Repository navigation
Description
Validate Collections for Silo 1.0 across the server, web, Apple, and Android. This is the feature-acceptance parent, not an implementation request or an RC-wide release gate.
Scope: Movies and Series. Product baseline: published milestone Collections card. Criteria revision: Collections acceptance v1, established by this tracking update. If scope changes, record a new criteria revision and review affected evidence.
Shared/smart authoring is web-admin only. Private authoring is available on web and Android mobile. Apple mobile and both TV clients consume collections without authoring.
Decision, 27 Sep 2026 (maintainer): a personal collection belongs to the profile that created it, and only that profile can change it, including its order. The owner can turn on Show to other profiles; every profile on the same login then sees it read-only under Shared with me. It never crosses logins. A shared personal collection shows each viewer only titles both the owner and the viewer can access. Personal collection groups are removed. Existing collections shared with only some profiles become private. Implementation: silo-server #1615, silo-android #406, silo-apple #534; all block this parent. AC2 and the cross-client checks were updated in place under Collections acceptance v1.
Source baseline (siloserver.org commit): 204bf691062a71ad0528fb1606c9ce6011446381. The website link opens the current published feature; the recorded commit identifies the criteria source used when this issue was created.
Acceptance criteria
- AC1: Browse a Collections section and open one to list its members on every required client.
- AC2: Shared collections show for everyone with applicable access. A private collection is visible and accessible only to its owner, unless the owner shows it to other profiles: then every profile on the same login sees it read-only, limited to titles both the owner and that profile can access. Only the owner can change it.
- AC3: Smart/rule collections auto-populate and stay current; an empty collection has a defined empty state.
- AC4: Collections spanning restricted libraries expose only allowed members. A restricted profile cannot add or access restricted content.
- AC5: An admin creates and manages shared/smart collections in web admin: members, rules, ordering, and artwork. Non-admin users cannot perform these administrative actions.
- AC6: Any user creates and manages their own private collections on web and Android mobile, respecting profile access.
- AC7: Shared/smart authoring stays web-admin only. Apple mobile has no authoring requirement; TV clients expose no collection create/manage entry point.
Surface validation tasks
Each linked issue is a native GitHub sub-issue of this parent. Phone and tablet need separate results even when they share a task.
| Surface | Task | Initial result |
|---|---|---|
| Server/API | silo-server #193 | S1–S7 pass: automated API checks (perms.py, 105 of 105) written by the agent and run by the maintainer on 2026-11-10 against a local sandbox of build 2141 · 30a6abd19. Earlier agent API testing on builds 927, 941 and 1012 is kept in the task. No acceptance yet. Accepted by the maintainer on 15 November 2026 (closed). |
| Web admin | silo-server #194 | A2, A3, A4, A5 pass (human validation, 2026-11-10, local sandbox of build 2141 · 30a6abd19). A1 fail on #3924 (duplicate name; blocking); the rest of A1 passes. Also blocked by #3696. No acceptance yet. A3–A5 accepted 15 November 2026; A1 and A2 wait on re-tests of the merged #3924 and #3696 fixes. A1 and A2 re-tested and passed on build 2405 · 7115ee702 (2026-11-15); all cases accepted, task closed. |
| Web | silo-server #195 | W1 and W6 pass (W1 re-checked on build 2141 · 30a6abd19; human validation, 2026-11-09, local sandboxes of build 2069 · a5294117 and 2072 · 4018816da (no Collections change between them)); W2 and W3 pass (human validation, 2026-11-09, local sandbox of build 2072 · 4018816da; W2 re-tested on build 2141 · 30a6abd19); W4 pass (human validation, 2026-11-10, local sandbox of build 2141 · 30a6abd19; failed on 2072 before #3697 was fixed); W5 and W7 pass (human validation, 2026-11-10, local sandbox of build 2141 · 30a6abd19). All Web cases have a human result. Non-blocking #3692 and #3693 fixed. No acceptance yet. W1, W3–W7 accepted 15 November 2026; W2 waits on the #3696 re-test. W2 re-tested and passed on build 2405 · 7115ee702 (2026-11-15); all cases accepted, task closed. |
| iPhone and iPad | silo-apple #20 | Not run on both |
| Apple TV | silo-apple #21 | Not run |
| Android phone and tablet | silo-android #5 | Not run on both |
| Android TV | silo-android #6 | Not run |
Cross-client checks
Assign an owner for these checks; surface passes alone do not prove cross-client behavior. Record the exact participating builds.
- X1 / AC1, AC2, AC6: Create a private collection on Android mobile. The same profile can browse it on web and Apple.
