Repository navigation
docs: activate Tobi Validator public naming - #7
Conversation
OrganeticSphere
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Main exact-head review findings from f03572b05f16237917a5571f426f8551d1a1079e have been addressed on the new correction head:
bc36264d42426c62b5ad83c6e34f5bea04b914c4
P2 closure implemented:
-
Current CLI help-banner mismatch
- the install guide now states that the released
stage1-tobi-validator-v0.7.0binary still prints the historicalAI Verification Engine / Tobi Validatorlockup; - the naming migration is explicitly documentation-only and does not claim the released binary banner changed.
- the install guide now states that the released
-
Interim Tsubasa reference naming collision
- the existing document is now titled
Tsubasa Public Syntax and Authoring Reference; - it is explicitly classified as an interim reference for the current released validator corridor;
- it explicitly does not replace the forthcoming complete
Tsubasa Language Referencebook.
- the existing document is now titled
-
Unsupported broad artifact-comparison wording
- removed wording that represented Tobi as a general artifact-comparison mechanism;
- current copy limits Tobi to acceptance/rejection, canonical output,
_hcompatibility identity, deterministic diagnostics, andgoldenconformance; - comparison language now refers to users or workflows recording and comparing observed canonical results under the same validator contract.
-
Workflow-gate authority overstatement
- current copy now states consistently that Tobi supplies validator success/failure;
- the consuming workflow owns allow/block/merge/release/escalation policy;
- README, NOTICE, SECURITY, CONTACT, workflow-fit template, Action starter, support guidance, agent guidance, governance note, and example workflow were aligned.
P3 handling:
drift-equivalentterminology removed;_his described as compatibility identity, whileHASH:is identified only as the CLI display label;- duplicate wording and
canonical meaning/canonical truthphrasing removed from current-facing surfaces; - a PR-triggered
Public surface checksworkflow was added, registering a GitHub CI context and guarding naming, claim boundaries, Action surface, links, JSON, Markdown fences, and formatting.
Exact-head CI:
Public surface checks / Public naming and documentation
run #18
conclusion: SUCCESS
Preserved unchanged:
- Action modes
canonandgoldenonly; - no
validatemode; TOBI_EVAL_TOKEN;OrganeticSphere/tobi-validator@v1;stage1-tobi-validator-v0.7.0;- Action execution body, broker path, checksum handling, commands, exits, validator behavior, semantics, diagnostics, canonicalization, and
_hmechanics.
The PR remains Draft. No merge or Ready transition was performed. Renewed Main exact-head review is requested on bc36264d42426c62b5ad83c6e34f5bea04b914c4.
OrganeticSphere
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
FINAL CORRECTION HEAD FOR RENEWED MAIN REVIEW
The previous re-review request on bc36264d42426c62b5ad83c6e34f5bea04b914c4 is superseded by the final correction head:
94e754aacd3e812381773bd16f51d9e615105ad1
No further file changes are planned before renewed Main review.
All Main findings from the reviewed head f03572b05f16237917a5571f426f8551d1a1079e remain addressed:
- current released CLI help-banner mismatch is disclosed explicitly as historical binary wording;
- the existing Tsubasa document is named
Tsubasa Public Syntax and Authoring Referenceand marked as an interim current-corridor reference, distinct from the forthcoming completeTsubasa Language Referencebook; - unsupported general artifact-comparison wording is removed;
- Tobi supplies validator success/failure, while the consuming workflow owns allow/block/merge/release/escalation policy;
drift-equivalent,canonical truth,canonical meaning, ambiguous_hhash wording, and duplicated phrasing are removed or bounded;- the PR now registers
Public surface checks / Public naming and documentationas a pull-request CI context.
Exact-head CI:
HEAD: 94e754aacd3e812381773bd16f51d9e615105ad1
WORKFLOW: Public surface checks
RUN: #19
CONCLUSION: SUCCESS
Preserved unchanged:
- Action modes
canonandgoldenonly; - no
validatemode; TOBI_EVAL_TOKEN;OrganeticSphere/tobi-validator@v1;stage1-tobi-validator-v0.7.0and other compatibility-sensitive identifiers;- Action execution body, broker path, checksum handling, validator commands, exits, diagnostics, canonicalization behavior, semantics, and
_hmechanics.
PR state remains Draft. No Ready transition or merge was performed.
Renewed exact-head Main review is requested on:
94e754aacd3e812381773bd16f51d9e615105ad1
|
FINAL CORRECTION HEAD AFTER MAIN DIRECT EDIT The remaining Main review findings were corrected in one commit: Closed:
Exact-head CI: The PR body now records the exact final head, 19-file contour, 46/0 ancestry, final correction, and CI evidence. The GitHub About-description is external repository metadata, not part of the Git tree. Target text is recorded in the PR body: The PR remains Draft, open, mergeable, and unmerged. No further branch commits are planned before final exact-head disposition. |
Purpose
Activate the Aset-approved Tobi public naming contract across the current-facing surfaces of
OrganeticSphere/tobi-validatorbefore the first long-form GitHub Action/category article.Approved public lockup:
Approved category line:
Approved positioning sentence:
Stage 1remains valid for internal engineering, compatibility, immutable release identifiers, and historical evidence, but is retired as a current public product designation.Exact state
Base:
Final head:
Final correction commit:
Ancestry:
PR remains Draft, open, mergeable, and unmerged.
Changed contour
19 changed files:
action.ymldisplay metadata onlyNOTICE.mddelivery wording reconciled with the live evaluation-broker path.github/workflows/public-surface-check.ymlpublic naming/claim guardPhysical filenames and repository slugs containing
STAGE1/stage1are retained for link stability. Compatibility-sensitive identifiers remain unchanged.Language and canonicalization guards
The public model is explicit:
The copy does not teach that submitted source is already canonical. The Tsubasa language contract owns semantics and canonical rules; Tobi is the reference validator that implements and operationally enforces that contract.
The interim document is titled:
It is explicitly distinct from the forthcoming complete
Tsubasa Language Referencebook.Workflow-policy boundary
Tobi supplies validator success or failure.
The consuming workflow owns:
The governance flow now branches accepted and rejected outputs explicitly rather than collapsing canonical output,
_h, and diagnostics into one result line.Preserved implementation and compatibility surface
No validator implementation, behavior, semantics, delivery mechanism, or compatibility identity changed.
Preserved exactly:
canonandgoldenvalidatemodeTOBI_EVAL_TOKENOrganeticSphere/tobi-validator@v1stage1-tobi-validator-v0.7.0default release identifier_haction.ymldiffers from the base only in three display-description lines: Action name, Action description, and release-tag input description.The released
stage1-tobi-validator-v0.7.0binary still prints the historical CLI bannerAI Verification Engine / Tobi Validator; this documentation migration does not rewrite an immutable released binary.Claim boundaries preserved
The migrated copy states or preserves that:
_his compatibility identity onlyThe ambiguous heading
Proof-by-example repositoryis replaced withValidator-Backed Example Repository.Public-surface CI
Workflow:
Exact-head run:
The workflow now uses:
The workflow verifies:
Stage 1wordingcanonandgoldenvalidateThe exact-head run validated all 18 current public-surface files successfully.
No runtime/validator execution test was required or claimed because the implementation and Action execution body are unchanged.
External repository metadata
The GitHub About-description is outside the Git tree. Its target current-facing text is:
This metadata update must be applied through a repository-settings-capable GitHub interface; it does not change the PR head.
Review request
Main should review exact head:
Review points:
TOBI_PUBLIC_NAMING_CONTRACT_v0_2.md;Do not merge automatically.