Repository navigation
Integrate Host request types and deep package export/replay - #389
Conversation
The GNAF request validation of SPEC §17.15 (`gnaf::validate`) becomes a conformance row: `validateRequest` of `GnafValidate`, a language-1.2 production root in the `bootstrap/` project, held to the Rust oracle byte for byte. R3 first commit: the row in model/ids.toml, the SPEC §31 row and total (459), CONFORMANCE.md, the README, repository.rs and spec_links.rs counts, the bootstrap.feature scenario, the bdd-parts and vv-rows entries, and conformance_bs_16, which fails with "no bootstrap case is wired for BS-16". Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`validateRequest` of `GnafValidate` as a language-1.2 module of the bootstrap project, its entrypoint, and the BS-16 case with its dispatch arm. The module passes `lexlean check`; the plant sites, the measured counts, and the differential run follow. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…275-gnaf-validate # Conflicts: # CONFORMANCE.md # SPEC.md
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Twelve plants are detected, the evaluator agrees on 3862 vectors and rustc on all. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…td.Host (#271) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…PEC and VERIFICATION (#275) Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ssue-271-effects-boundary # Conflicts: # README.md # SPEC.md # crates/conformance/src/cases/repository.rs # xtask/src/spec_links.rs
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…idate_request The lock pins GnafValidate; every bootstrap package's provenance records the new semantic digest, and validate_request joins the committed packages. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The package adds one manifest to the committed tree. BS-05 and BS-06 give the measured vector counts; the counts they assert after those are still being measured, and the text that restates them is not yet updated. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…fValidate's case The validate_request package adds a crate and a vector to each corpus that draws on the committed packages. cargo fmt reflows two spots of the BS-16 case. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
… rows BS-14 gives 333 vectors (the vector #371 adds and the one the validate_request package adds), 282 within the bound. The statements of BS-05 to BS-08, BS-13, BS-14 and BS-15, SPEC.md 17.23, CONFORMANCE.md, VERIFICATION.md and the CHANGELOG state the counts of the tree with the package. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The locks, goldens, shipped calculus modules, fixtures, production exports and verification records of the identity PD-10's registry rows move. The relock moved only the ID in 251 negative fixtures, so a lock that is wrong on purpose keeps its defect. The Atlas is language 1.0 and does not move. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ssue-271-effects-boundary
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
AU-04 holds every language-1.2 source of the product to its own printed form. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Focused progress: BS-14 passed in2,139.22s and SL-10 in485.74s, bringing the admitted phase to6/8 completed cases. BS-20 is running; PX-07's real65-element export/replay is still required. Existing strict corpus counts remain unchanged. Independent review also cleared the prepared16-path integration of landed #413 (actual release/v0.4 head5393f5528). It preserves all470 Host-candidate claims, both verification histories and every Host/#402 implementation/generated artifact; all905 embedded inputs are byte-identical. Only RP-14's statement and the reviewed CI orchestration change. This delta therefore requires no new identity regeneration. It is isolated preparation and has not changed the running Host checkout/index. After the focused phase completes, the final candidate will use actual #389 first-parent ancestry plus #402 and5393f5528, excluding the disposable conflict-audit history, then receive full final-head CI. Delivery scope is the Host publication in #382 and the integrated deep-reader fix in #378; #271 remains open for the driver/watchdog and other command-root work. The next identity wave remains #393. |
|
New blocking focused result: BS-20 passed in5,331.40s at2026-11-04 00:02:53 UTC, including its differential/mutation and final certified-export checks. PX-07 then aborted with a stack overflow (process status−6) after1.19s. The supervisor stopped, so the after-phase provenance checks were not reached. Seven named cases have passed; the required real65-element export/replay acceptance has not passed. No final commit, publication, readiness change or hosted full gate was created. The reviewed external CI-integration index remains unchanged. The failure log and boundary report are preserved, and a bounded source investigation is underway. This does not establish the earlier TC-03/RP-18 failure causes; no speculative stack increase, helper bypass or unchanged rerun is being applied. The already-authorized #391 validation acquired the shared lock after the failed Host phase; #396 remains serialized behind it. #382/#378 remain open. |
|
The PX-07 blocker is now localized further. Two temporary boundary diagnostics reproduced the same stack overflow, each in about1.19s. The 65-element source was copied, locked, loaded and checked successfully; root lowering and manifest construction also returned. The first unreturned boundary is The temporary instrumentation preserved the input, original expressions/lifetimes, assertions, helpers and stack settings; both source files were restored exactly afterward. Linked roots and all905 embedded inputs matched the admitted Host source, and the staged candidate tree remains da18af2e3d7746d55c487521f49fecbb3cf18df3. The seven completed focused passes remain valid. Diagnostic completion is not acceptance. I am narrowing the package-generation traversal before choosing a source fix. No stack increase, export refusal, identity bypass, new writer wave or full gate has been started. #389/#402 remain draft and #382/#378 open. #391's focused validation currently owns the shared phase lock; the next diagnostic remains serialized behind it. The separate #396 fixture correction is now reviewed and in final-head hosted CI. |
|
The PX-07 investigation has identified two recursive lowering boundaries. A reviewed thin dispatcher for Rust data constructors lets the complete package generation, printing and serialization return. Verification then reaches a second production lower_root invocation and overflows inside its pending-body term lowering, before any Lean process starts. The same root had already lowered successfully during the earlier build. This does not implicate the JSON readers, the Lean emitter, or kernel checking. A second independently reviewed refactor routes recursive Cons/Record/Constructor/Pair lowering through a small dispatcher, preserving the original arms and their operation order verbatim. The combined candidate compiled with confirmed checkout and embedded-input provenance, and one unchanged PX-07 run is now active. There are no stack-size, input-limit, fixture, helper or assertion changes. All diagnostic instrumentation has been removed; previous failed results remain recorded. This is provisional functional validation: the renderer pin is deliberately still the previously admitted pin, so no identity acceptance is claimed. If the unchanged regression passes, the reviewed final source still needs the official identity update and affected artifact regeneration before final-head full CI. Both PRs remain draft; #382/#378 remain open. The seven earlier focused passes are retained as historical evidence, not rerun for diagnosis. |
|
The unchanged PX-07 case now passes: one test, zero failures, 469 filtered out, 386.63 seconds with the two reviewed lowering dispatchers. This includes the 65-element production export/replay regression and existing tamper checks. No stack, input, helper or assertion changes were made. Formatting passed. Clippy then correctly rejected a wildcard enum arm in the new production dispatcher; the historical phase remains recorded as failed at that step. A narrow correction explicitly enumerates the other 38 variants while retaining the exact delegation body. A separate fmt/Clippy-only continuation passed (2.65s/25.96s), preserving the lint and avoiding another PX-07 execution. Both source files were restored exactly after validation, the candidate index is unchanged, and final source review is being bound to these results. The reproduced functional blocker is resolved in the prepared source. Identity acceptance is still pending: calculus/rust/lower.rs is a renderer fingerprint input, so the official renderer/1.2 identity and dependent artifacts must now be refreshed from the settled source. The earlier writer results remain evidence at their previous identity; they will not be presented as final-head acceptance. Language1.0/1.1 must remain unchanged. This continues the same owned Host+Order/#402 wave; no competing regeneration, publication or readiness change has begun. |
|
The same owned integration wave has resumed on the settled, reviewed lowering source. The canonical renderer fingerprint check passed at The official calculus writer and comparison passed for all977 files. Independent review found only source-identity/provenance JSON changes, with generated code unchanged. All22 valid relocks reached a fixed point;239 negative locks changed only their compiler identity, while59 remained byte-identical. The three target-descriptor refreshes received separate review and preserve malformed GNAF evidence, zero certificate IDs, the invalid package name and the original LLB6007/6006/6005 refusals. Local helper locks remain outside the candidate. One official all-five-project export writer is now running under the shared phase lock. No competing writer or full gate is running locally. A concrete writer-order dependency was also established: calculus Rust-package metadata reads the compiler golden manifest at runtime, so its final refresh/comparison must follow the upcoming golden regeneration. The embedded-input probe alone does not cover that dependency. These are intermediate regeneration results, not final-head acceptance. The PR stays draft until final artifacts, real integration history and source review are ready for full CI; merge and #382/#378 closure still require that complete passing gate. |
#275) CI at 7b854b6 passed BS-07, BS-08, BS-10, BS-11, BS-12, BS-15, BS-16 and BS-20 with the counts of the previous commit and named the first count assertion of four rows: BS-05 496 runs of validateCrate (211 refused) and 361 of correspondCrate; BS-06 687 vectors of printCrate (65 refused, 520 committed distinct), so 2,832 vectors; BS-13 104 vectors; BS-14 339 vectors. The statements, scenarios, CONFORMANCE.md, SPEC.md (section 31 and 17.23) and VERIFICATION.md state them. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
The final-source export refresh completed successfully: all 117 packages (10 production, 52 coverage, 22 stdlib, 30 bootstrap, 3 helpdesk), 3002.16 seconds. Owner and independent actual-artifact reviews agree: only the expected sources[0] and compiler-semantics metadata changed; generated code/configuration and package file sets stayed byte-identical. Frozen executables, the 905 embedded inputs and the three admitted negative descriptors matched their reviewed boundaries. The already-reviewed remaining writer sequence is now active under the same exclusive phase discipline. Golden regeneration passed (58.30s), followed by the required calculus metadata refresh against the actual new compiler golden manifest (20.95s) and one successful comparison (10.42s). The fixture writer is running; normalized non-Atlas verification follows only after it succeeds. Language1.0/1.1 remain unchanged. No final readiness or passing full gate is claimed. The integration still needs final artifact review, publication with actual PR/release ancestry rather than disposable audit history, and complete final-head CI before merge or issue closure. The earlier focused passes and provisional PX-07 result are retained without rerunning them during regeneration. |
The language-1.2 compiler-semantics ID stays d30b16b3 (the second relock moved 0 of 327 locks). Locks, golden and calculus copies, fixtures, production-export packages and the verification records are rewritten on the merged tree. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Live-head refresh found The active writer is left intact to finish its atomic phase. It has completed the fixture rewrite with negative inputs/codes/outcomes preserved and is now finishing non-Atlas verification. Its results will describe exactly that admitted source, not the newly added BS16 source. #390's remaining Unicode and BS15 prose corrections are already reviewed in30171790 and remain required. Final publication must explicitly reconcile the new contributor history with the coordinated source scope; it cannot silently count old artifacts as acceptance for the added source or start a second writer concurrently. |
|
The new Maintainer integration plan: preserve There is an important ancestry constraint: because #390's current head is now an ancestor of No force-push, history deletion, new writer or active-checkout mutation has been performed for this reconciliation. Final publication remains blocked on the admitted writer/artifact review and concrete source/history review; any further contributor head movement will be refreshed before mutation. |
|
All admitted official writers have now completed, including fixture regeneration (1063.80s) and all 21 selected non-Atlas verification projects (3849.247s). Negative inputs/codes/outcomes, frozen executables, 905 embedded inputs and 778 Atlas paths passed their recorded boundaries. No retry was needed. Actual artifact review stopped on one changed observation: R25.__fits_80._unsafe_rec printed Finalization is now preparing the actual reviewed tree, reusing #436's already-reviewed test-helper profile correction without another identity wave. The contributor-history/BS16 restack condition in6622709624 remains binding before merge. Final hosted acceptance is still required after publication; local writer success is not merge clearance. |
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Final source/artifact/tree review at 88b078c (tree5fba9f362ca17e23ffff208b09378b0cb60cd993). Independent review bound all10548 captured paths to the admitted official writer inventories, with explicit reviewed post-writer field-pattern, test-helper and documentation corrections. Model/spec/fmt/focusedClippy and exactRP11 passed; original failed attempts remain recorded. Actual ordered parents27e4525c/402b3ec/5393 preserve contributor/release history and exclude disposable9ca ancestry. BS16 is deliberately excluded and must be redelivered as a new nonancestor head in existingdraft390 BEFORE any Host merge. No merge clearance: require complete final-head same-run honesty/fullCI/repro and final actual merge-tree comparison. Self-authored integration review is COMMENT, not self-approval.
|
The required BS16 ancestry handoff is now published in existing draft #390 at7ca5a7ff369135c1c700cb376c19cc18ba227489. Its first parent is this reviewed Host head88b078cc; second parent30171790 preserves the reviewed Unicode/count repair. Original390ffb is retained, the actual Host→390 diff is nonempty, and the new390head is NOT an ancestor of Host. Thus this Host merge cannot mark incomplete BS16 delivered by ancestry alone. #390/#432 remain open and draft/pending; its explicit source-only restack does not claim generated correctness or execution. Host fullCI41781980948 and repro41781934634 are pending; this handoff is not merge clearance. |
|
The formerly failing deep-list path now has actual final-pin hosted evidence. At head The exact head retains the unchanged65-element project, exported JSON depth>128, package build, BindingsVerified replay, and subsequent tamper checks. This validates the final renderer/semantic pin on that path; it is distinct from the earlier provisional test. No stack increase, refusal, helper override, identity bypass or repeat local gate was used. Full CI is still incomplete, so this is not merge clearance. Keep #390's explicit draft redelivery open and outside Host ancestry, and keep #382/#378 open until the entire final gate passes and the actual merge tree is verified. |
|
#284 has now landed as1a690b51 on release/v0.4 after its complete passing gate; #428/#436 are explicitly closed and the actual merge tree matched. This advances Host's target beyond the5393 base used by the current CI run. I restored draft status while preparing the necessary integration with that actual release head. Keep the current Host run intact to finish collecting its exact88b evidence, including the already-passed final-pin PX-07; do not rerun or cancel it. Do not count that old-base run as acceptance of the future combined tree. The integration must retain DF-19 and the already-identical #436 profile fix, reconcile actual register/documentation counts and any genuinely stale DF-19 fixture lock, and preserve the completed Host artifacts/identities wherever their inputs are unchanged. No repeat writer or blanket regeneration is authorized. After source/artifact review, publish the integrated head and require its complete final-head gate. #390's explicit BS-16 redelivery must remain draft/open and outside Host ancestry; #382/#378 remain open. |
Preserve the accepted release and Host histories, reconcile the 471-claim register, and adopt the single official DF-19 fixture semantics relock. Host renderer identities and generated products are unchanged. The prior Host gate is historical evidence; complete changed-head CI remains required before this integration can merge.
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Final new-base source/artifact integration review at943bba379a (tree65aa81df). Independent source and emitted-lock reviews clear the18-path delta from Host88b: accepted DF-19, actual471 register/scenario/test union and truthful mirrors, only README/VERIFICATION conflicts, identical #436 helper. One official frozen-CLI fixture lock operation changed only compiler_semantics to currentHost1b848; the producer-owned empty guard is archived outside the tree. All other Host products,905 embedded inputs and identities remain unchanged; no broader writer or repeated local gate ran. Ordered parents88b+actualrelease1a preserve real history, and existing draft390head7ca is not an ancestor.
Prior exact88b CI41781980948 is now complete44/44success, including final-pin PX-07, with repro41781934634 passed. That evidence does not accept this combined tree. Source readiness permits the complete new-head gate; merge still requires every applicable final-head job, same-run honesty/repro, current390scope separation and actual merge-tree equality. Self-authored integration review is COMMENT, not self-approval. Prospective closure382/378 only;271/432/275 remain open.
afflom
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Final acceptance review is complete at 943bba3. CI41802893306 passed all 44 jobs with no skipped required stages; same-run honesty and reproducibility41802841576 passed. The final production PX07 and rest DF19 executions passed on synthetic333ce9b; the final BS15 package case passed with real Lean (10536.07s). No local cases or writer phases were repeated to obtain this final gate.
Fresh API head/base checks are unchanged:943b against actual release1a690b51. Reviewed head, tested tree and proposed merge tree all equal65aa81df295f974d87cec011a35aa427da2a6a63. The source/artifact review, official identity refresh and exact DF19 relock remain intact. Existing R25 group-union policy was preserved, not relaxed.
