Skip to content

PRP-STATUS.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
541 lines (409 loc) · 48.2 KB

PRP-STATUS.md

File metadata and controls

541 lines (409 loc) · 48.2 KB

PRP Implementation Status Dashboard

Last Updated: 2026-05-17 (Phase 0.5 / #48 Three.js Game shipped — PR #95 047) Previous Update: 2026-05-14 (v0.4.x stabilization milestones) Total PRPs: 16 (legacy) + 49 (SpecKit features — 000-brand-identity and 000-landing-page split out from 000-rls) Completed: 15 legacy PRPs (v0.3.0) + 18 SpecKit features Shipped + 5 Mostly Shipped (019 GA moved Shipped → 23 total) In Progress (Partial): 19 features (most of payments tier, blog/sidebar polish, OAuth UX fixes) Not Started: 4 features (013, 016, 028, 044) Backend Only: 3 features (014, 040, 042) Current Phase: v0.4.x stabilization — E2E flake mitigation closed at round 10 on 2026-05-13 (concurrency mutex + WebKit scroll-event fix). See STATUS.md for one-screen view.

Important note: The 2026-04-25 audit was the first full sweep across all 47 features. Don't trust spec.md **Status:** fields anywhere — they were uniformly stale and have been refreshed in the Phase 4 spec-update batch. This 2026-05-14 refresh updates the dashboard header + hotspots table for the round-10 E2E closure and #31 GA4 closure; the per-feature audit data below remains the canonical detail.

v0.4.x updates since 2026-04-25 audit

Six PRs landed 2026-05-12 to 2026-05-14 closing the round-10 E2E flake pattern and improving fork-onboarding:

  • #86 fix(docker): pin pnpm version — Dockerfile pulled pnpm@latest which broke 2026-05-12 when pnpm 11.1.1 shipped a stricter PNPM_HOME/PATH check. Pinned to pnpm@10.16.1 matching package.json packageManager field.
  • #88 docs(auth): #85 replace stale Supabase project ref with placeholder — 32 stale vswxgxbjodpgwfgsjrhq refs across 5 docs files swept to <YOUR-PROJECT-REF> placeholders.
  • #89 fix(ci): serialize E2E runs via repo-wide concurrency mutex — closes 9 rounds of "ongoing" E2E flake mitigation. Root cause was two concurrent CI runs racing against the same Supabase project (each run's cleanupOldMessages beforeAll hooks wiped data the other run was polling for). Fix: .github/workflows/e2e.yml concurrency group e2e-supabase-${{ github.repository }} with cancel-in-progress: false. Bundled WebKit scroll-event fix (4 el.scrollTop = N sites in tests/e2e/messaging/ now also dispatch Event('scroll', {bubbles:true}) since WebKit doesn't auto-fire it for programmatic scrollTop assignments).
  • #90 docs(status): #31 close + round 10 E2E flake mitigation resolution — STATUS.md refreshed with the round-10 closure framing.
  • #91 docs(fork): add service-config checklist + auth verification section — new docs/FORK-CHECKLIST.md (master walkthrough), AUTH-SETUP.md gains a Management API verification section that catches placeholder_* OAuth Client IDs in one line, README gains an Authentication Setup section.
  • #92 chore: gitignore .screenshots/ + capture round 10 lessons in CLAUDE.md — CLAUDE.md now has a "CI & E2E Stability" section codifying the concurrency rule, no-hook-bypass, the WebKit scroll quirk, branch hygiene, and CI API vs UI gotchas.

Issues closed:

  • #31 [Gap-Audit] 019 Google Analytics — closed 2026-05-13, code was already shipped (per-fork GA4 property config is per-fork work not code work).
  • #85 OAuth providers misconfigured — auto-closed 2026-05-13 when PR #88 merged. Note: the in-repo doc cleanup landed but the actual Supabase dashboard repair (placeholder Client ID → real OAuth client IDs) is still outstanding. See the issue closure comment for the recovery breadcrumbs.

Repo hygiene: delete_branch_on_merge=true set, 15 stale remote branches pruned 2026-05-12.

v0.4.0 — Full 47-Feature Audit (2026-04-25)

This section is the canonical source of per-feature status. Generated by a 4-agent parallel audit cross-referencing every features/<cat>/<NNN>/spec.md against actual code in src/, tests in tests/, and the wireframes manifest.

Raw data: scripts/audit/truth-table.json Top-level summary: STATUS.md

All Features by Tier

Tier ID Name Real Status Stated Status (stale) Tracking
1 000-brand-identity Brand Identity Shipped Draft —
1 000-landing-page Landing Page Shipped Draft —
1 000-rls-implementation RLS Implementation Shipped Draft —
1 001-wcag-aa-compliance WCAG AA Compliance Partial Draft gap-audit
1 002-cookie-consent Cookie Consent Shipped Draft —
1 003-user-authentication User Authentication Shipped Draft — (hotspot: ProtectedRoute)
1 004-mobile-first-design Mobile-First Design Mostly Shipped Specified gap-audit
1 005-security-hardening Security Hardening Partial Draft gap-audit
1 006-template-fork-experience Template Fork Experience Mostly Shipped Draft gap-audit
2 007-e2e-testing-framework E2E Testing Framework Shipped Draft — (hotspot: flake mitigation)
2 008-on-the-account Avatar Upload (On The Account) Shipped Specified —
2 009-user-messaging-system User Messaging System Shipped Draft — (hotspot: ConversationView)
2 010-unified-blog-content Unified Blog Content Partial Specified gap-audit
2 011-group-chats Group Chats Mostly Shipped Draft gap-audit (blocked on 043)
2 012-welcome-message-architecture Welcome Message Architecture Partial Draft gap-audit (blocked on 014)
2 043-group-service Group Service Partial Draft gap-audit (8 stub methods)
2 013-oauth-messaging-password OAuth Messaging Password Not Started Draft gap-audit
2 014-admin-welcome-email-gate Admin Welcome Email Gate Backend Only Draft gap-audit
2 015-oauth-display-name OAuth Display Name Partial Draft gap-audit
2 016-messaging-critical-fixes Messaging Critical Fixes Not Started Draft gap-audit
3 017-colorblind-mode Colorblind Mode Shipped Draft —
3 018-font-switcher Font Switcher Shipped Draft —
3 019-google-analytics Google Analytics Mostly Shipped Draft gap-audit (per-fork ID)
3 020-pwa-background-sync PWA Background Sync Partial Draft gap-audit
3 021-geolocation-map Geolocation Map Partial Draft gap-audit
4 022-web3forms-integration Web3Forms Integration Shipped Draft —
4 023-emailjs-integration EmailJS Integration Partial Draft gap-audit
4 024-payment-integration Payment Integration Mostly Shipped Draft #3 #4 #5 (existing eval-backlog)
4 025-blog-social-features Blog Social Features Shipped Specified —
4 026-unified-messaging-sidebar Unified Messaging Sidebar Partial Draft gap-audit
4.5 046-admin-dashboard Admin Dashboard Shipped Implemented —
5 038-payment-dashboard Payment Dashboard Partial Draft #3 PAYMENT-DASHBOARD
5 039-payment-offline-queue Payment Offline Queue Partial Draft #4 PAYMENT-OFFLINE-UI
5 040-payment-retry-ui Payment Retry UI Backend Only Draft gap-audit
5 041-paypal-subscriptions PayPal Subscriptions Partial Specified #5 SUBSCRIPTION-MGMT
5 042-payment-rls-policies Payment RLS Policies Backend Only Draft gap-audit (un-skip 25 tests)
6 027-ux-polish UX Polish Partial Specified gap-audit
6 028-enhanced-geolocation Enhanced Geolocation Not Started Specified gap-audit
6 029-seo-editorial-assistant SEO Editorial Assistant Partial Specified gap-audit (overlaps 033)
6 030-calendar-integration Calendar Integration Mostly Shipped Specified gap-audit (per-fork env)
7 031-standardize-test-users Standardize Test Users Shipped Specified —
7 032-signup-e2e-tests Signup E2E Tests Shipped Specified —
7 033-seo-library-tests SEO Library Tests Partial Specified gap-audit (technical.ts)
7 034-blog-library-tests Blog Library Tests Shipped (was Not Started) Specified — (commit c9f728d 2026-04-20)
7 035-messaging-service-tests Messaging Service Tests Partial Specified gap-audit (4 of 8 services)
7 036-auth-component-tests Auth Component Tests Shipped Specified —
7 037-game-a11y-tests Game A11y Tests Partial Specified gap-audit (visual a11y)
8 044-error-handler-integrations Error Handler Integrations Not Started Specified gap-audit
8 045-disqus-theme Disqus Theme Partial Specified gap-audit

Stability hotspots (post-2026-03-04 remake)

The feat/repo-overhaul-merge (commit 2259a86, "cherry-pick of eval models A+B") on 2026-03-04 introduced patterns that have caused 18+ reverts and a ~5x increase in fix-rate. The same patterns repeat across code that hasn't been reverted yet. See scripts/audit/code-review-findings.json for the full 35 high-confidence findings.

Update 2026-05-13: The "E2E flake mitigation" hotspot (rounds 1-9 in STATUS.md) is resolved at round 10 via the concurrency mutex in PR #89. Rounds 1-9 attacked symptoms (stale closures, retry budgets, stagger delays, Supabase priming); round 10 found the underlying cause (concurrent CI runs racing each other's cleanupOldMessages hooks against one shared Supabase project) and fixed it structurally. The other 9 hotspots in the table below remain open. See STATUS.md hotspot table for the consolidated view.

Hotspot Files affected Severity Status
Stale closures after async auth SignInForm.tsx:119, SignUpForm.tsx:103, AuthContext.tsx:79-88 HIGH Open
createClient() at hook top level useConversationRealtime.ts:42, useTypingIndicator.ts:31 HIGH Open (root cause of ConversationView regression)
Auth-race regression duplicated src/app/admin/layout.tsx:28-30 (mirrors the ProtectedRoute pattern that was fixed) HIGH Open (re-introduced after revert)
Context providers without useMemo AuthContext.tsx:283-296, AccessibilityContext.tsx:218-223 HIGH Open (ConsentContext does this correctly — copy that pattern)
Firefox focus-after-showModal timing PaymentConsentModal.tsx:46-57 HIGH Open (same shape as 3e67772 revert)
Hollow accessibility tests MessageBubble.accessibility.test.tsx, MessageInput.accessibility.test.tsx HIGH Open (placeholders only)
Crypto private key in plaintext localStorage key-service.ts:54-70 HIGH Open (defeats E2E zero-knowledge)
Client-only rate limiter src/lib/auth/rate-limiter.ts (whole file) HIGH Open (security theatre — must move server-side)
JWT prefix logged on every send message-service.ts:151-157 HIGH Open (token leak to DevTools/extensions)

v0.4.0 — Foundation & Core (2026-04-08 audit, partial coverage; superseded by section above)

A direct-verification audit found that ~70% of non-payment feature status fields were stale — many features marked "Draft" or "Ready for SpecKit" are actually fully implemented in production. Below is the corrected state based on reading the code (not the status fields).

✅ Complete — verified in production

Feature Evidence
003 User Authentication 82 files across src/lib/auth/, src/components/auth/, src/contexts/AuthContext.tsx. Email/password + OAuth. tests/e2e/auth/ covers all flows.
007 E2E Testing Framework 60 *.spec.ts files, 6 Playwright projects, 24-shard CI matrix. Run 24113858375 (2026-04-08) achieved 24/24 green across chromium/firefox/webkit.
008 Avatar Upload 10 avatar component files, crop interface, persistence, tests/e2e/avatar/upload.spec.ts.
009 User Messaging 23 files in src/lib/messaging/ + src/services/messaging/. E2E-encrypted (JWK+noble-curves). 12 E2E spec files cross-browser validated.
011 Group Chats group-key-service, group-service, CreateGroupModal, tests/e2e/messaging/group-chat-multiuser.spec.ts.
018 Font Switcher src/components/molecular/FontSwitcher/ full 5-file pattern.
022 Web3Forms useWeb3Forms.ts hook + ContactForm + form-submission.spec.ts E2E.
025 Blog Social SocialShareButtons component, author bio rendering, OpenGraph + Twitter card metadata in blog routes.
031 Test Users scripts/seed-test-users.ts, tests/e2e/utils/test-user-factory.ts, standardized env var naming.
032 Signup E2E Dedicated Playwright project, full sign-up flow coverage.
046 Admin Dashboard 4 admin domains (audit, messaging, payments, users). JWT claim-based RLS enforcement.

