; layout only.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy
afflom pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 16, 2026
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

# Conflicts:
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R0.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R1.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R10.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R11.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R12.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R13.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R14.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R15.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R16.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R17.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R18.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R19.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R2.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R20.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R21.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R22.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R23.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R24.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R25.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R26.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R27.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R28.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R29.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R3.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R30.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R31.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R32.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R33.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R34.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R35.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R36.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R37.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R38.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R39.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R4.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R40.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R41.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R42.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R43.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R44.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R45.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R46.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R47.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R48.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R49.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R5.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R50.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R51.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R52.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R53.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R54.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R55.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R56.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R57.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R58.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R59.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R6.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R60.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R61.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R7.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R8.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C2ee0173a5a920c78788fdf101ab63f44/R9.lex.tex
#	bootstrap/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json
#	examples/helpdesk/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ccfc71ddbf027d937d1dc66cd11b44fde/R0.lex.tex
#	examples/helpdesk/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ccfc71ddbf027d937d1dc66cd11b44fde/R1.lex.tex
#	examples/helpdesk/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ccfc71ddbf027d937d1dc66cd11b44fde/R2.lex.tex
#	examples/helpdesk/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ce1d7c2d7ad46d0ec6a462cf180203d1b/R0.lex.tex
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ce1d7c2d7ad46d0ec6a462cf180203d1b/R1.lex.tex
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ce1d7c2d7ad46d0ec6a462cf180203d1b/R2.lex.tex
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ce1d7c2d7ad46d0ec6a462cf180203d1b/R3.lex.tex
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ce1d7c2d7ad46d0ec6a462cf180203d1b/R4.lex.tex
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ce1d7c2d7ad46d0ec6a462cf180203d1b/R5.lex.tex
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/Ce1d7c2d7ad46d0ec6a462cf180203d1b/R6.lex.tex
#	examples/models/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json
#	examples/performance-corpus/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8630037de2e192eb3ebca9b3fb8e13fe/R0.lex.tex
#	examples/performance-corpus/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8630037de2e192eb3ebca9b3fb8e13fe/R1.lex.tex
#	examples/performance-corpus/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8630037de2e192eb3ebca9b3fb8e13fe/R4.lex.tex
#	examples/performance-corpus/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json
#	examples/production-coverage/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C27e2f04c213e278fbc03706131f6c5f5/R10.lex.tex
#	examples/production-coverage/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C27e2f04c213e278fbc03706131f6c5f5/R15.lex.tex
#	examples/production-coverage/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C27e2f04c213e278fbc03706131f6c5f5/R30.lex.tex
#	examples/production-coverage/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C27e2f04c213e278fbc03706131f6c5f5/R31.lex.tex
#	examples/production-coverage/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json
#	examples/reasoning/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8fbfbdea3770d51a1234c8a63996d4f3/R2.lex.tex
#	examples/reasoning/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8fbfbdea3770d51a1234c8a63996d4f3/R3.lex.tex
#	examples/reasoning/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8fbfbdea3770d51a1234c8a63996d4f3/R6.lex.tex
#	examples/reasoning/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R0.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R1.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R10.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R11.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R12.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R13.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R14.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R15.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R16.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R17.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R2.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R3.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R4.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R5.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R6.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R7.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R8.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C33b73b2e788713990dfe94c58c97a86e/R9.lex.tex
#	kappa/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R0.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R1.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R10.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R11.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R12.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R13.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R14.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R15.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R16.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R17.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R18.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R19.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R2.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R20.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R21.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R22.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R25.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R26.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R28.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R29.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R3.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R30.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R31.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R32.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R34.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R35.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R37.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R38.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R4.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R40.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R41.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R43.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R45.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R5.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R6.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R7.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/LexLeanPreserve/C8c92b1912a54722a45e96237fa1abe16/R9.lex.tex
#	stdlib/expected/verify/preserve/preservation.json

afflom commented Nov 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

honesty on the delivered 110d7a8c fails only at fmt-check. That is fixed by 91062968 (the cargo fmt layout of calculus/mod.rs and calculus_check.rs, neither a semantics input). CI and repro on 91062968 are queued.


