Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
681 lines (578 loc) · 40.2 KB

ACTIVE_MISSION.md

File metadata and controls

681 lines (578 loc) · 40.2 KB

Active mission

Updated: 2026-11-14

Current bounded diagnostic: R108

R108 evaluates autonomous grounded generation on eight trained task families, using 48 fixed counterfactual pairs. One preselected external control must qualify before the four retained recipient lineages run. R99 LoRA/distillation retain their matched historical budgets; the new control is not their teacher. No training, gate relaxation, native-host change, or broad-English claim. Preserve and publish every outcome.

The attempt ended at its registered 1,500-second control-process timeout: 13/96 initial responses, no replay, no recipients, zero training. Recorded NVIDIA telemetry shows a requested 10 W limit (80 W default), 210 MHz clocks and active power/thermal throttling. No hardware setting was changed. The complete verifier still rejects the run. R108 result. Resolve the operating constraint before an authorized separately recorded retry; do not change gates, overwrite this prefix, or infer a quality/host failure.

Previous completed bounded diagnostic: R107

R107 tests natural-text retention with a causal in-memory residual-neutralization intervention. Preserve all checkpoints; no training, new package or native-host change. Four existing recipient lineages (including matched LoRA/distillation) each run active/neutral, plus the unchanged ancestral DistilGPT2 reference. This does NOT qualify an English control, reopen the stopped R103-R106 matrices or relax their gates. Freeze before execution; one bounded audit and fresh-process replay, then publish.

All 18 executions now completed with exact raw replay. The primary parent residual effect is +0.03224 BPB, 95% CI [+0.02064, +0.04419], supporting interference on the fixed natural-text panel. Neutralization worsens parent repetition; it is not a qualified core. Coherence was untrained in R99, so matching distillation retention there is not a trained-route or superiority claim. See the R107 result. No new training follows automatically; acquisition quality and native-host conformance remain separate. The immutable tag and public reconstruction receipt are published. All 585 assets and 182 host bindings match; 55 focused checks and tagged CI pass. No live inference or independent hardware is claimed by that public-only reconstruction. No qualified English artifact is available for host acceptance yet.

Latest completed bounded diagnostic: R106

R106 separates grammatical discrimination from autonomous generation. Its external BLiMP labels support direct sentence-likelihood comparisons without the rejected R105 NLI judge. Qualification (200 pairs) precedes any frozen-recipient/interface comparison (400 separate pairs). All target tokens are supplied; a positive result cannot qualify free generation or pass the English-core product gates. No training, new model, route sweep or native LayerCake change. Publication remains authorized.

Completed at the control stop: 178/200 versus 190/200; irregular participles 37/50 versus 45/50. Fresh-process raw replay is exact. No recipients or training ran. The result packet preserves all scores, source identities and a disclosed upstream label anomaly. No free-generation qualification or product claim follows; no nearby sweep is authorized. The immutable research tag and reconstruction receipt are public: 581 evidence assets, 182 host bindings, four LFS paths and ten source files match; 52 focused checks and tagged CI pass. Reused public checkouts/cache and same-machine limits are explicit. The scientific result and tag are unchanged.

Previous completed bounded prerequisite: R105

R105 tests one frozen conventional NLI evaluator against externally labeled negation-scope data and prospective approval-scope obligations. No new regex patch, English teacher retry, training or native LayerCake change. Freeze before scoring; publish both successes and failures. This is evaluator suitability, not an ABI breakthrough or English-core certificate. The recipient matrix stays closed pending genuine qualification.

Completed: the evaluator scored 779/1,200 external cases and 62/64 approval cases, failing both gates. Fresh-process logits/tokens/predictions replay byte-identically. The full-study verifier closes the preserved missing-replay audit gap without changing frozen results. R105 packet. No training, English-control qualification, recipient comparison or LayerCake failure follows. The immutable R105 research tag and public reconstruction receipt are published: 40 evidence assets, eight upstream evaluator files and 41 focused checks verify. The same-machine public checkout/dependencies were reused; this is not independent hardware or another live inference run. No automatic evaluator sweep follows.

Previous completed bounded diagnostic: R104

The user authorized R104: validate finite evaluator obligations, qualify a raw English control, then run the paired recipient/interface comparison only if qualification passes. All gates are retained or strengthened; no training or native LayerCake changes. Freeze before execution, preserve failures and publish results. The weight-space research assessment keeps direct weight editing as a possible future competitor, not a new experimental arm or evidence of ABI superiority. Broad English and the moonshot remain open.

R104 completed: 155 finite evaluator cases passed, but the raw control scored 29/48 and failed four task floors. The old scorer gives 44/48 on the same outputs, but clarification still fails 4/6. Two new scope limitations are disclosed, not repaired in place; even removing every approval flag permits at most 30/48 on the registered screen. No recipient comparison or training ran. Evaluator validity and control qualification remain unresolved; see the result. No automatic substitute model, prompt sweep, training or host change follows. The immutable R104 research release and review assets are public. Same-machine public reconstruction matches 566 assets and 729 bindings and passes 43 focused checks; the tagged source's GitHub CI passes. No scientific gate is promoted.

Latest completed bounded diagnostic: R103

The user authorized R103 and publication. Test the measured raw-prompt versus Task/Response interface difference on unchanged recipient checkpoints, against a separately qualified native-chat control. Freeze before new model calls; zero training. Qualification failure stops the comparison, and no outcome alone certifies English or proves a native LayerCake defect. R103 has now stopped as registered: the native-chat control passed 41/48, with email/format/tone at 4/6 each. No recipient evaluation or training ran. Preserve the literal scorer's observed temporal false-positive without rescoring the gate. The next proposal must validate evaluation boundaries and qualify a control before attributing recipient failure. See the current packet.

Latest completed study: R102

The R102 protocol separates entity-coverage augmentation from optimization exposure using matched LoRA and adapter-distillation trajectories, fixed 384/1,536-update endpoints, and 96 prospective supplied-content prompts. This is a conventional acquisition diagnostic, not an ABI invention or broad-English certificate. Preserve all R98-R101 evidence and keep LayerCake source unchanged. The user explicitly authorized publication. The sealed R102 tag, checkpoint payloads and manifest are now public. Fresh public-only reconstruction matched 782 assets and 833 bindings, recomputed the negative decision and passed 42 focused tests without changing the scientific tag. Independent hardware and English qualification remain open.

The first corpus freeze failed before GPU work after 317 aliases. Preserve results/coverage_exposure_r102_preflight_v1/. The prospective A1 preflight repair selects token-compatible components from the same bounded proposal pool; it does not relax matching or scientific gates. A new successful freeze is required before any model execution. This construction result is not an acquisition pass. The successful 833-input freeze is committed at 935a41d; all 768 aliases passed exact length and inverse-identity checks. Source qualification passed 282/288 normalized versus 272/288 raw, without collapse/truncation. All four fixed training trajectories completed; the ten-endpoint evaluation matrix and strict recomputation are complete. Both repeat-policy 384-step checkpoints match the original R99 bytes. Repeat-data LoRA scored 51 -> 46/96 and adapters 32 -> 39/96 with more updates; renamed-data controls scored 14 -> 34 and 10 -> 24. Neither registered factor met its joint support criterion; no checkpoint passed quality. Preserve every failure and do not extend this alias/step-count sweep. The next proposal must test recipient/interface suitability and content grounding against a qualified English positive control. No native LayerCake defect or product promotion is established. The public R102 packet records publication and review scope.

Latest completed diagnostic: R101

The user authorized the next diagnostic and publication. Follow R101: fixed checkpoints, zero training/teacher calls, raw-logit execution-path comparisons and paired oracle-prefix continuation. Keep assisted diagnostics separate from autonomous quality and ABI integration separate from native LayerCake defects. Preserve all negative evidence. Broad English and the full moonshot remain unproven.

R101 is complete and strictly verified. All four checkpoints passed measured full/padded/cached comparisons; 288 unassisted token sequences replayed exactly. The primary 50%-prefix remaining-fact contrast was null (24/34 versus 24/34, 95% interval -0.14706 to +0.14706). Assisted joined-response gains are not autonomous quality. The full-model reference-token fit was 91.44% training and 78.91% development. Preserve raw tensors and all 864 generation rows; the next proposal should separate data coverage/generalization from optimization fit. No native LayerCake defect, fluent core or new product certificate is established.

Latest completed control: R100 negative; R99-FP32 remains closed

The continuation starts with the preregistered fit/grounding diagnostic: 24 balanced training examples and all 48 existing development examples, all three final learners and unchanged parent. No new optimization or teacher queries. Separate teacher-forced token prediction from autonomous generation before selecting the next representation. This is not a new quality test or permission to resume the failed JSON-plan mechanism.

R99-D1 completed: training-example free-generation passes were 7/24 ABI plan, 12/24 distillation, 13/24 LoRA and 0/24 parent. Teacher-forced response accuracy was only 76-80% in the restricted learners despite 97-99% fact-token accuracy. R100 tests one full-model optimizer-scope control under the same parent, training examples, seed and update count, with fresh development prompts and the retained controls. It is conventional fine-tuning for diagnosis, not a renamed ABI breakthrough.

R100 completed: full-model control 20/48, retained LoRA 20/48, adapter distillation 14/48, ABI plan 6/48, parent 0/48. The full control's training fit was 17/24; useful-quality, training-fit and scope-sensitivity screens all failed. The source gate passed 232/240 and all 384 optimization steps were finite. Preserve the checkpoint and every negative row. Do not repeat full-unfreezing or JSON-plan variants. Data coverage, parent suitability, optimization adequacy and autonomous-realization drift remain unresolved; any next study must discriminate them prospectively, not assert a cause from this control.

The user authorized continued bounded research and versioned publication. R98 stopped at its source gate: 206/240 mechanical passes, 31 truncated outputs, and zero student training. The additive C1 protocol also failed: 226/240, with 22/30 emails, despite exact completion prefixes and zero truncation. Seven emails exceeded the word limit. Both failures remain unchanged. R99 introduces only source-sentence selection for email normalization, with a fresh prospective development population. Only a qualified normalized corpus opens the learner comparison: learned supplied- proposition planning followed by autonomous English generation, compared with matched direct sequence distillation, conventional LoRA, and an unchanged LayerCake parent. All inherited weights and information are accounted for. Source qualification precedes training. Mechanical language proxies cannot certify fluency; broad English, human quality, CPU gates and production host acceptance remain open. Preserve failed prerequisites and attribute them to the measured source/acquisition/integration boundary. No LayerCake source changes or larger follow-on campaigns are authorized by this pilot. R98/C1's development set is known; R99's fresh population is frozen before capture. Neither supports unrestricted-English certification from lexical screens.

R99's normalized data qualified at 230/240, including 30/30 emails. Its first FP16 learner stopped after one successful update. A six-step numerical audit isolated loss-scale overflow without any quality evaluation. The FP32 restart repeats all three arms from the unchanged parent, with the identical data, seed, sample order, hyperparameters and gates, within the original R99 wall deadline. No failed checkpoint is resumed and no other precision/optimizer sweep follows.

The restart completed all three arms: ABI plan 10/48, distillation 20/48, LoRA 27/48, unchanged parent 0/48; the candidate gate was 44/48. The plan arm also had five collapse cases and 22 invalid plans. Close this serial-JSON-plan branch. The measured next target is supplied-fact retention and autonomous realization, not more nearby steps or a larger run of the same mechanism. Any successor needs a new bounded preregistration, fresh evaluation and matched controls. No current candidate is a production English core.

New readers should use docs/PROJECT_STATUS.md for the concise dashboard and docs/README.md for navigation. This file retains the detailed campaign mission and constraints.

Status

R7_BOUNDED_TECHNICAL_VALIDATION_PASSED_EXTERNAL_REVIEW_OPEN

V1089_LOCAL_COMPILER_PHASES_0_TO_7_MACHINE_COMPLETE_PHASE8_EXTERNAL_BLOCKED

INDEPENDENT_AUDIT_FULL_MOONSHOT_NOT_PROVEN_PUBLIC_CLONE_REPAIR_PENDING_REVIEW

PEER_REVIEW_CANDIDATE_BINDING_REPAIR_READY_HUMAN_RATINGS_ZERO_OF_21000

ABI R7 has passed local strict validation, pre-public hostile validation, durable public publication, clean public-manifest reconstruction, post-public hostile replay, and a fresh blind Codex red-team. The public release is:

https://github.com/Yoder23/abi/releases/tag/abi-final-validation-v2-repaired-r7-2026-08-30

This opens human and independent-hardware review. It does not complete them.

Phase 0 and Phase 1 of V1089 are complete within their registered bounded contracts. That does not make later conditional or external phases complete.

The 2026-09-14 independent audit is now first-class repository evidence. Its whole-moonshot rejection is accepted. The review repair preserves the audit, restores exact historical certificate/catalog paths needed by Phase 6-8, widens the default supported test surface, and stages the retained R97/V1089 payloads for Git-LFS publication. It does not hide the unrecoverable Phase 5 baseline tensors, manufacture human/hardware evidence, or merge the distinct R7, V1089, and R97 lineages.

The first repair was insufficient. A sterile clone at bf674f8 returned REPOSITORY_NOT_REPRODUCIBLE because dozens of required protocols and raw evidence files remained ignored and because Phase 8 had only unit-fixture tests. The current additive repair publishes the exact retained bytes and tests the real 52-file manifest. A new independent clone must accept this handoff before repository reproducibility is promoted.

The later V1089 compiler campaign is also part of the current local evidence lineage. Its Phase 4 B40 host passes the complete 4,200-row, three-seed machine quality contract; Phases 5 and 6 certify bounded three-domain exclusion and composition; Phase 7 certifies the same integrated English-plus-three-domain product on the registered CPU and CUDA device; and Phase 8 reconstructs it from detached clean source trees on the same machine. Phase 2 remains at 0/21,000 human preferences and Phase 8 still lacks an independent operator and different hardware, so neither the campaign nor the release is unconditional.

Additive R8 status: R8_LEVEL_0_PUBLIC_PREREQUISITE_FAILED_HELDOUT_UNREVEALED

R8 tested whether one source-acquired synthetic capability could become an immutable package that creates native behavior in frozen heterogeneous neural recipients. The source-side adapter and zero-parameter extractor recovered the public transition state exactly, but the recipient realization failed its first public host gate. Across 1,024 paired Pythia rows, AFTER−BASE was +0.001953 (95% bootstrap CI -0.019531 to +0.024414). The held-out secret was not revealed and Qwen/T5 were not run. This is Level 0 and leaves R7 unchanged. The public verifier hostile audit produced 8/8 expected outcomes, including rejection of missing/stale evidence and immunity to a forged pass boolean.

Additive R9 status: R9_GATE_A_CAPABILITY_SPECIFIC_RECIPIENT_STATE_BRANCH_FAILED

R9 tested whether the R8 package could be realized by a deliberately capability-specific Pythia backend before spending compute on a universal decoder. V1 failed to fit. The preregistered v2 repair used embedding plus final recipient states, 1,039,880 backend parameters, and 10,000 steps. Strict recomputation found 0.128472 training accuracy and 0.125 unseen-depth AFTER accuracy versus 0.073242 BASE; ZERO was also 0.125. Live replay reproduced all 8,480 stored rows, and 5/5 hostile controls were rejected. Gate B remains closed and R7 is unchanged.

Additive R10 status: R10_RUNTIME_COMPONENT_PASSED_OVERALL_SOURCE_GATE_FAILED

R10 connected the synthetic R8 extraction to one clean content-addressed package slot and frozen Pythia, Qwen2, and T5 recipients. AFTER and RESTORED were 1.0 on all 61,440 recipient rows, all negative controls were no higher than 0.15625, removal and interpreter removal exactly matched BASE, no model state changed, and a fresh execution reproduced all 65,536 source-plus- recipient rows byte-for-byte. The source model's native decoder reached only 0.59375 to 0.65234375 against the registered 0.99 source gate. The exact R10 contract therefore failed while its bounded synthetic runtime copy/paste component passed. This is not LayerCake integration, lossless source behavior, native neural transplantation, or English/domain extraction. R7 is unchanged.

Additive R11 status: R11_BOUNDED_SYNTHETIC_NATIVE_NEURAL_ABI_CONSTRUCTION_PASSED

R11 froze four capability-blind host codecs before revealing four held-out synthetic capabilities. The ABI-native teacher learned a compact neural state; the same 2,053-byte package then produced byte-identical teacher-equivalent outputs through frozen Pythia, Qwen2, and T5 native output heads with zero recipient training. Strict recomputation passed all 90,112 observations, removal returned exactly to BASE, 7/7 hostile mutations were rejected, and a fresh execution of the exact frozen package bytes reproduced both raw JSONL files byte-for-byte. A second acquisition was functionally exact but not bitwise package-identical, which remains an explicit open issue. R11 is a synthetic ABI-native construction pass, not conventional LLM teacher extraction, English/domain transfer, or LayerCake product certification. R7 remains the controlling public release.

Additive R12-A public status: R12A_BOUNDED_PUBLIC_FRONTEND_PASSED_STRICT_TEACHER_GATE_FAILED

R12-A trained conventional Qwen2.5-0.5B on one fresh synthetic capability, then used a fixed zero-parameter extractor and the unchanged R11 package/host boundary. The best native Qwen observation was 510/512 exact on 512 unseen, prompt-disjoint compositions; the registered prerequisite required 512/512. Atomic source behavior was 24/24 and the extracted 2,053-byte package executed 512/512 exactly without the teacher. No held-out secret was created or revealed. This proves a bounded public frontend construction, not exact teacher-relative transfer, pre-existing knowledge extraction, English/domain transfer, or LayerCake product certification. R7 remains controlling.

R13-B status: R13B_BOUNDED_ENUMERABLE_CAPABILITY_EXTRACTION_PASSED_LOCAL_PUBLICATION_OPEN

R13-B separately certifies capability canonicalization, not exact teacher-function transplantation. Four committed finite capabilities produced 96/96 exact Qwen atomic answers, four exact 2,053-byte R11 packages, 2,048/2,048 package/oracle rows, and 6,144/6,144 AFTER plus 6,144/6,144 RESTORED recipient rows. Seven fresh-process replay files were byte-exact, and the repaired hostile audit passed 9/9 controls after two failed audit revisions were preserved. Native source/package agreement was only 372/2,048. Track A therefore remains open. Bulk assets remain unpublished and R7 remains the controlling public release.

R14 status: R14_NON_EXHAUSTIVE_CAPABILITY_RECOVERY_FAILED_1_OF_3_PASSED

R14 replaced complete atomic-table probing with 256 mixed, non-atomic source observations against 4,642,668,576 possible evaluation behaviors per capability. One of three fresh Qwen-derived latent programs was recovered exactly and scored 10,000/10,000 unseen plus 1,000/1,000 order-counterfactual rows. Two latent selections were wrong, so the preregistered all-capability gate failed and recipient execution did not run. Three fresh source replays were byte-exact and 7/7 hostile controls passed. This is a bounded partial result, not certification, pre-existing knowledge extraction, or behavioral transplantation. R7 remains controlling.

R15A status: R15A_BOUNDED_FOREIGN_NEURAL_STATE_RECOVERY_PASSED_LOCAL

R15A replaced output-only probing with a generic frontend operating on an anonymous Qwen before/after effective output-weight delta. It recovered all 8/8 fresh held-out capabilities with no behavioral queries or answers inside the extraction capsule. Eight 2,053-byte R11 packages were exact across 88,000 unseen/counterfactual oracle rows and executed at 1.0 AFTER/RESTORED over 135,168 frozen-recipient observations. Strict verification, a fresh live source/extractor/recipient replay, and 9/9 hostile mutations passed. R15A is a bounded local pass for deliberately learned synthetic capabilities, not pretrained English/domain extraction. R7 remains the controlling public release until R15A assets receive durable publication and clean reconstruction. A fresh blind review of the exact R15A evidence commit returned PASS with no critical or high-severity blocker and preserved that claim ceiling.

R15B status: R15B_BOUNDED_PREEXISTING_REPRESENTATION_RECOVERY_BLIND_PASS_LOCAL

R15B used an unchanged pretrained Qwen2-7B-Instruct source with zero training. Across four secret anonymous slot mappings, a physical representation-only decoder recovered 4/4 transitions, emitted unchanged R11 packages, scored 40,000/40,000 deep oracle rows, and executed across Pythia, Qwen2, and T5. Strict recomputation, live replay of 24 source rows and 33,792 recipient rows, and 10/10 hostile mutations passed. The labels were externally registered and the source failed deep Track A behavior. A fresh blind review passed with zero critical/high findings; additive repair now compares regenerated tensors with all four committed bundles exactly and hash-inventories the complete pinned source snapshot. English/domain extraction, autonomous labeling, teacher cloning, and LoRA/distillation superiority remain open. R7 remains the controlling published release.

R16 public status: PUBLIC_FACTUAL_PREREQUISITE_V1_FAILED

The first broader factual/segregation probe used 16 public chemistry and geography facts. Semantic segregation was 48/48, but the unchanged source reached only 15/16 open answers, 43/48 shuffled-choice answers, and 13/16 three-view-consistent facts. The accented Brasília open answer was a normalization miss; the other five misses were a chemistry letter-selection interface failure. Preserve v1 and replace that interface before any held-out R16 certification.

R16 public v2 status: PUBLIC_FACTUAL_PREREQUISITE_PASSED

The materially different answer-free/candidate-sequence interface passed all registered public gates: 48/48 open generations, 48/48 candidate selections, 16/16 cross-view fact extractions, and 48/48 semantic labels. It used every v1 fact and template and did not lower a gate. This authorizes only a new preregistered held-out factual/segregation test; package execution, LayerCake ingestion, English transfer, minimality, and LoRA/distillation superiority remain open.

R16 held-out status: R16_BOUNDED_FACTUAL_ACQUISITION_AND_SEGREGATION_PASSED_LOCAL

The preregistered held-out run selected 16 facts across chemistry and geography. The unchanged source passed 48/48 answer-free generations and 48/48 candidate-sequence selections. Physically isolated compilation emitted 1,222 total package bytes containing 16 structured fact records. Package, source-agreement, and target-only evaluation were 48/48; other-domain and removed conditions abstained 48/48; the rotated-score control was 0/48. A complete live rerun was byte-exact and the expanded verifier rejected 21/21 hostile mutations. The teacher was absent at execution, source training was zero, and the generic package executor required no training. The candidate vocabularies and two-domain ontology were registered, so autonomous discovery, fluent English transfer, LayerCake ingestion, minimality, and LoRA/distillation superiority remain open. Blind review passed v1 with no Critical or High finding. A clean second selection bound to the repaired public protocol before reveal repeated every gate and expanded combined coverage to 27 facts. Final blind review of exact replication commit 26fb029 passed with zero findings. Durable public publication and clean reconstruction remain pending; R7 remains the controlling release.

R17 public status: R17_PUBLIC_V2_SOURCE_INTERFACE_FAILED_EXACT_TEMPLATE_BRANCH_CLOSED

R17 advances from structured facts toward bounded compositional English surface realization. Its v1 implementation was frozen before execution, but the unchanged source reached only 38/72 exact extraction and 28/48 exact evaluation outputs. The single v2 repair improved this to 67/72 and 47/48 but still failed the 120/120 prerequisite. Compiler and LayerCake paths were not invoked. This exact-template branch is closed; a successor must use a materially different functional and teacher-relative language boundary rather than another prompt or exact-string sweep.

R18 status: R18_PUBLIC_PREREQUISITE_PASSED_HELDOUT_REPLICATION_FAILED

The compiler was frozen at de8e54b and reused all R17-v2 teacher evidence. Its 3,881-byte, 24-template package scored 48/48 on lexically disjoint functional realizations, compared with 47/48 for the source and 46/48 for independent per-signature consensus. It regressed on zero source-correct rows; the mood-permutation control was 0/48 and removal abstained 48/48. Strict recomputation, a fresh byte-exact physical replay, and 12/12 hostile mutations passed. Its preregistered hidden replication then scored 46/48 and regressed on two teacher-correct plural present-question rows because cross-number pooling selected singular Does instead of plural Do. The hidden teacher capture, failed package, 0/48 control, 48/48 removal, and strict negative verification are preserved. R18 is not certified. A successor must change the factorization architecture, not rerun this selection or tune another prompt.

R19 status: R19_BOUNDED_REPLICATED_CONTRASTIVE_REALIZATION_PASSED_LOCAL

R19 removes cross-number pooling and learns same-number polarity contrasts without hard-coded English surface tokens. It scored 48/48 on both disclosed development sets, versus teacher scores of 47/48 and 45/48 and modal scores of 46/48 on each; regressions were zero. Both controls were fail-closed at 0/48 and removal was 96/96. Strict recomputation, 12/12 hostile mutations, and a fresh byte-exact physical replay passed. The fresh preregistered lexical replication then scored 48/48, versus 43/48 teacher and 48/48 modal, with zero regressions, 0/48 control, 48/48 removal, 22/22 hostile rejection, and byte- exact fresh physical replay. Its 4,263-byte package contains no source, host, or bridge parameters. This certifies only the registered supplied-slot 24- signature realization family, not general English, LayerCake acceptance, or the ABI moonshot.

R20 status: R20_PUBLIC_SOURCE_COMPILABILITY_FAILED_TEMPLATE_BRANCH_CLOSED

R20 broadened the interface to six raw natural-instruction/supplied-content behaviors over 72 extraction and 120 evaluation prompts. The pinned unchanged teacher produced all rows but reached only 10/72 and 19/120 registered-exact outputs, respectively. Six output programs could not be identified with the locked support, so compilation, packaging, and LayerCake correctly did not run. The result is strictly verified and isolates an ABI representation/source boundary failure. A successor must be materially generative and use semantic and teacher-relative quality, not another exact-template or prompt variant.

R21 status: R21_PUBLIC_PREREQUISITE_PASSED_HIDDEN_REPLICATION_FAILED

R21 trained matched raw-sequence, labeled-monolith, and six-factor generative LayerCake systems from 600 pinned teacher responses across three seeds. The factorized system scored 116/120 publicly on every seed versus 96/120 teacher, 94-99 labeled monolith, and 71-80 raw sequence. A fresh verifier reproduced 1,080 GPU outputs, 54 CPU outputs, and 24/24 removal, restoration, signature, and targeted-corruption controls; strict recomputation passed. The committed fresh hidden split then scored 113/120 on every factor seed versus 107/120 teacher, but summary was 13/20 against the locked 15/20 task gate. The hidden failure is controlling. Teacher self-labeling also remains failed; the passing registered-ontology label control is not autonomous discovery. See docs/R21_LABEL_SEPARATED_GENERATIVE_TRANSFER_RESULT.md.

R22 status: R22_NORMALIZED_SOURCE_FAILED

R22 preserved the 600 R21 raw responses and registered labels and made exactly 600 preregistered GPU calls for explicit task-and-field normalization. The source gate failed at 520/600 functional and 255/600 exact-field outputs, despite 600/600 non-hallucinating and non-collapsed outputs. No student was trained and LayerCake was not invoked. Unconstrained teacher rewriting is closed as a nearby repair; the next bounded test must use a preregistered semantic-equivalence contract and a new hidden split.

R23 status: R23_BOUNDED_SEMANTIC_REPLICATION_PASSED

R23 prospectively froze that semantic contract and a new hidden-row generator, then committed a 256-bit seed before reveal. Without retraining or changing the 24 R21 packages, every factorized seed scored 120/120 versus 96/120 live teacher and both controls. Fresh replay reproduced 1,080 GPU and 54 CPU rows, passed all 24 package lifecycle controls, and rejected 24/24 targeted tensor corruptions. The bounded six-task supplied-content mechanism is now strictly verified; general English and the ABI moonshot remain open.

Additive R97 status: R97_BOUNDED_PROSPECTIVE_REASONING_TRANSFER_PASSED_LOCAL

R95 directly compared the frozen R91 LayerCake bridge with a live pinned teacher and correctly failed at 1,328/1,400. Its seven-digit and family-2 failures motivated one bounded R96 length/structure repair. The frozen 530,050-parameter R96 bridge then faced the separately sealed R97 catalog and scored 1,399/1,400 versus 1,088 for the live teacher, 60 for the unchanged LayerCake parent, and 17 for a seeded random bridge. It retained 1,087/1,088 teacher-correct rows; its paired teacher advantage interval was [0.20071, 0.24429]; all 1,400 rows were physically sparse and collapse-free. Strict raw recomputation passed, 12/12 hostile mutations were rejected, and a second live execution reproduced the evaluation JSONL byte-for-byte. R97 proves bounded prospective teacher-derived two-hop reasoning transfer into LayerCake. It is not broad English, arbitrary-domain extraction, a global minimum, an independent-hardware result, or a general ABI-over-LoRA/distillation claim.

What R7 proves

R7 proves one bounded capability ABI result: four immutable packages execute through one canonical capability-runtime/conformance contract across three declared environments without capability files or success IDs being present during host certification.

The controlling evidence contains:

Check Result
Physical certification environments 3/3
Certification roundtrips 384/384
Reachable inventory rows 301,543
Reachable bytes content-scanned 11,681,888,205
Capability signatures / success IDs in certification 0 / 0
Locked matrix rows 5,043/5,043
Live causality rows / distinct condition PIDs 3,072 / 24
Live isolation rows / target successes 2,100 / 0
Pre-public hostile controls 19/19 rejected
Public reconstruction focused tests 17/17 passed
Blind USTAR/V7 prefix controls 12/12 passed
Blind post-public hostile replay 19/19 rejected

The blind reviewer returned VERDICT: PASS for this exact scope.

What remains open

Gate State
Three-rater human packet OPEN; 0/21,000 judgments
Different-hardware reproduction OPEN; not yet executed
Registered minimum-information certification OPEN; not yet executed
Teacher-to-ABI English extraction RESEARCH; not proven by R7
Capability labeling and segregation from arbitrary teachers RESEARCH
Quality parity/superiority versus teacher, LoRA, or distillation RESEARCH
Globally minimal English substrate RESEARCH
ABI-native neural copy/paste construction BOUNDED PASS; R11
Conventional open-weight teacher to ABI package BOUNDED PUBLIC FRONTEND PASS; exact/held-out gate failed in R12-A
Held-out enumerable capability canonicalization BOUNDED LOCAL PASS; R13-B, publication open
Non-exhaustive synthetic capability recovery FAILED; R14 recovered 1/3 fresh capabilities
Foreign learned-weight-delta capability recovery BOUNDED LOCAL PASS; R15A recovered 8/8 and passed strict/live/hostile verification
Pre-existing representation capability recovery BOUNDED BLIND-REVIEWED LOCAL PASS; R15B recovered 4/4 secret arithmetic mappings with zero source training
Pre-existing bounded factual extraction and segregation BOUNDED REPLICATED LOCAL PASS; two R16 selections, 32/32 selected instances and 27 distinct facts
Pre-existing English/domain knowledge extraction OPEN; R16 is closed-candidate structured memory, not fluent English or arbitrary domains
Bounded teacher-derived grammar realization BOUNDED REPLICATED LOCAL PASS; R19 96/96 disclosed plus 48/48 fresh hidden
General teacher-derived English capability OPEN; R19 is supplied-slot surface realization only
Instruction-conditioned supplied-content realization FAILED R20 source/compiler prerequisite; no package or LayerCake run
Label-separated generative supplied-content transfer PUBLIC PASS, HIDDEN FAIL R21; 113/120 hidden but summary 13/20 below gate
Teacher-side semantic-plan normalization FAIL R22 SOURCE; 520/600 functional, 255/600 exact-field, no student/LayerCake run
Fresh semantic supplied-content replication STRICT PASS R23; factor 120/120 all seeds, teacher 96/120, full fresh replay
Prospective teacher-derived reasoning transfer STRICT PASS R97; 1,399/1,400 candidate, 1,088 teacher, 60 parent, 17 random; 12/12 hostile; byte-identical live replay
Exact foreign-teacher behavioral transplantation OPEN; separate Track A

Current objective

Preserve and externally review R7 without changing its artifacts:

  1. give the frozen human packet to three independent raters;
  2. give the public archive and external reproduction checklist to an independent different-hardware operator;
  3. preserve every returned raw row, command, environment inventory, signature, and failure;
  4. verify the returned packets fail closed; and
  5. only then update the corresponding external gates.

Teacher extraction and minimization belong to additive campaigns. R16 supplies the first bounded held-out factual extraction/segregation pass, and R19 now supplies a replicated bounded surface-realization pass. The immediate additive work is to test a materially broader English representation with free-form, teacher-relative behavior; another nearby lexical, prompt, template, or signature variant is not evidence-supported. LayerCake product ingestion remains a separate acceptance gate.

Any R8/R9/R10 successor must start with a new additive preregistration and a materially different canonical IR or recipient injection architecture. It must fit a public capability-specific control before attempting a capability-blind backend. More static-prefix, package-gated LoRA, recipient-state GRU, nearby width/rank, or step-count sweeps are not evidence-supported.

R16 has now extracted and segregated pre-existing facts, but only through a registered closed-candidate structured-memory package. A successor must materially broaden the capability representation and require teacher-relative free-form behavior. Another nearby prompt, candidate-set, fact-count, or ontology sweep is not evidence-supported. Capability-specific recipient training and claims that a structured lookup package is fluent English do not qualify.

R13-B is the passed local Track B finite-table control. Preserve all 1,676 source/package disagreements and do not treat the pass as resolution of the Track A exact-teacher gate. Publish the hash-addressed bulk evidence before a public-reproducibility claim. The next capability-extraction experiment must be non-exhaustive: its probe budget may not enumerate the complete capability.

R14 executed that non-exhaustive test and failed the reliability gate. Preserve the one exact recovery and both wrong latent selections. Do not rerun nearby query-count, LoRA-rank, learning-rate, step-count, or affine-family variants. The measured bottleneck is the foreign source/frontend representation. A successor must materially change the available information by registering controlled foreign neural-state access (for example weights, activations, residual representations, or training deltas) while keeping the R11 backend fixed. Track A teacher-output equality remains separately open.

R15A remains the learned-delta construction prerequisite and R15B the narrow pre-existing-representation prerequisite. R16 advances the next factual stage for 16 held-out facts and two registered namespaces. Preserve all three. The next stage must test linguistic realization or a non-enumerable specialist capability with contamination-resistant holdouts, free-form teacher-relative quality, and complete imported-information accounting. Track A teacher-output equality and Track B capability quality retain separate verdicts.

Historical failures that remain authoritative

  • R3: public reconstruction succeeded, but blind review rejected incomplete content binding.
  • R5: blind review found first-window archive scanning and ordinary-row commitment defects.
  • R6: blind review found valid tar streams hidden behind arbitrary prefixes and a Windows long-member reconstruction failure.
  • R7: repairs both R6 defects and passes fresh public/blind validation.

Negative evidence is preserved under results/abi_final_validation_v2/ and must not be deleted or overwritten.