Repository navigation
Conversation
Integrates independently reviewed client leaf d34136859c086bdc1cd5e3d274a0c28e6eb5d366. Native runtime qualification remains separate.
|
Important Review skippedAuto reviews are disabled on base/target branches other than the default branch. Please check the settings in the CodeRabbit UI or the
 |
Preserve existing editor surfaces and original-user file authority. Exercise the real detector through public project add/remove with zero native calls and exact user/sibling preservation. Correct only the installed-package receipt framing and include the reviewed parent runtime frontend.
|
@coderabbitai full review Owner requested independent review before merge. Observed head: Prioritize presence-only Cline CLI discovery without version probes, preservation of existing editor surfaces and original profile, installed/source receipt framing, ACP session/approval/provider/probe correlation and exact named harmless tool permission. Keep literal updater suppression, native hosted-only execution, deadlines, process cleanup and closed/redacted artifacts. A single observed MCP call is not the complete A/B/user update/repair/restart/remove lifecycle. Report concrete source-bound findings and missing merge proof. |
|
777genius
left a comment
777genius
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Independent current-source evidence review: GO for closing the measured single installed ACP-attempt gate only; NOT approval to merge the complete project lifecycle.
I independently read the plan, implementation delta a075b668, final finish/deferred cleanup ordering and strict success/failure admission at current head 9d01aefb / tree 305e48fdd326813ee68236b063e60e9ac9ce7cbc. The exact transition checks retain narrow allow_once approval, the provider-issued call, fixed native identity, independent native/provider/probe join, original deadlines, source/receipt authority and false qualification flags. The prior failed captures remain failures; the new completion bit is reset if provider closure or the total deadline marks the test failed.
Genuine new-head run https://github.com/777genius/universal-agent-plugins/actions/runs/40456413669, native job 122030717462, has SUCCESS. Its raw log identifies GitHub-hosted Azure Ubuntu 24.04.5, image 20261012.334.1, exact checkout 9d01aefb, and reports test_passed=true/runtime_artifact_admitted=true. I downloaded both original artifacts and independently verified outer SHA-256:
- native
12713365628:bcf0458f258a527f8cbe5aab7e05183a21255bf2565d0bf700ad192ad09734e8 - frontend
12712348650:219a305e1db8f1edcd45eec389db4b5fe0293631f1b66176e737544b18413f41
I checked unique bounded ordinary ZIP entries/CRCs and inspected the exact 21 native members. This is independent archive inspection, not a claim that I reran the whole repository's admission implementation locally.
The ten fresh ACP frames use native session 1793079752200_QjCQR_cli. One permission request is followed by the measured in_progress/pending/completed sequence, exact final sentinel and end_turn. Native rawOutput, second provider-request tool content and independent probe facts are equal. The actual probe initialize/tools-list/tools-call records have one nonce, PID6100 and probe session 6100-1793079752523497153, in the native interval. Provider receipt has two requests/two responses, issued=true, approved=true, error=false. Prepared source/package/data paths remain distinct and receipt-bound. Frontend actual test transcript is PASS (5.67s), delegated service closed=true, forced_stop=false, forced_kill=false under UID/GID1001.
All five lifecycle/restart/MCP qualification entries and vendor-auth/real-model claims correctly remain false. Only add-A plus one installed ACP exchange is proved here. The next separately reviewed slice must still establish A/B/original-user preservation through unchanged reconciliation, update, recorded-input repair, fresh restart, remove/repeated remove and native absence. Do not use this success to bypass those gates. No branch, code, native client, qualification flag or CI retry was changed by this review.
