Skip to content

[Activation] Deliver a licensed demo song and measurable first-run rehearsal journey #964

Description

@seonghobae

Parent: #958
Baseline: #968

Buyer-visible gap

A buyer cannot evaluate BandScope from architecture documents, unit tests, or an empty workspace. The first launch must demonstrate the actual product value without requiring the user to locate a suitable song, understand MIR terminology, install an undocumented dependency, or guess the next action after analysis.

The live queue includes useful Storybook, empty/error, navigation, priority, first-part, loop, count-in, and cue slices (#897#905 and related T3 work), but no single protected journey proves that a new musician reaches a useful rehearsal action with licensed, reproducible input.

Product outcome

A clean installation offers an optional, clearly licensed demo rehearsal and a parallel Use my own song path:

launch
→ choose demo or local file
→ choose role and rehearsal goal
→ analyze with honest stage progress and limitations
→ open the most important cue
→ loop or mark it for rehearsal
→ save and reopen the project

The demo must exercise the same production file validation, resource admission, decoding, analysis, rehearsal-player, persistence, and recovery boundaries as user audio.

Required scope

Licensed demo package

  • Include or reproducibly acquire a redistributable song/fixture with explicit audio, stem, annotation, artwork, and attribution rights.
  • Record source, author/performer credit, exact hashes, transformation history, license text, and permitted redistribution/evaluation uses.
  • Use real decoded audio through the production boundary; do not substitute direct feature arrays or mocked browser success.
  • Include ground-truth annotations sufficient to connect the demo to [Product Gap] Add real-audio MIR accuracy acceptance benchmarks #770 accuracy evidence.
  • Keep private/commercial benchmark assets separate from the public demo.

First-run state machine

  • Present Try the demo and Use my own song immediately and state the local-first privacy boundary in one action-oriented sentence.
  • Ask only for information required to produce a useful result: intended role, optional skill level, and rehearsal goal.
  • Detect missing runtime/model/backend prerequisites before expensive work and offer a supported recovery action.
  • Show bounded, cancellable progress based on actual worker stages; never invent unsupported percentages.
  • Land on one prioritized rehearsal action rather than a dense dashboard with no next step.
  • Explain confidence, known limitations, and how the user can correct a role or section result.
  • Allow experienced/returning users to skip onboarding and reopen recent projects.

Live PR convergence

Activation evidence

  • Define local activation milestones without collecting audio, project content, paths, URLs, or identity.
  • Keep evidence local by default; optional aggregate telemetry requires explicit enablement and the privacy/diagnostics contract in [Operations] Build redacted diagnostics, crash evidence and an offline support bundle #963.
  • Measure at minimum:
    • first launch success;
    • demo/local-file choice;
    • first valid audio acceptance;
    • analysis started/completed/cancelled/failed by stage;
    • first cue opened;
    • first rehearsal action completed;
    • project saved and reopened.
  • Measure time-to-first-rehearsal before declaring a release threshold; do not invent a target from synthetic success.

Acceptance criteria

  • Clean supported Windows and macOS installations complete the demo journey without a terminal, external account, or undocumented dependency.
  • Demo audio/artwork/annotations have a checked license/provenance manifest and immutable hashes.
  • Demo and user audio use the same production intake, resource, decode, analysis, player, project, and recovery boundaries.
  • A measured time-to-first-rehearsal distribution is published before a release gate is chosen.
  • Every failure state provides a concrete next action and preserves retry, choose-another-file, demo, and support-evidence paths.
  • Keyboard-only and screen-reader users complete the entire journey.
  • Korean and English preserve the same choices, limitations, privacy statements, and actions.
  • Local activation evidence excludes audio, lyrics, project payloads, paths, URLs, and identity.
  • First-run state resumes safely after restart and never traps a returning user.
  • Repository-owned production statement/branch coverage and public API documentation remain 100%.
  • Current-head CI, security, license, accessibility, qualifying independent approval, zero unresolved actionable threads, and branch protection pass without bypass.

Real-world personas and failures

  • first-time singer unfamiliar with MIR terminology;
  • bassist selecting a role weakly represented in the mix;
  • keyboard-only and screen-reader users;
  • offline user after installation;
  • unsupported codec selected before choosing the demo;
  • low-memory device triggering resource admission/fallback;
  • analysis cancelled and resumed;
  • corrupt or missing demo asset;
  • returning user skipping onboarding and reopening a project.

Non-goals

  • No mandatory account creation or cloud upload.
  • No telemetry consent hidden in general terms.
  • No copyrighted commercial song committed without redistribution rights.
  • No synthetic or mocked result presented as production analysis success.
  • No onboarding copy that promises universal musical correctness.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    area: authAuthentication, authorization, identity, or tenant isolationarea: ci-cdCI, GitHub Actions, checks, release, or supply chainarea: dependenciesDependency or lockfile maintenancearea: securitySecurity boundary, hardening, or vulnerability preventionpriority: mediumNormal-priority or P2 workscope: product-gapCustomer-visible product gapstatus: triagedOpen issue has an organization taxonomy assignmenttype: featureNew or expanded product capability

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions