admission: uv global options can hide indirect requirement-source evidence

[seonghobae]

Security/evidence defect

Fresh review of canonical Agent Artifact Admission child #427@fd19ac126a0e90a60164f8f9a24a47ea29490336 found a distinct parser/evidence asymmetry that must be serialized after #426/#427, not folded into that queued exact head.

validate_artifact_operands() and is_install_root_selector_value() now locate the active uv ... pip install command via uv_active_command_index(), so reviewed parser-valid global uv options no longer hide direct artifact operands. requests_indirect_artifact_source() still uses the old fixed-position guard:

"uv" if arguments.first().is_some_and(|argument| argument == "pip")
    && arguments.get(1).is_some_and(|argument| argument == "install") => { ... }

That means a parser-valid global option before pip install can suppress the -r/--requirement, -e/--editable, --group, or --project indirect-source classification while the operand validator has already moved to active-command parsing.

Astral's current uv CLI reference documents both the global --color <auto|always|never> option and uv pip install [OPTIONS] <PACKAGE|--requirements <REQUIREMENTS>|...>, with -r/--requirement/--requirements meaning “install the packages listed in the given files”: https://docs.astral.sh/uv/reference/cli/

Hostile realistic RED

Use a value that intentionally collides with an already approved direct artifact token:

uv --color never pip install -r cwl-example==1.2.3 --require-hashes --no-deps --no-python-downloads

with declared/approved artifact_argument = "cwl-example==1.2.3".

CLI meaning: cwl-example==1.2.3 is the requirements-file operand of -r, not a direct package operand. On the reviewed exact head, active-command operand validation can count that token as the approved artifact while requests_indirect_artifact_source() misses the indirect source because arguments[0..2] are --color never rather than pip install.

Expected RED assertion on the successor test-only head:

• decision remains Block because the global-option form is intentionally outside supported_install_command();
• evidence must include ForbiddenCommand and ArtifactNotApproved for the unapproved indirect source;
• command hash remains exact/deterministic;
• ordinary uv pip install cwl-example==1.2.3 --require-hashes --no-deps --no-python-downloads remains the control and must not regress;
• non-install siblings such as uv --color never pip sync -r ... must not inherit install-only indirect-source semantics.

Also cover attached parser-valid forms where applicable (for example --color=never) and verify a consumed selector value cannot masquerade as an approved direct artifact.

Minimum causal repair

After #427 is exact-head GREEN and normally integrated into canonical #129, create a successor child from the then-current #129 head:

1. RED-only commit first.
2. Make requests_indirect_artifact_source() locate the active uv command with the existing uv_active_command_index() and inspect indirect selectors only when the active slice is exactly pip install.
3. Do not widen supported_install_command(); global-option uv commands remain fail-closed/forbidden until separately authorized.
4. Do not copy uv parsing logic; reuse the single parser helper already introduced in the canonical admission domain.
5. Run exact-head fmt/tests/clippy plus the focused hostile contract, then normal integration into feat(security): gate AI-agent artifact installation #129 only after GREEN.

Ownership / dependency

Wardnet owns this admission evidence semantics. No quarantine runtime, EgressWeave, contextual-orchestrator, appguardrail, CGC, EA, or central workflow logic is duplicated. This issue is deliberately serialized behind #426/#427 so the existing single-writer lane and queued evidence are preserved.

[seonghobae]

Fresh exact-head status for owning Draft #429 (0f206d6cb23ca88abfd6f0c0a84e1dcba6e35969): CI 34927770706 / rust 104249367485 is SUCCESS. Fuzz 34927770671 / job 104249367457 is FAILURE, but it never materialized on a runner (runner_id=0, empty runner name/group, no steps); this is not a Wardnet semantic RED. The exact specimen and same-head retry acceptance were handed to canonical runner owner ContextualWisdomLab/.github#712 in comment 5678309257. No submitted reviews or inline review threads exist on #429. Keep #429 Draft and source-stable until the unchanged head gets a materialized Fuzz terminal GREEN and then-live review/security evidence; no no-op churn, selector copy, synthetic status, predecessor evidence transfer, bypass, or merge.