🛠️ Mostly Implemented — minor gaps or per-fork config

Feature What's done / what's missing
006 Template Fork scripts/rebrand.sh (615 lines) + docs/FORKING.md in production. Payment missing-config UX landed 2026-04-08 (PaymentButton feature-flag gate + /payment-demo top-of-page banner). Gap: Supabase missing-config first-run banner (same pattern, not yet applied to Supabase).
019 Google Analytics 4 src/lib/analytics/GoogleAnalytics/ full 5-file pattern, consent-gated. Awaits per-fork NEXT_PUBLIC_GA_MEASUREMENT_ID.
030 Calendar Integration CalendarEmbed + CalendarConsent + providers dir + /schedule route. Awaits per-fork NEXT_PUBLIC_CALENDAR_PROVIDER/NEXT_PUBLIC_CALENDAR_URL.
033 SEO Library Tests 3 of 4 modules tested (keywords, content, readability). Gap: src/lib/seo/technical.ts untested.

❌ Not Started — real gaps

Feature Reality
034 Blog Library Tests src/lib/blog/ has 4 production modules (markdown-processor, seo-analyzer, toc-generator, blog-data.json) with zero unit test files. Real gap — blog library has no direct test coverage despite being used across production /blog routes.

🗂️ Known tracking issues (out of scope for this audit, noted for later)

  • 043 Group Service — moved from features/payments/ to features/core-features/ on 2026-04-08. Depends on 009 messaging system. Has 8 unimplemented methods in src/services/messaging/group-service.ts (addMembers, getMembers, removeMember, leaveGroup, transferOwnership, upgradeToGroup, renameGroup, deleteGroup) — messaging UI exists but these methods are the backing work.
  • Other features not in the tables above had their status fields reviewed and were either already accurate (rare) or could not be verified with direct file reads in limited time. A future audit pass should cover 001, 002, 004, 005, 010, 012–017, 020, 021, 023, 026–029, 035–037, 044, 045.
  • An initial audit via an Explore agent was unreliable — it reported ~40% false-positive "Not Started" claims for features that actually have substantial code (006, 019, 025, 030 among others). The entries in the tables above were verified directly, not via the agent.

v0.4.0 — Payments (Active Tracking)

Reality check (2026-04-08): Payments are far more built than initial status labels implied. Most of the code exists — what's missing is activating API keys, writing 4 route files, and filling targeted UI gaps. An earlier version of this section labeled 038-042 "Not Started" — that was wrong; the foundations are there. This update corrects the picture.

What exists:

  • Client libraries (src/lib/payments/, 1124 lines): payment-service.ts, stripe.ts, paypal.ts, offline-queue.ts, metadata-validator.ts, connection-listener.ts
  • Supabase Edge Functions (742 lines Deno): stripe-webhook, paypal-webhook, send-payment-email
  • Database schema: 5 tables (payment_intents, payment_results, subscriptions, payment_provider_config, webhook_events) with 20+ RLS policies
  • React components: PaymentButton, PaymentConsentModal, PaymentStatusDisplay, PaymentHistory, PaymentTrendChart, AdminPaymentPanel — all with 5-file test coverage
  • Working routes: /payment-demo (has passing Stripe + GDPR E2E tests), /admin/payments
  • Type definitions + config: src/types/payment.ts, src/config/payment.ts
  • Env var contract: All 6 keys listed in .env.example. .env has only empty commented template lines — no actual values yet

What's actually missing (the real backlog):

  1. Obtain API keys — create Stripe account + PayPal developer sandbox, set up webhook endpoints, populate 6 values: Stripe publishable + secret + webhook secret, PayPal client ID + secret + webhook ID. Public keys go in .env as NEXT_PUBLIC_*; server secrets go in Supabase Vault (accessed by Edge Functions via Deno.env.get). Budget 30-60 min of external account setup. Full walkthrough: docs/PAYMENT-DEPLOYMENT.md. Forker-facing overview: README.md "Payment Integration Setup".
  2. 3 route files — wire existing components into new page.tsx files:
    • /payment-dashboard (038) — compose PaymentHistory + PaymentTrendChart + live-update subscription
    • /payment-subscriptions (038/040/041) — new component, list active subs, cancel/upgrade
    • /payment-history (039) — wrapper around PaymentHistory component
    • (/payment-result (040) shipped 2026-04-16 in commit ffb33a1 — UX gaps remain, see 040 row)
  3. Targeted UI affordances — some components don't exist yet:
    • Offline queue status indicator / sync pill / count badge / retry button / clear-queue (039)
    • Grace period banner, duplicate-subscription prevention (041)
    • Rate-limit UI for payment endpoints (042)
  4. Verify RLS policies — policies are written; 25 E2E stubs in 08-security-rls.spec.ts need to be un-skipped and run to prove each policy enforces what it claims (042)