The live API confirms #390's explicit draft redelivery7ca5a7ff is divergent and not an ancestor of this head; it must remain open after landing. This delivery closes #382 and #378 only. #271 and the BS16/other parent trackers remain open. Actual merged-tree verification and explicit non-default-branch issue closure follow the merge. This is a COMMENT review of maintainer-authored integration, not self-approval.
RB-24's base, #389, landed; this takes the line at f1b70fe. The six conflicts keep both sides: release/v0.4's text with RB-24's own edits applied over it three-way, the register at 478 IDs (SPEC.md, the README in the line's wording, the RP-07 check and its case), both CHANGELOG entries, and both rows of plants in VERIFICATION.md. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds the language-1.2 Host request/effect types and eligibility boundary, retains landed Order and maintenance, and incorporates #402’s deep program/manifest readers plus the reviewed lowering dispatchers. This is the first Host slice; #271’s driver/watchdog work remains open.
Final integration head
943bba379a008c66ad362f6c53c58a95c461f8ed, tree65aa81df295f974d87cec011a35aa427da2a6a63, preserves Host88b078ccas first parent and accepted release/v0.41a690b51as second. The release parent contains #284’s DF-19 and #436’s generated-workspace profile correction. README/register/scenario/test mirrors reconcile to 471 claims; the #436 helper is byte-identical on both parents.The new DF-19 fixture’s semantics lock was genuinely stale against Host. One official frozen-CLI lock operation changed only its
compiler_semanticsvalue to1b848115…; all five other fixture inputs stayed unchanged. Its newly created empty advisory guard was archived outside the candidate. The initial review stop and subsequent disposition are preserved. This writer is lock-production evidence, not DF-19 acceptance. No blanket regeneration or repeated local gate was run for the integration.Completed Host official writers cover calculus/relocks, all 117 exported packages, goldens and the required post-golden calculus comparison, fixtures, and all 21 selected non-Atlas verification projects (3849.247s). Renderer pin is
fa09fcc9…; semantics 1.2 is1b848115…; 1.0/1.1 are unchanged. Frozen executable/905-input boundaries, negative guarantees and 778 Atlas paths were preserved. The DF-19 integration changes no Host renderer inputs or generated products.Artifact review initially stopped on R25’s mutual-partial axiom observation. Prerequisite review admitted it under the existing SPEC §17.17 group-union contract: exact partial pins, axiom union, normalized proof bytes and root policies are unchanged. The actual printed observation and historical stop remain; no policy relaxation or producer rerun occurred. This does not close #222.
At prior head
88b078cc/ tested tree5fba9f36, hosted PX-07 passed with real Lean in 202.6s in job126416296759. It retains the unchanged 65-element project, JSON depth greater than128, package build, BindingsVerified replay and tamper matrix. This is final-pin evidence on that earlier tree, distinct from provisional functional tests. It does not replace the complete gate on this combined head.Source/artifact review of the Host delivery and the new-base integration is complete. Earlier model/spec/fmt/focused Clippy and exact RP-11 evidence remains recorded with its actual source provenance; failures and corrections remain in VERIFICATION. No new local full gate or repeat of the seven focused cases/PX-07 is claimed. Merge requires complete final-head same-run honesty, dynamic inventory, supported hosts, Atlas shards/join, reproducibility and an identical actual merge tree.
The contributor’s
27e4525chistory is retained. Its incomplete BS-16 expansion is explicitly excluded and redelivered in existing draft #390 at7ca5a7ff369135c1c700cb376c19cc18ba227489, preserving reviewed Unicode and BS15 repairs. That new #390 head is NOT an ancestor of this Host integration and has a nonempty BS-16 diff. Refresh that separation before merge and verify #390 remains open/draft afterward. BS-16 projections/artifacts/counts/full acceptance belong to the coordinated next #393 wave; #432/#275 stay open.After accepted landing, #402 can be closed as superseded with the merged Host PR linked. Prospective closure scope is #382 and #378 only; #271 remains open. #428/#436 are already closed by the independently accepted #284 landing, not by this PR.
Closes #382
Closes #378