Generated by Claude Code

SP-06 requires every runtime construct of the registry to be exercised
by a root of the certified examples; primitive.update had none.
Coverage.Prims.updates is `prim update b i v : (Option Bytes)`, eligible
for rust-std with exactly the allocation effect (its eligibility report
names primitive.update and type.bytes as the sources). Its expected
products are written by regenerate.yml.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

afflom commented Nov 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Windows tests (validate) on 91062968: conformance_sp_06 fails with "runtime constructs no certified root exercises: ["primitive.update"]". This is a real gap in this PR, not a platform issue. The registry gains primitive.update, but no root of the certified examples used it.

Fixed in 95e0c6d3 with Coverage.Prims.updates in examples/production-coverage: prim update b i v : (Option Bytes). Locally it checks, is canonical, and builds. Its eligibility report shows it eligible for rust-std with exactly the allocation effect, sourced from primitive.update and type.bytes. The example's expected products are being rewritten by regenerate/bytes-set at 95e0c6d3.


Generated by Claude Code

What the CI on 9106296 found prim update had left out:
- LM-09: the semantic-module-v2 schema's operation enumeration names
  `update`.
- PD-01: the reviewed registry rows list primitive.update (runtime,
  allocating).
- TC-06: `prim:update` allocates in the realization, as the registry
  says (it returns a new byte string).
- SP-23/SP-29: the std runtime's machine calls end with bytesUpdate;
  SP-29's register row, scenario and SPEC row name update_bytes,
  bytesUpdate and the calculus primitive `update`.
- RP-11: the README states the 523 IDs (SM-43 and SM-44).
OR-02, RB-01 and SP-06 are met by Coverage.Prims.updates (95e0c6d).
validate-model and validate-spec-links: 523 ids, clean.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

afflom commented Nov 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

The CI on 91062968 (Windows lanes) found seven places where prim update had not been registered. All are fixed in 0ce9a0d4:

  • LM-09: update added to the schema's operation enum.
  • PD-01: the reviewed registry row added.
  • TC-06: prim:update allocates in the realization, matching the registry.
  • SP-23/SP-29: bytesUpdate added to the std machine calls, with the register row, scenario and SPEC row naming update_bytes, bytesUpdate and update.
  • RP-11: the README now states 523 IDs.
  • OR-02, RB-01, SP-06: met by Coverage.Prims.updates, added in 95e0c6d3.

validate-model and validate-spec-links are clean (523 ids). regenerate/bytes-set restarted at 0ce9a0d4, because the schema is a language-1.2 semantics input.


Generated by Claude Code

The language-model audit lists update as a total primitive returning
Option Bytes, and the byte-updates calculus fixture exercises it in range
and past the end.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

@afflom afflom left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Bounded review of the new source delta from 9106296 through 76164df credits the certified Coverage.Prims.updates root and the schema, PD-01, allocation, std-machine, SP-29 and README registration repairs. The latest commit also adds LM-09's update/option_bytes classification and calculus coverage for in-range and end-of-buffer updates. No new actionable defect was found in this delta; generated products and execution remain pending.

The schema change is a semantics input, so the earlier layout-only product receipt cannot qualify these additions. Reuse the existing producer 43899818065 at exact 76164df, then review its delivered products and resulting final-head/actual-tree acceptance. Keep canceled producers 43897616933 and 43894761302 separate. Existing owner retains implementation; no additional producer is requested. Reconcile the body's inherited family40 wording with the current registration.

Receipt pr443-7616-registration-review-20261116.json; SHA256 2fcedaced178904cf134d702b876ace43e712d1f36514df3ed77318260e300df. Full acceptance remains open.

… types

The canonical rewrite of Portable (b209368) renumbered the node table but
left the equation information of LexLeanRuntime.listIndex at its old numbers
(type 4316, value 4354), two nodes before its type and its value. Lean then
failed to generate listIndex.eq_1 in LexLeanCertification.Tail (GC-09):
'could not find .brecOn application'. The equations name 4318 and 4356 again.

The notation now refuses equation information whose type is not the
declaration's own type node, so a renumbering cannot strand it silently:
93 of the 94 equation records in the tree already held this, and the
94th was this one.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

@afflom afflom left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Bounded review of76164df1→6fe2cc41→7a5e84b5 credits the listIndex equation-record correction and the general formatter check rejecting eqn_info.type that differs from the declaration's type. This is a partial safeguard for #552: equation-reference remapping, value correspondence and a renumbering regression remain unestablished. The new source test covers matching/mismatched types; no independent test execution is claimed here.

The Option.zip rewrite preserves checked update outcomes; its additional eager conversion is pure. No new actionable defect was found in these three changed files. The PR body's family44 correction resolves the previous prose finding.

Existing owner retains the BS-07 certificate-size repair, #559's BS-11 repair/integration and resulting product/final-head/actual-tree qualification. Producer43909169458 is already active at7a5; keep canceled predecessors separate and use its eventual input-bound delivery. Current CI/repro failures do not qualify this head. No additional producer or competing patch is requested.

Receipt pr443-7a5-eqn-source-review-20261116.json; SHA256f65814e69ca60e50c94d18f7004e96104447e4f642cac4314e5d9e94a77f49ac.

#443 had merged the open #437 (decimal formatting through ToString, SM-43)
several times. That change is not on release/v0.5 and the certification
library is stated against the base formatting graph, so GC-09 refused
LexLeanCertification.Factor (primitive.eq_3170 and match_29.eq_1 are not what
the elaborator's construction makes once formatDecimal takes ToString).

This branch now differs from release/v0.5 by the update primitive alone:
- Portable is the base module plus LexLeanRuntime.update (112c5ee).
- RustLemmas is the base module plus the update cases (42919b1).
- Fixed, IdsSM, the semantic-ir feature, README and VERIFICATION are the
  base's.
- The tostring_instance writer, the decimal_format case and the
  tests/decimal-format fixture are removed.
#437 stays its own PR.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy
The update arm gives TargetSemantics.primitive's 29th matcher another
alternative. Every equation of that matcher, and its splitter, quantifies
over all the alternatives, so the 42 native rows Factor kept were no longer
what the elaborator's construction makes (GC-09: match_29.eq_1). Nothing in
the library uses them; they were the reserved names its elaboration made.
They are now derived rows, which the decoder has the construction remake,
as the preservation library already does for matcher equations (Compose).
GC-09 passes locally on this tree, relocked.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

afflom commented Nov 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

#443 now differs from release/v0.5 by the update primitive alone (34f88b9, b768135).

This branch had absorbed the open #437 (decimal formatting through ToString, SM-43) through earlier merges, and that change is what GC-09 refused. With formatDecimal taking ToString, LexLeanCertification.Factor's primitive.eq_3170 is no longer what the elaborator makes. The #437 change is dropped here, and #437 stays its own PR:

  • Portable is base plus LexLeanRuntime.update.
  • RustLemmas is base plus the update cases.
  • Fixed, IdsSM, the semantic-ir feature, README and VERIFICATION are the base's.
  • The tostring_instance writer, the decimal_format case and tests/decimal-format are removed.

The stale listIndex equation record was #437's renumbering, so it goes with it. The notation check that refuses an equation type other than the declaration's own stays.

The update arm adds an alternative to primitive's 29th matcher. Factor's 42 native rows for match_29's equations and its splitter are now derived rows, which the decoder has the elaborator remake, as Compose already does for matcher equations. No declaration in the library uses them.

GC-09 passes locally on this tree after relocking. BS-07's siteTrees budget is being measured locally, and regeneration runs on b768135.


Generated by Claude Code

@afflom afflom left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Bounded scope review credits removal of the absorbed #437 decimal-formatting work. Fixed, IdsSM, semantic-ir.feature, README and VERIFICATION match the v0.5 base by blob identity. Portable's160 existing declarations match after node-reference normalization, with update as the sole added declaration. listIndex returns with the base graph; the general equation-type guard/test remain. RustLemmas' claimed base-plus-update equivalence was not independently established from its oversized content.

Factor changes42 equation rows plus one splitter—43 declarations—to derived rows. Within Factor, these names occur only in their declaration headers. The decoder reconstructs reserved names and checks existence/kind; derived rows intentionally cease asserting stored levels/type/value identity. Certificate A refuses a derived row without a stored type. This is bounded source credit, not blanket native-to-derived acceptance or an exhaustive whole-library unused-name claim. Empty-axiom policy and final verification still apply; local GC-09 success remains owner-reported.

No new actionable defect was found in the inspected delta. Existing owner retains BS-07 measurement, #559's BS-11 repair/integration and resulting product/final-head/actual-tree qualification. Producer43924107489 already runs atb768; canceled predecessors remain separate. #437 and #552's broader obligations stay open. No additional producer or retry requested.

Receipt pr443-b768-scope-review-20261116.json; SHA25614469dbebb2ed73247f57f1959819085054fcd9c4ac616c9655312c10db98a06.

The write recipes of SPEC.md §9.2, run by regenerate.yml (https://github.com/UOR-Foundation/lexlean/actions/runs/43924107489),
rewrote 5675 paths.

The counts writer reported:

    BS-05 COMMITTED_CRATES: 306 -> 307 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 COMMITTED_FIXTURES: 122 -> 123 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 COMMITTED_MANIFESTS: 330 -> 331 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 COMMITTED_PROGRAMS: 247 -> 248 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 EVALUATOR_CORRESPOND: 326 -> 327 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 EVALUATOR_CRATES: 221 -> 222 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 EVALUATOR_VALIDATE: 461 -> 462 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 SEEDED_REFUSED_CORRESPOND: 253 -> 255 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 SEEDED_REFUSED_VALIDATE: 273 -> 266 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 VECTORS_CORRESPOND: 411 -> 412 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-05 VECTORS_VALIDATE: 546 -> 547 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_validate.rs)
    BS-06 COMMITTED_CRATES: 306 -> 307 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 COMMITTED_DISTINCT: 612 -> 614 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 COMMITTED_FIXTURES: 122 -> 123 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 COMMITTED_MANIFESTS: 330 -> 331 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 COMMITTED_PACKAGES: 330 -> 331 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 COMMITTED_PROGRAMS: 247 -> 248 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 EVALUATOR_CRATE: 612 -> 614 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 RUSTC_SEEDED_RUNS: 2989 -> 2990 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 SEEDED_EXPR: 400 -> 397 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 VECTORS_CRATE: 785 -> 787 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-06 VECTORS_EXPR: 2272 -> 2273 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_print.rs)
    BS-07 VECTORS: 411 -> 413 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_lower.rs)
    BS-07 VECTORS_WITHIN: 309 -> 311 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_lower.rs)
    BS-08 CRATES: 444 -> 445 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_moves.rs)
    BS-08 WITHIN: 359 -> 360 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_moves.rs)
    BS-11 EVALUATOR_MUTANTS: 270 -> 251 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_bodies.rs)
    BS-11 VECTORS: 158 -> 160 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_bodies.rs)
    BS-11 VECTORS_WITHIN: 157 -> 159 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_bodies.rs)
    BS-12 EVALUATOR_MUTANTS: 153 -> 154 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_succeed.rs)
    BS-13 EVALUATOR_MUTANTS: 137 -> 125 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_loops.rs)
    BS-14 EVALUATOR_MUTANTS: 553 -> 527 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_assemble.rs)
    BS-14 VECTORS: 415 -> 417 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_assemble.rs)
    BS-14 VECTORS_WITHIN: 313 -> 315 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_assemble.rs)
    BS-15 ACCEPTED: 330 -> 331 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_package.rs)
    BS-15 MANIFESTS: 349 -> 350 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_package.rs)
    BS-15 RENDER_MUTANTS: 330 -> 331 (crates/conformance/src/cases/bootstrap/rust_package.rs)
    BS-05: §31 row: 122 -> 123 (x1), 221 -> 222 (x1), 247 -> 248 (x1), 306 -> 307 (x1), 330 -> 331 (x1)
    BS-05: the §31 row does not state 253 (-> 255)
    BS-05: the §31 row does not state 273 (-> 266)
    BS-05: the §31 row does not state 326 (-> 327)
    BS-05: the §31 row does not state 411 (-> 412)
    BS-05: the §31 row does not state 461 (-> 462)
    BS-05: the §31 row does not state 546 (-> 547)
    BS-05: register: 122 -> 123 (x1), 221 -> 222 (x1), 247 -> 248 (x1), 306 -> 307 (x1), 330 -> 331 (x1)
    BS-05: scenario: 122 -> 123 (x1), 221 -> 222 (x1), 247 -> 248 (x1), 306 -> 307 (x1), 330 -> 331 (x1)
    BS-06: 3057 is VECTORS_CRATE + VECTORS_EXPR: -> 3060
    BS-06: §31 row: 122 -> 123 (x1), 247 -> 248 (x1), 330 -> 331 (x3), 612 -> 614 (x2), 785 -> 787 (x1), 2272 -> 2273 (x2), 2989 -> 2990 (x1), 3057 -> 3060 (x1)
    BS-06: the §31 row does not state 306 (-> 307)
    BS-06: register: 122 -> 123 (x1), 247 -> 248 (x1), 330 -> 331 (x3), 612 -> 614 (x2), 785 -> 787 (x1), 2272 -> 2273 (x2), 2989 -> 2990 (x1), 3057 -> 3060 (x1)
    BS-06: scenario: 122 -> 123 (x1), 247 -> 248 (x1), 330 -> 331 (x3), 612 -> 614 (x2), 785 -> 787 (x1), 2272 -> 2273 (x2), 2989 -> 2990 (x1), 3057 -> 3060 (x1)
    BS-07: §31 row: 309 -> 311 (x1), 411 -> 413 (x1)
    BS-07: register: 309 -> 311 (x1), 411 -> 413 (x1)
    BS-07: scenario: 309 -> 311 (x1), 411 -> 413 (x1)
    BS-08: §31 row: 359 -> 360 (x1), 444 -> 445 (x1)
    BS-08: register: 359 -> 360 (x1), 444 -> 445 (x1)
    BS-08: scenario: 359 -> 360 (x1), 444 -> 445 (x1)
    BS-11: §31 row: 157 -> 159 (x1), 158 -> 160 (x1), 270 -> 251 (x1)
    BS-11: register: 157 -> 159 (x1), 158 -> 160 (x1), 270 -> 251 (x1)
    BS-11: scenario: 157 -> 159 (x1), 158 -> 160 (x1), 270 -> 251 (x1)
    BS-12: §31 row: 153 -> 154 (x1)
    BS-12: register: 153 -> 154 (x1)
    BS-12: scenario: 153 -> 154 (x1)
    BS-13: §31 row: 137 -> 125 (x1)
    BS-13: register: 137 -> 125 (x1)
    BS-13: scenario: 137 -> 125 (x1)
    BS-14: §31 row: 415 -> 417 (x1), 553 -> 527 (x1)
    BS-14: the §31 row does not state 313 (-> 315)
    BS-14: register: 415 -> 417 (x1), 553 -> 527 (x1)
    BS-14: scenario: 415 -> 417 (x1), 553 -> 527 (x1)
    BS-15: §31 row: 330 -> 331 (x2), 349 -> 350 (x1)
    BS-15: register: 330 -> 331 (x2), 349 -> 350 (x1)
    BS-15: scenario: 330 -> 331 (x2), 349 -> 350 (x1)
    SPEC.md:8861: 158 -> 160 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8788: 330 -> 331 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8786: 444 -> 445 (BS-08)
    SPEC.md:8754: 309 -> 311 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8748: 153 -> 154 (BS-12)
    SPEC.md:8748: 309 -> 311 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8663: 330 -> 331 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8660: 122 -> 123 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8649: 2,989 -> 2,990 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8646: 2,272 -> 2,273 (BS-06)
    SPEC.md:8646: 612 -> 614 (BS-06)
    SPEC.md:8643: 330 -> 331 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8641: 2,272 -> 2,273 (BS-06)
    SPEC.md:8639: 330 -> 331 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8638: 122 -> 123 (BS-06)
    SPEC.md:8638: 330 -> 331 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8637: 247 -> 248 (BS-05)
    SPEC.md:8637: 612 -> 614 (BS-06)
    SPEC.md:8636: 785 -> 787 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8636: 3,057 -> 3,060 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8635: 330 -> 331 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8577: 306 -> 307 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8577: 221 -> 222 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8572: 546 -> 547 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8562: 306 -> 307 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8561: 122 -> 123 (every holder)
    SPEC.md:8560: 330 -> 331 (BS-05)
    SPEC.md:8560: 247 -> 248 (BS-05)