The 47 skipped E2E tests are still the acceptance criteria — un-skip them as each gap closes. But "un-skip a test" sometimes means "just flip the skip flag" (if the code already works) and sometimes means "build the missing page/component first".

Feature Real Status Active Tests Stubs Remaining Notes
024 Payment Integration Mostly Implemented — awaiting API keys 3 Stripe + 9 GDPR + 2 PayPal + 2 retry = 16 live 1 + 12 + 14 + 2 = 29 across 4 files Libs + Edge Functions + DB + components all exist; Stripe + PayPal keys NOT yet obtained (.env has empty commented templates). Needs account setup (~30-60 min) before any live payment flow works. Child features 038–042 hold the remaining work.
038 Payment Dashboard Components Built, Route Missing 2 20 PaymentHistory, PaymentTrendChart, AdminPaymentPanel all exist; /payment/dashboard page.tsx does not; also needs real-time subscription wiring.
039 Payment Offline Queue Logic Built, UI Affordances Missing 2 18 offline-queue.ts + payment-adapter.ts + connection-listener.ts work; missing: status indicator, sync pill, count, retry, overflow alert, /payment/history
040 Payment Retry UI Partial — route shipped, UX gaps remain 4 12 payment-service.ts retry logic + /payment-result route (commit ffb33a1, 2026-04-16) shipped; missing: idempotency-key reuse on retry, retry counter + cooling period, error-type categorization, offline error banner, audit log on retry, update-method flow, recovery wizard
041 PayPal Subscriptions Backend Ready, UX Missing 2 12 paypal.ts lib + paypal-webhook Edge Function + subscriptions table exist; missing: /payment/subscriptions page, grace period, duplicate prevention
042 Payment RLS Policies Policies Written, Unverified 2 25 20+ policies exist in monolithic migration; work is "un-skip tests, run them, fix any policies that fail" rather than "write from scratch". Also: rate-limit UI
043 Group Service N/A — — Moved to features/core-features/ on 2026-04-08 — it's a messaging feature, not a payment feature
07 Payment Performance (no feature file) 2 14 07-performance.spec.ts — needs a feature file or merge into 038

Recommended next actions (rough ordering):

  1. Unblock 024: obtain Stripe + PayPal keys (create test-mode Stripe account + PayPal developer sandbox app, configure webhook endpoints), populate .env (public NEXT_PUBLIC_* vars) and Supabase Vault (server secrets), verify /payment-demo works end-to-end against sandbox APIs. (~1-2 hours including account setup)
  2. 042 verification: un-skip the 25 RLS tests one at a time, fix policies where assertions disagree. No new code, just verification + policy tweaks. (half-day)
  3. 038 + 039 routes: create /payment-dashboard, /payment-history, /payment-subscriptions page.tsx files wiring existing components (kebab-case, matching /payment-demo and /payment-result). Some stubs will go green immediately. (1 day)
  4. 039 UI affordances: build missing queue-status / retry / clear-queue components. (1 day)
  5. 040 + 041 UX: result page polish, grace period handling, duplicate subscription prevention. (1 day)

Each step should land its corresponding E2E tests un-skipped and green on the next CI run — that's how we measure "done" honestly.

Tracking source of truth: when work progresses, update (1) the **Status**: line in the feature file, (2) the row in this table, (3) un-skip the corresponding E2E tests and make them pass.

Quick Status Overview

v0.3.0 Status (Complete) ✨

Phase 1: Foundation     [✅✅✅] 3/3 Complete ✨
Phase 2: Compliance     [✅✅✅] 3/3 Complete ✨
Phase 3: Privacy        [✅✅]   2/2 Complete ✨
Phase 4: Forms          [✅✅✅] 3/3 Complete ✨
Phase 5: Features       [✅✅✅] 3/3 Complete ✨
Phase 6: Authentication [✅]     1/1 Complete ✨
Sprint 3.5: Tech Debt   [✅✅✅] Complete ✨

Sprint 3.5 Accomplishments (2025-09-18 to 2025-09-19)

  • ✅ All 46 Sprint 3.5 tasks completed
  • ✅ Next.js 15.5 verified working without workarounds
  • ✅ Husky pre-commit Docker detection fixed
  • ✅ lint-staged git stash issues resolved
  • ✅ Font loading optimized for CLS reduction
  • ✅ Technical debt documentation updated
  • ✅ 13 TODOs documented and categorized
  • ✅ 793 tests passing, build stable

Post-Sprint 3.5 Cleanup (2025-09-30)

  • ✅ Fixed Next.js 15 async params warnings in blog pages
  • ✅ Updated TECHNICAL-DEBT.md (2 issues resolved)
  • ✅ Verified nodemon config already corrected
  • ✅ Only 1 low-priority issue remaining (Disqus themes)

PRP-001 Accomplishments (2025-09-30)

  • ✅ Created comprehensive PRP Methodology documentation
  • ✅ Generated SPECKIT-PRP-GUIDE.md quick reference (350 lines)
  • ✅ Updated PRP-WORKFLOW.md with SpecKit Integration section (320 lines)
  • ✅ Updated CLAUDE.md and README.md with PRP/SpecKit links
  • ✅ Demonstrated workflow by using it (dogfooding per NFR-005)
  • ✅ All 14 implementation tasks completed (T001-T014)
  • ✅ Success metrics validated: PRP-012 implementable using docs

🎉 Sprint 3.5 Technical Debt Complete (2025-09-19)

Major Accomplishments

  • ✅ 46/46 tasks completed in 2 days
  • ✅ 6 critical issues resolved (Next.js, Husky, lint-staged, fonts, etc.)
  • ✅ Zero workarounds needed - clean build process
  • ✅ 100% Storybook coverage - all stories working
  • ✅ 793 tests passing - stable test suite
  • ✅ Technical debt documented - 13 TODOs categorized

Sprint 3.5 Timeline

  • Started: 2025-09-18
  • Completed: 2025-09-19
  • Duration: 2 days
  • Result: All technical debt eliminated, ready for v0.4.0

Detailed Implementation Status

Phase 1: Foundation Infrastructure

# PRP Priority Status Branch Started Completed Notes
1 PRP Methodology P3 ✅ Completed 001-prp-methodology 2025-09-30 2025-09-30 PRP/SpecKit workflow documentation, dogfooded via workflow
2 Component Structure P0 ✅ Completed 002-component-structure 2025-09-13 2025-09-13 5-file pattern standardization
3 E2E Testing Framework P0 ✅ Completed 003-e2e-testing-framework 2025-09-14 2025-09-14 Playwright setup, local-only

Phase 2: Compliance & Accessibility

# PRP Priority Status Branch Started Completed Notes
4 WCAG AA Compliance P0 ✅ Completed 004-wcag-aa-compliance 2025-09-14 2025-09-14 Pa11y, axe-core integration
5 Colorblind Mode P0 ✅ Completed 005-colorblind-mode 2025-09-14 2025-09-14 Daltonization correction
6 Font Switcher P1 ✅ Completed 006-font-switcher 2025-09-14 2025-09-15 6 fonts including accessibility options

Phase 3: Privacy & Analytics

# PRP Priority Status Branch Started Completed Notes
7 Cookie Consent & GDPR P0 ✅ Completed 007-cookie-consent 2025-09-15 2025-09-15 Privacy compliance
8 Google Analytics P1 ✅ Completed 008-google-analytics 2025-09-15 2025-09-15 GA4 with consent

Phase 4: Forms & Communication

# PRP Priority Status Branch Started Completed Notes
9 Web3Forms Integration P0 ✅ Completed 009-web3forms-integration 2025-09-16 2025-09-16 Contact form with validation, 620 tests
10 EmailJS Integration P1 ✅ Completed 010-emailjs-integration 2025-01-17 2025-01-17 Fallback email service with failover
11 PWA Background Sync P0 ✅ Completed 011-pwa-background-sync 2025-09-16 2025-09-17 Offline queue, 646 tests passing

Phase 5: Additional Features

# PRP Priority Status Branch Started Completed Notes
12 Visual Regression Testing P2 📥 Inbox 012-visual-regression - - Deferred until UI stable
13 Calendar Integration P0 ✅ Completed 013-calendar-integration 2025-09-17 2025-09-17 Calendly/Cal.com support with consent
14 Geolocation Map P1 ✅ Completed 014-geolocation 2025-09-18 2025-09-18 Leaflet maps, desktop accuracy limited
15 Payment Integration P0 ✅ Completed 015-payment-integration 2025-10-03 2025-10-03 Supabase backend, Stripe/PayPal providers, offline queue, GDPR consent

Phase 6: Authentication & User Management

# PRP Priority Status Branch Started Completed Notes
16 User Authentication P0 ✅ Completed 016-user-authentication 2025-10-05 2025-10-05 Supabase Auth, OAuth (GitHub/Google), RLS policies, mobile-first UI

Status Legend

  • 📥 Inbox: Not started, awaiting dependencies
  • 🚀 Ready: Dependencies met, can begin
  • 🔄 In Progress: Active development
  • 🔍 In Review: PR submitted, awaiting review
  • ✅ Completed: Merged to main
  • ⏸️ Blocked: Issue encountered, see notes
  • 🔙 Rolled Back: Reverted due to issues

Dependency Graph

graph TD
    PRP1[1. PRP Methodology] --> PRP2[2. Component Structure]
    PRP2 --> PRP3[3. E2E Testing]
    PRP3 --> PRP4[4. WCAG Compliance]
    PRP4 --> PRP5[5. Colorblind Mode]
    PRP5 --> PRP6[6. Font Switcher]

    PRP2 --> PRP7[7. Cookie Consent]
    PRP7 --> PRP8[8. Google Analytics]

    PRP2 --> PRP9[9. Web3Forms]
    PRP9 --> PRP10[10. EmailJS]
    PRP9 --> PRP11[11. PWA Sync]
    PRP10 --> PRP11

    PRP3 --> PRP12[12. Visual Regression]
    PRP2 --> PRP13[13. Calendar]
    PRP2 --> PRP14[14. Geolocation]
    PRP7 --> PRP14

    style PRP1 fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style PRP2 fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style PRP3 fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading

Implementation Metrics

Velocity

  • Average PRP Completion Time: <1 day
  • Current Sprint: Sprint 3.5 Technical Debt - COMPLETE!
  • Sprint Completion: Sprint 3.5 completed 2025-09-19
  • Previous Sprint: PRP-014 (Geolocation) completed 2025-09-18

Quality Metrics

  • Tests Written: 793+ total (750+ unit, 40+ E2E)
  • Test Coverage: 58% overall (maintained during tech debt sprint)
  • Component Coverage: 98% (Web3Forms), 97% (PWA Sync), 100% (EmailJS)
  • Accessibility Score: 96/100 (4 minor issues in ContactForm)
  • Lighthouse Score: 92/100 (Performance)
  • Bundle Size: 102KB First Load JS (optimized)
  • Technical Debt: 13 TODOs documented (6 tests, 3 features, 4 templates)

Lessons Learned

Successful Patterns

PRPs (Features):

  • Component Structure (PRP-002): 5-file pattern enforced via CI/CD ensures consistency
  • E2E Testing (PRP-003): Page Object Model provides maintainable test architecture
  • Docker-first development: Consistent environment across all developers
  • Cookie Consent (PRP-007): Context-based consent management with localStorage persistence
  • Google Analytics (PRP-008): Privacy-first GA4 integration with consent mode, debug utilities
  • Web3Forms (PRP-009): Contact form with Zod validation, honeypot spam protection, TDD approach (98% coverage)
  • PWA Background Sync (PRP-011): IndexedDB queue, service worker sync, comprehensive offline support
  • EmailJS Integration (PRP-010): Provider pattern with automatic failover, retry logic, rate limiting, 100% test coverage
  • Calendar Integration (PRP-013): GDPR-compliant consent for third-party scheduling services
  • Geolocation Map (PRP-014): Leaflet.js with dynamic imports, OpenStreetMap tiles, GDPR consent modal

Sprint 3.5 (Technical Debt):

  • Build System: Next.js 15.5 works without Pages Router dummy files
  • Docker Integration: Husky pre-commit hooks detect and handle Docker environment
  • lint-staged: Fixed git stash issues with --no-stash flag
  • Performance: Font loading optimized with display:swap and preconnect
  • Documentation: Technical debt accurately tracked with TODO categorization

Challenges & Solutions

  • CI/CD pnpm versions: Standardized to exact version 10.16.1 across all workflows
  • E2E in CI: Tests require dev server, made local-only with clear documentation
  • Missing dependencies: Added to Dockerfile for consistency (Playwright deps)
  • PRP-009 Deferred Tasks: Offline support (T010-T011) moved to PRP-011, enhanced security features (T012-T016) marked as optional future enhancements
  • PRP-011 Test Issues: 4 integration tests fail due to React Hook Form async validation timing (production works correctly)
  • PRP-014 Desktop Accuracy: IP-based geolocation limited to city-level accuracy, documented as PRP-015 for v0.4.0

Process Improvements

  • PRP workflow: Clear /plan and /tasks commands streamline implementation
  • Parallel task execution: Identified independent tasks for faster completion
  • TDD approach: RED-GREEN-REFACTOR cycle ensures quality

Next Actions

Post-Sprint 3.5 Options (Choose One)

  1. PRP-001 (PRP Methodology Documentation) ⭐ RECOMMENDED

    • Document the successful PRP process while it's fresh
    • Create reusable framework for future development
    • Low effort, high value

  2. Component Test Coverage Expansion

    • Address 6 TODO comments in game components
    • Add comprehensive tests for CaptainShipCrew features
    • Improves code reliability

  3. Notification System Implementation

    • Replace console logs with toast notifications
    • Better UX for errors and success messages
    • Professional user feedback

  4. Production Error Tracking

    • Integrate Sentry or LogRocket
    • Essential for production monitoring
    • TODO in error-handler.ts

Sprint 4 Planning (v0.4.0)

Advanced Features:

  1. State Management (Zustand/Jotai)
  2. Animation System (Framer Motion)
  3. UI Components (Command Palette, DataTable, Modal)
  4. OKLCH Color System Scripts
  5. Developer Tools CLI

Deferred PRPs:

  • PRP-012: Visual Regression Testing (wait for stable UI)
  • PRP-015: Enhanced Geolocation Accuracy (hybrid approach)

Blocked Items

  • None currently

Resource Links

Notes

Risk Factors

  • High Risk: None identified
  • Medium Risk: GA4 integration depends on cookie consent
  • Low Risk: Calendar and geolocation are independent

Dependencies on External Services

  • Web3Forms: Requires API key
  • EmailJS: Requires account setup
  • Google Analytics: Requires GA4 property
  • Calendly/Cal.com: Requires account
  • Chromatic/Percy: Requires account for visual regression

Technical Debt Tracking

PRP-011: PWA Background Sync

  • Issue: 4 integration tests fail due to React Hook Form async validation timing
  • Impact: Test environment only, no production impact
  • Tests Affected: offline-integration.test.tsx (4 tests)
  • Root Cause: Complex mocking of hooks with form validation lifecycle
  • Recommendation: Split into focused unit tests + E2E tests
  • Priority: Low (production works correctly)

Deferred Features from Completed PRPs

PRP-009: Web3Forms Integration

The following tasks were deferred for future implementation as separate mini-PRPs:

Offline Support (T010-T011)

  • T010: Implement offline submission queue
  • T011: Update Service Worker for background sync
  • Priority: P1 Important
  • Rationale: Core functionality working, offline can be added later

Enhanced Security (T012-T016)

  • T013: Implement client-side rate limiting
  • T014: Add spam protection (honeypot field)
  • T016: Implement form analytics tracking
  • Priority: P1 Important
  • Rationale: Basic protection in place, can enhance later

User Experience (T017-T020)

  • T017: Add form draft auto-save feature
  • T020: File attachment support
  • Priority: P2 Nice to have
  • Rationale: Core form working, these are enhancements

Known Issues

  • 4 minor accessibility test failures in ContactForm component
  • Missing navigation link to /contact page in header menu
  • See /specs/009-web3forms-integration/COMPLETION_REPORT.md for full details

Dashboard Usage: Update this dashboard after each PRP milestone:

  1. Branch creation
  2. Implementation start
  3. PR submission
  4. Merge to main
  5. Any blocking issues