diff --git a/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/badge.jpg b/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/badge.jpg new file mode 100644 index 000000000..29190a95c Binary files /dev/null and b/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/badge.jpg differ diff --git a/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/cover_large.jpg b/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/cover_large.jpg new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d5f0f6064 Binary files /dev/null and b/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/cover_large.jpg differ diff --git a/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/index.md b/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/index.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b456baf41 --- /dev/null +++ b/content/posts/2026/11/19/porto-techhub-2026/index.md @@ -0,0 +1,198 @@ +--- +title: "Porto TechHub 2026" +date: "2026-11-19" +description: "Notes from Porto TechHub 2026: Embabel and agentic AI planning, a comparison of Spring AI, LangChain4j, and Embabel, and the new defaults in Git 3." +canonical: "https://blog.frankel.ch/porto-techhub-2026/" +authors: + - "nicolas-frankel" +image: "cover_large.jpg" +categories: + - "Conference" + - "AI" +related_posts: + - "spring-ai-langchain4j-three-stacks-one-test" + - "embabel-spring-boot-wikidata-definition-api" + - "yow-2025" + - "kcdc-2025" +--- + +My conference participation has dropped sharply since I left DevRel for a regular office engineering job. In 2023, I was proud to have had [70 talks](https://blog.frankel.ch/speaking/2023/); I'll finish this year with 4, including one online and one quickie. It has one beneficial side effect, though. Because I go to so few, I take the time to attend. On Tuesday, November 10th, I was lucky to attend and talk at the [Porto TechHub](https://portotechhub.com/) conference, for the 4th year. + + + +Here are the talks I attended and their respective summary. If you attended a talk or are the presenter, feel free to correct my possible misunderstandings. + +## Stop Prompting, Start Planning: Reliable Agentic AI with Embabel by Patrick Baumgartner + +I'm cheating with this one: I couldn't attend it, as it was running in parallel with one of the other talks. However, Patrick presented it at the Geneva JUG [last month](https://genevajug.org/session/2026-10-27-stop-prompting-start-planning-embabel/). + +Patrick introduced the subject by mentioning the core issue with LLMs: their non-deterministic nature. Two guardrails can help with that. + +* The first is Goal-Oriented Action Planning. GOAP is a planner that lets an agent decide its course of action by providing it with a context, a goal, and a set of actions. +* The second is standard programmatic constructs, _e.g._, conditionals (`if`). + +Patrick then described Embabel, which aims to leverage both: + +> Embabel is an Agentic AI framework for the JVM. Python has long been the go-to for machine learning experiments, thanks to its ease, ecosystem richness, and data scientist-friendly tools. However, it often struggles when you try to move from experiment to real-world, production-scale AI. +> +> —- [Embabel](https://hub.embabel.com/) + +Embabel relies on Java code, types, annotations, and Spring so you can program steps in a workflow. The wiring from one step to the next is inferred via types. If the method `taskA()` returns `TypeX`, and the method `taskB()` accepts `TypeX` as a parameter, then A and B are steps, and B follows A. + +Patrick showed several demos grounded in business use cases and the relevant code to highlight his points. At the end, he also did a demo of a visualization tool for the code. + +{{< tip >}} +**My opinion** + +I like Spring and strong typing, even though I could nitpick about having a proper DSL instead of annotations. In any case, I must admit that I fail to see the value proposition in Embabel. + +We have plenty of workflow engines on the JVM. I started my Java career on one. Today, [Camunda](https://camunda.com/) offers a modern Open Source platform fully compatible with BPMN. BPMN has the benefit of being backed by a [specification](https://www.omg.org/spec/BPMN). Icing on the cake, many software components provide visualization of any BPMN-based workflow. + +One could achieve the same benefits as Embabel with a workflow task calling an LLM. +{{< /tip >}} + +Material: https://github.com/patbaumgartner/talk-stop-prompting-start-planning-with-embabel/ + +## The Agentic Loops Every Developer Should Know by Rui Quintino + +I expected a talk in line with the title and the description. I missed the first 5 minutes, but the rest was mainly demos of what the speaker built with coding assistants. For example, he described how he wanted to edit a Word document in parallel with his assistant. However, Microsoft Word sets a lock so you can't do it. Thus, he used Claude Code to write his own Word clone to allow it. + +{{< tip >}} +**My opinion** + +The speaker was very enthusiastic about what he achieved, and I can't deny that it was great, but I didn't get anything actionable out of the talk. +{{< /tip >}} + +## Comparing Agentic AI Frameworks for Java by Sandra Ahlgrimm and Timo Salm + +The talk compares Spring AI, LangChain4j, and Embabel through the lens of an AI nutrition planner. + +
| Capability | +Spring AI | +LangChain4j | +Embabel | +
|---|---|---|---|
| Deterministic workflows | +Advisors & plain Java code | +Workflow agents | +@State and planner | +
| Pure agents | +Tool calling loop | +Supervisor agent | +Built in | +
| Memory and state | +ChatMemory advisors | +AgenticScope | +Blackboard | +
| Agentic patterns | +Experimental | +Built in, some experimental | +Built in, some experimental | +
| Observability | +Model level only | +Agent listeners | +Agent level | +
| Testing | +Mocks, evaluators | +Mostly manual | +Advanced testing support | +
| MCP | +Client and server | +No HTTP server support | +Client and server | +
| A2A | +Experimental | +Client only | +Experimental | +
| Maturity | +
+
|
+ Agentic experimental | +GA, plus some experimental features | +
| Legend: Built-in | Experimental or some effort | Limited | +|||