- X2 / AC2, AC4: Switch to another profile on the same account, then another account. The private collection and its direct links remain inaccessible.
- X3 / AC1, AC3, AC5: Change shared collection members, rules, ordering, and artwork in web admin. Required clients reflect the resulting collection; record refresh/reopen steps used.
- X4 / AC4: Use a collection spanning allowed and restricted libraries. On every required client, a restricted profile sees and opens only permitted members; confirm server-side rejection in Collections — Server #193.
- X5 / AC2, AC4, AC6: On Android mobile, as an unrestricted profile, create a private collection with titles above PG and turn on Show to other profiles. As a PG profile on the same login, it appears under Shared with me on web, Apple and Android with the owner's name, shows only PG-or-lower titles, and offers no management actions. A profile on another login never sees it. Turn the switch off; it disappears for the PG profile.
Related bug reports
These reports were reviewed for relevance, not reproduced on a new validation build. Keep their existing repository/parent relationships. A link does not by itself classify a release blocker.
| Bug | Coverage affected | Initial disposition |
|---|---|---|
| silo-server #990: web cannot create manual collections | AC6; Web #195 | Candidate acceptance blocker if reproduced on the selected build. |
| silo-server #935: template collection posters missing on native clients | AC1/AC5 presentation checks; Server #193 and native tasks | Reported on Android/Android TV; Apple impact is unverified. Record affected clients before classifying. |
| silo-server #903: smart collections lack generated collages | AC5 artwork; Web admin #194 | Related. Automatic collage generation is not explicitly required by this card; do not silently add it to acceptance. |
| silo-server #1131: artwork reconciliation rejects bundled poster paths | AC5 artwork maintenance; Server #193 / Web admin #194 | Related operational failure. Determine user-visible acceptance impact; not automatically a Collections blocker. |
silo-server #1552: personal collections always report item_count: 0 |
AC1, AC6; Server #193 S2, Web #195 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 27 Sep 2026). Found by agent API testing on 66f6a52a. Fixed by PR #1582; agent retest passed on build 1012 · 19e81846 (28 Sep 2026). Awaiting maintainer acceptance. |
| silo-server #1553: artwork upload returns 500 for non-image files | AC5 artwork; Server #193 S6, Web admin #194 | Not blocking: valid images upload correctly. |
| silo-server #1616: reordering collections from one profile rearranges another profile's list | AC2, AC6; Server #193 S6, Web #195 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 27 Sep 2026). Found by agent API testing on 941 · 82b5b39e. Fixed by #1615. |
| silo-server #1614: Collections page offers Delete on collections the profile didn't create | AC2, AC6; Web #195 | Not blocking. Resolved by #1615. |
| silo-server #1618: generated collection posters show titles the profile can't access | AC4; X4, Server #193 S3/S6, Web #195 W3/W5 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 27 Sep 2026). |
| silo-server #1612: personal collection imports fill the item limit with titles the creator can't see | AC4, AC6; Web #195 | Not blocking. |
| silo-server #1608: duplicate create buttons on the Collections page | AC6; Web #195 | Not blocking. |
| silo-server #1610: collection editor switches to two columns too early | AC6; Web #195 | Not blocking. |
| silo-server #1613: collection page's last row runs past the page bottom | AC1; Web #195 | Not blocking. |
| silo-server #3692: the empty Collections page's New collection card is half a poster's width | AC6; Web #195 W2 | Not blocking. Found during human validation on local sandboxes of build 2069 · a5294117 and 2072 · 4018816da. Fix merged in PR #3705 (491a7a4), in build 2141 · 30a6abd19; verified by human re-test on 2026-11-10 (W2 pass). Fixed. |
| silo-server #3694: a new smart server collection can't be created until libraries are picked, though its preview covers every library | AC5; Web admin #194 A2 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 2026-11-09). Found during human validation on a local sandbox of build 2072 · 4018816da. Fix merged in PR #3711 (7695787), in build 2141 · 30a6abd19; verified by human re-test on 2026-11-10 (W4/A2 pass). Fixed. |
| silo-server #3695: a smart collection can be previewed and saved with no rules, and then matches every title | AC3, AC5, AC6; Web admin #194 A2, Web #195 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 2026-11-09). Found during human validation on a local sandbox of build 2072 · 4018816da. Fix merged in PR #3710 (26062f8), in build 2141 · 30a6abd19; verified by human re-test on 2026-11-10 (W4/A2 pass). Fixed. |
