Skip to content

docs: record product and technical gap baseline - #999

Open
seonghobae wants to merge 196 commits into
developfrom
docs/product-technical-gap-baseline
Open

docs: record product and technical gap baseline#999
seonghobae wants to merge 196 commits into
developfrom
docs/product-technical-gap-baseline

Conversation

@seonghobae

@seonghobae seonghobae commented Aug 20, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Maintains docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md as the canonical single-writer buyer-facing product/technical/security evidence register. This is documentation of active candidates and remaining obligations, not protected functionality, release, certification, or approval.

Exact candidate — scoped 2026-09-13 refresh

  • Base: develop@e71d37e7c58118e6764c96ab7c4492fe33eed6f8.
  • Head: 791e2b5eb5cdf376bf18ce000522bf0117443ff9.
  • Tree: 9eb81fd8ef896b22de804919874c4a04ce20ff65; baseline blob b90dc811905916984b56c97a9e743524c08a9fa8.
  • Normal descendant of prior writer head b6b03f05158178d348ec4fe2b40e93319d523d89; no force push or history rewrite.
  • This update changes only the canonical baseline and existing CHANGELOG.md. The retained history remains byte-identical at blob 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6.
  • Local exact-tree documentation contract is 10/10 with a clean diff check.
  • The immediate predecessor writer head b6b03f05158178d348ec4fe2b40e93319d523d89 completed all nine repository workflows successfully. That evidence is historical after this commit and does not transfer; this head requires its own Checks.
  • No current source finding or unresolved inline thread is claimed. Independent current-head approval and required Checks remain merge gates, not Ready-for-review prerequisites.

Why the current entry point and history are separated

The preceding baseline mixed a September 8 live-state table with later appendices and repeatedly superseded head/status instructions. Updating only its top date would falsely imply every lane was freshly verified. This change keeps the current entry point explicitly scoped and preserves the full prior record as docs/product-technical-gap-baseline-history-6d6d7749.md.

Preservation is verified at the Git-object boundary: the retained file's blob is 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6, identical to the entire preceding baseline. Every corpus row, prerequisite, FP/FN boundary, source/run/artifact identity, standards reference, governance action and later appendix remains present. The same-directory location preserves its relative link resolution. Rationale was recorded before mutation in comment 5644684932.

No valid delta or obligation is waived, retired, or declared complete by preservation. The current entry point incorporates the retained inventory by reference; unrefreshed observations are historical and require live re-fetch before action. Newer PRD/ADR and CWL governance override contradictory historical prose. G-01 through G-08 retain their existing meanings: authoritative source proof, assurance completeness, safe remediation handoff, retention/audit/recovery, buyer evidence package, structural detector precision/recall, shared review/security settlement, and baseline freshness.

Fresh evidence recorded, not transferred

The first newly refreshed source lane is #1036, final head 832d066cd3adf6aa455435bc4ef4b12926514b68:

  • An existing 78-letter raw Cyrillic alphabet had only 39 lowercase JSON-escaped letters. Equivalent uppercase serialized skill names could evade detection.
  • RED e33988082a5a2c146d4fa27087c3e766a5409603 adds 164 real packaged _scan_file cases. Hosted Tests 34682100611, Python 3.13 job 103522497980, produced 43 failed / 1161 passed.
  • Production 79531336a02a05e10fb194b6b021e91ba48e3353 repairs the escaped-codepoint alternative without changing rule identities, severity, paths or the other three rules. Final documentation head is 832d066....
  • Hosted final-head Tests 34682258917, Python 3.13 job 103522937485, produced 1204 passed; Python 3.11 job 103522937541 also succeeded. Its checkout is synthetic merge f1fff397a326b2226134babbd3592babca0f4280 binding that source head to develop@e71d37e.... These are feat(scanner): skill-supply-chain detectors (homoglyph, injection, exfil, placeholder) #1036 test results, not this documentation PR's test results.
  • Eight feat(scanner): skill-supply-chain detectors (homoglyph, injection, exfil, placeholder) #1036 repository source/security workflows succeeded. CodeRabbit independently inspected that final head and resolved its uppercase-escape source finding in reply 3995617271. This is not formal current-head APPROVED evidence.
  • feat(scanner): skill-supply-chain detectors (homoglyph, injection, exfil, placeholder) #1036 CodeQL PR 34682258948 has a separate pending-verdict failure; native dispatch success is not authentic terminal scan evidence. Canonical .github#2040 comment 5644656829 now contains its exact target/base/head/run/jobs canary. The protected old-client log does not by itself prove the distinct new-client/base-ref bootstrap mismatch described by #2051.

The refreshed Claude-plugin lineage now reaches Draft #1174 through ordinary two-parent merges. #1150 browser-profile, #1151 deceptive-description, #1153 non-standard JSON, #1154 malformed UTF-8, #1155 NFC identity, and #1156 vendored-scope are each zero behind their current parent. Their exact-tree Claude-plugin family runs rise from 153/153 to 205/205.

Draft #1157 now has exact head ba1e146c759e3c6dedd5ea14fe651e0733320697, tree c76586500501f96b67f60f1b903a61302028037f, nine ahead / zero behind current #1156, and 221/221 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. It retains the verified full legacy Command path and independent Plugin, Skill/Command, and Agent identity domains.

Draft #1158 now has exact head 02d9490358aef41974e0367039cb29a3e712aee8, tree 8c1816d9f20ff215e54a8aec2f20d7addfd02c44, four ahead / zero behind current #1157, and 239/239 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. Draft #1161 now has exact head e899568e6fd98c0476832054d1f89336ce48af6b, tree a5709f7d79acb06f0f3c86c6a74ad05afb4ee858, ten ahead / zero behind current #1158, and 256/256 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. #1161 preserves exact secret references plus the documented MCP env, args, command, url, and headers surfaces. All named exact trees pass relevant compile and diff checks. These custom-base candidates have zero hosted workflow runs and no qualifying independent current-head approval, so they remain Draft; local exact-tree runs are not hosted coverage, approval, merge, release, or consumer evidence.

Draft #1163#1169 now form the current zero-behind ordinary successor chain: #1163 edeefc402959d1d8bb1c016b47a885449fa6e0a9 (265/265), #1164 fe1a2ec5749ad7bba6d1189efb970b73785b4bca (275/275), #1165 4714d13ec38d85a4c2f34e9518064b70127753c8 (287/287), #1166 348df03ac25d98d6c3ce31b9073f2428b06cd9e0 (311/311), #1167 e091853196297e0bb351752332c017a47525d579 (317/317), #1168 d39f4c6f0865aa5a83b21c8b6c9c4b25e167d113, tree f65f21896960b6faa8c716efe4669b1f5df96105 (323/323), and #1169 7f9689b879a6b948a852ac5d78012385199eecff, tree efcf85895b37197d44ffb756c6c7c34f78a0da13 (352/352). They preserve Command/Agent rule reuse, model-directed hide/self-modify/goal escalation, unsafe executable modes, archive decompression/aggregate admission, exact scanner release/policy provenance, deterministic CycloneDX 1.5 sbom_sha256 receipt binding, and first-party checksum admission. #1169 also repairs nested-target basename collapse and legitimate ..safe.bin traversal classification. Each exact tree passes detector/CLI compile and diff checks; all remain Draft with zero hosted workflows and zero qualifying independent current-head approvals.

Draft #1170 now has exact head f5c75be09b9effa753f1c4f29d931ebe74bc786f, tree ab082b4e4aa67e012d62e6fe7cd4520057381332, five ahead / zero behind current #1169, and 383/383 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. It preserves #1169 checksum path identity while adding bounded GitHub merge/release command detection. Targeted GitHub/checksum tests are 60/60; compile and diff checks pass. It has zero hosted exact-head workflows and no qualifying independent current-head approval, so it remains Draft.

Draft #1171 now has exact head c4ad59b28f6c3e9c9c1e5fa11f7db557d98799c3, tree f8002385507b8bb97ba917c7085305b3c2d207e3, six ahead / zero behind current #1170, and 400/400 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. It preserves checksum and GitHub command-context repairs while adding the credential-store boundary. Targeted credential/GitHub/checksum tests are 77/77; compile and diff checks pass. It has zero hosted exact-head workflows and no qualifying independent current-head approval, so it remains Draft.

Draft #1172 now has exact head 00cdb7966e10f6f6e283b10619723cefb8b4676a, tree 84a0ddcdb6138eadb3d0152b2ed86f57b66c901d, nine ahead / zero behind current #1171, and 432/432 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. It preserves checksum, GitHub command-context, credential-store, kubectl/Docker deployment-write, and adjacent dynamic-eval deltas. Targeted deployment/credential/GitHub/checksum tests are 109/109; compile and diff checks pass. It has zero hosted exact-head workflows and no qualifying independent current-head approval, so it remains Draft.

Draft #1173 now has exact head 6ec09ee32c972655f9e85eea7424df6ad9d3bff5, tree a3cf421773e52d39843575490d513287889deb0e, 42 ahead / zero behind current #1172, and 461/461 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. It preserves checksum, GitHub command-context, credential-store, kubectl/Docker deployment-write, Terraform/Helm, and adjacent dynamic-eval deltas. Targeted deployment/Terraform/Helm/credential/GitHub/checksum tests are 138/138; compile and diff checks pass. It has zero hosted exact-head workflows and no qualifying independent current-head approval, so it remains Draft.

Draft #1174 now has exact head efa33479920c2ccfd28bfaeba3cb304f91ce9dfb, tree 7bc6c895bfa6ec224333265f15937d8346e1d8f3, 17 ahead / zero behind current #1173, and 485/485 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. It preserves the Vercel/Fly hosted-deploy delta and every predecessor repair. Restack exposed and repaired two fixture-contract failures without suppressing hosted-deploy or undeclared-executable findings. Hosted/Terraform boundary tests are 53/53 and the targeted related detector set is 162/162; compile and diff checks pass. It has zero hosted exact-head workflows and no qualifying independent current-head approval, so it remains Draft.

Draft #1137 now has network-reference precision RED 55f4c02a558bb8e573f27f2467684bc0e8a3b035 (2 failed / 1 passed) and exact GREEN head 07fcbcd0764ff12180e64b7258db96505d1db812, tree 3920dab8a384a1a89bb6993566f1670a642dd7be. The bounded repair requires an identifier terminator after protected secret names, so longer shell variables are negative while exact $NAME and ${NAME} network copies remain positive. Exact scoped verification is 64/64 with compile/diff checks. Ordinary two-parent carryover now keeps #1138 through #1174 zero behind each current parent with every unique detector and regression delta preserved. Exact-tree Claude-plugin runs progress from #1138 70/70 through #1174 485/485. No hosted result, coverage, approval, merge, release, or #1099 completion transfers from these local exact trees.

Closed incident #1031 remains regression provenance and broader #1099 remains incomplete. Neither the central CodeQL repair/release nor protected scanner availability is claimed complete.

Preserved product and acceptance contracts

The current baseline retains the PRD/TRD/ARCHITECTURE/UML/ERD links and Context Map, the eight-field detector-development contract, the canonical candidate scan_outcome_code mapping, and the full linked historical obligation graph. Missing, queued, running, cancelled, unavailable, inconclusive or stale evidence never becomes Clean Scan. Runtime prevention and scanner detection remain separate.

Historical work remains preserved, including #1088/#1133/#1152 polling, #1080 credential/DNS provenance, #1068/#1107 storage/SSRF, #998 shell AST, #963 and the Clearfolio causal repair, the #1099 plugin successor stack, remediation/assurance #1006/#972, and the #1117/#1192/#1131/#1181 dashboard/browser boundaries. Earlier local AST/probe/test counts and artifacts remain bound to their original revisions, not to this refresh.

Verification and merge boundary

The latest writer update changes only docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md and CHANGELOG.md. Exact head is 791e2b5eb5cdf376bf18ce000522bf0117443ff9, tree 9eb81fd8ef896b22de804919874c4a04ce20ff65, and baseline blob b90dc811905916984b56c97a9e743524c08a9fa8; retained history blob 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6 is unchanged. Local documentation contract is 10/10 with a clean diff check.

Predecessor head 8091fa7973aa6aa94706cdb6a774ce74d5cd8cdb completed SAST Semgrep 34702585278, Retention Audit Coverage 34702585324, Pinned HTTPS Coverage 34702585224, Scan path context coverage 34702585321, OpenSSF Evidence Coverage 34702585451, Tests 34702585233, Security Process 34702585276, Security Scan 34702585310, and CodeQL PR 34702585242 successfully. Those results are historical and do not transfer. Intermediate predecessor head 9db9b7c... started runs 34704193462, 34704193480, 34704193493, 34704193485, 34704193518, 34704193509, 34704193542, 34704193562, and 34704193487; they became historical when the review-count correction advanced the writer. Intermediate writer head b5555890... started runs 34704314968, 34704314909, 34704314900, 34704314908, 34704314910, 34704314925, 34704314924, 34704314923, and 34704314917; they became historical when #1171 was added. Predecessor writer head 9c85172... started runs 34704741366, 34704741378, 34704741388, 34704741396, 34704741403, 34704741399, 34704741423, 34704741434, and 34704741466; they became historical when #1172 was added. Predecessor writer head 3479dc228... completed CodeQL PR 34705127142, Pinned HTTPS Coverage 34705127152, SAST Semgrep 34705127170, Scan path context coverage 34705127374, Tests 34705127161, OpenSSF Evidence Coverage 34705127216, Security Scan 34705127166, Retention Audit Coverage 34705127162, and Security Process 34705127231 successfully; those results are historical and do not transfer. Predecessor writer head b6b03f051... completed CodeQL PR 34705637256, Pinned HTTPS Coverage 34705637248, SAST Semgrep 34705637242, Scan path context coverage 34705637263, Tests 34705637249, OpenSSF Evidence Coverage 34705637282, Security Scan 34705637274, Retention Audit Coverage 34705637267, and Security Process 34705637299 successfully; those results are historical and do not transfer. Current exact-head runs 34706166188, 34706166195, 34706166169, 34706166203, 34706166193, 34706166171, 34706166196, 34706166197, and 34706166185 were queued at admission and remain non-authorizing until terminal. Qualifying independent current-head review remains a merge gate; seven historical CHANGES_REQUESTED reviews do not transfer as current-head approval.

Ready admits review, not approval. Integrate only through ordinary protected merge/auto-merge with current-head checks, qualifying independent review and evidence-backed thread resolution. No self-approval, gate weakening, stale evidence, blind rerun, or protection bypass. No PR or Issue is automatically closed by this documentation refresh.

Refs #1031, #1032, #1036, #1099, #1157, #1158, #1161, #1163, #1164, #1165, #1166, #1167, #1168, #1169, #1170, #1171, #1172, #1173, #1174, #1087, #892, #550, #938, #927, #928, #871, #309, #1106, #1117, #1192, #1131, #1181.

Summary by CodeRabbit

  • 문서

    • 제품 및 기술 현황 기준 문서를 2026년 9월 8일 스냅샷으로 전면 개정했습니다.
    • 개발 절차, 검토 규칙, 보안 결함 분석 현황과 제품·기술 격차 상태를 최신화했습니다.
    • 보안 결함 사례와 관련 분석 항목을 대폭 확장하고, 최신 진행 상황을 반영했습니다.
    • 거버넌스 절차와 후속 조치 목록을 9단계 흐름과 57개 항목으로 정리했습니다.
  • 변경 로그

    • 최신 기준 시점의 커버리지, 브랜치 정리, 초안 상태 및 후속 작업을 기록했습니다.

The generated release-note summary above describes the earlier historical snapshot; the September 12 scope and exact candidate at the top govern this update.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Aug 20, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Review Change StackReview Change Stack

Note

Reviews paused

It looks like this branch is under active development. To avoid overwhelming you with review comments due to an influx of new commits, CodeRabbit has automatically paused this review. You can configure this behavior by changing the reviews.auto_review.auto_pause_after_reviewed_commits setting.

Use the following commands to manage reviews:

  • @coderabbitai resume to resume automatic reviews.
  • @coderabbitai review to trigger a single review.

Use the checkboxes below for quick actions:

  • ▶️ Resume reviews
  • 🔍 Trigger review
📝 Walkthrough

Walkthrough

2026-09-08 기준선 문서를 전면 개정했다. 제품 계약, 보안 결함 corpus, detector 계약, 격차 상태, 거버넌스 절차와 후속 조치를 갱신했다. 관련 변경 로그도 추가했다.

Changes

AppGuardrail 기준선 문서

Layer / File(s) Summary
제품 계약과 책임 경계
docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md
Goal and evidence contract, 개발 루프, 금지 조치, 네 가지 제품 plane, UML/ERD status와 책임 경계를 갱신했다. Context Map의 GATE 노드를 제거하고 FIND와 EVID 정의를 수정했다.
보안 증거와 격차 계약
docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md
Security-defect corpus를 확장하고 head 상태를 갱신했다. Detector-development contract, Buyer-visible Gap register와 Technical/TRD gaps를 재작성했다.
거버넌스와 후속 조치
docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md, CHANGELOG.d/999-gap-baseline-0540.md
9단계 governance loop와 57개 next actions를 기록했다. Draft PR 상태와 restack 정보를 갱신하고 기준선 변경 로그를 추가했다. Standards 참조도 정리했다.

Estimated code review effort: 1 (Trivial) | ~5 minutes

Merge Risk: 🔵 Low · up to c35e0

This change updates buyer-facing security evidence and readiness records. Clarifying how inconclusive results are represented and whether the changelog is historical will prevent consumers from misreading security status or snapshot freshness.

🚥 Pre-merge checks | ✅ 5
✅ Passed checks (5 passed)
Check name Status Explanation
Docstring Coverage ✅ Passed No functions found in the changed files to evaluate docstring coverage. Skipping docstring coverage check. Docstring coverage is scoped to functions touched by this diff. Analyzed 0 functions across 0…
Linked Issues check ✅ Passed Check skipped because no linked issues were found for this pull request.
Out of Scope Changes check ✅ Passed Check skipped because no linked issues were found for this pull request.
Description Check ✅ Passed Check skipped - CodeRabbit’s high-level summary is enabled.
Title check ✅ Passed PR 제목은 제품 및 기술 갭 베이스라인 문서 기록이라는 주요 변경을 정확하고 간결하게 설명합니다.
✨ Finishing Touches
🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)
  • Create PR with unit tests
  • Commit unit tests in branch docs/product-technical-gap-baseline

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.

@seonghobae

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

@opencode-agent @cwl-noema-review Review exact current documentation head c13e6e0. Verify the baseline is current-state evidence rather than a merge claim, includes the live PR/issue queue and explicit buyer/product/technical gaps, preserves observed versus queued/inferred distinctions, and cites standards in APA 7th form without sensitive identifiers. Submit a formal verdict tied only to this SHA; do not update the branch or merge.

@seonghobae

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Review request: please run the primary OpenCode review and Noema follow-up for exact current head of (base ). This is a docs-only product/technical gap baseline; do not treat this comment as approval or merge authorization.

@seonghobae

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Correction to the prior malformed comment: @opencode-agent @cwl-noema-review please run the primary OpenCode review and Noema follow-up for exact current head 01ba616 of #999, base develop. This docs-only baseline comment is not approval or merge authorization.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

@opencode-agent @cwl-noema-review please review the exact current head 8c7e1aa for this PR. Confirm the implementation/docs scope, current-head tests and security gates, and report any actionable finding before protected merge.

@devin-ai-integration devin-ai-integration Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

✅ Devin Review: No Issues Found

Devin Review analyzed this PR and found no bugs or issues to report.

Open in Devin Review

@seonghobae

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

@opencode-agent @cwl-noema-review @coderabbitai please review the exact current PR head 1b5fe81 for PR #999.\n\nThis docs-only follow-up adds the current Dependabot alert and remediation PR #1004 to the 2026-08-21 queue refresh. Please validate only this current head; the table explicitly distinguishes queued Checks and robot review states from approvals and protected merge evidence. Report any actionable documentation accuracy issue with exact line and evidence.

@coderabbitai

coderabbitai Bot commented Aug 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Tip

For best results, initiate chat on the files or code changes.

🧩 Analysis chain

🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
set -euo pipefail

repo="ContextualWisdomLab/appguardrail"
target="1b5fe81"

echo "== Target commit =="
git rev-parse "${target}^{commit}"
git show -s --format='commit=%H%nparents=%P%nsubject=%s%ncommit_date=%cI' "${target}"

echo
echo "== Available matching refs =="
git branch -a --contains "${target}" || true
git tag --contains "${target}" || true

echo
echo "== Changed files against first parent =="
git diff-tree --no-commit-id --name-status -r "${target}"

echo
echo "== Document outline and numbered content at target =="
git show "${target}:docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md" > /tmp/product-technical-gap-baseline.md
ast-grep outline /tmp/product-technical-gap-baseline.md --items all || true
nl -ba /tmp/product-technical-gap-baseline.md | sed -n '1,360p'

echo
echo "== Target document diff against first parent =="
git diff --no-ext-diff --unified=80 "${target}^" "${target}" -- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md

echo
echo "== PR `#999` live metadata =="
gh pr view 999 --repo "$repo" --json number,state,isDraft,baseRefName,headRefName,headRefOid,updatedAt,url,title \
  || echo "Unable to read PR `#999` metadata."

echo
echo "== PR `#1004` live metadata and checks =="
gh pr view 1004 --repo "$repo" --json number,state,isDraft,baseRefName,headRefName,headRefOid,updatedAt,url,title,author,reviews,statusCheckRollup \
  || echo "Unable to read PR `#1004` metadata."

echo
echo "== Repository Dependabot alerts (if authorized) =="
gh api -H "Accept: application/vnd.github+json" \
  "/repos/${repo}/dependabot/alerts?state=open&per_page=100" \
  || echo "Unable to read Dependabot alerts (the token may not have security-events access)."

Length of output: 2508


🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
set -u

repo="ContextualWisdomLab/appguardrail"
target="1b5fe81326e7c46a4eb81a48eabb37cf64a1b447"

echo "== Target document with line numbers =="
git show "${target}:docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md" \
  | awk '{ printf "%6d\t%s\n", NR, $0 }'

echo
echo "== Exact target diff against parent =="
git diff --no-ext-diff --unified=100 "${target}^" "${target}" -- docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md

echo
echo "== PR `#999` live metadata =="
gh pr view 999 --repo "$repo" \
  --json number,state,isDraft,baseRefName,headRefName,headRefOid,updatedAt,url,title,reviews,statusCheckRollup 2>&1

echo
echo "== PR `#1004` live metadata =="
gh pr view 1004 --repo "$repo" \
  --json number,state,isDraft,baseRefName,headRefName,headRefOid,updatedAt,url,title,author,reviews,statusCheckRollup 2>&1

echo
echo "== PR `#1004` changed dependency files =="
gh pr view 1004 --repo "$repo" --json files \
  --jq '.files[] | {path, additions, deletions}' 2>&1

echo
echo "== Open Dependabot alerts =="
gh api -H "Accept: application/vnd.github+json" \
  "/repos/${repo}/dependabot/alerts?state=open&per_page=100" 2>&1

Length of output: 59956


🏁 Script executed:

#!/bin/bash
set -u

repo="ContextualWisdomLab/appguardrail"

echo "== Public GitHub advisory for CVE-2026-69247 =="
gh api -H "Accept: application/vnd.github+json" \
  "/advisories?cve_id=CVE-2026-69247" 2>&1

echo
echo "== PR `#1004` title and body =="
gh pr view 1004 --repo "$repo" --json number,title,body,url,headRefOid,baseRefName,state 2>&1

echo
echo "== PR `#1004` exact dependency diff =="
gh pr diff 1004 --repo "$repo" -- requirements-release.txt 2>&1

Length of output: 8035


@seonghobae Formal verdict for PR #999 commit 1b5fe81326e7c46a4eb81a48eabb37cf64a1b447 only: no actionable documentation-accuracy findings.

  • The commit changes only docs/product-technical-gap-baseline.md.
  • Line 91 accurately identifies PR #1004 as open against develop at head ff95e69, with queued checks and no qualifying approval.
  • The public GitHub advisory confirms that CVE-2026-69247 affects cryptography versions < 50.0.0, has high severity, and is fixed in 50.0.0.
  • PR #1004 states that it updates the transitive release-tooling dependency from 49.0.0 to 50.0.0.
  • Lines 78-81 explicitly keep queued checks and robot review states separate from approvals and protected-merge evidence.
  • The baseline states that it is a working baseline, not a release, certification, or merge claim.

GitHub denied repository Dependabot-alert API access with HTTP 403. This prevents independent verification of the alert’s live repository status. It does not contradict Line 91. Line 91 requires confirmation of alert closure only after merge.

You are interacting with an AI system.

@seonghobae

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Current exact head is 3a66056. @opencode-agent @cwl-noema-review please validate this docs head. It refreshes the queue row for PR #1005 from 58565d8 to d968a0e and updates the observed local test count to 1047. Report any documentation accuracy issue with exact line and current GitHub evidence. Queued Checks and robot review states remain distinct from protected approvals.

@seonghobae

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

@opencode-agent @cwl-noema-review please review exact current head 80c32e0 after the baseline refresh. The PR records the current #1006 remediation handoff head; no product behavior was changed. Required Checks remain queued and no failures are reported.

seonghobae commented Sep 12, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Exact single-writer refresh — 2026-09-12

  • New head 68dd4fb1c3d2ef552096524a1342b1c7fabf9005, tree d97309bc650e9df704a4a5ca8b3b0cab6a4ce4dd, baseline blob 05ec1242aa1f7f4bd7314fe900ae6d841102d984.
  • Normal descendant of prior writer head 2f4ef67c04f2284049df9a4611b409ac04b2a45c, one ahead / zero behind. The retained history blob 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6 is unchanged.
  • Records feat(scanner): reject GitHub write tokens and Docker sockets #1137 RED→GREEN root cause, FP/FN boundaries, and ordinary zero-behind carryover through feat(cli): scan a materialized Claude plugin artifact #1140. Explicitly retains feat(scanner): bind marketplace catalog identity onto plugin receipts #1141 and later as open Draft restack work; no valid delta is retired or marked complete.
  • The nine predecessor-head workflows completed GREEN, but that evidence is historical after this commit. Fresh exact-head workflows 34693072430, 34693072449, 34693072468, 34693072470, 34693072479, 34693072506, 34693072526, 34693072533, and 34693072662 are queued and non-authorizing.
  • Inline unresolved threads: 0. Current-head approval: 0; review history includes 5 CHANGES_REQUESTED.
  • A fresh auto-merge request was rejected because the PR is now Draft. Draft state is preserved; no Ready transition or merge is claimed.

No detector result, predecessor review, coverage, release, or certification is transferred to this documentation head.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-12 exact-head baseline refresh

  • previous writer head 68dd4fb1c3d2ef552096524a1342b1c7fabf9005: all nine repository workflows reached terminal success; that result is historical after this documentation change
  • exact head: ea4f95825890248fdfe6ccdb6b55f2d02d368a40
  • exact tree: ec5e5a77c71842eaa2d2a48ab1edab96bdaa8957
  • baseline blob: f5646f95d069f5dffda1090c1e2afc5acd132456
  • retained historical inventory blob remains byte-identical at 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6
  • local exact-tree validation: documentation contract 10/10 and git diff --check
  • current exact-head workflows: nine queued; no predecessor result is transferred
  • review state: zero unresolved inline threads, zero current-head approval, five historical CHANGES_REQUESTED submissions
  • lifecycle: Draft, mergeable, no auto-merge request while Draft

The refresh records verified ordinary carryover through #1145 and leaves #1146+ explicitly incomplete. It does not relabel scoped tests as hosted coverage, approval, merge, release, or Gap completion.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-12 baseline continuation through #1146

  • exact head: 1bfa097244f5831f5e58a1ba4a40684a05fd4385
  • exact tree: 16e617aea5617087edeb5bd1ffff4c77e9139729
  • baseline blob: 1d6975558ce8c9ce82fe035621b768fc27e9e88d
  • retained history blob: unchanged 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6
  • exact local documentation contract: 10/10; git diff --check passed

This normal descendant adds #1146 head 7bca8ffc0793ad50fc82f957523fe86439711df9, its 145/145 scoped exact-tree result, and the explicit #1150+ incomplete boundary. All workflow evidence for the previous #999 heads is historical; the new head must establish its own Checks. Draft state is retained and auto-merge is not requested while Draft.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-12 exact-head admission after carryover through #1161

  • exact head: 733207db93b91d186437d6fa4821957902d848d6
  • exact tree: a59612bc8b08b029a83f01617faa8140e42518e6
  • baseline blob: fb5791678e6d8f43ead5b4e31c76f3b3d7460e68
  • retained history blob: unchanged 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6
  • documentation contract: 10/10; diff check clean
  • recorded current ordinary lineage through feat(scanner): reject plugin secrets copied into MCP env and args #1161 exact e899568e6fd98c0476832054d1f89336ce48af6b
  • PR body stale head/lineage/check paragraphs were reconciled to this exact candidate
  • Ready restored because review admission is not approval; ordinary auto-merge enabled
  • required exact-head Checks and qualifying independent approval remain protection gates; no predecessor evidence is transferred

@opencode-agent opencode-agent Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull request overview

OpenCode could not approve from deterministic current-head evidence because GitHub Checks have failed.

Findings

1. HIGH Current-head GitHub Checks - Fix failed required checks before approval

  • Problem: Failed same-head checks remain for 733207db93b91d186437d6fa4821957902d848d6.
  • Root cause: The model-unavailable evidence fallback is allowed only when peer GitHub Checks are complete and clean.
  • Fix: Read and fix the failed check logs below, then rerun the current-head checks.
  • Regression test: Keep the model-unavailable fallback gated on an empty failed-check rollup.

Failed checks:

Changed-File Evidence Map

flowchart LR
  PR["PR changed files"] --> Evidence["OpenCode bounded evidence"]
  Evidence --> S1["Repository file: 999-gap-baseline-0540.md"]
  S1 --> I1["repository behavior"]
  I1 --> R1["Review risk: Repository file: 999-gap-baseline-0540.md"]
  R1 --> V1["required checks"]
  Evidence --> S2["Repository file: CHANGELOG.md"]
  S2 --> I2["repository behavior"]
  I2 --> R2["Review risk: Repository file: CHANGELOG.md"]
  R2 --> V2["required checks"]
  Evidence --> S3["Docs: product-technical-gap-baseline-history-6d6d7749.md (2 files)"]
  S3 --> I3["operator or user guidance"]
  I3 --> R3["Review risk: Docs: product-technical-gap-baseline-history-6d6d7749.md (2 files)"]
  R3 --> V3["docs review"]
Loading

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Single-writer Gap evidence refresh: exact head 90b875c2a16bc7b63b1e5fb5bebca138817ad84c, tree 25c42f72763a13bdbe8415262e996cd5b1ac1713, baseline blob cff4117a3f423c040dbd748489f6b650b08eccbe; retained history blob remains 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6. Documentation contract is 10/10 and diff check is clean.

The immediately preceding head 733207db93b91d186437d6fa4821957902d848d6 completed its nine pull-request workflows successfully. Those results are historical and do not transfer. This head's nine runs 34701603492, 34701603496, 34701603509, 34701603512, 34701603520, 34701603526, 34701603530, 34701603536, and 34701603543 were queued at admission. There are zero unresolved inline threads, zero qualifying current-head approvals, and six historical CHANGES_REQUESTED reviews, including the predecessor Noema-review failure. Ready admits review only; ordinary auto-merge remains the authorized integration path.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-13 single-writer Gap baseline exact-head 갱신입니다.

  • prior writer head: 90b875c2a16bc7b63b1e5fb5bebca138817ad84c
  • exact head: 0677e8452ea7e132a06b032ac9d6d55893169638
  • exact tree: aa261099f379cb4abf2d87c2779ad87b37c8f947
  • baseline blob: 751b9c62b4e26360d67d2e323a1ca16d4b530bd6
  • retained history blob: 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6 (unchanged)
  • local exact-tree documentation contract: 10/10; diff check clean

The canonical entry point now records the ordinary zero-behind successor lineage through Draft #1168 at d39f4c6f0865aa5a83b21c8b6c9c4b25e167d113, tree f65f21896960b6faa8c716efe4669b1f5df96105, including deterministic CycloneDX 1.5 sbom_sha256 receipt binding and 323/323 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests. #1169 remains the next incomplete carryover boundary.

Current-head workflow observation:

  • success: Scan path context 34702023885, Retention Audit 34702023856, Security Process 34702023901, SAST 34702023822, Pinned HTTPS 34702023897, OpenSSF 34702023826, Security Scan 34702023854
  • in progress: Tests 34702023837, CodeQL PR 34702023894

There are zero unresolved review threads and zero qualifying approvals; six historical CHANGES_REQUESTED reviews remain. Ready admits review only. Ordinary auto-merge is enabled, but current-head terminal Checks and independent approval remain protected merge gates. Predecessor results and #1168 local tests do not transfer to this head.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-13 single-writer Gap baseline exact-head 갱신입니다.

  • prior writer head: 0677e8452ea7e132a06b032ac9d6d55893169638
  • exact head: 8091fa7973aa6aa94706cdb6a774ce74d5cd8cdb
  • exact tree: 62c90a177c1c9ff49bf2423e7f14e1bbe186d561
  • baseline blob: 112e3f004e1711a7f939ba9f037a858f0b1c8661
  • retained history blob: 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6 (unchanged)
  • local exact-tree documentation contract: 10/10; diff check clean

The canonical entry point now records the ordinary zero-behind successor lineage through Draft #1169 at 7f9689b879a6b948a852ac5d78012385199eecff, tree efcf85895b37197d44ffb756c6c7c34f78a0da13, including checksum path-identity RED→GREEN and 352/352 exact-tree Claude-plugin tests.

Current-head workflow observation:

  • success: SAST 34702585278, Scan path context 34702585321, Retention Audit 34702585324
  • in progress: Tests 34702585233, OpenSSF 34702585451
  • queued: Pinned HTTPS 34702585224, Security Process 34702585276, Security Scan 34702585310, CodeQL PR 34702585242

There are zero unresolved review threads and zero qualifying approvals; six historical CHANGES_REQUESTED reviews remain. Ready admits review only. Ordinary auto-merge is enabled, but current-head terminal Checks and independent approval remain protected merge gates. Predecessor results and #1169 local tests do not transfer to this head.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Final exact-head re-fetch at 2026-09-13 00:34 KST:

  • successful: SAST 34702585278, Scan path context 34702585321, OpenSSF 34702585451, Tests 34702585233, Retention Audit 34702585324, Pinned HTTPS 34702585224, Security Process 34702585276
  • queued: Security Scan 34702585310, CodeQL PR 34702585242
  • unresolved review threads: 0
  • qualifying approvals: 0; historical CHANGES_REQUESTED: 6

Head remains 8091fa7973aa6aa94706cdb6a774ce74d5cd8cdb. Queued security workflows remain non-authorizing; ordinary auto-merge stays enabled.

@opencode-agent opencode-agent Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull request overview

OpenCode could not approve from deterministic current-head evidence because GitHub Checks have failed.

Findings

1. HIGH Current-head GitHub Checks - Fix failed required checks before approval

  • Problem: Failed same-head checks remain for 8091fa7973aa6aa94706cdb6a774ce74d5cd8cdb.
  • Root cause: The model-unavailable evidence fallback is allowed only when peer GitHub Checks are complete and clean.
  • Fix: Read and fix the failed check logs below, then rerun the current-head checks.
  • Regression test: Keep the model-unavailable fallback gated on an empty failed-check rollup.

Failed checks:

Changed-File Evidence Map

flowchart LR
  PR["PR changed files"] --> Evidence["OpenCode bounded evidence"]
  Evidence --> S1["Repository file: 999-gap-baseline-0540.md"]
  S1 --> I1["repository behavior"]
  I1 --> R1["Review risk: Repository file: 999-gap-baseline-0540.md"]
  R1 --> V1["required checks"]
  Evidence --> S2["Repository file: CHANGELOG.md"]
  S2 --> I2["repository behavior"]
  I2 --> R2["Review risk: Repository file: CHANGELOG.md"]
  R2 --> V2["required checks"]
  Evidence --> S3["Docs: product-technical-gap-baseline-history-6d6d7749.md (2 files)"]
  S3 --> I3["operator or user guidance"]
  I3 --> R3["Review risk: Docs: product-technical-gap-baseline-history-6d6d7749.md (2 files)"]
  R3 --> V3["docs review"]
Loading

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-13 exact-head baseline update:

  • Normal descendant head 9db9b7c37849c84ed42991c5ff90f9e9ba47b18d; tree f7870b3e1f08a7d223cda6d7e17d7e8282372bd8; baseline blob 9abd9368279425f2d594028d4e4604f4b44dfcf4.
  • Retained corpus history remains byte-identical at blob 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6.
  • The entry point and existing CHANGELOG now bind current Draft feat(scanner): fail closed on plugin GitHub merge and release commands #1170 head f5c75be09b9effa753f1c4f29d931ebe74bc786f, tree ab082b4e4aa67e012d62e6fe7cd4520057381332, 5 ahead / 0 behind current feat(scanner): reject plugin checksum files that disagree with the artifact #1169, targeted GitHub/checksum 60/60, full Claude-plugin 383/383, and the explicit FP/FN boundary.
  • Local documentation contract is 10/10 and diff check is clean.
  • All nine workflows on predecessor writer head 8091fa797... completed successfully, but those results do not transfer. This exact head started nine fresh runs. Six historical CHANGES_REQUESTED reviews and absence of qualifying current-head approval still block protected merge.
  • Ready and ordinary auto-merge are retained; no merge or release is claimed.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Correction after fresh review re-fetch: the repository has seven historical CHANGES_REQUESTED reviews, not six. The canonical writer was advanced by a normal descendant to exact head b5555890cfd1080e7477af64ce4bafb0dccaba76, tree e5b4702900ff1907cd3fb104bc574b788e0398e9, baseline blob 0b8fc50b2b9311f2fe6c219cd54f2ae4a4239493. The retained history blob remains 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6; the 10/10 documentation contract and clean diff check remain unchanged. All intermediate-head Checks are historical; nine fresh final-head workflows started queued. Ready and ordinary auto-merge remain enabled, with no approval, merge, or release claim.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-13 successor baseline update: normal descendant exact head 9c85172dbc000d08ce9baba77732fcb3265f6f4d, tree 968f7a632f225606eef6a2f7261f772f375e98bc, baseline blob 5310a6d4dbf6322d0a7cd2c63014f5e2bbc70ad5. Retained history remains blob 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6. The baseline now binds #1171 exact c4ad59b28f6c3e9c9c1e5fa11f7db557d98799c3 / tree f8002385507b8bb97ba917c7085305b3c2d207e3, 6 ahead / 0 behind #1170, targeted 77/77 and full 400/400 exact-tree tests. Documentation contract 6/6 and diff check pass. Nine fresh final-head repository workflows started queued; seven historical CHANGES_REQUESTED reviews and no qualifying current-head approval remain merge gates. Ready and ordinary auto-merge are retained; no merge or release is claimed.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-13 single-writer refresh through the current #1172 successor:

  • exact head 3479dc228dc5b20e0170cafc994d6c7e9c3bcb3e
  • exact tree 7bcdfcf6f5c99e21b537066c9e175f6f665f0058
  • baseline blob 2e0a6a843a5a385034e029ea7e99719d0e5cb17a
  • ordinary fast-forward descendant of 9c85172dbc000d08ce9baba77732fcb3265f6f4d; no force update
  • feat(scanner): reject plugin kubectl apply and docker push #1172 exact source head/tree 00cdb7966e10f6f6e283b10619723cefb8b4676a / 84a0ddcdb6138eadb3d0152b2ed86f57b66c901d, 9 ahead / 0 behind current feat(scanner): reject plugin access to cookie and token stores #1171
  • fresh exact-tree Claude-plugin regression: 432/432; deployment/credential/GitHub/checksum subset: 109/109; compile/diff checks pass
  • local baseline assertions: 6/6; retained historical corpus blob remains 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6
  • current-head workflows admitted as queued: 34705127142, 34705127152, 34705127170, 34705127374, 34705127161, 34705127216, 34705127166, 34705127162, 34705127231
  • prior-head workflow results remain historical and were not transferred
  • ordinary auto-merge is enabled; independent approval and exact-head required Checks remain protection gates

No merge, release, or broader issue completion is claimed.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-13 single-writer refresh through current #1173:

  • exact head b6b03f05158178d348ec4fe2b40e93319d523d89
  • exact tree 992623e3dee6f6ec7fdd8e7bbdc846fd6744ba58
  • baseline blob d8d3e2257b3420f6b09cd73de7efea143627f647
  • ordinary fast-forward descendant of 3479dc228dc5b20e0170cafc994d6c7e9c3bcb3e; no force update
  • feat(scanner): fail closed on plugin terraform apply and helm install #1173 exact source head/tree 6ec09ee32c972655f9e85eea7424df6ad9d3bff5 / a3cf421773e52d39843575490d513287889deb0e, 42 ahead / 0 behind current feat(scanner): reject plugin kubectl apply and docker push #1172
  • fresh exact-tree Claude-plugin regression: 461/461; targeted deployment/Terraform/Helm/credential/GitHub/checksum: 138/138; compile/diff checks pass
  • local documentation contract: 10/10; retained historical corpus blob remains 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6
  • immediate predecessor 3479dc228... completed all nine repository workflows successfully; those results remain historical
  • current-head workflows admitted as queued: 34705637256, 34705637248, 34705637242, 34705637263, 34705637249, 34705637282, 34705637274, 34705637267, 34705637299
  • ordinary auto-merge remains the integration path; independent approval and exact-head required Checks remain protection gates

No merge, release, or broader issue completion is claimed.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

2026-09-13 single-writer refresh through current #1174:

  • exact head 791e2b5eb5cdf376bf18ce000522bf0117443ff9
  • exact tree 9eb81fd8ef896b22de804919874c4a04ce20ff65
  • baseline blob b90dc811905916984b56c97a9e743524c08a9fa8
  • ordinary fast-forward descendant of b6b03f05158178d348ec4fe2b40e93319d523d89; no force update
  • feat(scanner): reject plugin vercel deploy and fly deploy #1174 exact source head/tree efa33479920c2ccfd28bfaeba3cb304f91ce9dfb / 7bc6c895bfa6ec224333265f15937d8346e1d8f3, 17 ahead / 0 behind current feat(scanner): fail closed on plugin terraform apply and helm install #1173
  • pre-restack RED: two fixture-contract failures
  • GREEN: hosted/Terraform 53/53, related detectors 162/162, full Claude-plugin 485/485; compile/diff checks pass
  • local documentation contract: 10/10; retained historical corpus blob remains 1953b92c6c6fcfbe9a30e2b78094c214c18e6fe6
  • immediate predecessor b6b03f051... completed all nine repository workflows successfully; those results remain historical
  • current-head workflows admitted as queued: 34706166188, 34706166195, 34706166169, 34706166203, 34706166193, 34706166171, 34706166196, 34706166197, 34706166185
  • ordinary auto-merge remains the integration path; independent approval and exact-head required Checks remain protection gates

No merge, release, or broader issue completion is claimed.

@opencode-agent opencode-agent Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Pull request overview

OpenCode could not approve from deterministic current-head evidence because GitHub Checks have failed.

Findings

1. HIGH Current-head GitHub Checks - Fix failed required checks before approval

  • Problem: Failed same-head checks remain for 791e2b5eb5cdf376bf18ce000522bf0117443ff9.
  • Root cause: The model-unavailable evidence fallback is allowed only when peer GitHub Checks are complete and clean.
  • Fix: Read and fix the failed check logs below, then rerun the current-head checks.
  • Regression test: Keep the model-unavailable fallback gated on an empty failed-check rollup.

Failed checks:

Changed-File Evidence Map

flowchart LR
  PR["PR changed files"] --> Evidence["OpenCode bounded evidence"]
  Evidence --> S1["Repository file: 999-gap-baseline-0540.md"]
  S1 --> I1["repository behavior"]
  I1 --> R1["Review risk: Repository file: 999-gap-baseline-0540.md"]
  R1 --> V1["required checks"]
  Evidence --> S2["Repository file: CHANGELOG.md"]
  S2 --> I2["repository behavior"]
  I2 --> R2["Review risk: Repository file: CHANGELOG.md"]
  R2 --> V2["required checks"]
  Evidence --> S3["Docs: product-technical-gap-baseline-history-6d6d7749.md (2 files)"]
  S3 --> I3["operator or user guidance"]
  I3 --> R3["Review risk: Docs: product-technical-gap-baseline-history-6d6d7749.md (2 files)"]
  R3 --> V3["docs review"]
Loading

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

documentation Improvements or additions to documentation priority: medium Normal-priority or P2 work status: draft Draft pull request type: docs Documentation, ADR, PRD, or technical writing

Projects

Status: Backlog

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant