Avatar from OwnTracks card

[tobru]

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

OwnTracks has a feature called cards.

Describe the solution you'd like

Use the card information from OwnTracks to set and display the user's avatar.

Additional context

This would make reitti an ever-increasing full-blown OwnTracks integrated app.

[dgraf-gh]

Hi @tobru,

Thank you for the idea. However, this particular suggestion raises several questions for which I currently don't have clear answers.

• Data Source: First, where would we obtain this information? As I understand it, OwnTracks publishes this on the info topic under /user/device/info. We would first need to subscribe to that topic. Assuming that's how it works, when exactly are these messages published? It appears to be when a user manually changes their own card, according to the documentation.
• User Preference: If we assume we successfully retrieve the card, we could technically overwrite the user's avatar. However, how do we determine if this behavior is preferred by the user? What if the user has updated it within Reitti and does not wish for it to be superseded by the OwnTracks data?

I can imagine having a button somewhere (though I'll address that point later) to fetch user information (if available) from OwnTracks. However, this introduces another problem: where would this feature belong within the UI/settings? While it's somewhat connected to OwnTracks, placing it in the OwnTracks section might be confusing for users who primarily configure via MQTT. Placing it directly within MQTT settings wouldn't work either, as this functionality is specific to OwnTracks. Furthermore, in the future, we aim to support various location providers over MQTT.

This would make reitti an ever-increasing full-blown OwnTracks integrated app.

This raises the question: should we intentionally pursue such deep integration?

Overall, this seems like a significant amount of development and maintenance effort for a relatively small portion of our user base. Please don't misunderstand, I genuinely appreciate the idea. However, I believe the benefits would likely not outweigh the substantial effort required to implement and maintain this feature properly.

[tobru]

Thanks for putting these thoughts into this feature request. I see that this isn't straightforward from a UX perspective and potentially not even intended for reitti.

Another idea could be that reitti publishes the user's avatar to /user/device/info as a _card. There could be an option in the MQTT integration setting "Publish avatar", but only when the "Payload Type" is set to "OwnTracks". This way, reitti would be the source of truth for the users avatar.