Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
94 changes: 94 additions & 0 deletions manuscript/narrative-review/CHECKLIST.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,94 @@
# Submission readiness checklist (TiCS Forum Review)

**Status: v2 Phase 5 final assembly complete.**

## Manuscript text

- [x] Title <= 80 characters (76)
- [x] Highlights: 5 bullets, max 80 chars each (Cell Press / Elsevier <= 85 limit)
- [x] Abstract: 116 words (TiCS 80-120 target)
- [x] Main text sections 1-7: 3393 words (TiCS Forum Review ~4000-word ceiling)
- [x] Trends Box: 191 words
- [x] Outstanding Questions Box: 7 forward-looking questions
- [x] Glossary: 15 defined terms, <=50 words each
- [x] Box 1 (HBN-EEG R3 anchor): 161 words
- [x] Abbreviations defined on first use (fMRI, EEG, iEEG, ISC, ERSP, LLR, AMICA, ICLabel, ToM, ERD, MEG, DMN, STS, MRI, ECoG, LM, BIDS, GLM, mTRF, BDF)
- [x] No em-dashes (CLAUDE.md global rule)
- [x] No emojis (CLAUDE.md global rule)
- [x] *The Present* italicised throughout
- [x] All F1-F5 critical findings from v1 self-review applied in prose
- [x] manuscript:paper-review pass (0 critical, 0 major, 6 minor; all 6 addressed in v2 Phase 5)
- [x] manuscript:humanizer pass (0 patterns matched; manuscript was clean upstream)

## References

- [x] Numbered references in references.md (82 entries, ordered by first appearance)
- [x] refs.bib (93 entries after F3 stray-key removal + F2 verification + Castelli2000MovementAM dedupe)
- [x] F2 (Schubring/Codispoti DOI) verified and resolved; body cites Codispoti
- [x] F3 (3 stray refs) removed from refs.bib
- [x] Castelli2000MovementAM deduplicated against castelli2000heider (same DOI; consolidated to action-strand canonical key)
- [x] Body cites converted from cite-card slug `[Key]` form to numbered `[N]` form (100 in-body cites converted)
- [x] All 82 cited refs match entries in refs.bib

## Figures

- [x] 4 figures built via figures:scientific-figure composer
- [x] All in Okabe-Ito colourblind-safe palette (0 off-palette after Phase 3 fix)
- [x] All shapes encode information redundantly (not colour-only)
- [x] Cell Press 174mm two-column width applied to all figures
- [x] PNG exports at 300 dpi
- [x] figure-qa reports under figures/qa/ (4 reports; all ship)
- [x] 211 of 211 text elements pass Cell 6pt minimum
- [x] All figures referenced from body
- [x] Embedded transparent-icon thumbnails (Fig 2: 6 stimulus thumbnails; Fig 4: 4 brain-topography icons)

## Style discipline (CLAUDE.md + Cell Press)

- [x] No em-dashes (project rule)
- [x] No emojis (project rule)
- [x] No AI attribution in commits or PRs
- [x] Atomic commits with concise messages (<50 chars)
- [x] Highlights and Trends Box use sentence-case headers (Cell Press body convention)

## Paper-review minor concerns (m1-m6) addressed in v2 Phase 5

- [x] m1: Highlight #2 now names the four perspectives ("Psychophysics, action, language, emotion diverge on per-shot EEG predictions")
- [x] m2: Abstract sampling-rate clause expanded for clarity ("the local 100 Hz cohort caps beta-band and gamma-band claims pending a 500 Hz validation")
- [x] m3: Section 4 Hickok critique now names substance ("mu suppression also reflects general attention to moving stimuli rather than a one-to-one mirror-system signature")
- [x] m5: Section 1 closing meta-narration removed ("Section 2 begins with..." dropped)
- [x] m6: Castelli2000MovementAM deduplicated against castelli2000heider
- [ ] m4: Section 6 social-cognition density (third paragraph reads as citation dump). DEFERRED to human author polish; restructuring requires content judgment beyond the skill pipeline.

## Submission package files

```
manuscript/narrative-review/
manuscript.md <- single assembled file (frontmatter + Highlights + Abstract + sections 1-7 + Box 1 + Trends Box + Outstanding Questions + Glossary + Figure legends)
references.md <- 82 numbered references in Cell Press format
refs.bib <- 93-entry BibTeX (post-dedupe)
STRUCTURE.md <- table of contents + skill checklist (v1 Phase 1)
frontmatter.yaml <- title, authors, affiliations, ORCID placeholder
highlights.md <- per-section source file
abstract.md <- per-section source file
sections/01..07_*.md <- per-section source files
boxes/box1_anchor.md, trends.md, outstanding-questions.md
glossary.md <- 15-term glossary
figures.md <- 4 figure legends
figures/
fig1-4.svg + .png <- composed figures at 300 dpi
panels/figN_*.svg <- panel sources
icons/*.png <- 10 transparent-icon PNGs
configs/figN.json <- composer configs
qa/figN_qa.md <- figure-qa reports
reviews/
internal-review.md <- paper-review output (v2 Phase 4)
humanizer-log.md <- humanizer audit log (v2 Phase 4)
```

## Out of scope (post-PR)

- Author ORCID
- Cover letter (manuscript:manuscript-formatting provides a template; apply once author confirms PI list)
- Final copy-edit by human author (including m4 social-cognition density)
- LaTeX export (use pandoc per manuscript-formatting skill if a LaTeX-mandatory submission portal is selected)
- Word .docx export (pandoc; Cell Press accepts .docx for submission)
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion manuscript/narrative-review/abstract.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -5,4 +5,4 @@ Skill pattern applied: Abstract Template adapted for narrative review

# Abstract

Naturalistic-stimulus neuroscience has moved from whole-clip inter-subject correlation (ISC) to event-locked methods that interrogate individual shots. Most empirical evidence is adult functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), adult intracranial electroencephalography (iEEG), or adult scalp electroencephalography (EEG) ISC. Per-shot event-related spectral perturbation (ERSP) in a developmental cohort viewing silent character animation has no published precedent. We review the corpus that constrains this design space and argue that psychophysics, action, language, and emotion make divergent, partly-falsifiable predictions about the 0 to 500 ms post-shot-onset window. The Healthy Brain Network EEG Release 3 cohort viewing *The Present* (Pixar 2014) sits at this empty intersection; the 100 Hz local working set caps beta-band claims until a 500 Hz validation pass.
Naturalistic-stimulus neuroscience has moved from whole-clip inter-subject correlation (ISC) to event-locked methods that interrogate individual shots. Most empirical evidence is adult functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), adult intracranial electroencephalography (iEEG), or adult scalp electroencephalography (EEG) ISC. Per-shot event-related spectral perturbation (ERSP) in a developmental cohort viewing silent character animation has no published precedent. We review the corpus that constrains this design space and argue that psychophysics, action, language, and emotion make divergent, partly-falsifiable predictions about the 0 to 500 ms post-shot-onset window. The Healthy Brain Network EEG Release 3 cohort viewing *The Present* (Pixar 2014) sits at this empty intersection, although the local 100 Hz cohort caps beta-band and gamma-band claims pending a 500 Hz validation.
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion manuscript/narrative-review/highlights.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ Elsevier house style. Filled by manuscript:manuscript-writing in v2 Phase 2. -->
# Highlights

- Naturalistic EEG has shifted from whole-clip ISC to shot-locked spectral metrics
- Four perspectives diverge on per-shot EEG predictions of naturalistic film
- Psychophysics, action, language, emotion diverge on per-shot EEG predictions
- Language-model regressors cannot transfer to silent character animation
- Per-shot EEG ERSP in children viewing animation has no published precedent
- HBN-EEG Release 3 sits at this empty intersection and can test the predictions
Loading
Loading