Skip to content

Independently audit the exact second-fragment phase and fresh inputs - #6733

Open
ToikY wants to merge 2 commits into
CrocSwap:mainfrom
ToikY:codex/b12-session-01
Open

ToikY wants to merge 2 commits into
CrocSwap:mainfrom
ToikY:codex/b12-session-01

Conversation

@ToikY

@ToikY ToikY commented Nov 5, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Checks zxv #6726, exact head 435bbe91fb28cb1d7a569ca70c6c4e9eb302d486, at its second retirement cut394→401, pivot4→fresh33. The literal retired character is q^-1 D10 and fresh33 obtains plain D11 D12 D13 D14. The full actual606-instruction word preserves all34 arbitrary inputs, including the first fresh32.

Two separately authored/sealed forward-field and reverse-output-covector implementations preserve exact Gaussian coefficients and all four q characters. Their entire21,141-byte first certificates agree, SHA256 31995c0964cb38939efc2f862aab4a7bc1aed5abbde3129029e614aadee77cbb: three complete matrices/3,401cells/175monomials, six identity gates and seven actual changed-word controls. Both prefix directions, absolute phase, literal prefix concatenation, freshness/noncontact and the entire final diagonal are checked. Primary additionally binds the actual inverse slice; oracle independently checks formal inverse orders and the complete changed-word endpoint. First runs0.1951/0.6492s,30.92/30.87MB peakRSS on Python3.12.14. No peer receipt inspection until both finished; neither author read/imported source/peer engines. The source-aware coordinator/proof role's inert replay-code exposure is disclosed.

Validation:60 actual normal/optimized packet/source/metadata CLI rejections; crossed implementation and independent mathematical reviews; four registered whole-certificate replays; exact final32-file committed-byte/source-history preflight (original31 plus one verification document and a role-specific prose clarification); official final export/declared21inputs check; four read-only Git-free empty-PATH whole-certificate cold checks. All21 proof inputs remain byte-identical after the documentation amendment. No original/native suite, Lean or Docker ran. The local global replay planner stopped on an absent canonical metadata blob in the partial clone:4,052 of4,075 historical VERIFY objects are omitted. The exact first missing blob was fetched and authenticated as metadata only; no complete local global-plan pass is claimed. Original hosted run42014242840, attempt1, SUCCESS:711helpertests/24platformskips, all four actual whole-certificate commands onPython3.12.16 and both worktree/index drift gates. Hosted planning selected exactly this package. Synthetic checkout b8ad370 has the exact final7f781f46 tree with canonical/public parents; completed logs retained once, no rerun.

This is one external formal application audit under the declared commuting native interface. It does not admit physical/native action, all columns,7,488contacts, stock/ownership/precision, the complete paid invoice, compiler/outer transfer or any of the five selected framework assumptions. Rank-equivalent q wording does not replace the literal q^-1 phase. No κ/frontier/adoption change or merge.

Task joint-query-controller, scope key4d7f1a9510e7821b7134, has an explicit changed historical application scope. Fresh canonical main7c49fe32/eightbindings/revision8/selected6030 are unchanged;682distinct open bodies traversed nonatomically, no changes at pre-submission; targeted indexed all-state searches, sparse notes, canonical ledger and visible Hub/start checked. Middle-Discussion/arbitrary-diff/full closed-corpus/hidden-work coverage remains incomplete. Advance claim. Scientific work froze10:40:54UTC; at least15minutes reserved for verification. All core/code/input/first-certificate bytes remain frozen.

Remaining questions and concrete next steps are in TASK.json. Credit zxv6726 paid fragments/construction/author checks; thu-nmrc6716a467 common-idle/fresh-input caller; DreamingOfClouds6702; Ali Romman6545/6551/6529/6348/6398/5599/5602/5611/5615; Rohan Arun6399/6417; ChaloupeMusic6453; Jacob Alan Sussman4268; Cinna Davis and retained native/helper/compiler/interval/analytic authors. PR6720's oldercut353 and PR6724's genericphase review retain separate scope/credit. ToikY with substantial OpenAI Codex assistance and distinct AI implementation/review roles, Apache-2.0; no human or proof-kernel acceptance. Maintainer edits and auto-merge disabled.

python3.12 -B scripts/research_package.py --package research/p104-second-fragment-phase-audit

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant