Repository navigation
Description
Future replay-cache infrastructure prerequisite for #338; scoped extension of the already-landed #126/SL-06 contract. It is NOT a prerequisite for initial Mathlib delivery #362. No duplicate Mathlib PR or independent regeneration wave.
Scope correction after independent call-site review: the conflict exists in the unsplit draft source, but every DigestSet/streaming consumer belongs to currently unused replay-cache infrastructure. The actual CLI/glossary/loaded-import path already uses certified Sha256Digest::of. Preserve the cache prototype, claims and tests together in future #338 preparation; do not add this capability merely to compile unrelated code in the initial #335/#336/#341 delivery. The R3 proposal remains unexecuted, and implementation is paused pending the future cache source/interface decision.
The reviewed source union retains SL-06’s certified stdlib-only SHA-256 and omits shipped sha2, but #362’s DigestSetWriter still imports sha2. The actual new consumers stream an executable in 64 KiB reads and declaration-group frames. The current certified package exports only whole-message sha256/sha256Hex; FramedHasher buffers its message. Reintroducing sha2, buffering whole files/groups, or calling generated numbered internal functions does not faithfully resolve this integration.
Deliver the smallest certified incremental interface needed by DigestSetWriter, reusing authored Sha256 compression logic. Reserve SL-15 (SL-12 Host, SL-13 reader and SL-14 maps remain distinct).
Acceptance:
- Follow R3 in v0.5’s authoritative spec sources: row/scenario/named falsifiable test before implementation. Keep every existing SL-02/SL-06 guarantee and strict comparison.
- Stable exported initialization/update/finalization state retains only chaining words, cumulative length and a partial block; processing memory is bounded by state plus the supplied chunk. The Rust adapter must use declared certified exports, without another SHA implementation.
- Digest bytes equal SHA-256 of the concatenated input for empty input/updates, arbitrary tested chunk partitions and FIPS padding/block boundaries. Preserve one-shot, framing, DigestSet JSON, BLAKE3 and caller I/O behavior. Use existing authority vectors and non-shipped differential oracle; retain a planted compression/length/padding defect refusal.
- Handle the actual FIPS 64-bit bit-length domain explicitly, including cumulative overflow. Streaming cannot reuse the one-shot assumption that a host cannot allocate 2^61 bytes. Review the closed public error contract and boundary tests; no arbitrary practical size cap, silent wrap or public panic.
- Replace only DigestSetWriter’s SHA component, exercise the actual executable and group-frame callers, and verify the bounded-state/chunk behavior. Do not claim cache replay, imported closure validation or broader Mathlib delivery through this slice.
- When the future cache source/interface is admitted, coordinate this source/roots/linkage with its required v0.5 identity/product wave. Initial Add pinned Lean-library imports, glossary generation, wrappers and axiom auditing #362 must not wait for it. Official model/export/identity/artifact writers and complete final-head CI remain required for this capability; explicitly close through its reviewed merged issue-closing PR, not source preparation alone.
Independent source/design audit: /workspace/work/forward362-hash-policy-review/REVIEW.md, bound to source candidate b0a02df8 (later spec-entrypoint additions do not change inspected hashing paths). No runtime execution or implementation has been performed for this prerequisite.
Activity
[-]SL-15: certified incremental SHA-256 for DigestSet streaming[/-][+]SL-15: certified incremental SHA-256 for future replay-cache streaming[/+]