Repository navigation
quality: enforce 100% production docstrings in Commercial Readiness #262
Description
Current state — 2026-09-15
The original Commercial Readiness production-docstring gap is repaired on active package/security PR #249, but the change is not shipped. Protected main@193a87ef54c3fe6dcda4755bce4d6bc81e3a0297 remains release authority.
Exact #249 09d1430ec0f3266740266519af36e78907482ca1 carries the permanent production-docstring contract. Purpose writer 34439856410 / job 102754008005 inserted 95 missing production JSDoc blocks and reported 116 required / 116 documented / 0 missing (100.00%) before self-retiring. The initial presence-only gate was hardened to reject empty/trivial documentation with deterministic explanatory-token evidence and hostile fixtures. Formatter writer 34448538730 / job 102778651638 canonicalized that gate with repository Prettier, reran repository/package quality, self-retired, and published workflow-free candidate ancestry. Ordinary descendant 09d1430... records the anti-filler contract in CHANGELOG.md and reacquired normal contributor workflows.
The exact current head has CI 34448871673, Commercial Readiness 34448871653, SAST 34448871714, AppGuardrail 34448871643, and required Strix 34448869518 SUCCESS. The Strix lane completed the long-running contextual-orchestrator/scan path normally; no elapsed-time/model timeout was introduced.
Repository-wide promotion remains blocked by evidence outside this package repair. Security 34448871689 fails closed because central dependency-review support cannot establish authoritative GitHub dependency-comparison evidence, tracked by ContextualWisdomLab/.github#810. CodeQL 34448871609 successfully dispatches current-head analysis but its compatibility jobs cannot consume/publish the required terminal receipt. The sole current canonical versioned settlement landing vehicle is now ContextualWisdomLab/.github#2106@298e6c14c9a56b51c61df2d2e35d7545f0f4f288, still Draft/mergeable.
The predecessor #2106 producer 34919439638 on 9defd52f... is terminal FAILURE, not queued. Dispatch validation and both CodeQL analyses succeeded. Python then failed the Medium+ SARIF gate on py/incomplete-url-substring-sanitization in a test-only workflow-source substring assertion; the Actions SARIF gate passed before its later required-job wake failed. Owner repair 298e6c... changes only the three hardened-runner endpoint assertions to exact stripped-line set membership; no query suppression, workflow/runtime behavior, or gate changed. Fresh owner-head Agent Review Runtime Quality CI 34968579029, Security 34968579016, Python Security 34968579092, SAST 34968579063, and CodeQL PR 34968579134 remain non-terminal. Two owner-qualified documentation identities also remain a source obligation on #2106. Submitted reviews on #249 are COMMENTED only, so independent current-head approval is absent. None of these facts justifies weakening LifeOS gates.
Production contract
The owned production denominator is production .mjs modules under packages/commercial-readiness/src; tests, fixtures and generated artifacts are excluded because they are not production declarations. The permanent AST-backed contract covers declaration forms used by the package, requires adjacent explanatory JSDoc, reports numerator/denominator and missing symbols, and rejects malformed/non-adjacent, empty and generic filler documentation. Comments are expected to capture non-obvious authority, failure, evidence, security or bounded-I/O semantics rather than restating symbol names.
#211 is the canonical documentation owner. Its active branch is now exact b54c279b27bfa77cd11dd781af8bca1646b87ee2, open Draft/mergeable, and source-publishes the package/currentness baseline plus quality traceability with .github#2106@298e6c... and the terminal predecessor-producer RCA. Fresh #211 exact-head CI 34968933152, Commercial Readiness 34968933038, Security 34968933093, CodeQL PR 34968933101, AppGuardrail 34968933036, and SAST 34968932937 remain queued/pending. It intentionally does not copy mutable #249 or central control-plane source: exact repository GREEN still depends on canonical foundations reaching protected authority, followed by ordinary non-force adoption/revalidation.
Acceptance
- Define the Commercial Readiness production declaration denominator explicitly.
- Add a permanent AST-backed production-docstring contract.
- Bring the current owned production surface to 116/116 (100%) documented declarations.
- Cover the declaration forms used by the package and reject malformed/non-adjacent comments.
- Add hostile empty/generic-doc fixtures and deterministic anti-filler rejection.
- Preserve substantive documentation focused on contract/authority/failure/security/evidence semantics rather than threshold filler.
- Re-run exact package formatting/lint/typecheck/test/build and normal current-head CI/Commercial Readiness/SAST/AppGuardrail/Strix evidence.
- Update
CHANGELOG.mdand source-publish the baseline, Test Strategy, quality traceability and review-policy reference through docs: establish LifeOS product and technical gap baseline #211. - Restore authoritative central Security/dependency-review evidence without scanner substitution or fail-open behavior (
ContextualWisdomLab/.github#810). - Restore authoritative current-head CodeQL terminal receipt publication/consumption through
ContextualWisdomLab/.github#2106@298e6c..., including final exact-head authenticated settlement and owner-identity traceability repair. - Obtain independent current-head approval and normal protected integration of fix(security): upgrade shared vulnerable dependency graph #249.
- Non-force restack docs: establish LifeOS product and technical gap baseline #211 onto the protected fix(security): upgrade shared vulnerable dependency graph #249 ancestry and reacquire exact-head repository checks before calling the documentation lane GREEN.
Boundary
This remains a LifeOS Commercial Readiness quality contract. It does not move domain truth, persistence, credentials or provider routing; does not introduce cross-service SQL or mutable sibling dependencies; and does not weaken #261's Integration 100% coverage/docstring evidence. #249 stays Draft until remaining central evidence and independent-review gates are satisfied. No threshold reduction, production exclusion, self-approval, bypass, force push, destructive rebase, scanner suppression or stale evidence reuse is acceptable.
Refs #145, #211, #212, #249, #261; ContextualWisdomLab/.github#810; ContextualWisdomLab/.github#2106; ContextualWisdomLab/.github#2000.
Activity
seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
2026-09-10 current implementation lane: #249 exact
3090de570c29c4835b3cb1daed62351e4166e97enow contains the permanent AST-backedpackages/commercial-readiness/src/production-docstring-coverage.test.mjs. It scans the package's production.mjssurface (excluding tests), requires adjacent JSDoc on top-level callable/class declarations and class members, reports exact documented/required counts and missing locations, and has a fixture proving a non-adjacent comment cannot satisfy a later declaration. One-shot run34436246532/ job102741797513is queued to add this permanent test to root formatter authority, canonicalize it, and capture repository-owned RED evidence before the causal documentation repair. The writer is fenced to the exact input head, must delete itself before publication, and does not weaken the 100% target. No GREEN claim is made while the job has no runner.seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
Fresh owner-state update: the permanent AST-backed gate is already present on PR #249 as
packages/commercial-readiness/src/production-docstring-coverage.test.mjs. The self-retired RED writer completed successfully and publishedddc385b88e061e8d3f3605dd7494104edefb0c2b, establishing that the production.mjssurface is not yet at 100% adjacent JSDoc. I have now put the minimal causal repair on the same single-writer branch as exact input5a2a547358f9ab3116dda0a0830b4ee25bc812ea: it inserts only explicitly mapped, rationale-oriented JSDoc for currently missing production declarations, fails closed on any unmapped declaration, runs frozen install + format/lint/typecheck/test/build + the permanent docstring gate, deletes its temporary writer before candidate publication, and refuses a push if the remote head moved. Purpose run34437959036/ job102746876383is still queued withrunner_id=0and no steps, so this is not GREEN and #262 remains open.seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
Additional verified finding while the single-writer run is queued: the permanent gate currently names its requirement “explanatory JSDoc” but
hasJSDoc()accepts any adjacent/** ... */block and its self-test only distinguishes adjacent vs unrelated documentation. Thus/** */or a trivial filler block can satisfy the machine gate even though #262 explicitly forbids filler comments. The current repair mapping itself uses rationale-oriented descriptions, so this does not invalidate those proposed comments; it does mean #262 must remain open after presence reaches 100% until the permanent AST-backed contract has a hostile fixture for empty/trivial JSDoc and rejects it without using arbitrary exclusions or lowering coverage.seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
Exact hosted follow-up: docstring presence repair input
5a2a547358f9ab3116dda0a0830b4ee25bc812eareached run34437959036/ job102746876383and failed before any project code ran.actions/setup-nodehadcache: pnpm, but Corepack/pnpm activation was the following step; the runner emittedUnable to locate executable file: pnpm. This is a reproducible workflow-bootstrap RED, not a Commercial Readiness implementation RED. The active ordinary descendantf838818e01edeadea8bdd166029a157ebc2d00f7removes the premature setup-node cache lookup, preserves explicitpnpm@10.15.0+ frozen install, and pins checkout/setup-node to the exact action SHAs used by the earlier successful formatter writer. Its purpose run34439856410is pending; do not claim presence GREEN yet. The separate substantive-docstring hostile-fixture requirement remains open even if this writer later reaches 100% presence.seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
#262 exact evidence update:
34439856410, job102754008005on inputf838818e01edeadea8bdd166029a157ebc2d00f7completed SUCCESS and published self-retired candidatea8e36664242b08c46c481f15b0d8b719b64a42cd; the temporary write-capable workflow is absent from the candidate. Hosted frozen install, repository formatting, Commercial Readiness lint/typecheck/test/build and the permanent docstring test all passed. The run inserted 95 missing JSDoc blocks and reported 116/116 (100.00%) production declaration coverage./** ... */counted, including empty or generic filler. Regression-only8bd71d032301918c9a6d89c295702d8a77dea4b9adds hostile empty/generic fixtures; its ordinary PR runs were superseded/cancelled before runner execution, so I am not claiming hosted RED for that intermediate head. The predecessor helper's classification is directly contradicted by the fixture expectations.1a0e07948cb1c0558acc69b1fdedc3a5ca6ef855now extracts the adjacent JSDoc, removes tags/generic vocabulary/declaration-name words, and requires at least two distinct explanatory tokens. This is an AST/declaration contract, not a line-count threshold. The hostile fixture remains and rejects/** */plus/** Does something. */while admitting a contract-specific path-traversal explanation.1a0e079...are pending; predecessor GREEN is not transferred. quality: enforce 100% production docstrings in Commercial Readiness #262 remains open until exact-head package/repository evidence is GREEN and the required baseline/Test Strategy/traceability documentation is code-current.seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
Exact-head evidence update for #249/#262:
1a0e07948cb1c0558acc69b1fdedc3a5ca6ef855reached hosted execution. Commercial Readiness34443694902, AppGuardrail34443694983, and SAST34443694868completed SUCCESS.34443695001completed FAILURE only invalidateafter the other four jobs (today-concurrency,compose_runtime,browser-acceptance,merge_compatibility) succeeded. Job102766102829completed frozen install and failed atpnpm format:check; Prettier 3.9.6 identified onlypackages/commercial-readiness/src/production-docstring-coverage.test.mjsas non-canonical. This is therefore a real hosted formatting RED for the new permanent docstring gate, not a product/runtime regression.cf279b199d1b5c90eb87f782a87da2a6cc109f7c, adding a bounded self-retiring formatter repair. Purpose run34448538730, job102778651638is currently queued withrunner_id=0,steps=[]. It will run exact-pinned checkout/setup-node, pnpm 10.15.0 frozen install, Prettier only on the docstring gate, full repositoryformat:check, Commercial Readiness lint/test/build plus the permanent docstring test, then delete itself before publishing; remote-head equality is checked before push.Do not mark #262 complete from predecessor package evidence. Completion still requires the self-retired candidate, exact-head GREEN on the permanent substantive-docstring contract and applicable repository gates, plus the required baseline/Test Strategy/traceability source updates.
seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
Current exact #249 evidence has settled further.
09d1430ec0f3266740266519af36e78907482ca1now has normal contributor CI34448871673, Commercial Readiness34448871653, SAST34448871714, and AppGuardrail34448871643SUCCESS. The earlier docstring writer34439856410/102754008005reported 116/116 after inserting 95 missing production JSDoc blocks; the anti-filler gate was then repaired and canonicalized by formatter writer34448538730/102778651638SUCCESS, with the temporary workflow self-retired before publication. Security/CodeQL remain fail-closed for the already-separated central evidence-path incidents (.github#810,.github#1929), not for a new Commercial Readiness source failure. Canonical documentation owner #211 now has a bounded self-retiring writer input004c370ed1836b31beb5e50258e0d1a6a3da5c76queued to refresh the baseline and add explicit Commercial Readiness test-strategy/traceability source. Keep #262 open until that publication is verified and normal independent-review/protected-integration gates are satisfied.seonghobae commentedon Sep 10, 2026
Documentation-source prerequisite is now satisfied, but the exact repository GREEN dependency is clearer. #211 successfully source-published the baseline/test-strategy/traceability through writer
34453674174/102794960823; ordinary descendant7ce7fc627169f385772cac88f73082eb93fd79ebthen produced real CI RED34453909480, validate job102796550407, only at formatting after compose runtime, merge compatibility, browser acceptance and Today concurrency passed. Bounded diagnostic writer inputaf8060aad48eb0e471de5abebf3f3779b6471550, run34454594073, job102797931880, ran on Ubuntu 24.04 with frozenpnpm@10.15.0: README and CHANGELOG were unchanged by Prettier; repositoryformat:checkidentified.github/workflows/appguardrail.ymlas the sole noncanonical checked path. That control-plane formatting is already canonically repaired on #249 exact09d1430ec0f3266740266519af36e78907482ca1. #211 did not copy mutable #249 source or become a competing control-plane writer; the failed temporary writer was retired by ordinary commit, current #211 exact isf46f471320abd02e46929856b0d5fc7365fedd29with no temporary workflow. Keep #262 open: #249 still needs central Security/CodeQL authority plus independent approval and normal protected integration, after which #211 must non-force restack onto protected ancestry and reacquire exact checks/review.