Skip to content
Merged
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -2,24 +2,70 @@

## Decision summary

Historically, S2-RO-10 composed and proved one bounded Lab1 VRRP observation
from the accepted S2-RO-01 through S2-RO-09 components. The current candidate
is a bounded target-aware composition extension for the complete accepted
Lab1 + Lab2 fixed registry. It returns only normalized S2-RO-01 evidence and
preserves the historical Lab1 path through the same target-aware operations.

The Lab2 candidate is validated only with synthetic offline data. It does not
claim a Lab2 live PASS, a Lab2 S2-RO-11 PASS, full Stage-2 Lab2 runtime proof,
production readiness, or write automation. No startup executable, CLI, live
task registration, or S2-RO-11 behavior is added.
The bounded Lab2 target-aware composition extension is integrated into `main`
and proven by offline validation, an independent read-only security review,
and post-merge hosted Safe CI. It retains the complete accepted Lab1 + Lab2
fixed registry, resolves the request-selected target, and returns only
normalized S2-RO-01 evidence. Lab1 and Lab2 use the same target-aware path,
with no Lab2-to-Lab1 fallback.

```text
S2_RO_10_LAB2_OFFLINE_COMPOSITION = PASS
S2_RO_10_LAB2_OFFLINE_COMPOSITION_MAINLINE_INTEGRATION = COMPLETE
S2_RO_10_LAB2_HOSTED_CI = PASS
S2_RO_10_LAB2_OFFLINE_STATUS = INTEGRATED_AND_HOSTED_CI_PROVEN
INDEPENDENT_SECURITY_REVIEW = PASS
UNRESOLVED_MATERIAL_FINDINGS = 0
S2_RO_10_LAB2_LIVE_VALIDATION = NOT_PERFORMED
S2_RO_10_LAB2_LIVE_AUTHORITY = NOT_GRANTED
NEXT_LIVE_ACTION = SEPARATE_EXACT_OWNER_AUTHORIZATION_REQUIRED
CANONICAL_STATUS = OFFLINE_INTEGRATED_AND_HOSTED_CI_PROVEN_LIVE_NOT_AUTHORIZED
```

This status does not claim a Lab2 live PASS, device compatibility, a Lab2
S2-RO-11 live PASS, full Stage-2 Lab2 runtime proof, production readiness, or
write automation. No startup executable, CLI, live task registration, or
S2-RO-11 behavior was added.

`OFFLINE_IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORITY != LIVE_EXECUTION_AUTHORITY`

`OWNER_VERIFIED != AUTHORIZATION_CONSUMED != TRANSPORT_SUCCESS != PARSE_SUCCESS != FINAL_OBSERVATION_SUCCESS`

## Historical delivery context

The original S2-RO-10 delivery composed and proved one bounded Lab1 VRRP
observation from the accepted S2-RO-01 through S2-RO-09 components. A later
scope review found three Lab1-only assumptions in composition: registry
retention and the target context supplied to credential resolution and
credential reading. The bounded extension corrected those assumptions by
retaining the complete fixed registry and using the existing target-aware
resolver and backend operations. It subsequently passed offline validation,
independent review, PR integration, and hosted CI.

## Integration and review evidence

- Implementation commit reviewed: `0750551cc4c1c941b250dc3328816ecb625549fc`.
- Independent read-only security review: **PASS**, with zero material findings,
one non-material observation, and zero unresolved material findings.
- Pull request: **#90**, which integrated the implementation commit.
- Merge commit: `1eca8576e1da8aba41cb3c8be23b54a9b720371f`.
- Merge tree: `2c7fa1ac21221b2d8f26ce47663941549710230c`.
- Post-merge Safe CI run: **34870907764**, successful for the `push` event on
`main` at the merge commit.
- Python validation: 4,018 collected; 4,016 passed; 2 accepted safety skips;
zero failed.
- Node validation: 128 tests across 9 files passed. Typecheck, lint, build, and
immutability checks passed.
- Report index: WARN with 1 pass, 13 optional reports missing, and zero
mandatory missing, failed, or unknown reports.

Hosted CI proves the recorded offline validation and repository checks only.
It does not prove Lab2 device compatibility, live execution success,
production readiness, or authority for a live attempt.

## Allowed scope

The candidate consists of exactly three files:
The integrated implementation extension was limited to exactly three files:

- [Composition](../../validation_framework/stage2_trusted_runtime_composition.py).
- [Offline tests](../../tests/stage2/test_trusted_runtime_composition.py).
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -203,17 +249,27 @@ Python process or caller-owned objects.
No prior-slice or integration-plan file changes, dependencies, second trust
root, second evidence schema, environment authority, CLI, interactive prompt,
startup executable, live registration, scheduler, worker, AI loop, retry,
configuration backup/change, or S2-RO-11 implementation is included. S2-RO-09
configuration backup/change, or S2-RO-11 implementation was included. S2-RO-09
is unchanged. The existing S2-RO-10 public API, seven-field configuration,
sixteen-category failure enum, evidence schema, authority order, and replay
semantics are unchanged. S2-RO-11 is not modified; its existing one-call handoff
continues to depend only on request-bearing trusted configuration.
semantics are unchanged.

S2-RO-11 source is unchanged. Its existing one-call delegation makes a
separately trusted Lab2 request and matching trusted configuration
source-reachable through the integrated target-aware composition path. That is
a configuration-only impact and is neither execution authority nor live proof.

```text
S2_RO_11_SOURCE = UNCHANGED
S2_RO_11_LAB2_IMPACT = CONFIGURATION_ONLY
SOURCE_REACHABLE != EXECUTION_AUTHORIZED
S2_RO_11_LAB2_LIVE_VALIDATION = NOT_PERFORMED
```

The implementation task performs no real trust-root/approval/known-host read,
Credential Manager read, persistent replay mutation, loopback, DNS, SSH, or
RouterOS access. Remote base inspection and local branch creation are separate
repository operations, not device validation. Staging, commit, push, PR, merge,
and branch/worktree deletion require separate authorization.
Offline implementation and validation performed no real trust-root, approval,
or known-host read; Credential Manager read; persistent replay mutation;
loopback, DNS, SSH, or RouterOS access. Repository operations are not device
validation. Any future live attempt requires separate exact Owner authorization.

## Offline validation and review boundary

Expand All @@ -236,12 +292,14 @@ known-host source, socket, DNS, SSH, and device access. The real S2-RO-05 ledger
is used only against disposable synthetic test state. No Lab1 or Lab2 device is
contacted, and no RouterOS command is emitted. Public failures remain sanitized.

The required local validation is exact three-file scope, UTF-8 without BOM and
LF-only text, `git diff --check`, focused S2-RO-10 tests without skips, Stage-2
regression with only accepted safety skips, full pytest with only accepted
safety skips, report-index, documentation readability, and secret-diff review.
An independent read-only security review remains the next task. This candidate
does not inherit the historical Lab1 security review as a Lab2 review.
The integrated implementation satisfied exact three-file scope, UTF-8 without
BOM and LF-only text, `git diff --check`, focused S2-RO-10 tests without skips,
Stage-2 regression and full pytest with only accepted safety skips,
report-index review, documentation readability, and secret-diff review. Its
independent read-only security review passed, and post-merge hosted Safe CI
passed at the merge commit. These offline and hosted results grant no live
execution authority and do not convert source reachability into a Lab2 live
PASS.

References: [integration gates](actual_automation_integration_plan.md),
[S2-RO-01 evidence](stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_01_contract.md),
Expand Down