From 22509c3ef33b089200671961613403fc1d8d8ede Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Richard McCracken Date: Tue, 26 Apr 2022 12:45:56 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] Added Responses from Twitter and Discord This is the Google Doc information compiled by Lloyd at this link https://drive.google.com/file/d/10clvXNZ5s0swhT4Md15VfvC1-hCL6Lsz/view --- Ballot-1-Draft.md | 615 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 615 insertions(+) diff --git a/Ballot-1-Draft.md b/Ballot-1-Draft.md index a2a7b75..b7e6e46 100644 --- a/Ballot-1-Draft.md +++ b/Ballot-1-Draft.md @@ -61,3 +61,618 @@ B. Yes, permit DripDropz to allocate 7.5% of the total supply. C. Yes, permit DripDropz to allocate 5% of the total supply. D. No, do not allow DripDropz to allocate any of the total supply. ``` +------Responses------ +============================================================== +Guild: DripDropz Official +Channel: Community / ballot-feedback +============================================================== + +[15-Apr-22 10:33 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 (pinned) +The First DripDropz vote is approaching! Here are 6 action items we need to address with voting and are looking for your feedback by Apr 25. + +Please comment in this channel about each of the 6 items and the vote choices. The list will also be posted on GitHub. Thanks! πŸ™ + +{Attachments} +https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/964533423656034334/964533947738488902/DDz-Vote.001.jpeg + +{Reactions} +DripDropzLogo (16) πŸ‡¦πŸ‡Ί + +[15-Apr-22 10:37 AM] KaniTomohiro#6361 +we ll have to see what the people want... on a different note, could cou guys implement a better system for onboarding maybe. so at least we could check our position in the queue etc... thank you! + + +[15-Apr-22 10:37 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Thank you for the feedback! We know that's important to token creators! + +{Reactions} +πŸ’š + +[15-Apr-22 10:38 AM] Pudgy Cat#4755 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. A +5. C +6. A + +And I agree with the idea of a "better" onboarding system πŸ™‚ at least "faster" (talking for a friend) πŸ˜› + +{Reactions} +πŸ‘ (2) + +[15-Apr-22 10:39 AM] KaniTomohiro#6361 +i would also think token creators could pay a small fee and /or allocate a certain amount of their tokens from their faucets to dripdropz.... + + +[15-Apr-22 10:40 AM] iFORGOT#9968 +BAABCD + + +[15-Apr-22 10:41 AM] iFORGOT#9968 +Can't wait to see the actual vote outcome. + + +[15-Apr-22 10:41 AM] KaniTomohiro#6361 +is that a future nato member i see? πŸ™‚ + + +[15-Apr-22 10:41 AM] iFORGOT#9968 +Proposal ballot looks good πŸ‘ + + +[15-Apr-22 10:41 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +remember friends, this isn't a vote yet. This is for feedback on the questions, and the answers. + + +[15-Apr-22 10:41 AM] Pudgy Cat#4755 +Hopefully πŸ™‚ + +{Reactions} +πŸ’š + +[15-Apr-22 10:42 AM] iFORGOT#9968 +My only criticism is try to highlight the difference in 5 and 6 a little more clearly. Some people have short attention span and won't read the whole statement. + + +[15-Apr-22 10:42 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Thanks for the feedback. It is noted! + + +[15-Apr-22 10:43 AM] iFORGOT#9968 +The summary statement in particular πŸ‘ + + +[15-Apr-22 10:46 AM] vincrypto#4289 +Agree with these choices + +{Reactions} +🀞 + +[15-Apr-22 10:46 AM] vincrypto#4289 +CCAACA + + +[15-Apr-22 10:47 AM] Swoops#9550 +If you are looking for my vote, which seems strange to run it this way this is what it would be. + +1. C +2. C +3. B +4. A +5. C +6. C + +If you are looking for feedback about the ballot itself it looks good. + + +[15-Apr-22 11:01 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Feedback on the ballots, not voting at this time. Thanks for the feedback! + + +[15-Apr-22 11:03 AM] KaniTomohiro#6361 +i love how noone can follow instructions 🀣 + + +[15-Apr-22 11:10 AM] astrolape#8562 +1. B +2. C +3. B +4. A +5. D +6. D + + +[15-Apr-22 11:16 AM] headelf#7886 +@Lloyd Duhon regarding minimum Ada wallet holding I would suggest it be pegged to Cardano minimum-currently 500 Ada to vote. + + +[15-Apr-22 11:18 AM] LapinMalin#5925 +1) C +2) C +3) A +4) B +5) A +6) A + + +[15-Apr-22 11:23 AM] RedDestruction#5297 +@headelf that's a lot if you just are trying to get your family members or kids familiar with cardano. Dripdropz and staking in a pool is a good on-ramp to Cardano. + + +[15-Apr-22 11:27 AM] RedDestruction#5297 +dripdropz is something to get someone into the environment and get them excited that they are receiving some tokens that they are interested in for participating + + +[15-Apr-22 11:33 AM] RedDestruction#5297 +staking is helpful but don't think it provides the gratification that dripdropz does and the freedom of choice in tokens + + +[15-Apr-22 11:34 AM] Douglass#0730 +C, C, A, A, C, A + + +[15-Apr-22 11:34 AM] RedDestruction#5297 +this is not a vote + + +[15-Apr-22 11:34 AM] RedDestruction#5297 +**feedback is being requested on the ballots only** + + +[15-Apr-22 11:36 AM] ruffleswithwater#5371 +1. B 2. B 3. B 4. A 5. A 6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 12:00 PM] SmartCATMod#6965 +1) C +2) C +3) A +4) C +5) C +6) A + + +[15-Apr-22 12:01 PM] MoonshotEoD#0416 +1) C +2) C +3) A +4) C +5) C +6) A + + +[15-Apr-22 12:07 PM] β‚³ngel_du$T#8462 +A, A, C, C, B, D + + +[15-Apr-22 12:12 PM] mike0#9755 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. A +5. C +6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 12:20 PM] Jonathan.lu#5028 +1) C +2) C +3) A +4) B +5) A +6) A + + +[15-Apr-22 12:38 PM] cryptogott#5365 +1. A +2. A +3. C +4. C +5. B +6. C + + +[15-Apr-22 01:02 PM] Kallehed#4644 +AAACDD - my greedy vote choices + + +[15-Apr-22 01:04 PM] Trina#2789 +1. C, 2. C, 3. B, 4. A, 5. C, 6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 01:08 PM] Nikos#4621 +1. A +2. C +3. C +4. A +5. C +6. D + + +[15-Apr-22 01:57 PM] SamerThePilot| 😈 | Charly#4846 +B, B, A, D, A (Decentralization is the soul of ADA), B + + +[15-Apr-22 02:22 PM] ahong#3736 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. C +5. C +6. C + + +[15-Apr-22 02:33 PM] egecan#9182 +1. C +2. C +3. B +4. A +5. B +6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 02:34 PM] Dunamis#0524 +1. A +2. A +3. A +4. D +5. A +6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 02:38 PM] Gera#1422 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. D +5. A +6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 02:49 PM] DomF2#5660 +A +A +B +C +A +A + + +[15-Apr-22 02:51 PM] Mase#5029 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. A +5. C +6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 02:58 PM] AndrewWestberg [BCSH]#7537 +https://tenor.com/view/head-shake-no-the-avengers-captain-america-chris-evans-gif-10638953 + +{Embed} +https://tenor.com/view/head-shake-no-the-avengers-captain-america-chris-evans-gif-10638953 +https://images-ext-1.discordapp.net/external/Enmhyl-1oEuS7qYnrD-Ml-MiyvuEN-Lcu8IgDXLqbck/%3Fc%3DVjFfZGlzY29yZA/https/media.tenor.com/aeJP_n0ZhgIAAAAD/head-shake-no-the-avengers.png + + +[15-Apr-22 02:58 PM] AndrewWestberg [BCSH]#7537 +"this is not a vote" + +{Reactions} +πŸ˜… (3) + +[15-Apr-22 03:05 PM] Arsam#5077 +1. C +2. A +3. A +4. C +5. C +6. C + + +[15-Apr-22 03:43 PM] jeremy_1341#2569 +A,C,A,A,D,A + + +[15-Apr-22 04:37 PM] Sebanimation#4151 +Guys itβ€˜s literally in the headline: This is not a vote, itβ€˜s about feedback! + + +[15-Apr-22 04:38 PM] Sebanimation#4151 +Not sure about 2) as I donβ€˜t know what dripdropz pro is… is the idea that we have to pay drip tokens to upgrade to pro? And only then we can stake? + + +[15-Apr-22 04:44 PM] andalib#0604 +1 c +2 c +3 c +4 c +5 c +6 c + + +[15-Apr-22 05:09 PM] Mnemor#4115 +1) C +2) C +3) A +4) B +5) A +6) A + + +[15-Apr-22 05:24 PM] VK#0425 +C, C, D, D, C, C. + + +[15-Apr-22 05:33 PM] freeman001#5570 +B, B, A, B, C, B. + + +[15-Apr-22 06:39 