| silo-server #3696: saving or creating a collection leaves you on its editor instead of returning to the collections list | AC5, AC6; Web #195 W2, Web admin #194 A1, A2 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 2026-11-09). Found during human validation on a local sandbox of build 2072 · 4018816da. Fix proposed in PR #3709, not merged. Fix merged 14 November 2026 (PR #3709); verified by human re-test on 2026-11-15, build 2405 · 7115ee702. Fixed. |
| silo-server #3697: admins and other unrestricted accounts see a stale smart collection count after a scan adds or removes titles | AC3; Server #193 S4, Web admin #194 A2, Web #195 W4, client C4 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 2026-11-09). Found during human validation on a local sandbox of build 2072 · 4018816da. Fix merged in PR #3707 (2a554c3), in build 2141 · 30a6abd19; verified by human re-test on 2026-11-10 (W4/A2 pass). Fixed. |
| silo-server #3924: creating a server collection with a name already in use fails with "An unexpected error occurred" instead of a name warning | AC5; Web admin #194 A1 | Blocking (maintainer decision, 2026-11-10). Found during human validation on a local sandbox of build 2141 · 30a6abd19; also on 2069 and 2072. Fix merged 14 November 2026 (PR #3933); verified by human re-test on 2026-11-15, build 2405 · 7115ee702. Fixed. |
| silo-server #3693: the collection editor's Description box blends into the panel | AC5, AC6; Web #195 W2, Web admin #194 A1 | Not blocking. Found during human validation on a local sandbox of build 2072 · 4018816da. Fix merged in PR #3704 (6e2f42f), in build 2141 · 30a6abd19; verified by human re-test on 2026-11-10 (W2 pass). Fixed. |
| silo-server #3698: changing a collection's poster or backdrop takes three clicks from a closed Look panel | AC5, AC6; Web admin #194 A3, Web #195 W5 | Not blocking (feature request). Raised during human validation on a local sandbox of build 2072 · 4018816da. |
Each failed case should link its existing bug or a new report in the owning repo. Link missing implementation separately: silo-server #1615 (no longer blocking: its server and web parts merged in #1873 and #1875 and S7 and W7 passed; what remains is removing the stub personal-group routes before the API lock, after silo-apple #534 and silo-android #406 — maintainer decision, 15 November 2026), silo-android #406 and silo-apple #534. Unrelated feature requests are not part of acceptance.
Completion
- Public documentation on siloserver.org explains how to use this feature, including setup, where to find it on supported clients, and important limitations. Link: ___
Validate the documentation by following its instructions on the tested build. A linked section in a broader guide is sufficient; the milestone feature card alone is not usage documentation.
- All required surface cases have build-specific evidence and human acceptance.
- X1–X5 have accepted results.
- Candidate bugs have recorded dispositions; no confirmed acceptance failure remains unresolved.
- A named reviewer records final feature acceptance with the accepted build set and any approved evidence carry-forward.
Feature acceptance may finish before the final RC. A later relevant change can reopen affected tasks and this parent. Implementation PRs may close bugs, but must not automatically close this parent or its validation tasks.
Reviewer: unassigned. Overall result: Not run.
AI-assisted tracking update using OpenAI Codex and GitHub CLI, at the maintainer’s direction. No runtime validation or acceptance is claimed. The 2026-11-09 update, made with Claude Code (claude-opus-5-5) and GitHub CLI, records non-blocking finding #3692 from human validation. A second 2026-11-09 update mirrors the Web task's W1 and W6 human validation results; no acceptance is recorded yet. A third 2026-11-09 update records non-blocking finding #3693. A fourth mirrors the Web task's W2 and W3 results. A fifth records blocking finding #3694. A sixth records blocking finding #3695. A seventh records blocking finding #3696. An eighth records blocking finding #3697. A ninth mirrors the W4 and A2 results. A tenth records non-blocking finding #3698. The 2026-11-10 update records the merged fixes for #3692–#3695 and #3697, now in build 2141, awaiting human re-test. A second 2026-11-10 update records W4 and A2 passing on build 2141 and #3694, #3695 and #3697 as fixed. A third records the W1 and W2 re-tests and #3692 and #3693 as fixed. A fourth records W5 and W7 passing on build 2141. A fifth records blocking finding #3924. A sixth records the A1 partial result. A seventh records the full Web admin results. An eighth mirrors the Server task's S1–S7 results. The 2026-11-15 update, at the maintainer's direction, records that #1615 no longer blocks #193 and #195, the merged fixes for #3696 and #3924, and the maintainer's acceptance of the passed Server, Web admin and Web cases. A second 2026-11-15 update records the A1, A2 and W2 re-tests on build 2405, #3696 and #3924 as fixed, and the Web admin and Web tasks as accepted.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
Type
Projects
- StatusShow more project fieldsIn Review
Activity