Skip to content

Consider optional cosmology-based distances for higher-redshift galaxies #354

Description

@ceibensteiner

Currently, galaxy distances used in distance_key.txt and related products such as moment_key.txt are treated as fixed/adopted distances. This is appropriate for nearby galaxies. However, for more distant galaxies, e.g. systems beyond roughly z 0.01–0.02, it may be useful to optionally compute distances from redshift using an adopted cosmology. This would allow more consistent handling of luminosity distances, angular-diameter distances, and physical scales for galaxies where cosmological effects are no longer completely negligible.

Suggested implementation
Consider adding an optional cosmology-based distance mode for galaxies with available redshifts.
For example:

  • keep the current adopted-distance behavior as the default;
  • optionally compute distances from redshift using an adopted cosmology, e.g. astropy.cosmology;
  • record whether the distance is adopted;
  • store/use the appropriate distance type: luminosity distance, D_L, for luminosities and flux-to-luminosity conversions; angular-diameter distance, D_A, for physical scales; possibly comoving distance only where explicitly needed.

Possible additions to distance_key.txt
Add optional columns such as:

redshift
distance_method
cosmology_name
H0
Om0
D_L_Mpc
D_A_Mpc
kpc_per_arcsec

Possible additions to moment_key.txt
If moment products depend on distance-based quantities, include enough metadata to clarify which distance was used, for example:

distance_used_Mpc
distance_type
distance_method
kpc_per_arcsec

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Fields

    No fields configured for Feature.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions