From 108758e94a8e04f0f6af5933621cbf77883eccfa Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Cursor Agent Date: Thu, 9 Jul 2026 21:53:05 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Document C8: dedicated /servers sheet UI vs faux DM/server. Recommend an action sheet/modal with search and tappable rows; keep bot-message fallback; avoid fake DM or injected guild UX. Co-authored-by: Daniel JB Clark --- OPTIONS.md | 31 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 file changed, 30 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/OPTIONS.md b/OPTIONS.md index 265696a..475fc27 100644 --- a/OPTIONS.md +++ b/OPTIONS.md @@ -100,7 +100,8 @@ Every option below must include an explicit **Risk** value. **Complexity:** Medium **Risk:** **Medium** — Revenge/Vendetta alert APIs differ by build; must keep markdown fallback (B2). -**Fit:** Direct upgrade to B2 +**Fit:** Direct upgrade to B2 +**Pairs with:** **C8** (full switcher sheet can absorb this) ### C6 — Export / import aliases @@ -114,6 +115,34 @@ Every option below must include an explicit **Risk** value. **Shipped:** Settings text rules (exact name, Discord id, or `~partial`); always skipped by fuzzy search; optional hide from `/servers` list. Recents slots still work for previously recorded ids. **Risk:** **Low** + +### C8 — Dedicated switcher UI (not in-channel) + +**What it is:** Open a real UI surface for `/servers` instead of posting bot messages into the current channel. + +**Recommendation:** **Yes, pursue a sheet/modal — not a faux DM or fake server.** + +| Approach | Verdict | Why | +|----------|---------|-----| +| **Action sheet / custom modal** with search field + tappable server rows | **Best fit** | Matches Discord mobile patterns; no channel spam; taps can jump immediately; builds on C5 | +| **Plugin settings-style screen** pushed onto the nav stack | **Good alternate** | Same React patterns we already use for settings; slightly heavier than a sheet | +| **Faux bot / DM “person” to talk to** | **Weak** | Still chat UX; typing latency; hard to make feel native; confusing vs real DMs | +| **Faux Discord server / channel** | **Avoid** | High Metro risk (guild/channel injection), permission/UI edge cases, looks like malware to users, breaks on client updates | + +**User-facing shape (preferred):** + +1. `/servers` (no args) → opens switcher sheet: search box, recent strip, A–Z list, tap to jump +2. `/servers query:…` → either jump immediately when unambiguous, or open the sheet pre-filtered +3. Keep a **fallback** to today’s bot-message list if the sheet API is missing on a given Revenge/Discord build +4. Optional later: entry from plugin settings (“Open switcher”) so you don’t need slash at all + +**Why bother:** In-channel replies clutter chat, feel like a workaround, and make search/jump harder to discover. A sheet is the natural mobile switcher UX. + +**Complexity:** Medium (sheet + list + search reuse existing command/search logic) +**Risk:** **Medium** — depends on Revenge/Discord alert / action-sheet / navigation APIs that churn; must keep slash + bot-message fallback. Fake server/DM approaches are **High** risk and not worth it. +**Fit:** High — this is the long-term home for list, pick-list (C5), recents, and pins (C4) +**Depends on / pairs with:** C5, C4, A1 (device QA of sheet APIs) + --- ## D — Engineering / maintenance