    VERIFICATION.md rows for the landing (counts | before | after):
    | `BS-05` COMMITTED_CRATES, COMMITTED_FIXTURES, COMMITTED_MANIFESTS, COMMITTED_PROGRAMS, EVALUATOR_CORRESPOND, EVALUATOR_CRATES, EVALUATOR_VALIDATE, SEEDED_REFUSED_CORRESPOND, SEEDED_REFUSED_VALIDATE, VECTORS_CORRESPOND, VECTORS_VALIDATE | 306, 122, 330, 247, 326, 221, 461, 253, 273, 411, 546 | 307, 123, 331, 248, 327, 222, 462, 255, 266, 412, 547 |
    | `BS-06` COMMITTED_CRATES, COMMITTED_DISTINCT, COMMITTED_FIXTURES, COMMITTED_MANIFESTS, COMMITTED_PACKAGES, COMMITTED_PROGRAMS, EVALUATOR_CRATE, RUSTC_SEEDED_RUNS, SEEDED_EXPR, VECTORS_CRATE, VECTORS_EXPR | 306, 612, 122, 330, 330, 247, 612, 2,989, 400, 785, 2,272 | 307, 614, 123, 331, 331, 248, 614, 2,990, 397, 787, 2,273 |
    | `BS-07` VECTORS, VECTORS_WITHIN | 411, 309 | 413, 311 |
    | `BS-08` CRATES, WITHIN | 444, 359 | 445, 360 |
    | `BS-11` EVALUATOR_MUTANTS, VECTORS, VECTORS_WITHIN | 270, 158, 157 | 251, 160, 159 |
    | `BS-12` EVALUATOR_MUTANTS | 153 | 154 |
    | `BS-13` EVALUATOR_MUTANTS | 137 | 125 |
    | `BS-14` EVALUATOR_MUTANTS, VECTORS, VECTORS_WITHIN | 553, 415, 313 | 527, 417, 315 |
    | `BS-15` ACCEPTED, MANIFESTS, RENDER_MUTANTS | 330, 349, 330 | 331, 350, 331 |

    For a reader:
      BS-06 SEEDED_EXPR: 400 is also the value of ["EVALUATOR_CAP", "EVALUATOR_MUTANTS", "SEEDED_CRATE"]; rewrite its statements by hand (400 -> 397)
      SPEC.md:8573 still states 411 (-> 413 for BS-07?) before "of `correspondCrate` (104 refused), and"
      SPEC.md:8745 still states 411 (-> 413 for BS-07?) before "per root: the committed target programs"
    wrote /home/runner/work/lexlean/lexlean/CONFORMANCE.md and /home/runner/work/lexlean/lexlean/ERRORS.md

    written, with SPEC.md and the model projected again; next: the parts without LEXLEAN_COUNTS

afflom commented Nov 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

honesty on b07b5aa: compiler/src/TargetFixtures.lex.tex is newer than compiler/expected/build. The oracles writer added the byte-updates calculus fixture in the same pass in which the records writer built from the tree without it. A second regeneration from the delivered head is running (43946279519) to bring the build up to date with it.


Generated by Claude Code

@afflom afflom left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

b07b5aa is the direct generated child of reviewed b768135. Producer43924107489 completed all seven jobs, and its identity/part/combined/final artifact metadata remain bound to b768; that is production credit, not delivered-tree acceptance. TargetFixtures is generated by check-calculus, although it lives under compiler/src. The delivered source adds byteUpdatesProgram/Run/Outcome, while its committed TargetFixtures.lean build output has none, confirming the specific stale-product gap in owner6927794785.

The workflow exposes two ordering edges: records starts from original+identity without the newly generated fixtures, and the oracles leg itself runs golden-write before calculus-write. The smallest future owner fix is fixture emission before both golden publication and dependent records, with explicit artifact/input custody, reusing completed independent outputs. Existing second producer43946279519 is already running at b07; no additional run is requested. Await its delivered products and final qualification. Prior bounded source credit and all existing obligations/STOPs remain unchanged.

…get)

With prim update, certificate A of CalculusCheck.siteTrees measured 3,166,544
bytes, 20,816 over three quarters of max_file_bytes (3,145,728). The 62 guarded
typings in CalculusCheck bound the accepting and the refusing outcome
(let yesN, let noN) and then selected one. Each now reads as one conditional
over the two outcomes. The program computes the same results, and the two
bindings and their environment entries leave every certificate of the
closure.

Measured part A of each root, written by the certificate generator on this tree:
  siteTrees          3,111,074 (34,654 below the bound)
  useTrees           3,112,500
  deadFunctions      1,343,409
  fallibleFunctions  1,073,690
  lowerTypes         1,592,526
Chapter 17 states the new figures. Nothing is added to the closure of
siteTrees.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy
Vector counts add both lines' fixtures: rust_lower 419, rust_assemble 423.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

@afflom afflom left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

At2445e350 the new producer43958196397 has a distinct delivery blocker: oracles133629895631 checks out that exact head and applies identity, then golden-write fails on kappa LLC0102 (stale/noncanonical lock) at21:39:06Z. It never reaches fixtures/calculus or capture/upload, so its earlier golden console writes are not a delivered artifact. Please reconcile the kappa lock with identity-relock coverage while preserving its oracle; no retry or additional producer is requested. The prior fixture-ordering mechanism also remains in both2445 and5595106: golden precedes calculus, and records receives only identity.patch.559's shared __taken_true/false lemma repair is now present in source and preserves the explicit rewrite/transport path; its kernel, size and delivered-product qualification remain owed. Existing owners and prior source credit remain retained.

The merge of release/v0.5 took kappa/lexlean.lock from the merged line,
whose compiler_semantics is release/v0.5's identity; every other lock of
this branch carries the branch's, so relock-identity kept kappa's back and
golden-write refused it as stale (LLC0102). `lexlean lock` in kappa/ moves
only that line, and the regeneration's relock moves it with the rest.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_013Asa3PPDQti4rghmmPSZGy

@afflom afflom left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

The new exact deltas are narrow: #443 (2445→6ba) and #559 (5106→023) change only kappa/lexlean.lock's compiler_semantics pin, a1477c2e→c0978bf3, matching the inspected compiler/collections pin. The oracle lanes of existing producers43962840356 and43962881592 now pass, resolving the specific prior Kappa writer blocker within those runs; exact-head repros also pass. This does not change general relock coverage or establish delivered products.

The fixture-ordering defect remains: the unchanged workflow still runs golden before calculus and gives records only identity.patch. Existing owners retain fixture-before-consumer custody and full delivered-head qualification; prior #559 shared-lemma source credit remains. No new producer or retry requested. Receipt pr443-559-lock-delta-review-20261116.json, SHA2566162107897144d2a48b4b321c0a316c83fa93e48dde040d8eb2e2609c3e3ff22.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants