From 22c0d6409a9c4856da89eecf91d4f6a6179d0a04 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Peter van Tol Date: Mon, 19 Oct 2026 11:39:13 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] docs: finalize R59 inspection content decision source delivery --- ...rge-r59-content-finalization-20261019.json | 16 ++ BOOTSTRAP.md | 13 ++ ...ON_CONTENT_DECISION_DELIVERY_2026_10_19.md | 185 ++++++++++++++++++ 3 files changed, 214 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .github/product-version-operations/forge-r59-content-finalization-20261019.json create mode 100644 docs/qualification/R59_INSPECTION_ADOPTION_CONTENT_DECISION_DELIVERY_2026_10_19.md diff --git a/.github/product-version-operations/forge-r59-content-finalization-20261019.json b/.github/product-version-operations/forge-r59-content-finalization-20261019.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..665562a --- /dev/null +++ b/.github/product-version-operations/forge-r59-content-finalization-20261019.json @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +{ + "baseline_version": "2.24.0", + "classification_rationale": "R59 own nonempty source finalization after protected implementation PR301; same allocation, no product behavior or R57 change", + "component": "product", + "event_lineage": "R59 own nonempty source finalization after protected implementation PR301; same allocation, no product behavior or R57 change", + "expected_head": "d13a65bac21f2de56f12711475c590b952fa8440", + "operation_id": "forge-r59-content-finalization-20261019", + "policy_revision": "forge-bootstrap-release-cadence-v2", + "product": "forge", + "projection_paths": "product-version.json", + "release_class": "NO_BUMP", + "requested_bump": "none", + "requested_version": null, + "schema_version": "1", + "target_version": "2.24.0" +} diff --git a/BOOTSTRAP.md b/BOOTSTRAP.md index ee3bad8..a55b800 100644 --- a/BOOTSTRAP.md +++ b/BOOTSTRAP.md @@ -1,5 +1,18 @@ # Forge bootstrap +## R59 inspection-adoption content decisions — source Finalization + +[Protected implementation and scoped evidence](docs/qualification/R59_INSPECTION_ADOPTION_CONTENT_DECISION_DELIVERY_2026_10_19.md) +bind PR301 at `d13a65bac21f2de56f12711475c590b952fa8440`, Forge2.24.0/schema46, +separate finite Business/Architecture content decisions over the original R55 +proposal, complete candidate CI, strict coverage and independent Quality/Security. +Actual TDE remains FAIL under unchanged observe-only policy. This separate source +Finalization requires its own protected delivery and NEW exact-final-main installed +HTTP/recovery acceptance in the owning register before terminal closure. No target +write, effect approval, project readiness or Mission is authorized. R57/PR298 stays +BLOCKED and intact; no automatic successor is selected. + + ## Production Mission 3 R3 acceptance stop — 20 September 2026 The [R3 production acceptance record](docs/operations/MISSION_3_PRODUCTION_ATTEMPT_R3_2026_09_20.md) diff --git a/docs/qualification/R59_INSPECTION_ADOPTION_CONTENT_DECISION_DELIVERY_2026_10_19.md b/docs/qualification/R59_INSPECTION_ADOPTION_CONTENT_DECISION_DELIVERY_2026_10_19.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..64520e7 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/qualification/R59_INSPECTION_ADOPTION_CONTENT_DECISION_DELIVERY_2026_10_19.md @@ -0,0 +1,185 @@ +# R59 — inspection-adoption content decisions: source Finalization + +## Identity and protected implementation + +- Assignment: `L3-INSPECTION-ADOPTION-CONTENT-DECISION-V1-20261019`, R59/plan1. +- JOIN: `L3-L4-INSPECTION-ADOPTION-CONTENT-DECISION-V1-20261019`. +- [Selected mandate](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/issues/207#issuecomment-6261535091), [pickup](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/issues/207#issuecomment-6261732653), [verification register](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/issues/207#issuecomment-6263372285). +- Same ARCHITECT_3/LANE_3_WORK session and sole Forge writer. +- Protected base: `8ee60c8409b2c3801e70cf129f20f1ff1480d03b`. +- Reviewed candidate: `16b396870981b40641ce9374f08f7dbaf8a4d39d`. +- [Implementation PR301](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/pull/301) merged through the ordinary protected route at **`d13a65bac21f2de56f12711475c590b952fa8440`**, 2026-10-19 09:37:12 UTC. +- Authoritative main readback matches that merge. Its tree **`5fd4dd1b92874acbbe6d7d70a2c6f84a03ebe9b6`** equals the reviewed candidate and qualified PR checkout. +- Forge **2.24.0 / schema46**: an independent canonical allocation skips unmerged R57's reserved candidate2.23.0. This separate Finalization is **NO_BUMP**, with its own operation receipt bound to the actual implementation merge. + +R58 and predecessors remain CLOSED. **R57/PR298 remains BLOCKED and intact** at +`3250e3ecd23e0217a1176699e99f561ee37ce274`, with its original branch, version, +fourteen local cases, five hosted failures and all counters/evidence preserved. +This delivery neither resolves nor resumes R57 and starts no successor. + +## Delivered product boundary + +The supported chain is an original, currently authorized EP inspection -> the +owning immutable R55 adoption proposal -> visible review of exact document +content and limitations -> separately explicit canonical Business and +Architecture content decisions -> original decision/intent/history readback. +The profile is **`INSPECTION_ADOPTION_CONTENT_ONLY/1.0`**. Both currently +applicable positive roles produce only `CONTENT_APPROVED_ONLY`. + +The separate service, ordinary local CLI and closed packaged HTTP schema reuse +the existing Forge Server and owning R55 services. Subject binding includes +instance, dossier, original operation/plan, request/input/result/proposal/ +manifest/record/raw-source digests, whole EP snapshot binding, selected mappings, +artifacts and original document bytes. A different proposal/source/context has +a different subject; old decisions never inherit approval into it. + +Historical Dutch vision bytes, the explicitly absent architecture addition, +optional unknown roadmap and typed limitations remain visible. The original +`AS_OF_OBSERVATION_NOT_CONTINUOUS` qualification never becomes a current +filesystem, CLEAN, ABSENT, mode, owner or HEAD claim. Missing relevant content, +metadata-only/oversize information and conflicts block a positive decision. +Only genuinely unknown, uncovered optional roadmap work remains an optional +question; it does not imply effect readiness. + +Finite owner-issued role-purpose grants bind the current canonical human/role, +source READ authority, exact subject, audience, instance, epoch and expiry. +R54 content rights, R55 PREPARE/READ, R56 effects, admin/pairing and arbitrary +actor/role headers gain no new authority. The canonical solo operator may hold +two separately issued roles; qualification does not invent two people. + +Durable immutable intent precedes the decision; append-only history and CAS +preserve original identity. Exact replay returns the same result; changed bytes, +actor, grant or source context under the same identity conflict. Current source, +peer, human and grant authority are rechecked at read, decision and protected +publication. No own authority lock spans an EP or client socket wait. Revoked +historical decisions remain history but cease to count as current approval. +Missing/corrupt initialized stores fail explicitly instead of inventing empty +healthy history. + +No new inspector, renderer, project registration, EP POST/apply, target/repo/ +Git/B8R effect, Genesis effect plan/approval, model call, READY, Action or Mission +is delivered or authorized. R55 Forge2.21.0/cd483fd9 and EP2.3.121/f3b56303 remain +historical pins; there is no new L2 producer requirement. + +## Complete candidate tests and independent assurance + +[Required CI39219426488](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/actions/runs/39219426488) +is **SUCCESS** on the exact reviewed candidate: all57steps, including all +existing installed integrations and preservation maintenance. The canonical +suite reports **1678 tests, OK with five skips**, in2890.683seconds. CodeQL and +canonical version checks also passed. + +The unchanged strict executable-line gate and independently parsed original +coverage XML agree for every changed production Python file: + +| File | Covered / executable lines | Coverage | +| --- | ---: | ---: | +| `inspection_content_cli.py` | 42 / 43 | 97.67% | +| `inspection_content_contract.py` | 47 / 53 | 88.68% | +| `inspection_content_grant.py` | 141 / 164 | 85.98% | +| `inspection_content_service.py` | 150 / 169 | 88.76% | +| `server_runtime.py` | 801 / 929 | 86.22% | + +All five are strictly **>80.2%**. Focused verification includes actual owning R55 +HTTP blocker reproduction, current role/source revocation and real expiry, +foreign/old-purpose denial, changed subject, CLI parity, concurrent CAS, durable +recovery, late authority loss, private-store loss/corruption and route/schema/ +OpenAPI/Postman coherence. The independent literal route catalogue retains all +104 old cases and adds five explicit selected routes and admin-scope denial; +no old authorization assertion or acceptance threshold was relaxed. + +Independent complete **Quality7 and Security7 source-delivery assurance PASS** +binds the exact candidate, full CI, strict coverage, original installed proof, +fault retention and actual TDE findings. Both reviewers read original statuses, +logs and artifact bytes independently, found no open concrete P1/P2 and made no +source edits or test/CI runs. Protected Finalization and final-main acceptance +remain separate lifecycle requirements, not inferred from these source reviews. + +## Actual TDE outcome retained + +[Own TDE39219426484](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/actions/runs/39219426484) +executed all four capabilities. Its actual result is **assessment FAIL / +repository qualification FAILED**, exit2/2, under the unchanged observe-only +policy. The original [artifact12173516575](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/actions/runs/39219426484/artifacts/12173516575) +ZIP SHA256 is **`caa11fd1540f0504e5c19b7b18318ea7be86d67fdd856c31778e55fdefda3e37`**. +Original logs, full assessment/qualification, coverage XML and evidence records +are retained, with download digest and ZIP integrity verified. + +There are715 findings. Quality/Security individually assessed all18 findings in +the five changed files:11 HIGH-complexity findings in new product files, plus +seven server findings including dispatch complexity76 (CRITICAL). Existing and +new complexity debt is explicit; these are not all pre-existing findings. +Manual review found no additional concrete authorization, privacy, integrity or +quality P1/P2 in those branches. This is **not TDE-PASS, suppression, a waiver or +a policy change**. The independent TDE canonical run also completed1678tests, +OK with five skips, in2825.360seconds. + +## Actual ordinary installed candidate evidence + +[Original installed artifact12170863331](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/actions/runs/39219426488/artifacts/12170863331) +ZIP SHA256: **`939b55900523b1a654983c57e15fd3025b02ab07a2157ec2c7957dccb7d5557e`**. +Qualified PR checkout: `aee21aa5661da0785ecdfe4c24acdae5d9bd68e5`, with the exact +same candidate/implementation tree above. Forge wheel SHA256: +**`fdc04a595c91d412d5dff521daab2296e636e4bbcc10cbc6884d79a57ab88934`**. + +Ordinary noneditable installations run outside the source checkout on the +supported hosted Linux context, using owning EP2.3.121 revision +`f3b56303b561a7193965f4aa41fd8da744a8c1c2`. Source/wheel/installed entrypoints +and351 Forge/201 EP payload files were verified. OS identity is explicitly +**`MODELED_TRUSTED_OS_FIXTURE`**; this is not physical Mac user acceptance. +Qualification decisions are **`SYNTHETIC_TEST_NOT_PETER_APPROVAL`**. + +Thirteen real case groups cover two separately finite role decisions over one +original R55 proposal; complete HTTP200 response loss at an external relay +(10554/10554bytes received), original GET-only intent recovery without a repeated +decision POST, separate Forge/EP Server OS restarts, original history, revoked +role applicability, actual finite expiry/source revocation, missing/corrupt +stores, ordinary CLI parity and restored installed faults. Adapter audit is +**55 GET / zero POST**. The separate test owner prepared exactly one original +inspection before the adapter. Target and original EP inspection-ledger bytes +remain unchanged. Original installed payloads are reverified after faults; +cleanup is true and EP stop is not pending. + +The original installed applicability detector is genuinely RED/exit1 under its +bounded defect and GREEN/exit0 after restoring identical original product +bytes. Public original RED/GREEN stdout/stderr, exact detector/source/tree/wheel +bindings and hashes are preserved; aggregate file hashes match. Quality and +Security independently verified the original evidence, closing the retention +P2. The existing owning R55 digest fault detector remains intact. + +## Preserved failures and concrete corrections + +The first local exact baseline verified346 Forge/201 EP payloads but failed the +owning initial inspection with503 `INSPECTION_WORKER_UNAVAILABLE`. Original +failure remains; no local native-policy workaround or false PASS was used. +Its original failed receipt's cleanup=false was preserved. Independent fresh +readback found no remaining own fixture prefix and no pending EP process. + +Original roadmap metadata/oversize HTTP REDs, finite-grant fixture expiry, +missing decision route, required Postman query, full-success loss gap, fault-log +retention gap and frozen-route catalogue RED remain preserved with their coupled +corrections/verification. Superseded candidate1/2 broad CI/TDE were deliberately +CANCELLED before their replacement candidates to avoid duplicate incomplete +full suites; original logs/statuses/installed artifacts are retained and are +never relabeled whole-CI PASS. No predecessor budget/history was reset. + +## Finalization and terminal acceptance boundary + +This is the separate, nonempty **source Finalization** on its own branch after +protected implementation. It changes only delivery documentation, the bootstrap +entrypoint and its canonical NO_BUMP receipt. It neither changes product bytes +nor claims a published package release. + +The automatically triggered implementation-main checks are a new phase. After +this Finalization receives independent review and its ordinary protected merge, +terminal R59 closure still requires **new exact-final-main** ordinary installed +HTTP/restart/readback/negative/privacy/restored-fault/cleanup evidence, with +fresh authoritative main identity and complete required CI readback. Candidate +or implementation-main receipts are not a substitute. Until matching final +receipts are recorded in the [owning register](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/issues/207), +this document is not a terminal whole-DoD acceptance claim. + +[Concrete L4 route/schema/authbinding and synthetic examples](https://github.com/pcvantol/forge/issues/208#issuecomment-6261952255) +were delivered early. L4's scope/pin remain unchanged; native implementation or +a general peer ACK is not a wait gate. No automatic successor, R57 resume or +new live EP environment is selected.