Skip to content

Hardcoded qp clipping #231

Description

@gakssultang

Summary

MAX_QUANT(BD) is bit-depth-aware (src/oapv_def.h:55) so the QP ceiling tracks bit depth:

#define MAX_QUANT(BD)  (63 + ((BD-10)*6))   // 10-bit -> 63, 12-bit -> 75

But the encoder validates/clips QP against a hardcoded MAX_QUANT(10) (= 63) everywhere, so the top of the 12-bit quantization range (QP 64–75) is unreachable.

Version: v0.3.0.0

Fix

The correct ceiling is always MAX_QUANT(<internal bit depth>) = MAX_QUANT(ctx->bit_depth).

1. src/oapv.cenc_frm_prepare (needs reordering)

-    // line 837 — runs before bit depth is known
-    oapv_assert_rv((param->qp >= MIN_QUANT && param->qp <= MAX_QUANT(10)) || param->qp == OAPVE_PARAM_QP_AUTO, OAPV_ERR_INVALID_QP);
-    ...
-    // line 868
-    for(i = 0; i < N_C; i++) {
-        ctx->qp[i] = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(10), param->qp + ctx->qp_offset[i]);
-    }

     // ... ctx->bit_depth_inp = ...; ret = enc_check_profile(...); ... ctx->bit_depth = ...;
+
+    // perform both AFTER ctx->bit_depth is assigned (after line 885)
+    oapv_assert_rv((param->qp >= MIN_QUANT && param->qp <= MAX_QUANT(ctx->bit_depth)) || param->qp == OAPVE_PARAM_QP_AUTO, OAPV_ERR_INVALID_QP);
+
+    for(i = 0; i < N_C; i++) {
+        ctx->qp[i] = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(ctx->bit_depth), param->qp + ctx->qp_offset[i]);
+    }

2. src/oapv.c:1005oapve_encode

-    ctx->qp[c] = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(10), ctx->rc_param.qp + ctx->qp_offset[c]);
+    ctx->qp[c] = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(ctx->bit_depth), ctx->rc_param.qp + ctx->qp_offset[c]);

3. src/oapv.c:1258oapve_config OAPV_CFG_SET_QP

-    // if ctx->bit_depth is set at config time
-    oapv_assert_rv(t0 >= MIN_QUANT && t0 <= MAX_QUANT(10), OAPV_ERR_INVALID_ARGUMENT);
+    oapv_assert_rv(t0 >= MIN_QUANT && t0 <= MAX_QUANT(ctx->bit_depth), OAPV_ERR_INVALID_ARGUMENT);

4. src/oapv_rc.c:169oapve_rc_estimate_pic_qp (needs bit_depth parameter)

This function has no ctx, so thread the bit depth in.

 // src/oapv_rc.h:44  — declaration
-int oapve_rc_estimate_pic_qp(double lambda);
+int oapve_rc_estimate_pic_qp(double lambda, int bit_depth);
 // src/oapv_rc.c:166
-int oapve_rc_estimate_pic_qp(double lambda)
+int oapve_rc_estimate_pic_qp(double lambda, int bit_depth)
 {
     int qp = (int)(4.2005 * log(lambda) + 13.7122 + 0.5) + OAPV_RC_QP_OFFSET;
-    qp = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(10), qp);
+    qp = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(bit_depth), qp);
     return qp;
 }
 // src/oapv.c:998  — caller
-    ctx->rc_param.qp = oapve_rc_estimate_pic_qp(ctx->rc_param.lambda);
+    ctx->rc_param.qp = oapve_rc_estimate_pic_qp(ctx->rc_param.lambda, ctx->bit_depth);

5. src/oapv_rc.c:196oapve_rc_get_qp

-    *qp = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(10), *qp);
+    *qp = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(ctx->bit_depth), *qp);

6. src/oapv_vlc.c:323oapve_set_tile_header

-    th->tile_qp[c] = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(10), qp + ctx->qp_offset[c]);
+    th->tile_qp[c] = oapv_clip3(MIN_QUANT, MAX_QUANT(ctx->bit_depth), qp + ctx->qp_offset[c]);

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions