Skip to content

Phase 3: full manuscript draft#54

Merged
neuromechanist merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feature/issue-49-phase3-draft
May 20, 2026
Merged

Phase 3: full manuscript draft#54
neuromechanist merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feature/issue-49-phase3-draft

Conversation

@neuromechanist

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Summary

Phase 3 of epic #46. Full prose draft of manuscript/narrative-review/manuscript.md, replacing the Phase 1 placeholders.

Main-text sections 1-7 total 3208 words, comfortably inside the TiCS Forum Review ~4000-word ceiling. Boxes, glossary, figure legends, and references are separate per TiCS house style.

Closes #49. Part of epic #46.

Section word counts (sections 1-7 main text)

Section Words Target
1. Introduction: the per-shot turn 326 ~450
2. The four-perspective scaffold 334 ~600
3. Psychophysics: the bottom-up floor 374 ~500
4. Action: mu-band ERD and event segmentation 476 ~500
5. Language: comparator of non-transfer plus silent-narrative sub-thread 570 ~600
6. Emotion: two predictions at different latencies 504 ~500
7. Synthesis: integration, falsifiability, open questions 624 ~450
Total main text 3208 ~3500-4000

Sections 1-2 are under target by ~390 words combined; Section 7 is over by ~175. Phase 4 review will rebalance.

Critical-finding remediations applied

  • F1: "All seven Category G cards in our language ontology (and 12 cards corpus-wide) carry transfer-to-silent: no" — Section 5a.
  • F2: All in-text references to the alpha-band-and-emotion review name "Codispoti and colleagues (2023)"; the Schubring slug does not appear in prose.
  • F4: Anchor case (Section 7.2 + Box 1) rebuilt around Petroni-Cohen 2018 + partly-validated pipeline. Two anchor assertions named as independent.
  • F5: Section 7.3 names the topographic-and-band rejection region: central-rolandic mu-band confirms action; frontal-asymmetric alpha confirms emotion; left-frontotemporal (Lipkin negative control) falsifies the four-perspective ranking.
  • I1-I5: Wishlist commitments dropped; narrative-position objection added (Section 7.4); Hickok-style mu critique named (Section 4); bridge sentences in Section 2; Section 5 split into 5a+5b.
  • S2: The Present italicised throughout.

Style discipline

  • No em-dashes; commas or semicolons
  • Abbreviations defined on first use (ERSP, ISC, LLR, AMICA, ICLabel, ERD, ToM, fMRI, MEG, EEG, iEEG, ECoG, BIDS, MRI, GLM, mTRF, BDF, STS, DMN)

Test plan

  • Pre-commit passes
  • All Highlights bullets <= 85 chars
  • F1-F5 and I1-I5 critical-review findings addressed
  • All 4 figures referenced from body
  • manuscript:paper-review pass (Phase 4)
  • Humanizer pass (Phase 4)
  • Cell Press numbered reference conversion (Phase 5)

@neuromechanist neuromechanist merged commit 0b80fc9 into main May 20, 2026
4 checks passed
neuromechanist added a commit that referenced this pull request May 21, 2026
* Revert "Phase 5: final assembly + icon polish (#56)"

This reverts commit 7045be3.

* Revert "narrative review phase 4: paper-review + humanizer (#55)"

This reverts commit 3fda6dd.

* Revert "narrative review phase 3: full manuscript draft (#54)"

This reverts commit 0b80fc9.

* Revert "narrative review phase 2: 4 figures + QA (#53)"

This reverts commit e200f6d.

* Revert "narrative review phase 1: TiCS scaffold (#52)"

This reverts commit 808dd6a.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Phase 3: full manuscript draft

1 participant