PM] Borgia#0064 +In regards to 1), we can already provide liquidity on a variety of DEXes to gain a reasonable amount of APY. The main focus and incentive for people to stake DRIP shouldnt be just for an APY gain. Instead the amount staked by a wallet should give that wallet a β€œlevel” ie gold,premium,diamond,etc. In my opinion this is what should be needed to access DripDropz Pro or other planned features. Additionally, I know this is not the voting stage yet, just stating my point: The minimum ADA should not be changed as since day one wallet splitting was encouraged to a degree. And with 44.5 billion tokens left to go, we have a long way ahead before we should be vary of depleting token resources. + +{Reactions} +πŸ™ + +[15-Apr-22 07:21 PM] ButterDoge#0672 +C + + +[15-Apr-22 07:21 PM] ButterDoge#0672 +C + + +[15-Apr-22 07:21 PM] ButterDoge#0672 +A + + +[15-Apr-22 07:21 PM] ButterDoge#0672 +C + + +[15-Apr-22 07:21 PM] ButterDoge#0672 +C + + +[15-Apr-22 07:21 PM] ButterDoge#0672 +A + + +[15-Apr-22 08:18 PM] Bracat#6276 +A A B B A A + + +[15-Apr-22 08:26 PM] BryantDenny#8315 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. D +5. B +6. C + + +[15-Apr-22 09:33 PM] jaytech7001#1804 +1. a +2. C +3. A +4. c +5. C +6. A + + +[15-Apr-22 10:19 PM] caseyTheCamel#8836 +An average user like me might not understand enough about Node Operation to answer question 5 in a meaningful way. I'd at least want a brief summary of how node operators are currently incentivized. Given that the other questions are relatively easy to answer, and more immediately clear how they impact the average user, people may decide to vote anyway, and give question 5 their best guess. Perhaps consider a 'Not Sure' option so that the vote is not muddied. +(This is obviously assuming that all 6 questions are presented as a set, as I'm understanding from the document that was shared. If you can just choose to vote for one but not another, then it's not a problem) +Also, I'm not sure what operational flexibility implies in question 6. + + +[15-Apr-22 10:32 PM] Pickled Penguin#0441 +1. C, 2. A, 3. B, 4. A, 5. A, 6. C + +My only feedback would be to make it easier for participants to give feedback.. perhaps with a form where we could enter/select options, rather than looking at a pdf and type in the answer separately. Thanks! + +{Reactions} +πŸ”₯ + +[16-Apr-22 12:15 AM] jaytech7001#1804 +are there to be any options for people who have their drip in liquidity pools ? + + +[16-Apr-22 03:03 AM] SellOuT#3839 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. D +5. - +6. - + + +[16-Apr-22 03:06 AM] SellOuT#3839 +Would it make more sense to have this answered directly on the homepage? + + +[16-Apr-22 03:25 AM] 10n9#6875 +1) C +2) C +3) A +4) B +5) A +6) A + + +[16-Apr-22 03:42 AM] Warhead#5096 +1) C +2) A +3) A +4) C +5) A +6) A + + +[16-Apr-22 05:30 AM] $alburrito#3930 +C +B +A +B +B +A + + +[16-Apr-22 07:30 AM] Yoven#7050 +You might want to pin this message for visibility. 🀣 + + +[16-Apr-22 08:08 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Pinned a message. + + +[16-Apr-22 08:09 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +There is a github link, I will post it today + + +[16-Apr-22 08:09 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Working on that + + +[16-Apr-22 08:09 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Done! + +{Reactions} +πŸ‘ + +[16-Apr-22 11:28 AM] Wilhelmus#8409 +@Lloyd Duhon it does look like you ask for the votes aswell in your first message "and the vote choices". +I do like it that you ask feedback. I would like to see some pros and cons or some more info about the questions. Most of us don't know the consequences of the choices. + + +[16-Apr-22 11:47 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Great feedback. We wanted to know if there is any ambiguity in the answers, or if the choices are unclear + + +[16-Apr-22 11:47 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Not specifically what your choice would be today + + +[16-Apr-22 11:56 AM] Wilhelmus#8409 +Check. I read it right now, 'comment about the vote choices' + + +[16-Apr-22 01:50 PM] astrolape#8562 +Providing liquidity on a dex and staking on the native platform of a token are really different and not interchangeable. Because of impermanent loss, the danger of exploits, and an APY that is often tied to a different token (in case of yield farming), I much rather prefer to have a lower APY via staking then providing liquidity on a dex. +If staking is combined with a lock-up period, it also serves to stabilize the price of a token, and can be used as an indicator to see how many people are "going long" on a project. +Last but not least, staking can be used to redistribute part of the fees earned by the protocol to the token holders, which is one of the stated goals of dripdropz. + +I actually chose 8% instead of 10% rewards, but I'm really glad dripdropz is making use of staking, and hope this will stay a central feature of dripdropz. + + +[16-Apr-22 02:07 PM] Borgia#0064 +You are right and I agree with you on choosing staking over LP, however the same people that choose to LP their ADA instead of staking it would choose the same with their DRIP. What I was stating is to give a reason for people to stake their tokens other than just the APY they would gain. Fee distributions like you suggested or access to the platform’s other features according to the amount staked. But for the lock-up, I dont think the team is focused on the token price (they might be legally obliged to) but rather giving functionality to the DRIP token and the platform. + + +[17-Apr-22 03:32 AM] manolo.yha#5118 +it will be good for the community so that there is more participation in the project... for the first voting session the points are not bad. + + +[17-Apr-22 06:38 AM] flying eagle#1369 +1.C 2. C 3. A 4. A 5. A 6. A + + +[17-Apr-22 12:04 PM] Perish#3056 +1. C +2. C +3. A +4. A +5. A +6. A + + +[17-Apr-22 02:26 PM] JamesCarther#3132 +Exactly my view. Could perhaps the DripDropz team write a medium article where they describe the current situation, motivation for change and implication the changes will bring? E.g. I understood that the team did not get any rewards for putting the platform together (at least no Drips). So how they fund themselves now? How big chunk is 10% of tokens compared with other platforms? How much work is operating nodes? Is there a similar function at other platforms? How they pay them? Especially it would be great to hear more from the founders about the token decay reviewing background. The slashing will depend on actual withdrawal volumes? You have some defined curve of token emissions already and you would just check against it? Why it would not be done continuously? + + +[17-Apr-22 06:45 PM] alphaz#1019 +1. A +2. C - or D if possible, more +3. A +4. B +5. D +6. A + + +[18-Apr-22 06:54 AM] Lauris (StakePool247 | EU01)#4674 +1. C +2. B +3. A +4. B +5. A +6. B + + +[18-Apr-22 07:14 AM] Lloyd Duhon#2044 +Excellent questions, thank you for the feedback. We definitely have medium articles planned to go into further details + +{Reactions} +πŸ”₯ (4) πŸ’₯ + +[18-Apr-22 08:39 AM] Rodrigo [CHIL]#8663 +1. b +2. b +3. d +4. d +5. a +6. a + + +[18-Apr-22 09:11 AM] cryptolemon#3587 +C C C A D D + + +[18-Apr-22 01:47 PM] cryptolemon#3587 +Yes, more DRIP must be held to get those benefits IMO + +{Reactions} +🍻 + +[18-Apr-22 02:00 PM] sannavagon#9721 +1.C +2.A +3.A +4.D +5.B +6.A + + +[20-Apr-22 10:46 AM] TheCryptoHorus#2490 +1 - C +2 - A +3 - A +4 - C +5 - D +6 - A + + +[20-Apr-22 12:12 PM] joe_dk#9367 +1.A 2.A 3.A 4.D 5.B 6.C + + +[20-Apr-22 12:52 PM] vlhoti#2162 +1 - C +2 - A +3 - A +4 - A +5 - A +6 - D + + +[20-Apr-22 04:04 PM] Xavier#4624 +1.C 2.A 3.A 4.B 5.A 6.A + + +[20-Apr-22 07:32 PM] th3rdwind#2830 +B, A, A, A, A, A + + +============================================================== +Exported 100 message(s) +==============================================================