|
@coderabbitai full review The prior request hit the reported hourly limit at approximately 05:12 UTC; the stated 59-minute window has now elapsed. This is one current-head review request, not a CI retry. Review The exact-source first installed ACP exchange now passes genuine hosted run |
|
a412ba5
into
feat/project-native-e2e-remaining-20261025
Current result: complete Cline project E2E passed
Qualified source:
e199b457ee7bd7e61aa5559924f6e930dbbde245; exact tree:f4bfe0b392a79cdc4677ad3fe95c7f4e7787300a.Genuine run 40552854540, native job
122365630884, passed the complete cycle in 69.413 seconds. All 45 executed checks at this head passed, including the preserved Claude/Codex/OpenCode macOS/Windows baselines; CodeRabbit was skipped while this PR was a draft.The fresh evidence covers 15 public commands, 14 paired skill/MCP catalog observations, 10 independent native ACP sessions, 18 source/state proofs and five independently correlated native MCP tool calls. It verifies empty/user/A/B coexistence, unchanged reconciliation, source update, exact missing-component repair, fresh-process discovery after removal, repeat removal and preservation of foreign content and retained data. All five requested lifecycle/restart/MCP qualifications are true in both native and frontend evidence. Ordinary provider/process shutdown completed without forced closure.
The supported activation remains the explicit Cline process-wide MCP settings override. Project installer state remains Prepared. The scripted loopback provider does not qualify vendor authentication or real-model behavior; those flags remain false.
Native artifact
12760270060: outer SHA256130320e15c629ec9842147ea017ab1884704b134986c179472341dc64394eee4, 54 closed ordinary members. Frontend12758367490: outer SHA2568cfced059d5d0fe559c21ea2940581638cf598a45d5373b9072380a776a09a5b, 31 members. Independent reviews verified source/tree, canonical membership/CRC, 130 nested and 30 frontend byte/hash joins, held source/binding/data identity, exact one-call permission and native/provider/probe nonce/session/PID/result relationships. Root replayed the same audit successfully. Unexported on-disk preservation is attested by the exact pinned live guards, rather than reconstructed from absent file bodies.Two independent plan rounds and exact-source implementation reviews passed. This PR is ready to merge into the project program base #520; no release is included.
Historical implementation and evidence
Earlier failed captures and source references below remain historical and are not relabeled as this successful run.
Purpose
Collect source-bound installed project evidence for pinned Cline 3.0.73, stacked on #520, and make the existing file-based project lifecycle recognize a genuine standalone CLI installation.
Current source and complete-cycle capture
Published source:
e5ec161d1ebe4e81f62a87a62ce2c39647bee17b.Exact tree:
f1d738deeb8ea2eee11e7b67490135ebb96daf21.Latest reviewed correction
This head carries two additional reviewed fixes. The privacy scanner distinguishes complete nonfinite JSON from ordinary metadata whose prefix merely resembles an overflowing number; its extra syntax check consumes the existing shared byte budget, and nested private values remain refused. The missing-skill fault now removes the exact independently verified owned directory with two checked nonrecursive removals. Leaving an empty directory was altered state under the real adapter's ownership contract, so the previous public repair correctly refused it.
The preceding complete-cycle run 40467050469, native job
122065612975, stopped atmissing-repair-aafter 53.22 seconds. It did not reach the deliberate final capture gate. Its native archive was quarantined, so unavailable raw repair stderr and empty-session frames are not claimed as observed. Frontend artifact12718201141was reverified: 31 closed ordinary members, all 30 stream joins, exact source6dedead8/ tree4e7e0601, clean receipts and normal service closure without a forced stop or kill. All five qualifications remain false.Both slices received desktop and shell plan/code GOs on their exact recovered bytes. Fresh focused Go checks passed in 0.105 and 0.171 seconds; affected all-enabled and unfiltered whole-file lint each reported zero issues. All 23 runtime Python contracts passed, and all 21 raw members of the earlier successful single-attempt capture pass the corrected scanner with unchanged unqualified admission. Real Stager/adapter controls prove absent-directory restoration while partial-leaf and extra-file tampering still refuse. Fresh genuine full-cycle evidence remains required.
The selected hosted test now exercises the complete original-user/project-A/project-B lifecycle: 15 public commands, 14 native listing pairs and 10 ACP observations under one original profile and one held scripted provider. It covers repeated add, unchanged update and intact repair, a source revision, missing-owned-skill repair, A/B isolation, removal and repeated removal, user removal, foreign content and retained-data ownership. Source files, current Store/planner/Stager receipts, installed trees and native selections are compared against independent authored expectations at each stage.
The first complete capture intentionally fails its final review gate. Its new empty-session ACP grammar and complete sequence must be independently reviewed from genuine hosted raw evidence before a separately reviewed positive amendment and a fresh successful full cycle. It cannot set lifecycle/MCP, real authentication or real model qualification merely by reaching the capture endpoint.
For the preceding complete-cycle implementation, root and two independent code critics approved the exact 16-file code tree
3dccec164c164f27e19994201b1a0d9a35e359e7. Review corrections enforce exact-zero receipts and a guarded absent data path for the legacy skill-only user allocation, independently reconstruct retained data after actual removal, reject malformed or coerced skill metadata, and inspect bounded nested JSON/JSONL strings before evidence encoding.Final focused Go contracts passed in 0.115 seconds; all-enabled affected lint and the unfiltered whole-file architecture/size/complexity gate each reported zero issues. The 22 Python runtime contracts and 5 shared Cline contracts passed. The old successful single-attempt envelope still re-admits unchanged with all qualification flags false. One optional local inert shell-only test is unavailable on this proc surface; genuine hosted process/cleanup gates remain required. No acquired client or installer ran locally.
Implemented slice
The bounded hosted ACP attempt uses public local-source project add, exact source/package/Prepared receipts, the unchanged installed skill and MCP transport projection, one supported loopback scripted provider, and manual native approval. Approval is restricted to the actual session, provider call, exact harmless tool and nonce. Existing process delegation, fixed deadlines, original-user isolation, runtime pins and closed redacted capture remain required. Every initial capture deliberately stays unqualified pending independent review of actual native bytes.
The presence correction appends only
cline_clithrough the existing read-only PATH lookup. It preserves all four editor surfaces, their order, the original.clineroot and empty executable/version metadata. It adds no native version probe or automatic execution. The installed package expectation now uses the reviewed production Stager receipt framing; the independent acquired source digest retains its separate versioned framing.Actual evidence and current gate
Runtime run 40357515451, source
4a5c4d32e8882217a9439fb6833938731943011e, tree9eeda83072ec9adae47b7b11b0bb7a7d40ef0a05, verified the acquired CLI reports3.0.73, then public add refusedtarget "cline" was not detectedbefore mutation or ACP startup. Native artifact12671534049SHA-256 ised0637625cba4c40ed2f3ccaac582deb3a024e2bc1613813faa97acc827e4560; frontend artifact12671673849SHA-256 is47d1583165a7e7a8af5282c5d3d655583a49a7f2cd8640f18d9ca03bf33c7a05.The presence/framing fixes are published as source
143b0fabf9af1a8de00bca391f7288a7ca4f54a4, tree97b37e1f368907cf098add97a76877529747a1a6, with both independent plan and implementation approvals. Its project-runtime run 40383018964 remains historical evidence at that source; it is not qualification for the current complete-cycle head. Inert detector/golden tests and a public local add/remove regression pass with the real detector and native execution blocked. That regression verifies Prepared delivery and exact removal of the owned skill/MCP/package binding while preserving original-user, sibling-project and foreign-client facts. No vendor executable ran locally.Remaining qualification
The new empty-session ACP grammar and complete user/A/B sequence still need a closed genuine capture and independent review. The earlier successful single-attempt grammar does not establish full update/repair/remove, restart/removal or complete MCP lifecycle coverage. Vendor authentication and real-model behavior remain separate gates. All five initial qualification flags remain false. No release publication.
Shared corrections included in this head
This head also includes the independently reviewed Go 1.22-compatible fixture/lint corrections and parent
2f7a885ec00622cb500ca1189b93659ca5bd9216's bounded Darwin process-group cleanup correction. Existing installed/source identity checks, native deadlines, output limits and genuine-host requirements remain strict. Earlier successful checks are evidence for their recorded source only; this head still requires its own applicable hosted results.