Skip to content

Archive this repository? #109

@abrown

Description

@abrown

As I prepare to change projects I'm working on, I decided to review this repository for archiving &emdash; I believe we should archive it. Here's why:

  • the AssemblyScript bindings here have been unmaintained for some time
  • the Rust bindings here have fallen out of date with the latest specification of wasi-nn
  • keeping this up-to-date is a chore that no one wants to take on because...
  • the best way to generate and use bindings for any WASI proposal is with wit-bindgen
  • this repository requires a bunch of extra work to fix CI, update examples, clean up unused parts, etc.

Some background: back when wasi-nn was first specified with WITX, it was difficult to access the low-level specification APIs. In that world, it made sense to generate the low-level, unsafe bindings to languages like Rust and AssemblyScript and then wrap them with a higher-level API that made it all more developer-friendly. Since then, the adoption of WIT as the IDL for WASI proposals and improvements in tooling (i.e., wit-bindgen) make this "generate and wrap" idea outdated. E.g., in #108 you can see how redirecting users to wit-bindgen is the right approach.

In the past, I kept this alive due to community requests but I will no longer have time to do so. I think now is the right time to archive this project and direct future developers towards wit-bindgen. Here's how I propose to do this:

  • leave existing AssemblyScript and Rust packages alone: this avoids breaking any existing users of this repository, who can continue to use them for older versions of wasi-nn (e.g., p1-style)
  • rewrite the top-level README to point to this issue, with a "This repository is deprecated, see ...; use wit-bingen instead" message
  • remove all other files in main
  • archive the repository

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions