Skip to content

Phase 4: paper-review + humanizer#55

Merged
neuromechanist merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feature/issue-50-phase4-review
May 20, 2026
Merged

Phase 4: paper-review + humanizer#55
neuromechanist merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feature/issue-50-phase4-review

Conversation

@neuromechanist

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Summary

Phase 4 of epic #46. Internal manuscript:paper-review pass + manuscript:humanizer polish.

Outputs:

  • manuscript/narrative-review/reviews/internal-review.md (full peer-review-style critique with 0 critical, 4 major, 10 minor concerns)
  • manuscript/narrative-review/reviews/humanizer-log.md (humanizer pass record; 11 of 29 patterns clean at baseline due to project style guide; 3 patterns triggered minor edits)

Manuscript edits:

  • M1: Figure 3 caption "twelve" -> "thirteen" no-coverage cells (factual correction)
  • M2: Section 2 restructured from theme catalogue into perspective-driven structure
  • M3: Section 7.4 (narrative-position objection) merged into a single open-questions/limitations subsection now numbered 7.4
  • M4: Abstract adds 100 Hz sampling-rate caveat as a one-clause disclosure
  • m1: Abstract opening tightened from 125 to 133 words then back to budget; final 133
  • m2: "stop-motion or stills" corrected to "natural movie clips and static images" (Dorr 2010 actual categories)
  • m4: "this Review" decapitalised in body (Cell Press style)
  • m5: Section 5b opens with a thesis sentence matching 5a's structure
  • m9: Section 6 adds explicit latency windows (80-300 ms occipital; 200-500 ms frontal) matching Figure 4
  • m10: "intracranial cortical recording (ECoG)" -> "electrocorticography (ECoG)" first-use definition
  • m8: Klin autism findings moved from Section 4 to Section 7.4 limitations
  • Humanizer: 3 small rewrites for patterns 3, 11, 25 (-ing endings, synonym cycling, anthropomorphic framing)

Closes #50. Part of epic #46.

Final word counts (sections 1-7 main text)

Section Words Delta from Phase 3
1. Introduction 320 -6
2. Scaffold 394 +60
3. Psychophysics 370 -4
4. Action 420 -56 (autism moved to S7)
5. Language 556 -14
6. Emotion 529 +25 (latency windows added)
7. Synthesis 656 +32 (absorbed 7.4 + autism)
Total main text 3245 -10

Main text well inside TiCS Forum Review ~4000-word ceiling. Section 7 still over its individual budget but the absorption of narrative-position into open-questions is structurally sound.

Test plan

  • markdownlint, typos pass
  • All Highlights bullets <= 80 chars
  • No em-dashes, no emojis, no AI-vocabulary tells
  • All 0 critical, 4 major, and 10 minor findings from internal review either applied or explicitly deferred to Phase 5
  • F1-F5 critical findings from prior self-review still satisfied
  • Final Cell Press numbered reference conversion (Phase 5)
  • Final formatting + figure font-size rescale (Phase 5)

@neuromechanist neuromechanist merged commit 3fda6dd into main May 20, 2026
4 checks passed
neuromechanist added a commit that referenced this pull request May 21, 2026
* Revert "Phase 5: final assembly + icon polish (#56)"

This reverts commit 7045be3.

* Revert "narrative review phase 4: paper-review + humanizer (#55)"

This reverts commit 3fda6dd.

* Revert "narrative review phase 3: full manuscript draft (#54)"

This reverts commit 0b80fc9.

* Revert "narrative review phase 2: 4 figures + QA (#53)"

This reverts commit e200f6d.

* Revert "narrative review phase 1: TiCS scaffold (#52)"

This reverts commit 808dd6a.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Phase 4: paper-review + humanizer pass

1 participant